Last week we focused on how we are observed in our travels across the information superhighway. Everywhere we go, companies gather and use information about us: they watch what we do, collect information about us, aggregate it, and then use it to target us with ads.
A generation ago, web pages were merely formatted text, albeit colorful and occasionally even informative. Today’s web pages are collections of content, ads, and tracking mechanisms that can talk to one another. The web rapidly is becoming an interconnected aggregation of trackers and bugs.
From The Nation article on microtargeting,
If you’re logged in to Facebook, Twitter, Google or Amazon, it’s safe to say these sites are tracking and retaining everything you’re doing on their sites and on any other sites that host their scripts and widgets. It’s how they make recommendations: for friends, products, events. … A newspaper’s website may know all the visitors to its site, but it knows nothing about their activities elsewhere. Its advertisers might, however, and Google Analytics certainly does: it offers a wide array of services to websites, tracking where users are coming from and what they search for before arriving at a page, all behind a slick interface. In exchange, Google gets to see the entire history of a site’s access logs. Google Analytics and similar services … are so ubiquitous that most of your web browsing is likely captured by one or more of these companies. They don’t have your name, but they have your IP address, rough physical location and a good chunk of your activity online.
Far more information has been collected than has been put to use, and the purposes to which it has been put have not always been visible to consumers. There is the danger of your personal information being sold, resold or otherwise distributed so that deleting it becomes practically impossible. If this data is your personal profile, more than simply knowledge of your consumer habits is available for discovery.
An article in Digital Trends, Top 100 websites: How they track your every move online, published in August 2012, highlights the biggest companies that track you, what they do, and how you can (sometimes) avoid the tracking.
In total, about 125 different companies or company products are used to track your online activity through the top 100 sites. Many of these are simple advertising networks — but others are particularly nefarious. To get a better sense of what each of these companies are, I reached out to attorney Sarah Downey, a privacy strategist for Abine, which created Do Not Track Plus [now DoNotTrackMe].
If you’re interested in the topic, do read the whole article; it contains good info, and links to a free download of DoNotTrackMe as well as “delete me” and “mask me” tools.
The value of this collection of data is frequently thought of only in terms of selling us stuff. Fine-grained targeting of online ads is invasive and more than a little creepy, but usually not dangerous. But other uses of that data are equally creepy and can be dangerous, too!
For example, your FICO credit score is calculated by a secret formula that uses your payment history, credit types and use, length of your credit history, and recent searches for your credit rating by third parties. But FICO is silent on what information it uses, or its source. Nothing prevents your Internet browsing activity from figuring into this calculation if credit bureaus are able to obtain it.
Your profile can reveal all sorts of healthy — or unhealthy — habits to insurance companies, like your gym memberships, bar tabs, poor diet, serious illnesses, time spent on dating websites, or interest in recreational drugs or certain social activities. If you “like” the Alzheimer’s Association, or a Gold’s Gym, or a local bar, for example, it won’t just be advertisers who might take notice. And if there are errors in your profile, you won’t know about those either, or have the chance to correct them. You won’t know why your insurance premiums are so high or your credit application was turned down.
Finally, there is the government, as you might expect. The National Security Agency, Department of Homeland Security and FBI already collect a huge amount of information on Internet activity. Dana Priest and William Arkin exposed the extent of collecting in Top Secret America: The Rise of the New American Security State. Most of the data was simply a vast stockpile of information on ordinary people, collected with a huge dragnet and permanently filed away because there was no pressing reason to delete it. Once your profile is created and shared among companies, the entities that know your behavioral patterns and day-by-day online and offline activity will only grow, and you’ll be helpless to corral it. You had no say in your profile’s collection or sale, but it is a resource that can be put to use in both benign and dangerous ways. You would not even know that your profile is being turned over to the government, just as you probably didn’t realize it was being created.
Next week, I’ll wrap up with the (mostly worthless) privacy promises companies make about their activities, and how we can deal with what’s in store for the future. As the Nation article suggests,
…few people end up leaving Facebook. All of your friends are there, being watched and anonymized as they “friend” and watch you, all of them doing, in the words of Joseph Turow, “free labor in the interest of corporate profits.”



89 Comments

OK, the doors are open, c’mon over!!
Thank you….will have to read the Intro later. Glad it worked.
Thanks, RevBev. We all seem to be able to jump right in and chat without much coaxing, but I hated to see all the work go to waste if the post was really gone.
Please come back to read.
Rabbit, rabbit. Now to read the post.
I have noticed that if I make a comment on FB that is oriented toward some kind of content (for example a FB friend was talking about elder care facitities the other day, and I made a comment) that I get e-mail about elder care facilities afterwards. So I figured there is tracking to that. Incredible.
