
DREAM Act Student | Dreamactivist on Flickr
In an effort to win GOP favor on immigration legislation in Congress, the Obama Administration stepped up ICE deportations of undocumented workers to record levels. More than 800,000 immigrants were moved out of the United States in just two years by President Obama to appease Republicans, according to the Washington Post.
Whenever Rep. Luis V. Gutierrez (D-Ill.) and other immigrant-rights advocates asked President Obama how a Democratic administration could preside over the greatest number of deportations in any two-year period in the nation’s history, Obama’s answer was always the same.
Deporting almost 800,000 illegal immigrants might antagonize some Democrats and Latino voters, Obama’s skeptical supporters said the president told them, but stepped-up enforcement was the only way to buy credibility with Republicans and generate bipartisan support for an overhaul of the nation’s immigration laws.
Playing with the lives of literally hundreds of thousands of human beings is a despicable political ploy for any politician, let alone a Democratic President. And the “strategy” predictably failed, as with every other move to appease Republicans. This weekend’s defeat of the DREAM Act in the Senate shows the complete fallacy of racing to ruin the lives of immigrants in pursuit of legislative compromise with the GOP.
On Saturday, that strategy was in ruins after Senate Democrats could muster only 55 votes in support of the Development, Relief and Education for Alien Minors (DREAM) Act, a measure that would have created a pathway to citizenship for undocumented immigrants who were brought to the United States as children. Under Senate rules, Democrats needed 60 votes to overcome Republican opposition to the bill. The House of Representatives had passed the measure this month, 216 to 198. [...]
“It is a strategy which has borne no fruits whatsoever,” Gutierrez said. “This administration has unilaterally led the march on enforcement, yet the other side has not given one modicum of compromise.”
“If you really want to bring Republicans to the table,” he added, “so long as they are getting everything they want, every piece of enforcement, why, why would they come to the table?”
It’s yet another example of President Obama compromising with himself ahead of a legislative fight, and with Republicans predictably failing to act as Obama expected them to. Only this time, Obama did so by deporting more immigrants in two years than George W. Bush could even dream of. This chart from America’s Voice tells the whole story:

It’d be one thing if Obama sought to maintain parity with George W. Bush, or to back off of a threat to slow down or halt deportations to win concessions from Republicans. But a separate Washington Post story indicates that ICE, with cheerleading from Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano, actively sought to break last year’s record number of deportations.
When ICE officials realized in the final weeks of the fiscal year, which ended Sept. 30, that the agency still was in jeopardy of falling short of last year’s mark, it scrambled to reach the goal. Officials quietly directed immigration officers to bypass backlogged immigration courts and time-consuming deportation hearings whenever possible, internal e-mails and interviews show.
Instead, officials told immigration officers to encourage eligible foreign nationals to accept a quick pass to their countries without a negative mark on their immigration record, ICE employees said. [...]
Without these efforts and the more than 25,000 deportations that came with them, the agency would not have topped last year’s record level of 389,834, current and former ICE employees and officials said.
The Obama administration was intent on doing so even as it came under attack by some Republicans for not being tough enough on immigration enforcement and by some Democrats for failing to deliver on promises of comprehensive immigration reform.
This is sick and disgusting, and Obama has nothing to show for it. But my money is on ICE striving to break this year’s record in 2011, cause Obama can’t look soft on immigration, ya know. Even though Republicans (and coward Democrats) will continue to attack Obama’s soft spot for “amnesty” or whatever.



40 Comments

Snort. It is, of course, impossible to consider that Obama is using the GOP as a convenient scapegoat.
Democratic House, Democratic Senate, Democratic President, but everything they do is the fault of the minority of Reps who remained after their Party was swept from office in disgrace for their years of blundering.
Can a single day go by without us learning about something new that makes me want to pull my hair out? These fuckers are attacking the American poor in ways we never even thought of.
I Could be ok with this if the CEO’s of these companies repeat offenders in particular should get jail time.
But of course Obama isn’t doing that.
Tangential–
Something to watch: “Andrew Cuomo To File Fraud Charges Against Ernst & Young For Lehman Repo 105 Involvement” (by Tyler Durden, Dec. 20, 2010, link: http://www.zerohedge.com/article/andrew-cuomo-file-fraud-charges-against-ernst-young-lehman-repo-105-involvement )
Re the IMF: ‘IMF Director says IMF “forces coordination” and there’s “no other solution” to Greek-style austerity’ (by FauxCapitalist, Dec. 19, 2010, link: http://fauxcapitalist.com/2010/12/19/imf-director-says-imf-forces-coordination )
“Cash-rich IMF plans to refurbish its ‘opulent’ [DC] headquarters” (Dec. 19, 2010, link: http://www.guardian.co.uk/business/2010/dec/19/imf-refurbish-us-headquarters )
“IMF bailout plan to get more inflexible over time despite assurances” (Dec. 19, 2010, link: http://www.tribune.ie/business/article/2010/dec/19/imf-bailout-plan-to-get-more-inflexible-over-time- )
Another JP Morgn whistleblower comes forward: “JPM Fraudclosure Whistleblower Emerges” (by Tyler Durden, Dec. 19, 2010, link: http://www.zerohedge.com/article/jpm-fraudclosure-whistleblower-emerges )
I think crime the crime of hiring immigrants Mitt Romney got caught twice with illegal landscapers, Lou Dobb’s stable hands come to mind also should be punished.
