Let’s say you’re a middle-aged, well-educated progressive woman who speaks her mind plainly.
Let’s say you’re hungry to serve others and make real, transformative change happen in doing so.
Let’s say you’re a Hoosier, too.
Sister, right now you’re fucked, and here’s why.
1) The progressive community in Indiana has lost much of its spark.
Take a look around the progressive blogosphere in Indiana; it’s difficult to find more than a few blogs which provide solid and detailed content of interest to progressive Hoosiers, let alone those which post daily. This is a mirror of progressive politics in Indiana; the grassroots are thin and growing sparsely, and there’s not enough fertilizer to encourage thicker, rapid, healthy growth.
Take a look, too, at Meetups and events on Facebook. It won’t take long, because there are few if any even in an election year.
If you want to win, you will first have to build your own empowered and energized posse, because the progressive cavalry which existed in 2008 has become disenchanted and disaffected when not co-opted. You are also going to have to talk with and recruit bloggers who can make things happen with mere words.
2) Training for candidates and campaign supporters is wanting.
There’s simply not a lot of it in your neck of the woods, and what there’s been during the last several years put on by the state’s Democratic Party apparatus has been co-opted by a single incumbent, Evan Bayh.
Yeah, imagine wanting to train as a candidate to run for the senate against Evan Bayh, at a program with his name on it.
You will have to find an alternative method for training, like Democracy for America’s Night School programs. Contact EMILY’s List and find out if they are offering training in your state. Look into programs offered by The White House Project.
3) About that party machine…
Yes, there is one, no matter how much pooh-poohing you hear from the mainstream media and from the Democratic Party itself. There’s a hierarchy of power which is entrenched and exists in almost every single state in the union. It doesn’t like to give up power (or money) easily, and it won’t like any newbies who threaten its worldview and its ability to call the shots. You need to recognize it and figure out how to work through or around it effectively.
You also need to avoid ever, ever mentioning the machine because it will call you a paranoid, crazy-assed bitch for doing so, even if you can see them, the old boys network gathered in the smoke-filled rooms patting each other on the back as they point at you and laugh. You may refer to running into their obstructionism as “experiencing cultural stickiness” or “the expected resistance of the status quo to change.”
Unfortunate, you also cannot count on training to teach you this; you may have to learn this by networking with others and from cagey blogs. When pressed about this topic, smile broadly and change the subject to a key platform issue dear to your heart.
And fundraising…did I mention fundraising? You are going to have to make "the ask" for money every day, too, put a time set in stone on your calendar to do so. Get comfortable with explaining why you are a worthwhile investment with a well-crafted 30-second elevator speech. Start with organizations which are women-centric and women-friendly and work them for financial assistance. Reach out to other minority groups regularly, too. This is a necessity because you sure as hell can’t count on a nanometer of silver from the good old boys in the party machine we won’t ever mention out loud.
4) You have to run more than once.
Name recognition is absolutely essential to running successfully for office, in addition to being highly organized and projecting a powerful, determined brand and presence. These things all go hand-in-hand, too. You must plan right now to run for office at least twice in order to have adequate name recognition, let alone develop a brand which can be identified readily beyond your name alone.
And it will also require a period of time to become deeply versed in election rules and campaign finance laws and the numbers you’re going to need to win, as well as developing a trustworthy and deep posse who will be with you all the way, who’ll get your back for those two runs. You also have to commit to knocking on doors and making the ask at least three times.
If you’re not ready for a long-term commitment, well, running for office isn’t for you. Otherwise start shopping for those ugly but comfortable and durable door-knocking shoes. You’re going to need several pairs.
There’s a lot more, but if you can grasp and embrace the challenges in these four points, you are somewhat less fucked than you were when you started reading this.
And for those of you who aren’t Hoosiers, here’s the gawd-awful truth — ALL of this stuff applies to you, too. Been there, done that, photographed the wreckage, comforted the grieving, picked up the pieces and moved on.
One more thing: Some idiot female with the Republican Party did a disservice to potential candidates by making a mealy-mouthed comment about women needing “hand-holding” to run for office.
No, they don’t. What they need is a fighting chance, a lot more information about running successfully, and for the power-hungry good old boys in politics and the media to stay the fuck out of their way and keep their nasty comments, petty assumptions and their little toy shivs sheathed.
