We find ourselves like our founders at a turning point. Do we try to incrementally change our way of being governed even though the Court of St. James isn’t even listening to our pleas or do we put our necks out and try to change this country from the outside?
Chris Hedges has a piece on "Truthdig" on health care reform being "More Like a Rip-Off Than Reform". At the end of the article he has a very interesting statement by David Himmelstein, head of Physicians for a National Health Plan:
“We are considering a variety of striking efforts for early in the fall,” Dr. Himmelstein said, “includingprotests outside state capitals by doctors around the country, video links of conferences in 70 or 80 cities around the country, with protests and potential doctors chaining themselves to the fence of the White House.”
Make sure you join them."
Tuesday, on Firedoglake book salon, Matt Taibbi discussed his new article in "Rolling Stone". In the discussion Taibbi said:
"I think that’s probably one step [voting people out]. The other step is probably boycotts of some kind, maybe tax strikes. There has to be some kind of drastic consequence, because this whole deal proves that simple voting with in the current parameters doesn’t work."
Taibbi also thinks that if there is no public option and progressives vote against the bill, "that would be a big deal."
At this point, I am with Taibbi. We must work like hell from all angles and some people should continue to work inside D.C. But I think the real action will come from outside the beltway.
We must not fall in line. We must not back down, as Johnny Cash would sing. We have cajoled and pleaded with our representatives. It hasn’t worked very well. We have been side lined at listening sessions if we advocate for HB 676. Time to bypass them and talk to our neighbors and get them educated and righteously angry. Time to join with the Physicians and the Mad as Hell Docs who are heading to Washington. Look at their itinerary on line at: Mad As Hell Docs
That’s why the 18 Montana Democratic Central Committees formed a coalition that would address the lack of response from our Senator. In a progress report Tuesday, the Chair of the Coalition said:
Finally, the Senator was giving his strongest supporters in Montana the attention and respect they deserved and was responding to them face to face (or, at least,phone to phone).
The official response from the Senator’s office to the coalition was:
"Senator Baucus included a public option in his November 2008 White Paper, which is essentially his blueprint for reform and a public option has always been on the table," says a Senate Finance Committee aide. "Senator Baucus has said all along that he wants to hold the insurance companies’ feet to the fire. He believes reform must ensure quality affordable care, lower costs, hold insurance companies accountable and — most importantly — one that will pass the Senate."
Thanks, Celinda, for those great buzzwords.
Both political parties are damaged goods. They are compromised, craven, and are almost non-functioning. The collapse of free market crony capitalism and bailouts of the banksters has made most Americans, left and right, justifiably mad as hell. It is our duty as citizens, community leaders, and citizen journalists to say "Enough". There will be no more business as usual.
Listen to Green Day. "Silence is the Enemy".
Footnote: The Montana Democratic Party Officers Convention is Saturday with cocktails Friday night with Max and Brian. Wish the Coalition luck.



20 Comments







RE strikes and boycotts; I’ve been pushing Larry Flynt’s strike idea, but no one at FDL or Seminal seems much interested.
And WTF is this banner about ‘Chat about Faith’ and ‘God’s purpose 4 my life’ doing on this website?
Yeh, what’s with the crickets regarding strikes?
Thanks for the link to the Flynt piece. It’s very good. I liked this:
I’m reading William Greider’s “Secrets of the Temple” and the callousness of the bankers in 1981-82 while farmers were committing suicide and there was “blood on the floor” is breathtaking. Farmers were part of the People’s Party populist movement in the 1880s and 1890s.
Not bad for uneducated farmers. But then the Progressives came along with their fixation with “experts” and politics as “science”. They were middle class and mostly urban and they pooh poohed the farmers. That’s why I can’t call myself a progressive. I’ve learned a lot being married to a rancher. We over educated middle class policy experts could use a good swift kick in the pants now and then. I’ve been humbled by being on a cattle ranch and watching things die on a daily basis whether it’s a cat catching a mouse or a hawk sweeping down catching the cat. For the first time I see myself as just part of a food chain and not necessarily on the top. I imagine some giant hand coming down and putting me on a spit.