I missed the OE chat yesterday for the most part, if ysd stops in, I made a very late comment to her and was sorry I missed the day. I have not been able to go back and read all the comments, gotta get to it some time later.
I don’t mind being mined. I get off on being scary to tptb.
Standard comment on Facebook, et al: If you’re offered something for free, you’re not the customer. You are the product.
Boxturtle (Never on facebook. Never going to be on facebook)
You don’t scare them. If they think you’re scary, they’ll try to sell you things scary people would find useful. Duct tape, handcuffs, chloroform, ammo, etc.
Boxturtle (Even scary people are consumers)
Now getting an ad for “Ever Been Arrested”, thanks, msmolly. *snort*
Background checks used to be done in my neighborhood (next to IBM and around the corner from NSA) by hired agents asking things like Do you know if he drives under the influence often? I actually made a neighbor unhappy by refusing to answer this sort of question when he was applying for a job he wanted.
I think Facebook is one of the top trackers (as is Google). And Facebook keeps looking for ways to “monetize” us. Have you noticed the offer to “promote” (not sure if it’s someTHING or someONE) at a cost of $7?
Mine me, baby.
If you’re not on facebook, how do you know what the standard comment is?
I am on Facebook because I was informed by my son a couple of years ago that if I wanted to “see” my older grandkids, that’s where they are. So I usually go to FB about once a day, usually just scroll through the posts. My son and daughter sometimes post photos or video clips of my grandkids (for example, the junior playing a sax solo at state competition or the 10 yr. old scoring a basket in her game).
I rarely post anything.
Google is not the only purveyor of your activity.
So, Ruth’s the only one who responded to my query about tomorrow’s topic. Guess I’m on my own.
Hey
!
He means the standard comment about Facebook.
Figured that’d get a rise outta ya.
Just teasing. I’m too far away, and I’ve already got a great miner. And, I’m not into Sharing either. :)
Morning, msmolly! Morning ‘pups! Morning demi!
I have a response ~ just took me some time to get here and start talking!
I like ‘Some of my favorite things.’
It seems early for ‘Spring cleaning’ …. and frankly, for me, that ship sailed a long time ago. Need more sunlight to even deal with the idea! LOL. But I’ll try to stop by no matter what you choose!
Because it’s my standard comment about facebook. I can see where my statement above could be interpreted as “What I usually say when I’m on facebook”.
Boxturtle (Englitch *sigh*)
Morning pups,
Several irons in the fire today. Noticed that FDL page tab indicator is continually uploading as if the page will never finish fully loading. Also noticed that if I refresh a page, that instead of coming back to the comment I refreshed from, it will sometimes bump me up to the middle of the list. Yesterday while reading beyond comment #150, I would page refresh and I continually got bumped up to about comment #70.
Thanks, Reader. I’ve been wanting to do Favorite Things for a while, so I’ll go with that. See you then.
Well, I’m rarely around when that post is made, so I figured I’d keep my mouth shut.
Were it me, would probably discuss winter pet care. And preparing for flea season.
Boxturtle (Will someday invent a doggie dryer/footcleaner that attaches to a pet door)
I have noticed that as well. Blocking the twitter links worked for me last time.
Boxturtle (Twitter tracks just like Google, I think)
Thank you, BT. I figured your fingers weren’t broken and you’d explain.
My daughter lives far far away from me and she can facebook photos of places she’s been or something she bought. It’s nice.
I also have a good friend who moved from LA to Europe and I enjoying chats with him and some of his super smart friends. Also, get to see photos from him too.
It’s okay that some people like FB and some don’t It’s a pretty big world.
Too late. I’m going with Favorite Things because it’s a really wide topic and encourages a Positive attitude. Good for a Saturday morning.
But, thanks hon. I don’t have much to say about winter pet care other than dog and cat in, dog and cat out. :)
I haven’t had the page load problem, but I noticed the refresh thing yesterday, had to keep scrolling back down to the bottom of the comments.
And I’ve been seeing a lot of page (mis)redirects the past week or so.
And of course I can insist that I didn’t change the publish time, but of course I probably did — by accident. No ghosts in this machine.
Read the article I linked to from Digital Trends when you have a chance. It is amazing who does the tracking and linking.
I am going to look into installing that “DoNotTrackMe” tool when I have time. I block ads with AdBlock Plus which, according to a very techie friend, MAY block the remote server from getting the ad request and thereby tracking you. I always thought it just blocked the ads from my view, but apparently that’s not all it can do.
That would be the doggie wash door, doggie retina scan opens door, pup sees/smells (favorite meat) at end of tunnel, walks through wash and blow dry, final brush and vac before getting into the house. I here it is being tested for roll out in June.
