Students at public universities in California are planning a series of demonstrations across the state protesting tuition hikes today. While a few isolated incidents in recent weeks have provided fodder for some in the media to dismiss their concerns, the students’ cause is incredibly important. If we continue to yearly raise tuition in California far beyond inflation, we threaten to derail all that has enabled my home state to prosper in decades past.
It is no accident that the Golden State’s Golden Age of economic innovation coincided with the establishment of and continued investment in the best public university system in the world. Fifty years ago, forward-thinking policymakers declared that California would be a state where higher education was the birthright of every qualified resident. Since then, we’ve become the world’s great innovator in computers, biotechnology, space exploration, and clean technology.
Unfortunately, the vision that made California one of the largest and most diverse economies on the planet has fallen to the wayside in recent years, as Governor Schwarzenegger and state lawmakers have decided that it’s politically easier to balance state budgets on the backs of students.
The result? Student fees have more than doubled at the University of California and California State University systems over the past decade, and enrollment was reduced by more than 45,000 in the past two years. When you price students out of a college education, you don’t just harm the individual. You deny the state the future teachers, nurses, and engineers necessary to propel our economy forward.
According to the nonpartisan Public Policy Institute of California, if California fails to significantly boost its college enrollment rates soon, we will have one million fewer college graduates than required to keep pace with the growth of our economy by 2025.
"California faces a skills gap," PPIC’s Hans Johnson explains. "There will not be enough young adults with a college education to meet the increase in demand for highly educated workers after the baby boomers retire."
Other studies show that for every dollar the state invests in UC and CSU, it gets back $5.67 and $4.41 respectively in long term economic output. Taking a long view, higher education in California pays for itself and then some, meaning every qualified student we force away from a higher education is a dent in California’s productivity and output. Taxing students is simply bad fiscal policy. Luckily, there’s a better way.
California can maintain its commitment to higher education without taking a penny more away from students or the general population. California is the only oil-producing state in the nation without an oil severance tax. When the building blocks of our economic development are in jeopardy, why should we let the oil companies take California’s oil for free?
The University of Texas has been endowed by an oil severance tax since the 1800s, and in 2007, then-Alaska Governor Sarah Palin instituted a 25 percent oil severance tax in her home state. If it works for Texas and Alaska, why shouldn’t California consider it?
In January, the California Assembly approved AB 656, a bill by Assemblymember Alberto Torrico (D-Fremont, CA) that would follow the Texas model by taxing oil production in California to help fund higher education. The 9.9 percent oil severance tax created in the bill would generate nearly $2 billion for UC, CSU, and California’s community colleges, helping to bring enrollment closer to the state’s needs and helping to reduce the burden imposed on students struggling to stay afloat.
This week marked the fiftieth anniversary of the formation of the California State University system. Since 1960, it has conferred 2.5 million degrees and helped create a broad swath of Californians prepared to contribute to California’s economic development. For most of my lifetime, California’s system of higher education has been the envy of the world, and we have reason to celebrate our past success.
Yet the history of human civilization is replete with examples of great societies that fell into decline when they no longer prioritized education. What will happen to California if we continue to systematically defund higher education at the expense of our future workforce?
You can call the draconian increases in tuition happening to California’s students taxes or fees. Whatever they are, they are bad economics. Our students are right to be angry, and for the future of California, I stand with them.
Congressman John Garamendi (D-Walnut Creek) represents California’s 10th Congressional District. As California’s Lieutenant Governor from 2007 to 2009, he served as a University of California regent and California State University trustee.



43 Comments




Great piece. Rec’d, and thanks for being here.
Thanks so much, Congressman Garamendi.
Can you tell me what you’re hearing about SAFRA? If it doesn’t pass soon, it’s my understanding the budget crisis is going to get worse.
thanks for bringing this up, Congressman. Ex-Californian, and UC Berkeley alum from the sixties, another time like this when UC and higher ed generally were under attack by the Reaganites.
Great to see you focused on the issue.
Students lead the way.
Again.
Thanks, Congressman, for standing with them.
Do we know what chances Assemblymember Torrico’s bill has of passage?
