Written by Elise Higgins for RHRealityCheck.org – News, commentary and community for reproductive health and justice.
My name is Elise, and I’m a pro-choice activist from Kansas. I have never-ending gratitude for those who have devoted their lives to reproductive rights. At the same time, I have some serious problems with comments made that disparage my generation’s involvement in the pro-choice movement.
For the last four years I’ve grown as an activist, surrounded myself with other activists and helped to train new activists at my school. I’ve pretty much devoted my college career to making a ruckus for reproductive justice. So imagine my surprise when I read Newsweek’s piece “Remember Roe! How can the next generation defend abortion rights when they don’t think abortion rights need defending?”
My peers and I are full-time feminists. We’re planting pro-choice gardens at the University of Northern Kentucky and throwing Sextivals at the University of Kansas. We’re working with organizations like Choice USA that lift up the voices of young people. We’re volunteering for local, statewide and national organizations. And we’re blowing up the Internet with the tools and information to create change. There are thousands of us working hard for the movement every day. How disappointing to find that those in positions that we will surely take someday doubt our passion.
We are more passionate than you can imagine. We know that the right to an abortion alone is meaningless without contraception, sex education and freedom from sexual assault and domestic violence. We’re expanding our understanding of “choice” and talking about all the ways that race, gender identity, class and sexual orientation impact reproduction, AND we’re doing it all while performing underpaid or unpaid labor that sustains giant, national pro-choice organizations.
Some say that millennials don’t view abortion as imperiled or in need of defense. I beg to differ with this massive generalization. Do I think we need to be defensive about our abortion rights? No. I think we need to launch some offense. From the Hyde Amendment to the Nelson Amendment, universal rights to safe abortions have eroded since Roe, and no one knows that better than young people. We are on the front lines; we’re victims of policies that marginalize poor people, queer people, people of color and people with disabilities. We’re more than aware that abortion rights are imperiled. We live that reality every day.
Meanwhile, about the moral complexity some claim that advocates haven’t quite grasped: I have never heard a pro-choice activist tell me that the decision to make an abortion is an easy one. In fact, from the beginning of my involvement in the pro-choice movement, great pains have been taken to demonstrate to me what a complex, difficult decision abortion is. I have been inside a clinic and heard the stories of women who have chosen abortion. Those experiences have only solidified my conviction that we must listen to Dr. Tiller’s words: Trust Women. No one understands the complexity of a reproductive decision better than the person making it.
One of my favorite things about the feminist movement in general and the pro-choice movement in particular is our tendency toward self-reflection. Self-reflection is only effective, though, when you listen to dissenting voices and not just your own. So take heed: Youth are advocating for choice, and the pro-choice movement must do better by us. Leaders in the movement need to acknowledge our contributions, and work to make us the movement’s next leaders.



3 Comments

Elise, thanks very much.
Recommended.
You are probably already aware of this, but Roe is no longer the legal precedent upon which choice is based. Jan Crawford Greenburg in Chapter 6 of her terrific SUPREME CONFLICT, detailed how O’Connor used PLANNED PARENTHOOD v. CASEY to put it on a much more solid ground.
Now, unfortunately, that does not help uncover funding for poor and middle class women.
Thank you for your thoughtful and thought provoking post, and thank you for your actions and participation.
I know that there are activists in all generations, so kudos and keep up the good work.
I have sadly had the experience, though, of younger women (younger than me), who have stated to me that they don’t “need to do anything” about pro-choice issues; or that they don’t “want to” get involved (in any way), etc. I’ve heard a number of “excuses” for this passivity from embarressment to be associated with the pro-choice movement (even though they support the right to choose) to belief that the “it’s law so it can’t be changed” (would that were so) to basic laziness or feeling that it’s “dumb” to protest, etc.
Hopefully, as a younger woman, you can reach out to other younger women and share your passion for this eminently worthy cause because I see these rights being eroded in serious ways. At this stage, it doesn’t have much impact for me personally. Although I am committed to continuing to fight for the right to choose, I do feel that the younger generation has to take the erosion of their rights very seriously.
Kudos and good luck. I’m right behind you!
A great read, and rcc’d of course.
Thanks for your work, commitment and here’s wishing you and all success.
Choice is something ALL citizens must have if we are to be a true representative democracy.