One of the first fruits of the poison tree that is the Roberts Court’s Citizens United ruling is the creation of the business-funded group MN Forward, the allegedly "bipartisan" outfit whose actual political leanings may be divined by the following evidence: Its head honcho is none other than Brian McClung, who less than two months ago was the deputy chief of staff for Minnesota’s outgoing Republican governor Tim Pawlenty; and its first TV ads have been for Republican gubernatorial candidate Tom Emmer, who is essentially Pawlenty without the mullet and even less humanity, which is of course why he (with teabagger support) beat out the somewhat less blatantly evil Marty Seifert for the Republican nomination, even though Seifert, the RPM’s favored candidate, was expected to walk away with the nod.
But a funny thing happened on the way to buying yet another corporate-friendly Republican governor. A couple of funny things, actually.
First of all, Tom Emmer proved to be incapable of toning down the evil that won the hearts of Republican primary voters into a more palatable form suitable for fooling the masses. First, he made war on the restaurant service workers of Minnesota by proclaiming that, since they made $100,000 a year with tips, they didn’t need that much in the way of a minimum wage. Seriously, he actually said that. Next, he tried a few ham-fisted attempts to make nice with the state’s waitstaff even as he still repeated his $100,000 line to friendly audiences, but that didn’t work out well. In fact, the most infamous meet-and-greet of his, at the Republican stronghold the Restaurante de Ol’ Mexico, gave local immigration activist Nick Espinosa (aka Robert Erickson) the chance to link Emmer’s inhumane attitude towards restaurant servers, many of whom are immigrants, with his similarly-inhumane attitude towards undocumented workers who are often exploited by employers seeking to use the workers’ "illegal" status as leverage.
No sooner had the hubbub over this died down than a new one erupted — and unlike the previous one, this one has had a nationwide reach.
What happened was that Target Corporation was found to have given, at the behest of its CEO Gregg Steinhafel, $150,000 to MN Forward — which, as noted earlier, claims to be "bipartisan" yet has run TV ads for (and spent the vast bulk of its money on) only one candidate, Tom Emmer.
Why is this a big deal? Because Target’s spent a lot of time and money marketing itself to the gay community — and Tom Emmer is a notoriously anti-gay politician. This touched off a firestorm, one that is still blazing with groups like MoveOn and Common Cause and the Human Rights Campaign all joining with other groups to condemn Target’s actions. MoveOn’s Ilyse Hogue pointed out that Steinhafel’s "apology" over this was nothing more than "I’m sorry I got caught".
All of this might help explain why MN Forward suddenly announced its endorsement of six candidates not named Tom Emmer last week — and golly gosh gee, three of them just happened to be Democrats: State Senators Terri Bonoff and James Metzen, and State Representative Gene Pelowski.
Bonoff’s endorsement seemed to be one that Brian McClung was particularly interested in flacking; as Bluestem Prairie’s Sally Jo Sorensen notes, he repeated her name at least a dozen times during the August 5 taping of At Issue, Tom Hauser’s Sunday morning talk show on the Twin Cities’ ABC affiliate KSTP-TV. But that might not have been McClung’s wisest move, as Sorensen also notes, quoting from Bonoff’s response to the endorsement:
"I have always worked hard to maintain a constructive relationship with the business community that puts the needs of our state first. I’m also proud to have a voting record that reflects my commitment to equal rights for the gay and lesbian community, opportunity for working families, and the importance of a high-quality education.
"I am, however, concerned about the effect of the Supreme Court ruling in the Citizens United case, which opened the door to direct corporate spending in political campaigns. This new influx of money, combined with self-financing millionaire candidates, threatens to drown out the voice of the people who are supposed to be deciding our elections.
"I remain committed to Minnesota’s long-standing and proud tradition of campaign finance laws that give everyone a fair chance to have their voice heard and force candidates to focus precious resources on the issues that matter most. I will continue working to defend these laws in the Legislature and call on the members of our state’s federal delegation to provide the leadership we need on this issue in Washington."