All over the US, states are taking the position of balancing their budgetary woes on the backs of students. I recently read a news article about tuition at GA state institutions possibly going up 77%. There is no way for us as a nation to move forward and up out of the economic morass we are in if we allow public higher ed to fall back down into the mess – we will never catch up.
Thank you Congressman. As a postdoc at Berkeley in the mid-eighties, I ate my bag lunch on Sproul Plaza many days with the protests aimed at divesting from apartheid. The highpoint of those days was an incredibly inspiring appearance by Desmond Tutu.
Thanks for remaining committed to a system (and its students) that has fueled so much success in our culture.
Thank you for this post – recommended
As a graduate of Shasta Community College (AA degree), CSU-Chico (BA, MA) and UC Davis (MS) I know and value what state schools do for the State of California as a whole. Not everyone can afford places like Stanford.
And Jim White, I saw Desmond Tutu at UCD in the ’80′s too!
Go Bears!
Thank you Congressman for bringing up this issue!
I’m a Californian with two college age kids. I attended public schools in CA and got a great education, but I can’t say the same is possible today unless you live in certain zip codes.
I want to know why the Regents can give themselves huge Wall Street type raises and bonuses while cutting jobs, pay, and raising tuition. It is galling. Can we please open the books? Thank you.
Thank you for supporting the students. And please call out the people who say kids just want something for nothing. Nothing could be less true. My anger stems from the unfairness of the pay at the top and what they expect from kids trying to make something of themselves.
I hope the students get to read this. I think this would mean a lot to them
This just might be the thing that shocks many of the newly awakened students out of their political apathy
At first, after clicking on the first link, Congressman, I thought it was a link to the Onion. But it seems William McGurn (fat-old-wealthy-east-coast-economic-elitist-white-man) is serious. What a steaming pile of
bullshitignorant, vacuous, banal gibberish. Where do they get these people? I am so tired of their hackneyed, simplistic and outdated ideas as to anyone actually lives, and should live outside of their Wall Street-Manhattan-Hamptons-DC megaplex world is beyond me.Go Students!
Student protest blog here: http://ucregentlive.wordpress.com/?tsp=1
My husband and I both went through college in California and put our son through the U.C. system as well. The schools were quality institutions. When our son went through in the 90s, it was not cheap, but it was a good deal based on competing costs across the nation. While I sympathize that this rate increase is an unfair burden, I wonder just how California is going to survive without draconian revenue increases across the board. They have lived on the credit card in fantasy land for so long that the day of reckoning had to come. Having lived in the coastal southern portion of the state (that is largely well-to-do conservatives) perhaps, some of these people will have to drive a year old car for awhile or put off their face-lift in favor of more pressing priorities like their kids education.
Thanks Congressman Garamendi. Gotta ask the obvious: why is there money for wars but not for education?
I haven’t heard anyone mention that it was St. Ronnie who put an end to free tuition for California residents at state schools.
If I remember right, until Reagan, qualified students in California could attend state schools free.
Love of Ronald Reagan is the root of many evils.
Thanks so much, Congressman Garamendi.
I just cannot understand the shallow thinking of those Conservative(Reganites) who think education is a privilege for those who can afford it!!
Education is the ONLY way we as a country/state can continue to be what it has been for decades. A place where with hard work, affordable education can/will give you the tools to become a productive contributing citizen. Without it you are more likely to end up on welfare or worse in prison and why because without a good education you Will never get much further than a minimum wage job.
And hell yes it is high time California charges for the oil pumped from our State… Cheveron is raking in billions in profits and our education system is a complete failure! I think a flat rate on 10% of all profits made in the state should be paid by the oil Corporations!!
We must invest in the education of ALL of our children just to give them the Hope that they also can be successful in life and raise thier own children into a good life.
This really is a no brainier… Education is key to the success of the United States.. Period!!.
What???!!! You don’t think Reagan should replace Grant on the $50 bill?
Jeebuz Ronnie Xmas. Now I’ve seen everything.
Thank you, Congressman Garimendi.