Women also need a Kevlar flak-vest, a hard hat and a pair of pointy-toed shit-kicking shoes with an attitude to match, figuratively speaking.
Let’s hear you say it with me: Hoosier mama.
Now get out there and win.




41 Comments







I agree with everything you say, it’s a sorry state of affairs for sure, but I have one small quibble;
In Minnesota at least, some of the good ol’ boys are really good ol’ girls, and they carry shivs too.
Also. while the back rooms may no longer be smokey, that’s still where the deals are made.
It seems some people only objected to the smoke.
Oh, you’re right, there are some good old girls out there, too. But let’s not kid ourselves that this party is still driven by men from top to bottom; names like Emanuel and Carville have been key to continued entrenchment in spite of local/state party rules which require diversity in delegations. They may not be actively thinking “men only,” but their practices assure gender-bias.
And smoke-free only happens in some public buildings. Many of the deals I know of happen in bars after hours. When the party gavels an end to a meeting, be sure to follow them afterward, because that’s when the rest of the deals get cut.
Tell it like it is.
It is all true.
I think this is very important:
“4) You have to run more than once.” This is the key idea, the chances of initial success are small, but good efforts to organize and get recognition from voters can be built upon in future campaigns.
About this:
“What they need is …… and for the power-hungry good old boys in politics and the media to stay the fuck out of their way and keep their nasty comments, petty assumptions and their little toy shivs sheathed.”
The only way this happens is if the candidate is viewed by the GOBs as irrelevant.
So the candidate better have a strategy to deal with this because it will be coming if the challenger has traction.
The underemployed and unemployed are the biggest unused campaign asset available. All necessary skills and experience are available, they just need to be shown how to use those skills in the political arena.
They unfortunately have the time, they may have some motivation to change things.
The traditional Democratic party structure will not use these people, the Republicans will.
Progressives should use these volunteers to counteract the media spending spree that is coming. Person to person is more effective than the broadcast media.
Time shall tell.
Hence the Kevlar vest, hardhat and shit-kicking shoes with attitude.
Find the right candidates and they will just need the steel toes that they already own and use.
The attitude of the above mentioned candidate will negate the need for the Kevlar vest and hard hat.
“You also need to avoid ever, ever mentioning the machine because it will call you a paranoid, crazy-assed bitch for doing so, even if you can see them, the old boys network gathered in the smoke-filled rooms patting each other on the back as they point at you and laugh. You may refer to running into their obstructionism as “experiencing cultural stickiness” or “the expected resistance of the status quo to change.””
The right candidate might also answer this by stating to the (female) voters:
“Sister, right now you’re fucked, and here’s why.”
This message is easy to understand for the voters, also the GOBs understand this type of talk.
Well, the right candidate sometimes cannot come with enough internal Kevlar of their own. I’ve seen the perfect candidate run the perfect race only to be attacked savagely during the last two weeks of a campaign — see the part about photographing the wreckage.
Even the right candidate often needs training in how to handle the kind of savage abuse which the opposition will throw at them.
I know a few women who would be happy to vet you and move you into a main stream candidacy. Hillary often claims to have been a pioneer in politics, But Anne Delaney, Virginia Dill McCarthy are the real deal. Progressive to be certain, but they learned to be effective working within the system.
All the advice….is what Sarah Palin has accomplished.
(Except for Emily’s List, etc.)
Therefore I conclude that the article’s points have been proven by at least one politician.
Those two ran for office but lost. Ann repeatedly.
Interestingly, Congresslady Julia Carson of Indianapolis was noted as a Black civil rights leader but in many ways she was quite the feminist always encouraging and supporting females in political life. Most would agree Julia was quite the progressive Hoosier too! She never lost an election from 1972 to her passing in 2007.
*ilson !!
Long time….
(*ilson, welcome back! How is it in the Hoosier trenches?)
Is there an actual distaff candidate willing to put her name up in front of the state party central committee for nomination as the Democratic Senate candidate? Or is this excellent but general advice, Rayne, for another time?
And what say all of you about this persistent Mellencamp chatter?
State Senator Vi Simpson was repeatedly mentioned as a Bayh replacement but took herself out of the running. Simpson is the State Senate Minority Leader & progressive representing the college town of Bloomington and hilly surroundings. When I spoke to her Thursday morning she hinted she might take another run for Governor in 2012. She’d be great!!!