English translation: "Thanks for the kind words you didn’t really mean, Mr. McClung, but I think you and your group suck rocks and that the SCOTUS ruling that made your group possible sucks rocks as well, and I will work to fix things so your group ceases to exist."
And that is that.



35 Comments

Hmmm. So is Bonoff for real? Does he have a real chance?
And did the “endorsement” include any actual money for Bonof or the others? Equal to Emmer’s amount? Just curious.
I let Target know that Wal-mart got the $80+ I would have spent last week at their store. Haven’t darkened their door since this came out, and I’m normally there at least once a week.
Wal-Mart is not a good alternative, of course. This week I bought my toiletries (face wash, shaving cream, etc.) at my local grocery store, instead of Target.
Emmer’s attitude to the minimum wage pisses me off at least as much as his anti-gay-ness. I wish that would get more press coverage.
Whaddaya think, PW? Any chance Target will back down? Or just more kabuki with the MN Forward playing even-handed?
WalMart really is ‘six of one, half a dozen of the other’ here, its lobbying against public interests, and treatment of its employees, are not a good practice to support, either.
I seldom shop at either Target or WalMart, but unfortunately I do buy a few things at Sam’s Club, since I like to buy big sizes or quantities to save money where I can, and there’s no Costco here.
I stream Minnesota Public Radio (news and classical) a lot, so I feel like I’m more familiar with Minnesota’s political environment than with Indiana’s. We don’t have any decent congresscritters at all. None.
I keep wanting to ask that Target CEO if he will donate an equal amount to a progressive group.
On last Friday’s Morning Swim we were discussing all of this in the thread.
All the Target designers should become vocal about their client.
“This new influx of money, combined with self-financing millionaire candidates, threatens to drown out the voice of the people who are supposed to be deciding our elections.”
God that is stupid. Who are “the people” who are being drowned out? If corporations were not allowed to run ads, would “the people” have more airtime or something?
I just don’t get MN. I know rural folks have more of a tendency to be conservative and Ventura scared them ( probably their best Gov ever). But is it not obvious to them by now that hanging with the Republicans is a one way trip to disaster?
Our only chance now that the republicans are total fascists, is to get some people friendly people in office.
Ah, if only we could see into the hearts and minds……..
I hope ( there’s that feathered thing again Dickinson wrote about!)that America has not turned into one of the most despotic nations on earth…yet. But I was reading lists of the most despotic and every one of them featured torture most foul.
We really passed a limit when the sheeple of this country thought that was A-OK During their terror of terror.
I don’t even know that my vote counts anymore after both parties just play with the ballot box anyway they see fit.
I’m still boiling about Halter.
and now Roberts is doing what he was put there to do and giggling like a troll every time we see him. Creepy
PS: I never shop at Target
‘Who are “the people” who are being drowned out?’
We call them Voters. And without correct information, their choices to govern them are less intelligent, which is fine with businesses who wish to fool all of the people all of the time.
It’ll take a very short while for the corps to get their candidates to be a bit more polished (better selection & training) and then they’ll be in like flynn. Give ‘em 2-3 years to fully implement their program.
We’ve stopped shopping at Target; Best Buy too.
Incidentally, my partner tells me there’s lots of FaceBook ‘news’ about this Target donation: one chain letter claims that the donation came from a single store, not the corporation. I don’t understand why the CEO wouldn’t mention this in his tepid non-apology, if it’s true which I doubt. But has the HRC claimed victory yet? I was sure they would after the tepid non-apology — even though it’s the return of the money to Target that would really, to use HRC’s ad’s words, “make things right.”
Probably best if Target re-direct the $150,000 to Joe Solmonese’s botox fund. From his Countdown appearance last week, he seems pretty hooked on the stuff…
Example One: Bigot McDonnell in Virginia. Weathercaster handsome, with the stone cold heart of a talibangelical.
