• About us
  • Advertise
  • Contact Us
  • Send Comments/Tips
  • My FDL
  • Firedoglake
  • News
  • TBogg
  • La Figa
  • Book Salon
  • FDL Action
  • The Dissenter
  • Pam's House Blend
  • Elections
  • FDL TV
  • Just Say Now
« Dear Tim,
Al Gore to Georgia »
User Picture

HCAN

By: Ari Tuesday November 18, 2008 12:13 pm

TweetTweet
digg stumbleupon

comment on this1 Comment Recommend

One Response to HCAN

  1. selise November 19th, 2008 at 4:22 am «

    Ari – i hope you see this comment, because HCAN is a con. i used to think it was just a way to provide electoral support but i was wrong. i’ve been posting about this in the comments at the mothership, maybe i should write a diary about it too. anyway, here is my take, modified from a comment made a few days ago:

    …

    i think we’re going to have to fight the dems on this one – just take a look at the HCAN ads that have been running here and everywhere. while i’m glad they are giving fdl $, they are also selling a big con. as i’ve said before, it’s goal is to manipulate expectations so that party leaders can craft halfway measures that have corporate support (insurance and pharmaceutical companies) without antagonizing the voting public too much. this is the essence of clinton’s third way that has now become so central to Democratic party governance and something that we’ve got to work to change if we’re going to be able to advance workable solutions to the problems we face.

    the single payer story is that conyers introduced a bill for single payer in 2003 (38 cosponsors), 2005 (78 cosponsors) and 2007 (93 cosponsors). each time there have been a lot more cosponsors and the work of groups like Healthcare-Now (HC-N!) and Physicians for a National Health Program (PNHP) have been working for years (HC-N! since 2003 and PNHP since 1987!) to educate and push for single payer was paying off.

    but there was a slight problem this year. the democratic presidential candidates proposed health care plans that were a far cry from single payer.

    so… a bunch of “progressive” organizations got together and pooled resources ($40 million) to start a “grass roots” campaign they call “Health Care for America NOW!” (HCAN – i’m sure there was no intention to confuse people by choosing a name so similar to the single payer advocates’ organization /s). they came up with a set of “principles” that don’t require single payer and asked us to lobby congress to support it. we did. congress pretended to respond – obama signed up on oct 6. i used to think the whole thing was just a way to give electoral support to dems – but now that all these ads are running after the election i see that’s not the case. this must really be about health care reform – so they can do what they (and their industry supporters) want to do while pretending that they are responding to the people.

    the whole thing stinks and a lot of good people got suckered. i hope it isn’t successful in preventing us from advocating for single payer.

« Dear Tim,
Al Gore to Georgia »

Help the Occupy Supply Fund continue to support more than 60 occupations across the country!

$202,345.00 RAISED
$191,293.71 SPENT

Last updated 2/15

100% of donations committed to the occupations served by Occupy Supply

Welcome to FDL

Login to Firedoglake and participate in our community.

Not a member? Create an account.

Toolbox

Explore
Find Diaries Find People
Site Activity Find Groups

About MyFDL

MyFDL is the community site of progressive political blog Firedoglake. Anyone can participate by writing a diary, commenting on others’ diaries, or joining groups to find other people in your area. Content posted to MyFDL is the opinion of the author alone, and should not be attributed to Firedoglake.

» More about MyFDL.

» MyFDL Comment Moderation.

» NEW: Report site problems and bugs.

