As every fan of American professional football knows, the NFL lockout of its professional referees has ended. Most of the coverage has focused on the veritable plethora of truly horrendous calls, starting with a fumble clearly recovered by my beloved Broncos during a Monday night game, but ruled Atlanta’s ball. Even a Raiders fan posted on ESPN’s website that the Broncos “got screwed.” If a Raiders fan thinks THAT, it must be true.
Then things just got exponentially worse, culminating in the “Fail Mary” Seahawks pass that was clearly intercepted by a Packer, but ruled a Seattle touchdown by either bewildered or partisan refs, take your pick. Howls of outrage permeated the airwaves and the blogosphere. Even fanatical anti-union folks like Scott Walker and Paul Ryan called for an end of the lockout, effectively supporting a union. As Wendy Davis would say, “My stars!”
The amount of money in dispute, some 30 million dollars a year, max, for the ref’s’ pensions is pocket change to billionaire NFL owners(with the exception of Green Bay, which is owned by a couple of hundred thousand season-ticket holders. How socialist of them!) This wasn’t about money. It was about power. First, break the referee union, then target the players down the road. The players, who now get about 50% of NFL revenue(and why not? It is their labor that makes the game a success, is it not?) knew this as well as the refs and the owners did.
So, just yesterday, some Green Bay Packers players tweeted that if the real refs weren’t brought back right now, that the Packers just might refuse to take the field this Sunday. Players from other teams hinted that they might just stage a sympathy strike(source: NPR’s All Things Considered yesterday). And, just a few hours later, Hey Presto! Tentative agreement reached! Lockout ends! The real refs will be on the field for tonight’s game in Baltimore, thereby probably ending the Browns’ best hope for a victory, but that’s another story.
The M$M is telling us that the reason for the end of the lockout was that even the owners were horrified by the atrocious play-calling even as they deny that players’ safety was ever in jeopardy. Commissioner Roger Goodell even issued this apology to NFL fans:
http://espn.go.com/nfl/story/_/id/8431573/roger-goodell-apologizes-fans-replacement-refs
and then said all of the publicity was good for the league. Not a peep from him or most of the media about the very real threat the players were starting to make. If the players had gone on a sympathy strike, that would have hit the owners’ pocketbooks HARD. Hence the quick settlement.
There’s a lesson here for all of us who want fundamental change brought to our corporatist economic and power structure. It takes power to challenge power. The NFL players threatened to take away the means of production from the capitalist bastards who own all but one NFL team, and those bastards caved post-haste to save their profits.
There’s only three things that work on those people, threats to their profits, their liberty, or their lives. That’s it. Moral suasion doesn’t work, for they have none. It is well past time for everyone who isn’t happy with the current system to learn that fundamental fact.



21 Comments

Excellent diary entry, OB -
Highly rec’d!
Media coverage did an amazing job of tip-toeing around the fact that the referees were missing due to a labor dispute involving actors such management, employees, a union, negotiations, a lock out and so on. It was as if the refs just sort of went away one day and we had a sad and now because a pass didn’t get intercepted, the refs are back and we are happy.
I think some of those MSM types would choke before they used the U word, espcially in a context where the U wins.
That’s definitely true. But who gives the MSM type their talking orders? Certainly not the U people(pun intended).
That’s for the, uh, “post-game wrap up.” I only know the basics, as I’m not a football fan, but I was well aware that the gazillionaire owners took this opportunity to break the balls of the Refs on their pensions, cuz: why not? Let the Refs take all the risk with their 401 (k) plans, whilst also giving the gazillionaire crooks on Wall St yet more “funny money” to play with.
You’re right about how to deal with the 1%. None of ‘em gives a flying fuck about something trifling like “morals” or “ethics” or “caring for others.” Those psycopaths crack up when bullshit nonsense like that is spoken aloud. Who cares?
That said, seems to me (and I claim ignorance mostly) that the Refs still got a raw deal in the end. My understanding is that the current crop of Refs, plus some new hires for the next 4 years (?), get the defined benefit plan for life, but after that, new hires will be shafted with a 401 (k) plan. The so-called “victory” seems a bit hollow to me – correct me if I’m wrong. Looks to me like the Union, in the long run, caved to their gazillionaire masters. For which I’m sorry. I think this could’ve played out differently, and I don’t feel like doing a victory dance over this, speaking just for myself.
Thanks for your usual good analysis, though.
Oh, I didn’t intend this as a victory dance. I don’t know all of the details, though I have heard that the refs, or at least new ones, will be forced to give up the traditional pension plan in favor of 401K’s.
In that scheme of things, this was at best a successful delaying action. Still, it WAS a useful illustration of how to apply real power.
I’m glad you straightened this out because i thought the Bosses in Vegas were taking out contracts on the NFL Bosses for messing with their books. Did anyone notice any horses missing their heads?