Vi Simpson has been mentioned several times. There’s a Facebook group trying to draft her.
Thanks, Rayne!
Much of what you say applies anywhere, especially the part about being willing to work, and work HARD, and wear out shoes doorknocking.
*ilson – how ya been buddy?
This kind of ignores the fact that a “progressive” candidate (male or female) cannot win statewide office in Indiana. Indiana is Alabama with corn.
Having said that, Tamyra D’Ippolito was a disaster waiting to happen.
Birch Bayh did, but that was ages ago. In fact, the key reason his son Evan is so conservative is because his father’s loss to Dan Quayle in 1981 seared his political soul at a formative point in its evolution.
Hmmm. Good to think there’s a logical reason for Evan’s ass-hattery.
Btw, I’m a former Hoosier – grew up there in the 50′s and 60′s when Vance Hartke, Dem, was long-time Senator. Of course, Home Capehart (R-idiotville) was the other.
We actually lived next door to a Democratic sheriff of Marion County, and my mother was rescued from her dumb-child(me)’s stupidly locking all the screen doors and going to bed while Mom was out by Dem. Rep. Andy Jacobs. There were a fair number of Dems on the ground, then.
But then, the Repubs hadn’t entierely turned into loons yet.
I used to work for Dave Obey {D-WI] when he first came to Congress. he and Andy Jacobs were great pals.
Jacobs had a Great Dane puppy that he named “C-5A,” after a cargo plane used in Vietnam [this was during Vietnam].
Jacobs used to have his staff walk the dog in a park near the Longworth Office Building where we worked. [Soon the dog grew big enough to walk them]
Jacobs also used to take a picture of C-5A next to the same piece of furniture about every two weeks, to show how much he’d grown. He was always saying that the dog grew like the cost-overruns on the C-5A.
He and Obey also used to put out monthly press releases re what could be done domestically with the funds spent on some piece of military equipment [like the C-5A]. “With $ X millions, we could build _____ schools.”
Very effective.
When is the last time a Progressive tried to run statewide in Indiana? It seems to me that the powers that be don’t want anyone to run who might buck the system. Just look at the candidates the DCCC and the DSCC try to recruit.
Birch may have actually been the last one. Evan blames his dad’s loss to Dan Quayle on his being too liberal, as opposed to the Quayle and Pulliam families owning much if not most of Indiana’s media outlets.
When was the last time someone in a wheelchair made it as a running back in the NFL? Elections aren’t the Special Olympics; the goal is to win, not to take home a participant trophy.
I have a different take. In fact I think in my state at least, it is that attitude that continues the primacy of Blue Dogs in so many state and local parties. And very few Democrats in office — and those Blue Dogs.
It is my opinion that we in that situation should shift our goal to present and explain the Liberal/Progressive political philosophy. There is no better way to get free media than in an election campaign. I think the crazies on the right got a lot of their “credibility” from free media campaign related media coverage.
As the electorate, becomes better informed and aware of genuine alternatives to conservatism then we can begin to think of winning.
Did Eugene V Debs hail from Alabama?
Indiana is a complex state. Underground Railroad supporters led to KKK dominated democratic party… and the Klan domination occurred simultaneously with Debs rise to notoriety.
The state Democratic party has problems. During the period between the Consent Decree on PCB clean up in Bloomington and the implosion of the decreed incinerator deal I saw what local Democrats valued: Bloomington’s mayor Tomilea Allison at an EPA seminar cheering the PR funding EPA was providing. She wasn’t promoting the remediation of city owned facilities, no she was saying we need to have money to sell this abominable deal to the public in the face of grassroots opposition.
Which led me to doing independent campaigns during the 90s. Successful campaigns as far as raising the level of discourse and moving the Overton window. Campaigns that earned respect from the machine. Ultimately they were helpful in stopping the incinerator as well – rather than producing 750,000 cu yards of contaminated incinerator ash Westinghouse cleaned up 600,000 cu yards of contaminated soil.
I don’t live in Indiana now. I do have strong ties and stay informed, have regular contact with people in Bloomington and Indianapolis both in and out of the Democratic party.