MYFDL RECOMMENDED DIARIES
  • Video: DUI Checkpoint Refusal, Know Your Rights, Protect the Fourth
    By: jbade 1 Comments
  • MONSANTO Found Guilty of Poisoning French Farmer : Breaking Good News!
    By: Robert Alexander Dumas 2 Comments
  • Chris Hedges, the black bloc's not the problem, capitalism is.
    By: GA_spoken 16 Comments
  • The Million Dollar Question: What Happened to the $10K OWS Donation
    By: tobiasfox 0 Comments
  • Atrazine: A "Molecular Bull in a China Shop"
    By: Rebekah Wilce 4 Comments
  • Rocky Anderson On Real News
    By: Michael Cavlan RN 1 Comments
  • At CPAC, Romney's Calls for Cutting Social Security and Medicare Rankle Conservative Rank-and-File
    By: Daniel Marans 1 Comments
  • Homage to the people of Greece - Αφιέρωμα στους ανθρώπους της Ελλάδα
    By: David Seaton 4 Comments
  • What's the Matter with Chisago County?
    By: Eric Laursen 2 Comments
  • Want Guns With Your Grande at Starbucks?
    By: spocko 58 Comments
Follow @Firedoglake

Subscribe to Firedoglake RSS

» More FDL feeds

News. Community. Activism.

Firedoglake is a member-supported organization.
Help us continue our work for as little as $45/year.

MYFDL RECENT DIARIES
  • Rocky Anderson On Real News
    By: Michael Cavlan RN 1 Comments
  • MONSANTO Found Guilty of Poisoning French Farmer : Breaking Good News!
    By: Robert Alexander Dumas 2 Comments
  • Catholics and Contraception: Letters From the Laity Paint a Very Different Picture Than the Bishops Want You to See
    By: RHRealityCheck 0 Comments
  • At CPAC, Romney's Calls for Cutting Social Security and Medicare Rankle Conservative Rank-and-File
    By: Daniel Marans 1 Comments
  • PA Must Reads: Delaying School Construction Penny Wise and Pound Foolish
    By: ThirdandState 0 Comments
  • Lawyer With Ties to GOP Turns Up Dead at Construction Site
    By: RogerShuler 0 Comments
  • Video: DUI Checkpoint Refusal, Know Your Rights, Protect the Fourth
    By: jbade 1 Comments
  • Ari Berman: The Politics of the Super Rich
    By: Tom Engelhardt 0 Comments
  • Homage to the people of Greece - Αφιέρωμα στους ανθρώπους της Ελλάδα
    By: David Seaton 4 Comments
  • One + One = Two (Not Too Wonkish)
    By: letsgetitdone 0 Comments
  • Faithful America and Bishop Gene Robinson Deliver 20,000 Petition Signatures to MSNBC
    By: NSementelli 1 Comments
  • Watercooler: Walk Off The Earth
    By: Kelly Canfield 2 Comments
  • Mormons! I Smite Thee in the Name of Common Sense
    By: Omnipotent Poobah 2 Comments
  • Want Guns With Your Grande at Starbucks?
    By: spocko 58 Comments
  • Atrazine: A "Molecular Bull in a China Shop"
    By: Rebekah Wilce 4 Comments
  • The Million Dollar Question: What Happened to the $10K OWS Donation
    By: tobiasfox 0 Comments
  • Newark, NJ Police Evicts Occupy Newark
    By: tobiasfox 0 Comments
  • What's the Matter with Chisago County?
    By: Eric Laursen 2 Comments
  • Obama's tax reform/loophole closing does neither as lower Corporate taxes added to no Clinton tax rate return
    By: papau 2 Comments
  • Houston, Let's Address This Problem
    By: Mike 1 Comments
  • Amazing Diary at Kos by Donovan and Holder re Settlement
    By: janeeyresick 21 Comments
  • 2012 is Make or Break (the Planet) for Dirty Duke Energy
    By: Philip Radford 9 Comments
  • The Nephew from Hell: Edward Bernays and the science of American bullsh*t
    By: David Seaton 5 Comments
  • What is Occupy? [OWS Visits OccupyBuffalo]
    By: SueMarie 1 Comments
  • Casey Mulligan Has Another Head Scratcher On Unemployment Insurance
    By: Dean Baker 2 Comments

Read More »

Home  |  Advertise  |  RSS Feed  |  Register  |  Login  |  Subscribe to updates  |  WordPress  |  About  |  Contact  |  Privacy
MyFDL
  • Log In
  • Create a Firedoglake Account
  • ?