Written by Jodi Jacobson, editor of RHRealityCheck.org – News, commentary and community for reproductive health and justice.
In two interviews yesterday, Michigan Congressman Bart Stupak revealed a great deal about himself, the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops, politics and the internal workings of our "pro-choice" Democratic party.
First, in what shouldn’t be surprising to anyone, Stupak told Fox News that he "doesn’t listen to nuns."
Why would he? They’re only women, after all. And we know the men run the institutional Catholic church. If they didn’t, there wouldn’t be an international pedophilia scandal.
Yesterday, according to ThinkProgress:
“60 leaders of religious orders representing 59,000 Catholic nuns” sent a letter to federal lawmakers urging them to pass the Senate health care legislation. They decried the “false” information floating around about abortion provisions and said that the bill’s “historic new investments” for pregnant women are the “REAL pro-life stance.” The nuns’ letter was a significant and unusual break with the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops, which continues to denounce the legislation.
Bart, however, consults the experts in controlling women: Men of privilege. "Male religious figures and far-right religious organizations," notes ThinkProgress.
According to Fox:
Congressman Bart Stupak, D-Mich, responded sharply to White House officials touting a letter representing 59,000 nuns that was sent to lawmakers urging them to pass the health care bill.
The conservative Democrat dismissed the action by the White House saying, “When I’m drafting right to life language, I don’t call up the nuns.” He says he instead confers with other groups including “leading bishops, Focus on the Family, and The National Right to Life Committee.” [emphasis added.]
Consult the nuns? People who, despite their vows of chastity, also menstruate, and work directly with–indeed touch every day–the people who are most in need?
Yet, despite his unyielding efforts to front for the USCCB and the male "right-to-life-except-for-women" elite, Bart apparently wants us to feel sorry for the backlash he is experiencing in his crusade against women’s most basic rights.
The Hill reports that "Leading a revolt against President Barack Obama’s healthcare legislation over abortion has been a “living hell” for Rep. Bart Stupak."
The telephone lines in his Washington and district offices have been “jammed” and he’s gotten more than 1,500 faxes and countless e-mails — most of which he says don’t come from his constituents.
The fight has taken a toll on his wife, who has disconnected the phone in their home to avoid harassment.
“All the phones are unplugged at our house — tired of the obscene calls and threats. She won’t watch TV,” Stupak said during an hourlong interview with The Hill in his Rayburn office. “People saying they’re going to spit on you and all this. That’s just not fun.”
Welcome, Mr. Stupak, to the daily life of reproductive health providers, who are subject to such harassment every day courtesy of your friends at Focus on the Family, National Right to Life, and the USCCB.
Stupak told the Hill "he didn’t anticipate how big the abortion issue would become during the healthcare reform debate, nor did he figure to find himself a household name."
“I’m a little surprised,” Stupak said.
The worst part has been the pressure from groups and individuals from outside his district on Michigan’s Upper Peninsula.
“How’s it been? Like a living hell,” Stupak said.
The 57-year-old Democrat told the Hill he "has a history of working behind the scenes with Democratic leaders on abortion."
“In the past, we’ve always been able to work it out,” he said. “This is the first time we’ve not been able to work it out.”
I am sure many of us would like to know what exactly has been worked out "behind the scenes" with Bart Stupak, the USCCB and others to placate a minority position that affects the health and rights of all women in this country.
Don’t you?
Other anti-abortion-rights Democrats have said they’ll support the Senate bill.
Rep. Dale Kildee, another Democrat from Michigan known for opposing abortion, released a statement on Wednesday supporting the Senate bill, which he said would prevent federal funds from going to abortion services.
But the intensity of the resistance to Stupak’s position has, if anything, stiffened his resolve. He shows no signs of voting for the Senate healthcare bill, which could hit the House floor this week.
“I’m pretty stubborn,” said Stupak, who keeps in his shirt pocket a list of lawmakers who are willing to vote no. The so-called Stupak Dozen met Tuesday morning on Capitol Hill to strategize and exchange stories of the pressure they are under.



11 Comments







Surprise surprise
Thanks for this diary – very interesting. It unveils Stupak for the dinosaur sexist he is. Glad to see people are letting him know – I feel sorry for his wife – for several reasons.
Well, of course he doesn’t listen to nuns. His religion is exclusively controlled by men, who worship only male deities. Mary is noteworthy because she gave birth to God’s son — which elevates her to the status of God’s personally chosen ambulatory incubator. All other women are simply men’s chosen ambulatory incubators, and since when does an incubator have any right to determine what it hatches?
Stupak is suprised that he’s hearing from people all over thr country, about legislation that will impact the entire country? Wotta maroon.
Doesn’t listen to nuns? sounds like a wannabe priest to me…
Bingo!
Perhaps Stupak needs to be reminded who he’s really listening to… a bunch of pedophiles and their enablers.
What an “honorable man”!!!! Stupak is the perfect example of what we in the wimmin’s movement used to call a PIG.
I bet he isn’t getting a faction of the “harassment” Dr. George Tiller got….
I can’t imagine the wimmin of Michigan ( where we used to hold the Michigan Womyn’s Music Festival) aren’t calling him up and giving him hell as well. He’s just another bigot in Christain clothing.
Bloomberg:
Stupak’s Viagra Is Health Bill Abortion Ban: Margaret Carlson
Viagra is covered but birth control isn’t? Has anyone told Bart where babies come from?
Might do well to point out here that bishops are capable of excommunicating members of the church, but nuns are not.
I think the real problem we should be looking at is why a bunch of mostly white men wearing cassocks belonging to a religious order are making veiled threats against citizens of faith by demanding that their religious dogma is embedded in our legislation.
I’m very, very unhappy with Stupak, but if he is a devout old school Catholic, he may well be terrified about the state of his soul and excommunication from the church. We should remove that from consideration by demanding the IRS begin an investigation into the Catholic Church’s status as a 501c3 organization; if they are going to inveigle themselves into government, then they cease to be a church and should pay taxes and abide by other laws which govern lobbying.
Why focus on the Church instead? Because Stupak will come and go — but the Church remains. Unless it is forcefully pushed out of politics, it will reach even farther into our legislation and tyrannize even more of our democracy.
Seconded!
This guy is nuts the Nuns are the Catholic backbone against abortion. Just who does Bart thinks teaches Catholic all school especially after the Priest scandals? Just who does he think gives the girls what ever the Catholic girl sex talk is?
Its the Nuns who guide a whole generation of Catholic kids there are not enough priests. Heck given the sex Scandals in America, Ireland and Germany no sane man is joining the priesthood without people wondering.
A job of respect has turned into a question mark. Ask Bart if he asked Cardinal Law his opinion over the Nuns.