Terri’s a she, and she’s probably in decent shape. She’s from the Minnetonka area, which is a ritzy suburb/exurb of Minneapolis, but while much of her constituency may be Richie Rich types, there are enough people with consciences among them to make a full-fledged embrace of MN Forward political suicide for any non-Republican.
The other two pols are men. Metzen’s the Dems’ senate leader, and he’s not in any particular danger and doesn’t need anyone’s help; Pelowski’s a rural legislator who is quite conservative especially on abortion, so it’s not surprising that he’d be one of the token Dems picked by MN Forward to receive some token efforts in the form of glossy mailings.
Heh!
Actually, all of the three Dems can stomp Emmer in the general. Polling has shown that for a while. So my advice would be to wait until tomorrow’s DFL (aka Democratic) primary and see who wins, then donate to the winner.
Just to add to this: MN Forward is strictly a media shop; they don’t do ground games. Glossy mailings is all the ground game they’ll do; the bulk of their efforts and cash this cycle will go into TV ads for Tom Emmer.
The following is about the Minnesota Farmer–Labor Party from Wikipedia;
I’d like you to pay close attention to the bold;
1. Successful third party.
2. Unity of purpose between Farmers and Labor Unions.
3. Call for social security laws.
My point?
1. We’ve been this way before.
2. We’ve been successful when we’ve sought solidarity.
3. The opposition will always attack our strengths.
The enemy portrays our efforts to build new coalitions as crazy.
They try their hardest to divide our constituent groups, this is especially evident in their efforts to demonize organized labor, which has been tragically successful.
They continually work to propagate the myth that independant parties have never known any success.
Minnesota used to be a shining beacon of sanity, and good government in a country tending generally toward insanity and partisan paralysis.
Even Minnesotan Republicans used to be sane and honorable people (just listen to former governor Arne Carlson sometime).
Good plan. There are still a lot of locally owned grocery stores in smaller towns, and if you look, yo can find them in big cities too. Keep local money local.
I took the Move On letter to the Target store manager on Friday at noon. I was the only one there at that time in Leesburg, FL. I explained that nobody in my social or business circle would ever set foot in a Target or Best Buy again. Ever. I wrote to the CEO and told him he could pay back his shareholders 150K out of his own pocket since he took it from theirs.. no reply. No matter where else they contribute money to candidates, they still supported a BIGOT. I WILL NEVER SHOP THERE AGAIN, NOR BUY A DAMN THING FROM NEBRASKA BUSINESSES WHILE NELSON HOLDS A SENATE SEAT.
Minnesota is still relatively good, despite the best attempts of Pawlenty and the republicans to turn it into a bible-belt state. The Iron Range is a tough nut to crack and the cities will never go red. The issue is that the DFL cannot get their act together where the governor’s race is concerned. Both in 2000 and 2004 Pawlenty won by a plurality, because there were two liberal candidates in the race. Not that I’m against strong 3rd parties, but at some point (preferably before the general election) the liberals need to pick one.
The other issue we have is, as someone mentioned previously, is that Minnesota held on to the old republican party (and by that I mean the Eisenhower type republicans) longer than most places, embodied in people such as Arnie Carlson and Rep. Jim Ramstad, who were fiscally conservative and socially moderate-liberal. That party is now dead, and it’s taken people here a little longer to realize, because T-Paw is a good actor.
I asked Jim Ramstad once why he didn’t run for senate (this was back in 2003), because there was no one who could stand against him in MN politics really (that remains true today, he could take the governorship from anyone currently running) and he just looked at me kind of sadly and said “because the republican party would never nominate me, I’m too liberal.”
Sorry for the rambling, just some thoughts about the home state.
