I read something just now that makes my blood boil:
It starts the minute he wakes up and puts his feet on the floor. The nausea quickly builds from the base of his stomach to the back of his throat and he tries to think mind over matter but matter generally wins and this is just the beginning of the day. The really hard time, he would tell you, comes later in the afternoon, when he must force down the pills he needs to stay alive and hope they stay down. Food? The thought of it makes him gag and this goes on day after week after year. His parents wonder whether he can survive it. So far, in 14 years, Bennett Black has only found one thing that eases the nausea enough so that he can eat, so that he can live.
That’s marijuana.
Now there’s a move afoot to repeal the medical marijuana law that Arizona voters have approved three times now. Bennett Black’s father is hoping the Legislature will take a pass on [state Representative John] Kavanagh’s bill to put repeal on the 2014 ballot.
Back in 1997, when Bennett was 14, he was hit by a car while riding a Go-Ped. This caused brain trauma that led to life-threatening grand mal seizures so severe that the best specialists in the nation haven’t been able to totally stop them despite many years, treatments, and surgeries. The anti-seizure pills he takes do cut down on the number of seizures, but at the heavy price of a constant nausea that renders eating virtually impossible and his waking life a living hell. Frankly, I’m amazed he didn’t give up years ago.
The only reason he’s able to eat at all is because a couple of years after the accident, after Bennett went from 180 pounds to 114 pounds because he couldn’t get, much less keep, anything down long enough for it to be absorbed into his body, a sympathetic neighbor with neck problems suggested to his mother Cindy that he try marijuana. It was a godsend. It allowed him a brief period each day to have a fighting chance to eat — and, more importantly, to digest — enough nourishment to stay alive.
There were a couple of problems with this treatment. One was that it was illegal to use pot, even for medicinal purposes, at the time that Bennett first tried marijuana. The other was that Bennett’s father is former U.S. Attorney Mel McDonald, a Reagan appointee who enforced and even helped set Reagan-era policies in the War on Some Drugs. The family had to live a strangely bifurcated existence: Cindy procured the weed, Bennett consumed it — and Mel, the U.S. Attorney, made a point of staying well out of sight on both sets of occasions, so he wouldn’t be witness to something he would have to consider as a crime even as it saved his son’s life. The advent of legalized medicinal marijuana has enabled the family to have something more closely resembling a normal state, and Mel McDonald’s attitude towards medicinal marijuana has done a 180-degree turn, as he’s seen how it’s helped his own son. But they now face the possibility of being forced back into the shadows again because of Rep. John Kavanagh’s bill to put repeal of medicinal marijuana on the Arizona ballot.
Why does Kavanagh want to repeal the state’s medicinal marijuana law? Because he apparently thinks that the people taking advantage of it are all plain old recreational dopers and that no real doctor would actually approve of it: “No medical authority would say it’s helping you. They all say it’s harming you.” As anyone who’s studied the medical marijuana debate for more than five minutes knows, this is a lie; there are many, many studies done by many, many doctors and scientists showing the efficacy of marijuana as an anti-emetic, among other things.
Bennett Black needs marijuana to live. John Kavanagh wants to take it away from him. It’s as simple as that.
Photo by Dank Depot under Creative Commons license




33 Comments

Thank you, Phoenix Woman, for bringing this important practice to light. This country needs to point out doctors who betray their patients’ confidence and health in this way.
It is a whole new field of study for some physicians, but it is their responsibility to learn this new field.
So what. Big deal. Let people have their drugs. Legalize all drugs. It can’t be any worse than putting sick people in prison. These authoritarian asshats just have to have control over everyone’s bodies. Drug addicts, women, gays, children. But try to take away their guns and no fucking way.
It’s amazing how the GOP lack empathy.
Dick Cheney would be hatin’ on the gays unless his daughter was one.
Reagan appointee U.S. Attorney Mel McDonald would still be lockin’ up dopers if not for his son, or maybe he still is?
Until someone they love is touched directly and negatively by their horrific policies, they can’t understand how badly people are hurt by what they execute across our country every day.