You know it just keeps getting worse with this guy every day. He’s such a friggin disappointment. What’s really sad though is to have to watch and listen to black friends of mine who endlessly make excuses for this putz, even though they know how bad he’s turned out for their own community. I understand their deep solidarity up to a pt. but it’s starting to grate on me a bit.
WASHINGTON (CNN) – Federal officials raided Wal-Mart stores across the United States Thursday, arresting about 250 illegal immigrants working on cleaning crews at 61 stores in 21 states.
http://money.cnn.com/2003/10/23/news/companies/walmart_worker_arrests/
How much has Wallmart given to anti immigrant GOPers? Give us that number in a follow up post:)
Time for a primary opponent yet?
I am not sure I have a problem with this. We have an immigration law for a reason. My complaint about George Bush was that he did not enforce this law and let certain corporations get away with hiring illegals. I cannot get upset for PBO doing his job.
The Obamabots on the blogs if they follow the normal trend of Bloggers to be White are also annoying. I can understand African Americans feelings for Obama and looking at their unemployment rates I pity them.
Then I listen to the Righties who think Blacks are taking all the jobs. (Mod I use Black because thats what the Righties say accuracy in reporting what they say I think trumps my personal feelings on the term people need to know).
Past time!
I would agree but as long CEO’s keep hiring them then this is Kabuki.
RENO, Nev. — Two executives and the corporate owner of 11 northern Nevada McDonald’s restaurants pleaded guilty to felony immigration charges and agreed to pay $1 million in fines.
Authorities say Mack Associates Inc. employed illegal immigrants at the fast-food restaurants by giving them names and Social Security numbers belonging to others.
Nevada U.S. attorney Gregory Brower says the company pleaded guilty Wednesday as a corporation to two felony charges including conspiracy and aiding and abetting.
The case stems from the arrests last September of 56 people in Immigrations and Customs Enforcement raids at restaurants in Reno, Sparks and Fernley, and at franchise offices in Reno.
Company directors Joe Gillespie of Sparks and former vice president Jimmy Moore pleaded guilty in federal court in Las Vegas to one charge each.
Read more: http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,384521,00.html#ixzz18hIoyvjy
One felony count for 30 immigrants? thats outrageous each immigrant should be a single felony count!
Next question why didn’t Mitt and Lou get convicted I assume these that in America law is applied equally to everyone but GOP corporations, GOP Presidential Candidates and GOP Press are above the law?
Any Immigrant Haters out there prove your not a Corporate tool boycott Walmart, Mcdonalds, Fox News for employing Lou Dobbs and Mitt Romney
I’d assert that Obama’s job is not to deport people but to propose new legislation that stiffens penalties and creates a better enforcement mechanism. WalMart operates with impunity and will continue to hire these folks as long as they get away scott-free.
If people continue to see an opportunity in the US, they’ll continue to come here. This is a problem of our own making and deportation is not the solution.
Chris Hayes, guest hosting for Rachel Maddow, did a segment on this topic several months ago. Its title was “Deporter in Chief”. I remember thinking at the time (when I was still conned by Obama) “Why would he do something like that?” Now we know.
I like to point to this episode for the benefit of those who think Keith, Chris, and Rachel have drunk the Kool-Aid.
Agreed Jail Mitt, Jail Lou Jail the CEO’s punish the cause deporting treats the symptoms if even CEO’s go to jail then nobody would hire illegals.
I think illegals if deported should be paid 6 months wages then sent back to Mexico why punish the immigrants?
But if CEO’s have to cough up the cash from personal rather than corporate funds then this will stop.
If the company pays then shareholders get punished and no shareholder agrees to criminal action.
Plus I still support jailtime for CEO’s the Buck stops with them if they don’t know what their company is doing then they deserve to go to jail for stupidity.
How many legal Hispanics have gotten arrested under the Obama sweep?
President Origami has lost the black intelligentsia and the working and middle class are following.
I agree. It’s a felony, it should involve jailtime. If a young black man can go to county for 90 days for having a joint in his posession a CEO should go to jail for at least that for having an ILLEGAL alien in his posession (I believe knowingly employing illegal aliens amounts to slavery in most cases, because of the obvious wage discrepancies and the threat of exposure that most of these employers hold over the aliens’ heads.)
And I think you’re forgetting our recently rejected friend e-Meg! Wasn’t she the one with the illegal housekeeper for years?
Whats the latest on AZ’s immigrant law?
We’ll never know because they probably can’t afford adequate representation for a civil suit.
It was time 9 months ago. Unless one of the major liberal/progressive groups get behind a challenge it’s unlikely to happen no matter how fast we blog.