I’m glad to see the Emmer stance on minimum wage here– as I wish it would be seen everywhere. Not to take any fire away from the GLBT outrage, just pointing out that there is a world of crap coming from Emmer and his party. Minnesota used to be the shining light of how to be a state, and my family moved here from Chicago to raise families because of that. But we started seeing carpetbagging idiot Republicans begin to migrate here because of the great standards of living, all the while whining and moaning about having to actually pay to support it. Emmer plays to this crowd of barbarians, and also to the rural (Stearns County, AKA CD6) anti-choice bible-beaters. Target’s CEO is one of those guys who is looking for a way to make tons of money, any way he can– and if he could dispense with minimum wage or any steps toward that, he’s on board. Pretty disgusting perversion of what was once a gold standard in community care and involvement. This is one of my biggest gripes with Target, the Republicanisation of what was once a true community partner. Republicans don’t care about community, only themselves and their money. Sad, and infuriating.
Very true. Ramstad is a great reminder of what could have been, but Fox and its poison have gotten hold of most Republicans’ mindsets. Not to mention KQRS, and its insidious hinting of social hegemony. I also had some very good conversations with him when he was in office. Pretty inspiring to see what a real “loyal opposition” guy can be. Arne is consistently contributing good ideas and commentary, though I was not a fan of his when he was Governor. But he makes Pawlenty look like a silly puppet by comparison. T-Paw has done much to wreck this state, and his sick “vision” and hopes to be President are cause for mass concern. People vote for his smile, and never realise how much they are losing.
Good points all, add to them that over the years, the DFL leadership has seemed content to focus on maintaining control over the party, as opposed to winning elections.
I hope they realize that if they win this year, it’s not because everyone admires them so much, it’s also that they’re up against a disgusting alternative.
Yupper. Though if Hatch had just kept his mouth shut during the month of October 2006, he’d be governor today and probably cruising to an easy re-election.
My worst fear is that Matt Entenza and Mark Dayton, should they lose tomorrow in the primary (which is likely), will refuse to back Kelliher and instead run races guaranteed to let Tom Emmer win.
I have to disagree with you on third parties — you see Minnesota has a third party, the Independence Party, or the Jesse Ventura Party, and for the most part it serves the interests of electing Republicans. The Independents are mostly what remains of the old moderate republicans, combined with fairly centrist or conservative otherwise DFL voters. Most elections it gets between 10 and 15% in state wide races.
There are really two DFL parties…there is the formal elected party organization (Central Committees, ongoing committees, party officers, etc.,) and then there is the party of elected officials, the House and Senate Caucuses, and other elected official groupings. The formal organization takes care of party business between elections, organizes caucuses, makes party rules and the line — but the real election efforts are in the work of the Caucuses. They more likely have the campaign cash.
Sara! Good to see you! How goes it?
Everyone, this wonderful lady was invaluable to those of us who wrote or blogged about the recent Franken-Coleman contretemps. Sara’s been involved in Minnesota politics for many, many years now. She knows whereof she speaks, and she was so kind to me even when I made silly mistakes.
The thing about Emmer is that there’s so much to dislike and he is so very bad at hiding it. His closest advisors are apparently not much better.
I’m afraid I didn’t make it clear that I was talking about the historical record for the successes of the Farmer/Labor Party, and not the recent history of IP.
Yes, I understand that the impact of third party candidates has been bad for the DFL/progressive interests, but I wonder if it necessarily must remain so?
Isn’t it possible that Pawlenty has damaged the Republican brand as concerns Minnesota voters?
Is Emmer the kind of person that ‘Eisenhower’ republicans can get behind?
I guess I’m hoping there is some sanity in the Minnesota republican base?
Maybe we could get Cheney to take him hunting?
[Mod Note: And let's not go any further down that path, not even as a "joke"]
‘Yes, I understand that the impact of third party candidates has been bad for the DFL/progressive interests, but I wonder if it necessarily must remain so?”
The Farmer-Labor party was of a different era, you have to comprehend the differences if you are to do a comparison.
In the first half of the 20th Century the MN Democratic Party was essentially an urban machine, centered on St. Paul. It was mostly Irish-ethnic. It could elect local officials, some legislators, but it put off the Lutheran/Scandinavian rural voters, and the part of the labor movement that was oriented toward Industrial Unions, whereas the Democrats (mostly Irish Catholic) got the Trade Union votes. The Scandinavians (Farmer Laborites) were pretty dry, with just a few damps, whereas the Democrats were wet as they could be — remember Prohibition was the wedge issue between the pre-world war one period and the end of Prohibition in 1934.