Empathy: it’s what separates authoritarians from the rest of us.
Since the rules governing the MM users are so lax and anyone with $200 and a backache can get a user card these programs are open to attack. Even the advertising for the dispensaries look more like High Times than a medical supplier.
It’s ironic that this Reagan drug warrior may have to return to the drug underworld to supply his son’s habit.
Indeed. That, and the ability to extrapolate empathy so that it covers people besides those in one’s immediate family.
Canada’s medical marihuana; Kavanagh should try doing some genuine research.
http://www.hc-sc.gc.ca/dhp-mps/marihuana/about-apropos/index-eng.php
But it’s not just the Republicans, unless you are willing to say that Obama is a Republican. He is in charge of who occupies the top office of the DOJ. And all that has to happen is to have Eric Hlder re-schedule Marijuana.
What it really is all about is the fact that for the last fourteen years (Probably longer than that, but the year 1999 is the earliest I found actual proof,) all the big pharmaceutical companies have been patenting marijuana. They want to own every last cannibinoid in all the varieties of the plants. They are willing to let the Bennett Black’s among us DIE as long as they can keep it illegal long enough to fully patent the stuff. Then they can rake in the big bucks, something they won’t be able to do if we can all grow our own!
Elise – your information really got my attention. Found this at stopthedrugwar website (http://stopthedrugwar.org/speakeasy/2008/jul/23/significance_us_govt_cannabinoid) The article is about a U.S. gov’t patent on cannabinoids. Here it is: http://patft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-Parser?Sect1=PTO2&Sect2=HITOFF&p=1&u=%2Fnetahtml%2FPTO%2Fsearch-bool.html&r=1&f=G&l=50&co1=AND&d=PTXT&s1=6630507.PN.&OS=PN/6630507&RS=PN/6630507 Patent No. 6630507 The abstract discussed the medical benefits of cannabinoids as antioxidants (help w/auto-immune diseases) and neuroprotectants (helping people after stroke, with Alzheimer’s, etc.). The patent belongs to the U.S. gov’t/Dept. of Health & Human Services.
This would be the same U.S. government that, if memory serves, recently denied a medical researcher the right to conduct medical trials using marijuana because, the gov’t insists, it has no medical value?
Sigh… Now I’m wondering what company sells the pill, Marinol by prescription, whether the gov’t sold the patent to the manufacturer, the price of the patent, and how much people who are afraid of breaking the law are being charged for these pills? (Pills which may be fine for a glaucoma patient, but don’t stay down long enough to help someone experiencing nausea from chemotherapy, or lack of appetite/nausea from AIDS-related illnesses/meds, or young Mr. Black)
I do hope the young man’s father reconsiders his earlier opinions, including why he held those opinions and how they compare to what he has learned about marijuana, politicians, and government.
That’s what struck me about Mel McDonald. I wonder how many dope smokers he locked up while his son was trying to stay alive with the same stuff.
Anyone who spends any time with the medical marijuana literature knows it is a flat lie to say that marijuana has no medical value. My brother worked out the chains of impact on pain, and others have done the work to show how cannabinoids work to produce other kinds of relief.
I hope Kavanaugh rots in the Eighth Circle of Hell for his lies and hypocrisy.
It’s the FDA that would re-schedule the drug. Holder needs to priortize the DOJ to go after criminals that do actual harm to our country, not marijuana dispensaries operating according to state law. But other than that point, I agree that the pursuit of medical marijuana, as well as most other unjust aspects of the war on drugs, two-tiered justice system, and prison industrial complex are bipartisan.
Nice tag-teaming, elisemattu and Hystoric1. Marinol seems to be made by Abbot Labs, but while poking around I saw that there is a generic now.
I’m licensed for MMJ and it can help some of the time with pain, but even when it doesn’t, it allows me to be a *bit more* sanguine about it moment to moment. Trying different species of both Indica a Sativa are important. And it does help with sleep, which can be invaluable, and the anti-inflammatory cannabinoid joint salves are great for temporary help (so is celadrin cream).