Hear for here.
Later everyone. Couple of places opening for business and I have a couple of calls to make.
Many folks LIKE being tracked. Sometimes I like being tracked. Kroger tracks me via their shoppers card, but my benefit is that every so often they send me a bunch of coupons tailored to me. Exactly the brands I buy, exactly what I buy and they’re GOOD coupons. It’s like finding money.
Otoh, I signed up with AARP and my mailbox promptly exploded with offers for insurance and retirement spots.
Boxturtle (And AARP is robocalling me!)
When ysd comes by this also came to mind in re: the coffee bags. A couple of other views are at “previous” so click back.
I also saw some very pricey butterfly chair covers made from similar fabrics, and if I can find it, one of the high end catalogs had chairs made from it, like director’s chair covers, which are very simple construction and I think would be fab with the coffee bags.
I run an http server on my PC. Anything directed to anything I have blocked in my hosts file gets dropped before it even hits the router. And the server “responds” to the web page so it thinks it has served me an ad and doesn’t wait. Anything from one of the blocked sites gets the bit bucket without further ado.
I’ll get through all the links eventually. Just not there yet.
Boxturtle (They know who you are and they saw what you did)
My only concern with using coffee bags for chairs (with nothing supporting the seat, as in a directors or butterfly chair) is that I assume the cloth is loosely woven and fairly flexible, and might stretch out with very little sitting on. But I haven’t seen the bags up close, so my notion of the fabric of a bag may be wildly off.
ARGH! I’ll have the patent filed by noon and the lawsuit on your doorstep before close of business Monday.
Boxturtle (That said, LMK if you get it working and I’ll write you a check)
I figured you hadn’t — I don’t expect everyone to read all of the stuff, and the doors opened late today anyway. But that site is particularly interesting, when you have time.
I’m off to get some things accomplished.
Thanks for this, Molly.
Back from starting lunch/early dinner in the crockpot, and yes, getting coupons for stuff you like is all good. My Kroger card is one of several I have taken, for places I shop, that track by what I buy and send them to my email. As does my bank issued credit card.
Three busy signals and one put on hold… I’d have to get a dog first, to be motivated.
Ooops, I mean debit card, which I use as credit occasionally for the rewards.
Good Morning Ms Molly and Firedogs -
I am behind on a project – so just a drive by Howdy
hope everyone has a good day
this week’s adventure in sugar:
Spidey and Venom cookies for a nephew
Easter prototypes
prototype detail
oh and p.s. – dear oldnslow went with me to the big cake show – as some of you know, he is a lifelong racing fan, but took his girl to the cake show on NASCAR’S biggest day – ah’m keepin’ him !
There is no doubt he is a keeper, cbl! We kinda like him here, too!
I’m gonna consider him taking you to the cake show to be enlightened self interest. :-)
Boxturtle (Absolutely nothing bad can come from accompanying one’s spouse to a cake show)
There is a keeper, indeed, give him some sugar, or icing, whichever is handy.
LOL! That’s the spirit!
I am having that refresh problem again that Nonq mentioned upthread. When I refresh at the end of comments, it plops me back to about mid-thread. Minor nuisance.
Here is more coffee bag upholstery. You know, we could do this for the Over Easy booths.
I have noticed that too, recently, but not today, it seems …
Oh, those are really nice! Very graphic and modern. Amazing. We should do that for the booths.
I was just looking around, and there is a blog on how to print/paint your own coffee graphics on burlap to get the look, ysd should just sell the bags and let people have at it, apparently it is a look people want. I am wondering if I should do that on my own DR chairs, I keep them covered to keep the cats from ruining them.
Oh yeah, my perfect cats do scratch and shed their fur everywhere, so I keep my furniture covered. I could use some coffee bags.
True, only if one does not have a wt problem; but Im assuming
there are samples…
Also burlap bags are useful for starting seed, like a lawn. You can lay them over the bare ground when it’s seeded, water lightly, leave for a few days, remove while grass is barely sprouts.
There is something that looks like burlap that the parks people put here, for example along a new paved bike path, that covers newly seeded areas. They just leave it and it rots away, I think.
Seen that but don’t know what it is, there are seeding blankies too that just are absorbed into the soil while they start your garden.
demi,
I second the suggestion of reader at #19 for “Some of my favorite things.” Sounds like a very interesting topic as are all the posts here at Over Easy and PUAC.
Looking forward to the post.
Coolio. Gracias, senor.
(Am getting myself into the proper head place to write, right now.)
demi, you funny.
I aim to please.
The world just feels better when we’re smiling, don’t you think?
Thanks for the picture.
With me, a picture is worth a thousand words.
Smiles are much better.