It’s a crying shame what has been happening to K – grad public education in CA. Good luck! It seems that CA citizens are more interested in themselves than in funding education of future citizens, who, after all, will be the driving engine of our nation’s economy. The Republicans have done an excellent job in creating this cosmic disconnect between cause and effect of such short-sighteness. Good luck with your efforts. I remain cynical, but wish you all the best.
From a prior post:
“Having lived in the coastal southern portion of the state (that is largely well-to-do conservatives) perhaps, some of these people will have to drive a year old car for awhile or put off their face-lift in favor of more pressing priorities like their kids education.”
– don’t make me laugh! These are the same people who allowed Congressman Darral Issa to gin up a costly campaign to kick former gov. Grey Davis out of office based on the fact that Davis was going to – legally – re-raise the auto. fees some years ago when these fees were desparately needed. It was wealthy southern CA citizens who whined the most bc they are the ones constantly buying new cars (and back then, esp very expensive ones), and who would’ve gotten dinged the most by the fee. Of course, the solution was to either buy a cheaper car and/or not buy a new one so often. The fees go down, the older your car gets. But that was totally infringing on their rights to be self-indulgent selfish jerks.
And so we ended up with Gov. Schwartenegger (thank god Issa got kicked in the butt), who couldn’t solve our budget crisis either. Because this budget crisis cannot BE fixed without raising taxes and/or fees. It’s just ridiculous. But self-indulgent uber rich in CA feel: I got mine, eff the rest of you.
Reagan’s moving up in the world. His legacy-makers are intent on having something named after him in every one of the 50 states. As for currency, last I remember, they wanted him to replace FDR on the dime.
Welcome to Conservative Utopia! This is the world Reagan and the conservative movement dreamed of; low taxes, slash spending, and to hell with the people. If you are one of the college kids whose parents voted for Bush either the 1st or 2nd time, you need to shut the hell up, stop complaining, and take what the system gives you, because that is the world they voted for when they voted for that moron and his evil troll vp, Cheney. You thought they were voting against gay marriage and to protect the family from the non existent terrorists under your bed, wrong, now you are experiencing the real harm to your everyday lives. I said at the time Bush was elected that America is going to see what real conservatism means for the people, and that world is now here. We have allowed Grover Norquist and his cretons to scare the hell out of federal and state lawmakers in to not raising taxes. He worked to put referendums and balanced budget amendments in California and other states to control tax hikes, and when the parents in California voted down the proposed budget via referendum, they were warned by the lawmakers these kind of cuts would be inevitable. So you need to go home to your parents and yell and scream at them, and maybe yourselves as well. When will Americans understand that to have functioning schools, efficient public safety, efficient health care, and other efficient social services that states need, it has to be paid for. You can either pay for them or lose them.
Berkeley and UCD grad. I recall that I went to Cal the fees for the entire year were about $700 (in the late 1970′s). After Prop 13 they escalated to three times that. Now they are an incredible $10,000. The UC’s are now approaching the stage where the Middle-Class are being cut out. The suggestion is that students should take their GE courses at a Community College and transfer. But many of the courses that I thought were the best were taught at the introductory level by Nobel Prize winners and other exceptional instructors. One realized that they were approachable, human, and thus that one could…through hard work, discipline and perhaps risk and serendipity also aspire to great discovery or provide great social service. The love and excitement of actual research was instilled.
I don’t comprehend at all the current logic of increasing fees to pay for financial aid. The Middle class will flee to community colleges, and who will be left to pay the tuitions that is supposed to support the financial aid? And rather than encouraging those students with deficiencies in writing and math skills to CC’s you are instead sending the well-qualified kids there? That leaves a large pool of students at the UC and CSU who will likely struggle to graduate.
They should do both, just go for broke.
So to speak.
BTW, I was at the protest at the Capitol and I have to say I expected a larger crowd given how much these cuts have affected education. I’m not great at estimating crowd sizes but it seemed like about 2000 people. I know many faculty at Sac State did encourage their students to attend and took a furlough day off on that date to ensure that students would have the opportunity to attend. I think they just decided to sit on their butts at home. Oh boy…free holiday!