It’s very unclear how Holder/Obomba will treat either the MMJ dispensaries or the ‘recreational’ mj shops (or shoppers) once the Governor gets all the protocols in place. Last I’d hear he wouldn’t say directly, so…I have concerns, as do many in CO and WA.
Oh, and apparently cannabinoids help those with MS, too.
I suspect that the two biggest reasons for keeping it illegal are as follows:
1) The mobsters who control much of the trades would see their profits plummet overnight, as they wouldn’t be able to charge jacked-up prices justified by its illegality (and certain on-the-take law enforcement officers would see corresponding decreases in their unofficial revenue streams), and –
2) The prison-industrial complex (see also: CCA) gets most of its profits from drug arrests and incarcerations. They too would dry up and blow away if marijuana were legalized.
CCA is the biggest culprit by far:
http://whyihatecca.blogspot.com/
For profit prisons would likely be dumped back onto the taxpayer until things got sorted out. Just like for profits in Florida
couldwould not afford the privately sourced medical insurance premiums for inmates and passed that cost back to the state.I hope that wasn’t an intentional choice of words, as though his son merely has a weed habit rather than needs this to survive, because if it was intentional, it’s offensive.
I think it’s a particular type of lack of empathy. It’s a desire to claim moral superiority – a holier-than-thou attitude.
There are stories, told by the people who work in clinics that provide abortion services, about the occasional times that one of the people outside protesting needs to bring a daughter to the clinic to get one of the abortions that they scream against out on the sidewalk.
Here’s some examples.
A common theme of those stories is that those people, suddenly confronted with the massive irony of their situation, will insist they they are different. That the only moral abortion is the one they need. Often, they demand to be separated, to not sit in the same waiting room as everyone else.
Because they are not the same as everyone else, you see. It’s an accident for them, unlike the other women, who are morally lacking.
Let’s all go to the bar and discuss how horrible it would be if recreational users got a free pass.
Dirty f’n hippies.
Heh, that used to crack me up when tending bar at our local American Legion.
These guys would sit there for hours consuming A DRUG while simultaneously bitching about all the DRUGS other people are using and what assholes they are and how they should be locked up.
I really don’t understand how some of these people handle the cognitive dissonance, although I suppose technically there really isn’t any, as they appear to be completely unaware that they’re harboring two opposite ideas at once.
The obvious response to Rep. John Kavanagh is to begin a campaign against Rep. John Kavanagh’s reelection that does everything conservatives do to Obama et al:
I’m sure you can find quotes from Kavanagh that parallel quotes from Obama and Holder and others in the Obama administration – they don’t need to be about pot, but just express the same appeal to the authority of science, or technocrats, or Federal role in health care, and turn Kavanagh into a virtual Obamabot.
Drug legalization is clearly required ideology of conservatives who are spouting all the anti-Obama and attacking big government dictates of every aspect of your personal life.
It is the anti-government attacks of conservatives parroted by Republicans that has shifted the public opinion on subjects like gay marriage and women in combat – if the Republicans are attacking government dictates on individuals and winning, then gay marriage, women in combat, and using pot are things government should stay out of and leave individuals alone.
Adopt the conservative arguments and talking points to turn legal pot into core conservative Republican ideology. And you can find lots of Ron and Rand Paul quotes to attack Kavanagh’s political position.
Fuck Arizona Republican Bullies………I am so damn sick and tired of this kind of Thuggery…..let one of them try to overcome this boy’s problems, or live with nerve pain…..screw them, this kind of thing is unmanageable no matter how resolved or Macho one strives to be…..Cowardly, Bullying Thugs….screw them and the horse they rode in on……ty ps….sorry, I get so pissed, it is time for us to start doing Right and Good
Here is an article, that when downloaded as a PDF, offers up the citations for all the various ailments that pharmaceutical companies have proven that marijuana cannibinoids work on.
http://www.safeaccessnow.org/article.php?id=4558#research
I was so happy when Med Marijuana legality happened due to how many Californians were informed of its benefits. Yes, sure, it gets used by recreational users, who only need to claim they have migraines or PMS to get a med marijuana card.