The Farmer-Laborites were quite isolationist, with the single exception of being interested in export of farm commodities, and while isolationism passed muster as ideology during the 20′s, you have to question it as party ideology as you move into the late 1930′s. In fact, one cause of the death of the FL’s in the midst of WWII in 1944, was the very general recognition that an ideologically isolationist position was no longer one with much voter appeal.
The real reason for the merger in 1944 was because Franklin Roosevelt asked Hubert to get the job done, because he was concerned about not having a three way split of the votes for electorial college in the coming 44 election. FDR understood that if the FL and the D’s both had their own slates of electors, it was probable the Republicans would get Minnesota’s electorial votes. So FDR called Hubert to DC (Hubert had been a statewide WPA administrator in the early 40′s) and met with him, and charged him with getting the merger done. He earned his stripes by accomplishing this. A side benefit of the merger was the possibility of electing progressive reps and Senators as a result of combining the cultures of the old FL and the D’s.
As to Pawlenty ruining the Republican brand name — not sure he has done enough damage to get that far. He still pulls down polling approval numbers in the mid 40′s, which is what he had to get elected. If he were running again and the Independents had a quality candidate, I think the results would be the same as in 2002 and 2006. Just look at the splits in the Franken-Coleman-Barkley race in 2008. Emmer is very much damaged goods, what with his position on tip income, his support for 4 day school weeks, and his tax stance, and refusal to answer any budget priority questions. But I suspect that Republicans who hold their nose for Emmer will follow the lead of Durenberg and probably Arnie Carlson, and vote Independent. We just have to hope the DFL candidate can properly mix it up with both Horner and Emmer.
By the way PW — did you notice that Tom Mason walked out on the Emmer Campaign? I always laugh at the mention of Tom Mason’s name, it reminds me of that fantastic 1990 Wellstone ad, where he taps the BMW in the Boschwitz staff parking area, and says “nice car” — that was Tom Mason’s car. Just the name makes me laugh. For those not into ancient DFL symbols and all — Tom Mason managed Rudy Boschwitz’s campaigns in 84 and 1990 and again when Boschwitz got a return match against Wellstone in 1996 — and he ran Coleman’s campaigns in 2002 and 2008. Mason is the author of the strategy of turning Paul’s Memorial Service against the DFL in 2002 in the wake of the plane crash. Nothing I like more than hearing on MPR that Mason, who was running Emmer’s campaign this year, has decided to sit this one out.
Wow! I’d forgot about all of that. Though I do remember that a number of the local conservatives, including the KQRS morning crew and Sara Janacek on MPR’s Mid-Morning programs, tried to push the “applause signs” lie the next morning — that’s the one where they pretended that the captioned TVs in Williams Arena, the TVs used to show events to the hearing-impaired and for general closeups much like the electronic screens at other stadiums, were “applause signs” instead of TVs with captioned commentary.
I, who was actually at Williams Arena for the ceremony, tried to get on the air by calling KQ to correct them, but they are notorious for not letting liberals correct their bullshit and will even mock those that try to call in. Reality-based folk had better luck with MPR: The second Janacek tried pushing that lie, dozens of people who’d actually been there lit up the MPR switchboard and smacked her down.
By the way, Tom Mason: Your orchestrating this is why Al Franken now has Paul Wellstone’s seat. You finally went too far and ticked off Al enough to make him run and beat Blo-and-Go in 2008. (Al’s written about the Republican demagoguing of the Wellstone event here and here.)