But I digress. STRIKE!
A general strike may be just the thing.
Well said, MM.
This is so true:
“Both political parties are damaged goods.”
It often is just a battle for corporate money.
MM, I live in San Diego County and one thing I have noticed is that all the ‘trades’(meaning those jobs where one gets dirty and may end up with calluses on one’s hands) are now being ‘manned’ by those who are NOT white; very few caucasians are now involved in the ‘trades’.
Having spent some time in my youth on either a ranch or dairy farm, I concur with you re “over educated middle class policy experts could use a good swift kick in the pants now and then.”
And the technology ‘push’ does nothing but drive people away from that which is a lot bigger than the human race.
And those not familiar with Shay’s Rebellion which led to the Bill of Rights
montana maven – in case you haven’t heard this yet:
Tester: ‘I trust Max, wont fight for P.O.’
and thanks for all you in montana are doing in this fight – looks like you have your hands quite full
montanamaven and himmelstein rock!
“Thanks, Celinda, for those great buzzwords.” ah, indeed!
Thanks, mm. From that I assume you have read Kip Sullivan’s piece on THAT, too. Sent him a link to your blog. He’s a college classmate of mine, who I reconnected with via a chance comment at FDL.
Also thanks for highlighting the “mad as hell” docs. There’s been a lot of discussion about impact on patients, but, if I may quote an anonymous friend:
“(in addition to the impact on patients) I am really concerned about the effect the current system is having on the morale of docs and nurses.”
I gather that many are not willing to speak out, name names and give details, because…
“You rarely see honest descriptions of how insurers intimidate docs into denying services to patients, mainly because docs don’t want to get on the radar of the industry. The industry has been known to blackball trouble makers.”
I love Kip Sullivan. Made everything crystal clear to me. How great that he is a friend of yours. I think the Physicians being arrested in Baucus’ Senate hearings was the Rosa Parks moment of this health care movement. We need Doctors in the streets. I asked an ACLU lawyer if lawyers should have protested the Bush v. Gore Supreme Court decision like the Pakistani lawyers did by taking to the streets. He said, “Sadly, yes”. It just can’t be the same old activists. It is also sad that young people have not joined up much either. Maybe I’m wrong, but I don’t see many of them at the meetings and rallies.
Celinda Lake is from Montana and I wish she would retire. I am sick to death of public relations and marketing people telling politicos what to say. Wasn’t it Freud’s nephew that help start public relations. So now we have human resources instead of workers. We have Joe and Jean Six Pack instead of John and Jane Q. Public.
Here’s the link to Kip Sullivan’s pitch perfect explanation of the crap that’s coming from D.C. “Bait and Switch”
And here is Kip’s piece on pollster PR Celinda Lake. “Why Does Celinda Lake Oppose Single Payer?”
Yep- I had the same “crystal clear” aha reaction once I started reading Kip’s comments. The FDL comment that tipped me off actually mentioned that the commenter had just heard him give a presentation to a small group in MN, and how clear it was.
I don’t know if you’ve seen his bio, but it’s here:
http://www.amazon.com/Health-C…..038;sr=1-1
snip of that:
~~In 1986, COACT endorsed universal health insurance and appointed Mr. Sullivan as the campaign director for that issue. This assignment required Mr. Sullivan to develop a thorough understanding of the health-care crisis – not just its obvious symptoms, but its origins and the various proposals to solve it – and to explain the crisis to the average person. Since 1986, Mr. Sullivan has explained the health-care crisis and the debate about it to thousands of people, including members of religious organizations, unions, farm groups, political organizations, and legislators.~~
“Celinda Lake is from Montana and I wish she would retire. I am sick to death of public relations and marketing people telling politicos what to say.”
Alas, there’ll probably be another one to take her place.