I have to think that students, teachers, and even fellow faculty members (including tenured faculty) are now so enured to silence and sheepishness – or short-sighted egoism- that the University and public education system will continue to be used as a whipping boy. How many times have I heard that the “teachers unions” are to blame and that we get fantastic pension plans? Ahem. Most of the university classes are taught by INSTRUCTORS and to get those pension plans you have to continuously work at meagre wages that rarely allow one to put aside any other money. Instructors earn only half as many “credits” as FT professors annually. So to get that 20 year pension that is so fantastic would have to work 40 years. And unless they forgo owning a house and having family, they would be unlikely to have anything else to supplement that pension.
This is sort of like the old time “spinstress schoolmarm” – teach and you aren’t expected to lead a normal lifestyle.
Welcome to the Lake, Congressman. Thank you for sharing this idea. I would be very grateful if the state can find another revenue source. My nephew is in the middle of his first year at a UC campus and I often worry that he could become the first in our family for several generations to NOT obtain a college education because our country has its priorities backward.
As an earlier commenter asked, how can we afford to wage two foreign wars yet not afford to finance our own children’s higher education?
Republicans refuse to require wealthy corporations and the ruling class to pay their fair share of income taxes, so education is starved. Republicans prefer the indebted/indentured serf/student model in the 21st century.
This genius wants to rename Mount Diablo after St. Ronnie
http://cbs5.com/local/mount.diablo.name.2.1456551.html
Here’s another one
http://occupyca.wordpress.com/
Sorry to hear that there weren’t more students at the protest rally at the State Capital today. While there is some burgeoning of thought and protest across the CA campuses, I am disheartened to see the laziness and apathy displayed by a number of students that I happen to know.
I’m not sure how to characterize that, other than perhaps the entire system is geared towards ennui and entropy. Why go protest when I can a lay on my bed (as my roommate’s daughter seems to do 24/7/365) playing computer games, textings my pals, updating my Facebook, allegedly studying (cough cough) and watching some crapulous brain-draining junk on my flat screen tv.
I think our consumerist society has gotten these kids right where they want them: dumb, drugged by their toys, lazy and not really wanting to exert much effort about anything.
Of course, the piper will come for the payment one of these days, but until then – eh? where’s my facebook? let’s watch America’s biggest loser, and so on.
Sigh. Too bad. Would like to see more energy out there behind this.
A lot of kids these days don’t get this one iota. They are too busy texting each other (about nothing), watching junk tv, updating their facebook accounts & so on.
It’s too bad. Got ‘em right where the Republics want ‘em: cowed under and too dumb to understand what’s happening to them. At least, that’s the way it looks to me given the college age kids I know. Wish they were different. It’s next to impossible to start any kind of political discussion with these kids either. Just aren’t interested, even though their fees are going up. Guess mommie & daddy will just pay for it??
Congressman Garamendi, thanks for participating here today. I wish you luck at finding additional revenue sources for California higher education.
But you really need to look at the structure of higher education and determine your priorities. Across the board, higher education tuition has increased at double or triple the rate of inflation, exceeded only by health insurance. Private school or non-subsidized/out-of-state tuition has become completely unaffordable for most Americans. Indeed, this combines with health insuarnce to make the formerly middle class not so middle class anymore. I realize you are referring to the in-state rate, but if the full costs go up, you can not afford enough subsidy for in-state.
Certainly California is not alone in the excessive costs. The insistence everywhere is on research, not much on teaching. Some research is good, it keeps faculty and students interested- but the American people cannot afford to underwrite so much. We can’t pay inflated salaries so every school can snag a better bio-tech researcher. From what I read, you can’t afford to pay over 1000 administrators in the California higher education system well in excess of $100,000 a year. I believe they may be paid at “competitive rates” compared to other academe. But we can’t afford it! It is time to recognize that higher education is eating up more than it is worth and to start cutting back. And of course California is not to blame for this phenomenon. But only California can fix California schools.
Higher education is going to wither on the vine significantly for the next decade because people can’t afford it, the sooner you start making changes on the cost structure, the more useful you universities will be to your citizens.