Historical correction: in Indiana the KKK was Republican (unlike the South). In many ways its was a reaction to the rise of unionism and progressive politcs such as Eugene V. Debs and the founding of the Socialist Party USA in Indianapolis.
Sam Ralston was a Democrat elected with KKK support. His Republican successor McCray vetoed KKK supported legislation creating Klan day at the Indiana State Fair.
It’s a mixed bag as Governors Branch and Jackson were Klan supported Republicans… it appears that the KKK switched party allegiance in the mid 1920s in Indiana.
Glad you pointed that out. In the twenties the KKK had a strong resurgence becoming incorporated into the Republican Party. Race has always been a huge issue along the Ohio River.
In the Old Confederacy the KKK continued dominance of the Democrats until the Nixon/Reagan era. (Though we hear a lot about the solid south of New Deal days the southern Democrats were far from supportive across the board.)
Having been that progressive woman twice in NH (nominee for governor and congress despite the best efforts of the risk averse democratic party). It is important to remember that the voters are NOT the party and primary wins are not about the will of the majority who rarely participate in primaries but about the activated minority that actually shows up and votes. It is ironic that you talk about the Indiana Bayh party. I did a radio show Friday morning in NH and we talked alot about Bayh Take a listen. It is time we frame what Bayh did as anti voter, anti democratic and incredibly selfish (or as I described him…a democratic despot)
Link, MP3 podcast – Dan Mitchel/Arnie Arnesen talks about upcoming political races and health care
[Ed. note: link embedded to prevent breaking column.]
Enjoyed your comments on the talk show. Overall I find it sad and almost overwhelming the truth expressed by the host on self-interest driving the candidates. “That’s the American.way.”
You’ve pointed to one of the key reasons it is absolutely essential for progressives not to turn their nose up at local Democratic politics. Only the actively engaged know how the machine works and how it trends towards entrenched power, or how the political process can be gamed to ensure outcome.
It opened my eyes when I became active in the local party back in 2004 after the election. I couldn’t figure out why we were having such difficulty with getting support for Howard Dean, but until I actually joined the party there was no way to see inside the closed system to know that it had been stacked against him by the apparatus. The system had to be taken back, and doing so meant a commitment. And as soon as you let up your guard those old school party machine folks will seize the party back and prevent real democratic (little d) process. Quite literally, until those old coots die, we will be working on taking back the party and moving it to its real Democratic roots. Don’t give up, because the future of democracy literally depends on it.
Boy, that is the truth.
More than ten years ago, a co-worker and I (we were lawyers, for Gawd’s sake, we thought we could get taken seriously) walked into local Dem party headquarters in the 12-mo before a pres election, to offer our services.
We hung around nearly half an hour before giving up and leaving. Not a single person so much as glanced our way or approached. (they were behind a glass office window; they saw us, all right).
Tried again a couple years later. Same response.
True, I did give up for quite awhile (and my own personal and financial problems played a large part in shifting my focus and energies).
this time, I went straight to MoveOn, after a slightly less obvious ignoring from the local party.
But, you are so right. The far right began quietly taking over the R party decades ago, starting at low-levels like school boards and small-town councils, moving up to wider elective office. They were off the radar of the organized R party, too, and before they woke up, the loonies had taken over by virtue of organization and patience.
In my experience dating back to the early ’70′s, liberals (I’m sorry, I prefer the supposedly discredited name to “progressive”) lack such patience, as well as, of course, the willingness to organize with those who are less than pure matches in ideology.
Both of those characteristics have hurt us badly, and contriubted to allowing the current political atmosphere to develop.
It comes from our deepest personality traits, but we must overcome them if we are going to save our society and political system.
Without FDL, I fear I would have given up again. People like you, Rayne, and posts like this, help me pick myself off the floor of despair and try again. Thanks.
(correction to my @30) That’s Homer Capehart, of course.
Absolutely is the word!. And, at least in my region, it won’t come quickly. My experience with my local party was similar to yours. Most of the activists for Dean, then Kerry got little cooperation from the Democratic Party. Most of Obama’s support came from former Deniacs. When Obama was nominated, same story. In fact in the midst of the Obama summer campaign my county party stopped having regular meetings.
pregame speech hoosiers.