And, as I read that Celinda Lake piece, she was a useful tool. HCAN is the root problem, the villain of the piece, imho. So, I’d go with “sick of politicos asking/ depending on PR and marketing people to tell them what to say.”
Oh, that aside, she was a useful tool because she was on board with massaging the data, “framing the debate”, without scruples or integrity.
You are way Kool!
i will second that!
Montanamaven:
Thank you for not mincing words and daring to confront the moment with courage, humanity, and substance.
This is the moment for bold and daring proposals.
We need to take large, adult-sized, not baby-steps.
The dearth of imagination and considered thought which has characterized the last several decades must be deliberately and intentionally ended.
DW
Great piece, MM. Good luck at the barricades; go get Baucus.
Also, I sense that all of us think getting marginalized in the health insurance reform debate is getting very old and increasingly unacceptable. We need to keep pushing for “Medicare for All” everyday.
Who knows what can happen. The Mad Doctors are coming, ideas for a general strike and a new party are circulating. MM and compatriots may move Baucus over to the left and give Tester pause. The truth about HR 3200 may begin to emerge for many people, and they may get good and mad that the PO won’t be available until 2013, and that even then it will be a choice you can make only if you have no other insurance.
I know it seems now that everything is arrayed against real change. But these politicians haven’t seen a real angry mass movement since the ’60s; they don’t know what it will feel like. And most of these folks don’t strike me as the type that will stand up well, when there’s real anger abroad in the land, rather than this phony, manufactured tea bagger stuff.
We have to get noisy. I heard second hand that a OFA person was on the phone call with Baucus the chairs and thought we “were rude”. In response to Gabriele, we cannot let party officious officials use the “rude” and “shrill” trick. Our representatives are disrespectful to us and it’s got to stop. I am on my way to the State Officers convention in Bozeman. The last one I went to was pretty disgusting with arm twisting and threats because the liberal wing of the party ran a candidate not approved by the elected leaders. It really opened my eyes to the sorry mess. That was in 2005 and that’s when I started looking for other ways to make change. Our weekly radio show gets more and more listeners and we have focused on health care for 5 years in preparation for this fight.
I bought 10 copies of “Sicko”. A Republican young couple watched it the other night. They are seriously thinking of moving to Canada because it’s just across the border and not far from their relatives in Montana. They had to also admit France looked the best but was too far away.
Talking in bars and cafes to conservatives works. I had a Republican say to me last night that he was “disconsolate” about this health care debate. He thought the Democrats would fix it. We Democrats have failed Americans and I want no part of such a party if they/we screw this up.
But today I go to Bozeman and will not back down. I will respectfully but forcefully stand my ground on Medicare for All. This will be in the face of, quite frankly, misogyny and bullying by large red faced men.
I am so tired of being yelled at by of all things family members, who shout and yell at me when I try to correct their misinformation, demanding to know where I got my information, and that unless I got it from Fox News or other such “reputable sources” I cannot possibly prove to them that my information is, in fact, correct. Are we men or mice? How come these right wing extremists are able to get their message across, yet we sit around impotently, sending messages to each other. What is needed here? I do not wish to become a deranged right wing nut, but are we perhaps being too logical, and polite? Please help me out here, as I am beginning to feel a little crazy myself. I read the constitution once again today, and came to the conclusion that it really only mentions the post office, roads, and the military. Does this mean in the minds of the people screaming about socialism that we should abolish all government programs, including Medicare, Social Security, etc., in order to return to happier times? What are we going to do, other than spending many hours at our laptops, stroking out. Any ideas, anyone, please!
The traits of a good society have been measured. As it works out, Scandinavian socialist countries rate highest on those beneficial traits. The USA doesn’t rate anywhere near third place on any of those traits. I know you knew that. We continually let words like, ’socialism’, scare us witless. It is very clear that socialized medicine is working well all over the world. It is also clear that medicine for profit is killing our country. What can we do, what will we do?