I don’t want to underestimate the efforts. UCDavis did have a protest at the same time which likely drew off participation at the Capitol. And there were a great deal of students there. Someone claimed that there were “only 500″ people there according to the CHP. But I was under the understanding that they didn’t do crowd estimates. It was certainly larger than that. My impression was that there were about 1000-2000. But considering the size of all the campuses in the area (Sac State, the Community Colleges, and that this was also a K-12 protest) I was hoping that the lawn out to the street would have been filled. If the ground had been dry it would have as everyone there was standing shoulder to shoulder on the sidewalks, rather than sitting on the lawn listening to speakers.
Having discounted joining with the Teabaggers against the Gov./Wall street collusion, here’s a chance to increase the mass of visible disaffection with the increasingly Fascist government that thrives under both parties.
Unless America starts marching against Washington’s sell outs to Money, no amount of e-mails and kb activism will even bend a bit the current trajectory.
Reagan and Clinton should each figure prominently on 1 million and 5 million dollar bills which may soon become useful to supplant the need for wheelbarrows when shopping for staples.
You make many good points, mesquite, about excessive administrator perks, but you lose me a bit here with this generalization
Here is a very good explanation of the impediments of governing and of solving the structural deficit by Noreen Evans, Assembly Budget Committee Chair
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ogfNEw2XSbY
California schools are overcrowded–crammed to its inability to educate and–WHY–you ask. WHY! Is very simple? The schools through k-12 to even college level have been hijacked by millions of illegal alien schools children and students. It’s become a heavy burden on not just California, but all border states. It’s been spreading like rotten fruit for decades and its now uncontrollable. That the truth of where taxpayers money is going? Its certainly not going for Americas infrastructure that’s crumbling. It’s not going to our homeless veterans, our senior citizens or single Mothers. The liberal ‘s assembly in Sacramento have frowned on any law that cuts public subsidies to who ignored our laws of sovereignty. California–has become a–THE SANCTUARY STATE –for these illegal immigrants and families who are robbing each state blind, in health care, education and a long list of supporting program that is costing–BILLIONS OF DOLLARS.
Steve Poizner, just filed his intention to be Governor and is the perfect candidate to bring California out of the financial doldrums, because he is a anti-illegal immigrant. He has also stated he will cut of all public subsidies to illegal immigrants, which could help stop the draining of the states treasuries of–BILLIONS–of dollars.
If you want to learn more how laws are being undermined by corruption in Washington go to NUMBERSUSA, JUDICIALWATCH, IMMIGRATIONBUZZ, RIGHTSIDENEWS & DIRECTORBLUE. Or call the Capitol switchboard at 202-224-3121 for a more direct approach.
How many days a week do professors pretend to teach while their under-paid grad students do the work?
What value are the schools getting for their out-of-the-classroom professors work?
Is publish-or-perish still the rule? What a waste.
Put Meg Whitman in charge of the schools and squeeze out some value.
These Education Protests are Communist at heart.
http://www.communislam.com/communist-education-rallies-140
You think? The regents are getting Wall Street style pay and bonuses and “competitive compensation” to draw and retain “the best talent”…in administration.
One of the reasons the kids are protesting is the unfair cuts to school employees – that affects their “product” if you will, while Regents sit and decide to raise their own pay. Chilling parallels to other industries. If they want belt-tightening, they should start with their own.
Two words for you and MarkH:
Prop 13.
There is no governor or candidate for governor who can fix the problems whether you think it’s illegal immigrants or whatever until you get rid of the draconian processes of the State assembly and senate.
The problems are linked to lies about our economy.
We are paying Trillions to Wall Street for managing to destroy the world economy, – we are paying, 99% of us to be more exact. AIG insures healthcare in europe, we back their losses. How about healthcare for all through AIG – we only own 90% of it – hello wake up!
The recovery from the U shaped recession is ephemera, as is the notion of a W shaped recession which will merely precede the shape of things we’re not being told about or simply refuse to acknowledge. The future doesn’t even look like an L, but rather like a ‘y’.
You can get a glimpse of our future, even before Bowles and Simpson are through with us, in Greece
I wager that Obama will throw money at the schools, after all – that’s where revolutions usually start, and they are treading the outer edge of the audacity of economic terrorism as is.