Former FDIC chair Sheila Bair makes the following provocative proposal:
For several years now, the Fed has been making money available to the financial sector at near-zero interest rates. Big banks and hedge funds, among others, have taken this cheap money and invested it in securities with high yields. This type of profit-making, called the “carry trade,” has been enormously profitable for them.
So why not let everyone participate?
Under my plan, each American household could borrow $10 million from the Fed at zero interest. The more conservative among us can take that money and buy 10-year Treasury bonds. At the current 2 percent annual interest rate, we can pocket a nice $200,000 a year to live on. The more adventuresome can buy 10-year Greek debt at 21 percent, for an annual income of $2.1 million. Or if Greece is a little too risky for you, go with Portugal, at about 12 percent, or $1.2 million dollars a year. (No sense in getting greedy.)
[...]
Because we will be making money in basically the same way as hedge fund managers, we should have to pay only 15 percent in taxes, just like they do. And since we will be earning money through investments, not work, we won’t have to pay Social Security taxes or Medicare premiums. That means no more money will go into these programs, but so what? No one will need them anymore, with all the cash we’ll be raking in thanks to our cheap loans from the Fed.
I’d take this one step further: At the end of the ten-year period, declare an old-timey, Biblically-sanctified Debt Jubilee.
Yes, former Chair Bair is speaking very satirically — her proposal is actually a Swiftian attack on, among other things, the ways that the Wall Streeters were and are allowed to profit from our misery — but really, is it any worse than what has actually been done in the name of shoring up capitalism?




29 Comments

You are up early this fine Sunday morning Phoenix.
Good morning.
Well, gotta go. Campaigning and all that. I see that the VP was just in town. Doing a fundraiser for your Senator Amy Klobuchar.
See ya Phoenix.
OMG just commented on another post that I hoped this was put up on FDL. Here it is. She sums it all up. Let’s make it go viral. Everyone no matter how dumbed down they are can understand this. MSM can try and hide the truth and make it sound boring and complicated, but Sheila has shown with satire what it is and how simple the scam is.
Oooohh, where do I sign up?
I remember being gobsmacked back in 2004 when my local stadium, the Skydome, the beneficiary of millions of dollars worth of land, tax breaks and outright subsidies, was sold to Rogers Communications for a paltry $25 million. When I heard about it I was sore. Jeez, if I had know it was for sale, I coulda got a $25 million mortgage from my bank, no? But I didn’t know about it, and neither did anyone else. Which is my point.
Sheila is totally right, *everyone* should be able to take advantage of these sweetheart deals. Love you Sheila, and are you *sure* you are a Republican?
Always liked Sheila Bair…
She’s not perfect, see WAMU + Jamie Dimon, but this is one heck of a soapbox piece. Thanks for mentioning Jonathan Swift in your writeup, this is perfect satire that sticks a couple of fingers into the eyes of the establishment.
Call it satire, but this is the least objectionable way that Wall St and the TBTF banks currently “make money”.
The other means that they use, unregulated dark market derivatives, naked shorts, manipulation the commodities market (gas, food, etc), manipulating the metals market, robo trading (and flash crashes), MERS, ninja loans, empty MBS trusts, etc, are much more destructive.
By definition this system isn’t capitalism, it’s fascism.
Don’t degrade the language by calling this capitalism.
Real capitalists: people who make steel, domestic goods, agricultural products, computers and so on, probably don’t like this either.
This is simply unelected aristocracy centered in NYC / DC / London.
We don’t call them kings, barons, and marquise (secondary to the degradation of our language); but that is what they are.
Apparently you folks didn’t read the original article wherein Democrats are lampooned regarding income inequality…
… and ridiculed for taxing/borrowing/printing your way to glory.
Ms. Blair was the one fighting Greenspan, Summers and Geitner during the Clinton administration declaring that if we gut Glass-Steigle we will see a calamity that will rock the US economy.
She was silenced by all three as well as Pres. Clinton and you know the rest! Sumners was Obama’s chief financial consultant, Geitner is working with the banks as Secr. of the Treasury and Greenspan has said he was sorry!