That is actually my e-mail handle Smiles@…
Okay, okay. I am procrastinating.
Fact, if you add up the comments from both of this morning’s Over Easies, we now have over 100 comments.
Just saying.
I gotta get out of here and get some work done today.
msmolly, thank you again for the post and you never need to worry about a glitch in the system. You covered it really well today.
Sweet!
Now, that is another interesting topic or theme. Is there a story behind each of our handles, assuming it’s something other than a name.
Thanks again, Mr. Canyon. I just put that idea on my bulletin board. Must keep PUAC topics for future.
Gotta scoot out, peeps. Odd morning here with the post mixup, but fun as always. I will look in again later to see if our latecomers have put in an appearance.
*poof* for now!
I blame Obama.
Boxturtle (well, SOMEBODY had to say it)
You love to play the brat, doncha BT? :)
These crises wouldn’t happen if only we could get tort reforms to pass. Or lower taxes.
Ahhh. An upside down egg cookie cutter to make Spikey and Ninja cookies. Brilliant. Easter cookies cute too.
Those are cute. I’ve seen upholstered ottomans that are really da bomb. I’m not sure how comfortable those chairs would be to sit on, though, because burlap coffee bags are scratch and unpleasant to the touch. They can be washed and softened, but then the ink deteriorates.
Here’s some fun ottomans covered in bags.
http://www.google.com/search?q=burlap+ottoman&hl=en&tbm=isch&tbo=u&source=univ&sa=X&ei=MwYxUY7fCMffqAGgjYGABg&sqi=2&ved=0CFQQsAQ&biw=1007&bih=512
I’d rather put my feet on the burlap than my delicate bottom. Heh.
Lampshades!
If you’re concerned, use
Startpage
to search, same results as google, but no tracking.
I’ve been looking online and found ideas for rugs, table runners, framed as art, and of course, pillows and totes!
So sorry to be late. Migraine. Took pharmacy 4 hours to fill Imitrex, b/c the Rx was a transfer. Can just now read, so can’t wait to see the discussion. I enjoy Friday. Your ideas are so interesting. I thought about addressing Facebook Graphs, but did not feel I had enough into.
iito should read info. I can read but cannot type, apparently.
The joker in the deck, LOL! What happened this morning, with post mix-up? I missed it. Better read the thread!
I’m so sorry to hear about your migraine. I have them too, and Imitrex is a lifesaver. That is awful it took so long to be filled, as you well know the sooner you can take it, the better…hope you continue to feel better!
Yes, it is. While Fred was out getting it, I have some nightmarish paranoid thoughts along the lines of what would happen if people developed resistance to Imitrex. I’d die badly, going down in flames, bleeding from my eyeballs. I’m sure of it.
Think I understand that there was a glitch. So sorry, and I get the panic that sets in, like that time we lost our broadband connection and did not get it back until, like, 30 minutes before the post was due. It’s a sick feeling, but good that it worked out.
On my drive today I was thinking that the coffee bags could also be put together to make a sun shade, also a sort of blind on a fence or attached to wire fencing, not chain link but flat wire. They used army canvas tarps at El Cosmico in Marfa to make the “walls” outdoors for the showers/bathrooms. It was totally cool. Anyway, I think they could be used nicely outdoors, and also maybe as a structure for keeping spring plants sheltered. Curtains too, I suppose. Or framed on room divider indoors or outdoors to make a private area.
But I guess we can move on from the coffee bags now. Cranking.
I have a Facebook page but I rarely visit, because I don’t care for FB much. Prefer Twitter.
Lord, what an image (((C-S)))
Back at you (((Om))). From one who understands.
Bliss be to you all.
Or, at least non-painful wishes for you all.
I’ve only experienced migranes when I was going through meno-youknow-pause.
What’s the pause?
I just had a conversation with my sister about that phase. Good to have a sister, or at least, a friend to talk to. It’s challenging to experience physical changes and it helps to talk about about it with someone you care and trust.
Mine was a surgical menopause. Very strange experience, in the end I chose not to use hormones. Remember being tired, and also remember some bizarre, out-of-the-blue heat attacks. They weren’t flashes. They lasted a while.
I haven’t taken a single hormone.
Just the herbal stuff. Ain’t fun, but then, what the heck is?
Oh! I’m sounding negative and I don’t want to do that.
Eh, or m’eh, whatever. We deal with what we have.
And, dance with it too! Ha.
PS, Rachel, I’m sorry you had to have that surgical menopause. I’ve known several girls who had to do that. Not fair. But, most of it isn’t.
Hug.
Oh, it’s not a bad thing, it was actually a relief. My son was 11, I knew he was all I would have; I was 34.
Well, I’m glad it worked out well for you, in any event.
((You))