
Politico is a right-leaning media outlet which claims to publish news. This piece — Obama takes chopper for 6-mile trip bylined by Abby Phillip — is one of many of their works which not only make me nauseous but make it clear they are not really in the business of reporting news.
No, Abby Phillip, an American president using Marine One helicopter in the completion of his duties as the head of the Executive Branch is not news.
But it’s not entirely Phillip’s fault. Her editors should have done right by her by telling her they were going to spike it and to find some real news.
Her editors are also catering to the sources from whom she got her quotes by letting this piece run. Phillip should be more skeptical not only of her sources’ agenda(s), but her editors’ agendas, or she’s going to continue to be a hack.
Somewhere both Phillip and Politico editors lost sight of the fact that the government is not the only entity which may have expenses when the President of the United States drops in for a visit. Local businesses and inviduals whose day-to-day work is directly impacted by changes in routes and security checks are stakeholders, too, and they don’t appear in this piece at all.
Let me give you an example from 2004, when then-Vice President Dick Cheney made a visit to my hometown. Cheney’s security team and entourage
- Locked down all traffic along an interstate highway for 30 miles north and south of the venue at which he was speaking for an hour before, during his visit and an hour after he’d left;
- Locked down the local international airport located more than 30 minutes away, one which served three Fortune 100 companies, for more than three hours;
- Locked down all the surface traffic for several miles surrounding the facility at which he spoke, including truck traffic in and out of an automotive part manufacturer’s largest, multi-plant facility in the U.S.
All for a presidential campaign stop.
What a massive time-and-expense suck to local businesses and inviduals. And nobody questioned the cost then, let alone the possibility the use of government resources might have been a Hatch Act violation — that angle might actually have been news.
Don’t even get me started on the ever-present medical retinue including the personal ambulance which accompanied Cheney that day. I can’t even begin to imagine the additional cost to taxpayers.
A six-minute chopper ride by POTUS? Meh. A bargain compared to what it would cost to businesses and individuals for a security lock-down of the area through which the POTUS’ limousine and security detail might otherwise have to drive. It’s not as if businesses and individuals have much extra cash lying around these days to suspend business long enough to let the president drive back and forth through their neighborhood.
Perhaps the real problem with young Phillip and Politico is that they don’t want to do the leg work it takes to do real reporting. It’s easier, cheaper and faster to just make a couple of phone calls and gin up something inflammatory, rather than go through the exercise of calculating all total costs to stakeholders for this particular story.
In other words, hackery pays.
[Photo: In a demonstration of "not news," Marine One ferries President George Bush for a day trip to Frederick, Md., Jan. 18, 2008. (source: jaydoubleyougee via Flickr) AP photo taken same day confirms trip.]



29 Comments




Help!
Thanks Rayne!
I saw that “article” and could only shake my head
Dog Bites Man.
In other news, IOKIYAR, but it’s gawdamfookingawful when a Democrat does it.
Thanks, Rayne. Since I don’t read Poltiico, I wasn’t aware of this.
Further steps in the death of journalism.
Frankly I hate all the fossil-fuel burning travel that all presidents and other bigshots do for nothing but bullshit and the Bullshit Aggrandizement Complex.
That said, blow me Politico, you sorry piece of fuck.
Politico: Albritton-funded propaganda organ.
Riggs Bank: Albritton-owned bank, funnel and money-launderer for BCCI and Carlyle, Manuel Noriega and the bin Ladens.
Who did GWBush call on at his press conference scheduled for Politico’s very first day in business? Mike Allen, lickspittle “reporter” extraordinaire.
Why does anybody still read Politico???
I keep trying to get off their e-mail and they ignore me.
To echo sharkbabe, Politico accomplishes physical opposites simultaneously, as it both sucks, and blows.
That being said, wouldn’t it be smarter to not paint a big ol target on POTUS when doing these cross town limo gigs? That seems more about “State” and “Ego” than it does about security, as dashing cross-town in a cab is WAY less conspicuous.
That’s what I do, and I never get targeted. *g*
LOL :)
Politico: Vapid ragsheet for the terminally shallow and those addicted to petty and vile gossip. Believe anything they say at your own risk.
If you’re the damn President of the damn United Fucking States of America you have earned a certain right to such travel privileges.
Did it make a lot more sense and take him a lot less time? Sure I bet it did.
And what does it cost taxpayers for any of the official POTUS vehicles to be transporting the man or sitting idle? My guess is probably about the same either way.
So fuck it. Bush, Clinton, Obama, it doesn’t matter. If you’re POTUS, and you have a chopper at your disposal, fucking use it!
Ah, canister vacuum cleaner. Which end you connect the hose to determines whether the dirt disappears or goes all over the place. (Describes Politico too, doesn’t it?)
I just went over and read the piece and the first 20 comments. At least the vast majority of comments were similar to ours.
Wonder if the Politicos ever read them?
It’s amazing how sour those grapes still are when the election was so long ago.
I don’t remember them complaining when St Ronny tied up traffic, or when Shrub did it – I do recall that Shrub tied up traffic so thoroughly on one trip to CA that one school class missed its opportunity to see a particular theater production.
Teddy Partridge is upstairs!
Sunday Late Night: “Conjecture, speculation and fears are not enough.”