Brooksley Born
Better example than Blair.
^^ sorry, Bair, having trouble editing.
If Romney wins, he could worse than nominate Sheila Bair to be Secretary of the Treasury.
Won’t make any difference since he will tell her what to do.
I love the idea of borrowing from the fed at zero interest, just like the banks.
Yayyy Sheila! Cheap,interest free loans for everyone! Heck I don’t even need 10 million. I’d settle for less than half that. Most of us have been surviving on far less than $200,000 a year.
Agreed.
Exactly. And as she says, this is exactly how the hedge fundies helped themselves to great big heaping stacks o’ money.
Funny how you lift tiny snippets out of context, Shooter. (By the way: I can always tell when I’ve written something that gets under an Old Town Alexandrian right-wing messaging-school maven’s skin. You show up!)
The only reason this shouldn’t be taken as a perfectly serious suggestion is that some people can’t handle debt. I’ve heard stories of lottery winners who went bankrupt after a spending spree.
However, I am very responsible with finances and I’ll be happy to sign up for a loan from the Fed. They can check my credit score – it’s excellent.
Heh! Clever. Pity Obama didn’t appoint Sheila Bair Secretary of the Treasury instead of Goldman Sachs’ boy Timmy, but he didn’t dare now, did he?
Anyway, thanks for posting this, PW. Recc’d. See, miracles DO happen.
Really? I’m pretty sure the average American isn’t any more irresponsible than a banking official that chose to hand out loans without any regard to an ability to pay on down the line as was the behavior at most of the large of the large banking establishments did in the run up to the housing bubble. Or as Sheila Bair points out more irresponsible then a Federal government that fails to raise taxes on those that have not only benefited the most from government but that are most able to afford paying more.
No, I feel fairly confident that a 10 million dollar spending spree by Americans would be more productive than handing over money to the robber barons of banking.
Your ability to ignore the snippets where she lampoons the Republicans extending the Bush tax cuts and excoriates the banking industry as being treated as “special” and being given zero percent loans to the detriment of those of us paying higher prices at the pump and in the stores is duly noted.
If the printing presses can be run full tilt for bankers than it ought to be run for “we the people” as well.
Bair for Treasury secretary!
I think “irresponsible” is the wrong word. “Criminal” is more accurate because they were getting paid to make loans that that they knew were financially irresponsible and unlikely to be repaid. That’s why the loans are called “liar’s loans.”
They were paid to make liar’s loans in order to create as many mortgages as possible so the mortgages could be sliced, diced, bundled into financial instruments of mass destruction and sold to unsuspecting buyers.
It was the greatest financial fraud in history and the banksters knew exactly what they were doing.
A crime doesn’t get more premeditated than that and Obama and Holder are determined to make sure that no one who is responsible for committing this geenormous crime ever suffers any consequence for doing so, except an occasional chump-change fine.
I know I’m not telling you something you don’t know because I think you’ve said this here at the Lake. Just as we all do, you got temporarily careless with your words and I seized the opportunity to remind everyone that Sheila Blair’s satirical levity notwithstanding, the banksters committed a horrific crime that we the people are being forced to pay for many times over.
Yes, I do have a sense of humor and I think her satirical recommendation is a hilarious put-down of the criminal banksters and their enablers Bernanke, Geithner, Summers and Obama.
Sorry, cwaltz. I meant no offense and I hope you are not offended. I just couldn’t stop myself from reminding everyone what really happened here.
Namaste.
Uhm, excuse me. That would be Bair, not Blair.
Recommended.
Nope not offended. :)
Interesting how many Conservative acolytes, Paul Craig Roberts, David Stockman, and now Sheila Blair, have found the inspiration to speak out AFTER they left the hen house.
Or like Ike – warning about the Military Industrial Complex on the way out the door.
When they were in it, they were part of the problem. Dared not criticize the machine then – When it might have done some good.
Now that they can’t do anything about it, they knock it.
It truly is a liberal/progressive approach cloaked in satire. Who dares implement policies that benefit the little people and ultimately the entire economy.