TBogg (13) — You know, I think a progressive candidate can win in a swing state like Indiana, but it takes a savvy candidate who groks all the points above AND understands how to frame issues so that they can break through to conservatives.
Take guns, for example. Howard Dean’s frame was the right one: what works in Montana doesn’t work in NYC, and vice versa. It’s local.
Teddy (16) — it’s a postmortem for D’Ippolito, who may not be able to salvage her situation; it’s a guideline for others like D’Ippolito who are out there and need the kick in the butt to run.
D’Ippolito is burnt toast. She bragged about almost having the required signatures but it turns out she had gotten only 3 out of the required 500 from Indianapolis. That’s the capital city that elects progressive African-American Muslim Congressman André Carson.
Word on the street is that she’s saying she’s going to be the Libertarian Party candidate now. Libertarians are apoplectic!
Got any details about the party apparatus in that county? Because that’s a key piece of the equation here, based on what I’ve heard from other Indiana progressives.
the key is race.
Marion County is about 25% African-American who vote way over 90% Democratic. The 7th CD is a slightly smaller subset of that county & 30% Black. Julia Carson was the first ever African-American in the U.S. to win in a white-majority District in 1996. It’s a union town too. It took a number of behind-the-scenes battles for local Democrats to realize “diversity” is the way to go for electoral success.
Our current Congressman from Indianapolis is André Carson, an African-American Muslim who’s in the Progressive Caucus, the Black Caucus & the LGBT Equality Caucus. He got there by winning 7 (seven) straight elections and party caucuses.
I should also add Julia Carson was quite the master at recruiting both progressive candidates and good precinct workers. Over the years she built up the fabled “Carson machine”.
You forgot about putting on your hiking boots and doing the Lawton Chiles introduction to voters. If this is your strategy, your target is tough–Richard Lugar not Ellsworth.
In fact, if you think long term, it might be good to introduce yourself to Indiana by helping the Ellsworth (or other machine candidate) campaign statewide. Just don’t be naive and easily co-optable about it but use the experience to build yourself a statewide address list of Indiana progressives for use later. Yep I know — progressive principles and all that. But if you can bring a sufficiently large number of voters behind a candidate, you can bargain about policy; you can even offset the influence of money because politicians use money to get voters and use policy to attract money. Your value added is the ability to get voters in exchange for policy without the intervention of the money middlemen. Now this assume that the politician is not turning campaign cash to personal cash (which then becomes an excellent issue for someone running against them).
The internet-age version of a Rolodex is your best friend–especially one that lets you make notes about your contacts. And a map of the state, showing the distribution of folks on your “Rolodex” by county (or precinct if you can get it).
It’s trenches time. And there are around 3400 precincts in Indiana’s 92 counties. Rough math is 500 people, at least 5 in each county for volunteer recruitment for a campaign and a minimum of 17000 volunteers, at least 5 to handle canvassing in a precinct (even if they don’t live there).
Nationwide there are 3080 counties and 192,480 precincts.
I’m a Bloomington, IN resident, and D’Ippolito is indeed headed towards the Liberatarians. What has amazed me about this trainwreck is that the things she wants to transform are all local, county-level and state-level problems. Going for a Federal seat makes no sense at all.
I found your analysis interesting.
Here is my take on how it is slightly different out here in the pacified northwest state of wishy-warshy.
There isn’t enough to really steal in the state of WA., so you don’t the level of corruption and inbred-edness of MA. Other than gates, a few other software zillioniares, some boeing big shots and university of washington big shots, this pond ain’t big enough for enough sharks.
So the local Dem party stuff gets too sidetracked by your typical petty pinheaded bureaucrat who exists everywhere – there is NOTHING more satisfying to a petty pinhead than having the world waiting on the pinhead.
Want to get “active” ? – the FIRST thing you have to do is piss away 4 to 6 hours a month in idiotic meetings appeasing the processes of boring pinheads. IF you have a real job, AND you want a life … good luck.
And then you have the cantwells and her types – “born in this century, tempered by war, disciplined by a hard and bitter peace” – born into getting their asses kicked by raygun-ites, tempered by the right lies passed off as political truths, disciplined by a cowed and craven herd mentality.
I’d gamble 300k on cracking the system if I had 3000k in the bank. I grew up on welfare, I couldn’t take the thought of working my ass off to end up f’king BROKE.
rmm.