Heh! Well, I heard the Vegas bookies lost about 15 million on the Fail Mary pass. If this had kept up, I’m sure pressure from that sector of the ruling class would have mounted.
However, the timing of the settlement, so quickly after the mere mention of a possible sympathy strike, seems more than coincidental to me. And I’m one of those people who believes coincidence is more common than dirt.
Lesson learned? Imagine- if the Chicago teachers had been joined by..oh.. every other local educator’s union in the country.. and even joined by every other public labor group (police, fire, administrative, etc..) and then every other laboring group private too???????????? It is stand or sit isn’t it? Solidarity means power as you state. thanks.
Fuck the fucking fucks, this was ALL about busting down unions, salaries and more, as you said.
Let’s all make sure we get it, and repeat it.
End of story.
Highly rcc’d.
yes, I agree with that. OTOH, I still think the Union caved, which is unfortunate.
Problem is: most US citizens, often including Union members, are pretty much doing eff all about the slow to fast erosion of our rights, including having defined benefit plans. For whatever reason, citizens willingly drink the Kool Aid that defined benefit plans are not sustainable and/or are “unfair” and/or the citizens getting them should not be getting them blah blah blah… I hear it far too much, and as I said: OFTEN from union members who, themselves, are getting a defined benefit pension.
I wish that the NFL Ref strike had had more traction in the news, albeit it’s for sure that our rightwing propoganda wurlitzer did its best to suppress what was happening and then play to the audience, who just got pissed off bc the games weren’t ref’ed well. No one bothered to really figure out WHY this was important (other than places like FDL).
So enough for now. Thanks for your insights. This does show how solidarity CAN and should work for all workers. Sadly I think that lesson is pretty much lost on the bulk of US workers today, who are too willing to sell out both themselves & other workers.
sigh…
Interesting… I hadn’t thought of that side of the equation. I tend to agree that the strike was settled more due to other pressures, but you make a good point about the bookies. That’s the other side of sports – the big giant buck$$$ made on gambling – that I & most others often forget.
For sure the bookies must’ve been making some noises. I can’t believe they would’ve just shrugged it off.
I can’t find the link, but somebody somewhere said that the scab refs were the best thing that has happened to the previously despised real refs since Ed Hochuli started wearing short sleeves.
This bit of news surfaced yesterday as well: Seattle/Green Bay scab ref poster child Lance Easley turns out to be even worse of a douchebag in real life. He’s a BofA VP with three, yes THREE, whole days of college football training. He needs to be flagged for unnecessary stupidness. These guys would have done a better job.
Rec’d and thank you for making a point that the MSM is trying very hard NOT to report.
ROFLMAO, the SNL skit in that last link above is sponsored by . . . Bank of America.
I think the league couldn’t stand the BULLSHIT chant, loud and in unison, at this weeks games. It would have been universal .
The umps should have stood for more then themselves in facing down the 1%ers.
I’m a little wary of calling this a great union victory or even seeing it relates to the working class at all. These guys are more of a highly paid professional sports guild who make upwards of 100k for a part time job.
If the strike had continued i doubt we would have seen Joan Baez singing I Dreamed I Saw Joe Hill for them.
Yeah – everything is relative. But football fans of all political persuasions get that NFL owners are some seriously greedy, immoral mofo’s and that the refs’ salaries were a pittance compared to their profits. If that kind of example (frivolous and elitist as it may be) reminds or educates them about more important labor issues, that’s not a bad thing.
Just FYI, the bookies really don’t give a crap about poor referees unless people stop betting on the game. If people keep betting, it’s just one more variable to take into account, and the big money bookies do a way better job of analyzing all of the variables than the general public. It’s true that they could have lost money on Monday Night (because, despite many who claim to the contrary, books that have deep bets will often have more money on one side as long as the point spread is fair), but it isn’t true that they would be upset about this. Supposedly 150 million changed hands on the Fail Mary, but the bookies still get their cut and there are a lot of happy people too!
I completely agree that the bookies coulda given a crap about the Refs and their pensions and whatever.
I have NO clue how the gambling business works, so I’m ignorant. But the issue about the Refs making lousy & incorrect calls potentially having a negative impact on the big book-makers? Well, I could see some pressure coming to bear to “correct” the situation (maybe), but NOT bc the bookies give a crap about any worker, whether they’re a Ref or a player. It would only be about the money.
Just an interesting sidelight, that’s all.
I hope no one is naive enough to believe the NFL or any other sport either at the college level or the pro level is free from Mob influence.
This is Amerika and the whole fucking place is corrupt.
Good analysis of the labor power issues.
But I think that screwing up the calls on a major game that resulted in some folks having to pay out bets likely also put some pressure on the owners.
Oh absolutely. This whole thing was about ball busting. In the end, that’s what the whole friggin political economy is about. The refs vs. the zillionaire owners is a microcosm.