Right/left, doesn’t matter. This kind of stuff has got to stop. I am sick and tired of the pain and suffering that security inflicts on the public when the POTUS or any world leader comes visiting. Forget good will, it is about oppressing the people and inconveniencing them beyond belief. Look what happened at the G20 the past couple times. How much money was spent on those meetings? Did they have to be in the middle of a city? If they’re so goddamn concerned with security, go have it in a field in the middle of Indiana or something. Why the hell do they have to fuck everyone over for their photo ops? Democrat, Republican, doesn’t matter. Just royalty on display… the peons need to bow and step aside. Fuck that.
It shocks me that anyone is really interested in protecting these Bozos. Would life really change tomorrow if Cheney’s pacemaker took a vacation?
I am sick and tired of the pain and suffering that security inflicts on the public when the POTUS or any world leader comes visiting. Forget good will, it is about oppressing the people and inconveniencing them beyond belief.
I take your point that G20 meeting, you’re right, they should be held in resort areas instead of tying up major cities (of course there’s no need for the President to go to any summit, kick it to the Secretary of State).
Bear in mind though, most of the inconvenient security procedures are Secret Service requirements. They’ve got a tough job and I would never second guess what those guys think is required to protect the President (this one or any other). Frankly, any President who didn’t follow their advice on security matters would be acting terribly irresponsibly. Ron Kessler wrote an eye-opening book that’s worth reading– In the President’s Secret Service.
As someone who was actually assigned to HMX-1 (the presidential helicopter squadron at Quantico) while Nixon was president I have a very simple explanation: all sorts of flights are made every day of the week by the military whether carrying the president or not. Pilots need stick time; crews need in-flight experience; million dollar pieces of equipment need to be used and maintained.
As for Politico and who reads it – Maddow and Olbermann sure refer to them alot and even give their hacks face time. That’s part of the problem making them appear neutral. They aren’t and should be treated like a pox just like the news group that rhymes with that malady.
Excellent point (a jarhead as the voice of reason, who would have thunk it) :)
The helicopter needs to be in the air for x amount of time each month anyway, the President might as well hitch a ride when he needs one.
It’s a win-win situation.
If he had driven the route, the article would have focused on the amount of money and economic suffering he caused by locking down six miles of DC.
It’s not reporting. It is manufacturing rage for the wingnuts.
And as the example I stumbled on while looking for a photo — Jan. 18, 2008 covered by AP photog — shows, it wasn’t news that Dubya took a chopper on a round-trip to Maryland.
Whatever Bush did that day probably made some local news, and it might even have been another campaign-related rah-rah event for all I know; it wasn’t news, just another day in the life of a white, Republican president.
Seems just shameful, too, that Phillip appears to be too young and shallow to realize she’s been used like this by her editors who should know better.
I watch both KO and Rachel, and I don’t recall anyone from Politico appearing on either show, although both may have quoted Politico. (I do get very tired of Ezra Klein and Richard Wolffe, however.)
Then I’m all for moving the White House to the middle of nowhere to ensure that the President is secure. Oh wait, they wouldn’t want to do that, right? After all, in the age of the Internet and fast data technologies, if you’re so worried one of your people are going to take a shot at you, why not do everything via video conference?
After all, if the Secret Service are the ones that are causing all the problems, why not “fix” it?
No, the will of the people isn’t as important as that of the pompous aristocracy, so we get inconvenienced and that’s “too bad”. I don’t care which party is involved.
If you claim you don’t want to live in a state of perpetual fear, do something to lower the risk. Leave the area. That is what infuriated me beyond belief in the wake of 9/11. You have Wall St. in the middle of NYC, a prime target beyond all belief. If you don’t want to face that risk, MOVE IT.
It’s all about show, it’s all about status. If it isn’t security locking the people out of things, it is money ensuring that the people wouldn’t be around the royalty or powerbrokers downtown.
As far as stick time and all that goes, is the military making any cut backs in training for simulators? Just seems like they should. Oh wait, the oppressors need the valuable and cherished flight time in lieu of crummy sims.. :
I guess that author has never been to DC. At any given time, there are several Marine Ones in the city’s airspace. I assume they’re decoys.
So, if the President actually boards one of them, how is that irresponsible?
Couple of things, one, coincidentally there’s a photo of Obama and the helicopter (“AMERICA”) on the front page of Michael Moore right now (scroll down), but the story is unrelated to yours: “Chance, Blown: Negative view of Obama has risen in Arab world from 23% in 2009 to 62% today” (August 6th, 2010). I ping back and forth between the two stories, but I like his photo with your story.
The other thing, the biggest story I know of that’s pretty much lost on this kind of subject of presidential travel hoopla fiddling while the city burns, is the one about how San Diego’s Balboa Navy Hospital was shut down to accommodate a Bush photo op visit during Katrina –
I mean I think that’s huge. ER shut down, pharmacy shut down, and patients having their chemo appointments canceled? At a huge military hospital? Collateral manslaughter?
The helicopter is not named “America.” It’s labeled “United States of America” on the side of the fusalage and tail boom. The photo is cropped to show only the last word.
Otherwise, good tip to the MM page.
I was describing and quoting the photo. I dream of a quote function that allows us to actually do that, cut and paste a visual section of a webpage, or snip within a video clip.
Thanks.