Oh, and Tom? The wildly disparate GOP/Media Complex treatments of Wellstone’s and Strom Thurmond’s deaths are, along with the Bush/Cheney runup to invading Iraq, what kick-started the reality-based side of the blogosphere. You remember how the very same Trent Lott who you said suffered during the Wellstone event at the hands of booers who nobody watching on TV ever heard, was the guy who a few weeks later was talking about how lovely it would have been if Thurmond’s race-baiting 1948 run for president had succeeded? You also remember how, unlike the Wellstone event, it took the GOP/Media Complex the better part of a week to notice this — and they did so only because bloggers like Atrios were hammering their asses over it?
More on Bad Sara Janacek (to distinguish from Good Sara Not-Janacek here in the comments) and her pushing the “applause signs” lie:
And here:
And of course the “respectable” media immediately ran with it, in a way they would fail to a few weeks later when Trent Lott made his infamous eulogy of Strom Thurmond. It took the constant pressure exerted by progressive bloggers like Atrios to get the corporate press to care — and then only grudgingly. Then Karl Rove realized he could use this as a pretext to get rid of Lott as Senate Majority Leader in favor of the far more malleable Bill Frist, and that’s when the TradMed really started to cover the story of Lott’s racist praise of Thurmond — and his own racist connections.
Thank you for the history lesson, it fills in a bunch of blank spots in my understanding.
My Scandahoovian forbearers, on my Father’s side, fresh off the boat in their wooden shoes, went to the end of the road near Thief River Falls and hacked a trail to their homestead where they raised their family among the wolves.
My Mom’s family was first generation Irish and for her entire life, my Grandmother was afraid of being deported due to lack of proper status.
I understood the ethnic issues pretty well, but hadn’t appreciated how wide the gulf was between those two political cultures until recently.
A friend once pointed out that I was much too passionate to be living amongst the Nordic types who she described as laying awake at night worrying that somewhere, someone was having a good time.
I’m afraid however, that I’m never going to learn enough to understand the appeal of Tim Pawlenty or Michelle Bachman to any Minnesotan.
“I understood the ethnic issues pretty well, but hadn’t appreciated how wide the gulf was between those two political cultures until recently.”
Oh yea, the ethnic divide stretched well into the late 20th Century. When we revised our Civil Rights Laws in the 1960′s, one issue that almost killed off the process was the fact that rural school districts were either Lutheran or Catholic, and had been drawn that way. No Catholic Teachers had been hired ever in some Lutheran Districts, and vise versa. Revised laws provided real penalties for such patterns, and one little job I had to do about 1966 when the laws were revised, was to collect the data, write an analysis, and then get all the Lutheran and Catholic Bishops in the same room and tell them how vital it was that they solve their problem, at least to the face saving level. (I was Director of a Religious Civil Rights Organization in those days.)
And the Scandinavians are not at all alike. Norwegians tended to be FL, but the Swedes tend to be Republican. Danes split down the middle, they used to talk about the happy Danes and the Holy Danes — the Holy ones were more Swedish acting, and Republican. The Happy Danes are Grundvigians and were Farmer-Labor.
Michelle Bachman is German. Moreover, she grew up in Wisconsin Synod Lutheran Churches — that Synod is further right than Missouri Synod, and can’t fathom what devil has got into the multi-merger that is ELCA what with their permission for married same sex couples to co-pastor a church.
Over the past year I have been meeting with Somali Women who are trying to understand in a little more depth this crazy place they landed in, and where they intend to stay and “make it” In the end, I tell them to see the little details as a way to comprehend things — but also to laugh at them.
Laugh, indeed.
I can remember when I was very young; my grandmother telling me what nationality lived on the farmsteads as we were driving through rural Minnesota, by the color of the shingles on their roofs!
I also remember my relatives describing people as being in a ‘mixed’ marriage, meaning a Catholic married a Lutheran. People in ‘mixed’ marriages often fought with their in-laws over very important issues, such as how to properly celebrate Christmas.
I’m sure it must seem very funny to Somali women to understand how much seemingly identical white people wish to discriminate amongst themselves?
Sara, you should write a series of Seminal diaries concerning Minnesota politics. I can’t think of many people whose knowledge on the subject even comes close to matching yours.