But isn’t it better to have the stuff supplied by US citizens who are licensed by the state, then by the blood thirsty members of drug cartels? Among the more unsavory practices of the big cartels: here in Calif, they kidnap some unsuspecting new arrival to the USA, and drop them out in the middle of a national forest. The person is left there to care for numerous plants, with food of dubious quality supplied, no paycheck, and just the threat of the fact that the cartel biggies know where the victim’s family lives to keep the person from walking away. Often at the end of the grow season, the immigrant is killed in cold blood, despite complying with all the demands of the cartel.
Why Obama/Holder are more willing to keep Calif.’s prisons filled to the max with MS sufferers, recreational pot users, and also, why they aren’t at all interested in the amount of economic recovery that the medical dispensaries were contributing, I have no idea. I do know people who think that Big Drug Cartel Money has helped both men, but it could just be that the Big Bankers like the ability for the laundering of money, and we all know how Obama loves the Big Banking types.
X2 Dude. After about four hours of sucking up the shit on the M$M and worse, the stories of MyFDL, I’m cursing and throwing stuff. Surprised the neighbor lady hasn’t called the cops.
Wish I knew what was “Right and Good.”
… good comment elisemattu …
B.H.Obama(D) is POTUS and E.H.(D) is DoJAG ….been so since Jan.20,2009.
POTUS Obama(D) needs to step up on MJ and change USG legal climate / status while AG E.H.(D) who’s boss is POTUS Obama(D) could do alot about MJ just by and in conduct example by #1 not doing and with #2 pulling back and #3 ceasing what is being done by Obama DoJ.
… ditto comment @ 23
Scarily enough, that might actually work.
“Shit is fucked up and bullshit” applies.
Based on real experience here as well.
The worst are the alcoholics!
Book Salon up with Charles Euchner’s Nobody Turn Me Around: A People’s History of the 1963 March on Washington hosted by Toure Reed
How’s this for Right and Good? I called “Bullshit” on a Nurse Aide at the hospital the other day. She started in on me with the neurosurgery story. She quickly departed, but I can’t say I think she learned anything.
“Bullshit”http://www.snopes.com/politics/medical/neurosurgery.asp
I called a woman a liar at the barber shop sometime back. Didn’t phase her, but I think some of the barbers and other patrons were surprised.
It starts to look hopeless. Seem to be dealing with zombies.
I don’t want to hear you fair-weather liberals blaming “He with the sweetest oral delivery skills ever” as complicit, just because he’s in a position to ease the heat on medical-marijuana via federal policy if he wanted to. It’s obvious from his sincere, majestic declarations that unlike the GOP, he’s full of empathy for everyone from the top of Wall Street, all the way down to DC’s K Street. Have a little patience. Consider His burden, and “full plate”. It’s barely two weeks since the inauguration.
The GOP?
Who has been President since January 2009?
For whom does Eric Holder work? http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/04/25/obama-marijuana-raids-rolling-stone_n_1451744.html (Obama Explains Increasing Medical Marijuana Crackdowns, Raids In ‘Rolling Stone’ Interview)
For whom does Michele Leonhart work? http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/06/21/michele-leonhart-dea-crack-heroin-marijuana_n_1615270.html (Michele Leonhart, DEA Chief, Won’t Say Whether Crack, Heroin Are Worse For Health Than Marijuana)
I know. IOKIODI.
Read more: http://www.upi.com/Top_News/US/2013/01/06/Obamas-back-in-Washington/UPI-65371357450871/#ixzz2Jp6Z8xHl
The D of J cracks down on medical marijuana in states where it is legal, like California.
The head of the DEA refuses again and again and again to take bait from Democratic members of Congress asking her incredulously if she’s absolutely sure that marijuana is as harmful as, and as big an enforcement priority as, heroin and crack.
But a story about some obscure state rep from Arizona is what elicits tears about the subject even though he can’t do diddly outside Arizona and not all that much by himself inside Arizona?
Why? Because he is a Republican? Or because he doe sot work for Obama?
Sorry. that last should have read “Or because he does not work for Obama?”
Stubborn keyboard!