I think that there should be a threshold, like six illegals (or some other graduated scheme). The threshold should enable regular guys like me to hire who ever I want (for a short term) without going through a lengthy process and without being subject to jail time.
Example 1: When I need some help for my yard/garden, I go to the local 7-11 (in Los Angeles) and I hire them for $10/hr. Under employment law, I am required to keep records of my “employees” if I pay them more than $600 per year. I like that threshold.
Example 2: If I were a pissed off HR director losing my job over Christmas, I would only hire illegals. After a couple of months, I would call immigration and presto, the CEO would end up in jail or severely fined. The threshold would prevent pissed off employees from screwing over business owners.
It looks like criminal deportations were the bulk of the rise. I don’t see why that’s a bad thing.
Many US Citizens who are minors have been undoubtedly captured in this. But they are “anchor babies” so we can just throw out the Constitution I guess.
That’s why god made contingency fees.
Given the sentencing disparities between poor and African American citizens can Hispanics Immigrants expect to get fair trials when poor and African American citizens can’t?
Senator Jon McCain’s wife gets busted with enough drugs to get my entire High School High she gets no time. But McCain complains about Immigrants bringing in drugs to America?
Rudy Giuliani’s state campaign chair gets busted with a half kilo of coke and he’s out of jail already?
Call me when the rich get punished for breaking our laws.
I don’t have to call you. Seems you’re the one with the problem, so when you think have some sort of persuasive argument why criminal aliens here illegally shouldn’t be deported, you can call us.
Prove that they are getting tried fairly in a country where a defense lawyer can fall asleep in a trial and his client gets convicted but sleeping during trial is not thought to have effected the clients defense?
If American Citizens can’t get fair justice what chance do immigrants have so the question of criminal immigrants is suspect.
During their working life, undocumented immigrants in the United States will pay, on average, approximately $80,000 more in taxes per capita than they use in government services, owing to the fact that they are not eligible to take advantage of almost all of the social service programs offered by the federal government
http://www.truth-out.org/undocumented-immigrants-pay-more-taxes-than-they-receive-benefits59264
Every Immigrant we send back increases taxes.
“Appease,” huh? You mean like Neville Chamberlain?
I am so glad the lead includes the reminder of the Dream Act….a bunch of millionaires in DC casting a petty vote against youngsters who were brought here by their parents. I have heard the Laura Ingraham arguement that their parents “committed a crime…” What about the other cheaters and criminals whose children are in no way considered responsible or guilty. So sad: we had the opportunity to do the just and moral thing to let these young people who have grown up in this country become successful citizens. Mean spirited…
Mean spirited…
This is what these people stand for.
Obviously, ICE didn’t hit my town..we are still drowning in a sea of illegals..they are bleeding us dry
You obviously don’t live in Arizona.
President Origami – more folds than the dollar-bill scorpion on the cover of Matt Taibbi’s Griftopia!
TheMalcontent says he’s working on it with his New Progressive Alliance.
What part of $80,000 more in taxes they pay over a lifetime than they get back from Social Security, Unemployment Insurance, medicare etc That Illegals don’t get but still pay taxes on don’t you understand?
Is it any wonder that AZ the state that tried to pass that horrible immigration law is now so indebt they are cutting transplant patients from getting state cash? Cause and Effect.
That article, by Shankar Vedantam, waits until about the ninth paragraph to mention, “At a recent press briefing, Department of Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano denied that the administration had increased deportations to bring Republicans to the bargaining table.” So much for the objectivity of this article.
Illegal immigrants drive down wages for the poorest workers here. They also displace young workers who are trying to enter the job market. There’s been a signficant decrease in native teenage employment in recent years and most of it’s because of immigration. Foreigners taking our jobs, period.
Unless things change the whole country will probably end up looking like California today: crowded, poor, and not that great of a place except for a relatively few well off. I don’t know about you, but I would rather that the country not have 600 million inhabitants, or even 500 million. Is it really worth the price of having more Democrats?
The DREAM Act: even people like Pat Buchanan think there should be allowances made for young people who’ve lived in the United States most of their lives. In this particular instance the bill called for those 15 years old as the cutoff age. Restrictionists wanted it to be seven years old. Allowances can be made now for young people who are caught in this situation. I think most people, even those who want far less immigration, believe such people should be accommodated.
Immigration reform is not a simple “throw them all out” issue. I think we should all remember that it is an issue that is about human beings. While people who are in the country and are not citizens or do not have documentaion to legally be here in the country, are definitely breaking the law, put yourself in their place and consider their plight. Many pay smugglers hard earned money for a chance to better themselves who end up dying in the desert, or they are exploited and made to work in sweatshops for low wages; there are guest workers who are here legitimately who experience terrible treatment and make very little money. What to do about these undocumented folks, demonize them, scapegoat them? I think that is what we must not do. Work needs to be done Congressionally.
Just remember the saying “There, but for the grace of god, go I.”
I think we should be compassionate to these people, it is the human thing do. The immigration courts who hear deportation proceedings is a travesty and should be made to be more humane. The NATION has an article about the issue.