Written by Shivana Jorawar for RH Reality Check. This diary is cross-posted; commenters wishing to engage directly with the author should do so at the original post.
See all our coverage of the tragic case of Savita Halappanavar here.
For days now, I’ve been putting myself in Savita Halappanavar’s shoes.
I’m expecting. Seventeen weeks in, piercing pain sends me to the hospital. For three days, I’m miscarrying. There’s no hope for my child and my own health is fading. For three days, I’m in physical agony and doctors refuse my pleas to terminate the pregnancy to save my life. The child won’t survive, but there is a “heartbeat” and doctors fear terminating will violate my country’s laws. The unthinkable happens.
The tragedy that ended Savita’s life put a human face on the abortion issue. People are demonstrating in droves and even the Indian government is pressuring Ireland to change its laws. One demonstrator held a placard reading, “Savita had a heartbeat, too.”
For many of us, the disregard for women’s human rights in the name of religion just became personal. When I see Savita’s face, I can’t help thinking that she looks like me and, like me, was educated and could afford health care — but she still suffered this indefensible fate. Everyone knew the child could not survive, but that Savita could with proper care.
What does it say about a society when it leaves a woman to die in the name of “life?”
Where is the respect for women’s lives? This irony pervades the politics surrounding women’s health in my own country, the United States. Right-wing calls for abortion bans not only keep women from living full lives of our choosing, but often fail to include exceptions for our health or death. Most of those backing these so-called “pro-life” measures are also the ones blocking efforts to provide equal pay, health care, and safety net programs women and children rely on. It seems their concern for life ends when a baby is born.
And, if this can happen to someone like Savita, a doctor herself, what about more vulnerable women? As U.S. conservatives rush to eliminate the right to choose, it is poor women, disproportionately of color, who are seeing that right fade most quickly. It is these women who often cannot afford abortions, or do not have the time and know-how to see a provider during their first trimester. Twenty-week bans and funding cuts are not only sexist, but covertly racist and classist, too.
As I plan my own future and explore whether parenthood is right for me, I am thankful I live in a place where abortion is legal and safe, and that I can afford the right to choose. I am thankful that women have always been resilient in my country, and that we have a long history of fighting for and winning reproductive rights.
With strength and courage, women in the United States have come a long way. But our journey is not complete. Too many women are still left out and too many lawmakers threaten to send us back to a time when Savita’s story could happen here. That’s why I work to not only preserve the rights I have, but to expand them for all women — because we all have a heartbeat, too.
Photo by C-Monster under Creative Commons license.




12 Comments

Don’t be so sure, half of our hospitals are Catholic hospitals, and they will protect the heartbeat of a fetus over the heartbeat of a woman every day. Believe it.
The citation is in this post, and there is more.
I’m unclear as to what this post is trying to say . . .
Could it be that the writer is hoping for a world in which women have the right to terminate their pregnancy only when the unborn baby most likely will die, and the woman’s life is at grave risk?
Surely that can not be the intention of this post, can it?
Shouldn’t the law allow a woman to terminate her pregnancy at anytime, and for any reason she wants???
I believe she is promoting all choices for women and thinks we have choice in the US, if we can afford it. She thinks what happened to Savita is not possible in the US. That is not correct. It can happen, and one of every two hospitals is Catholic in the US. They have death panels for women.
Such is the inevitable result when you allow unelected shamans to write laws. I don’t see how anybody defends this rationally. I just don’t.
Something like this almost happened to me.. I was pregnant and started having a miscarriage. I went to the hospital and I was crying. They wouldn’t admit me. I didn’t have proof of insurance which I actually had. I had a new job and I really didn’t understand my insurance. I cried and cried and they wouldn’t admit me. The nurses accuses me of being a drug addict and simply told me to beat it. I look nothing like a drug addict BTW. I was bleeding and one of the nurses actually told me that didn’t mean anything but I was hurting really bad.
Anyway, I know most nurses are really good people but these women were not. It was a small town in CA and they basically wouldn’t let me in. I was new to the area and didn’t know my way around the town. I went home and returned to the hospital again. Worse and crying. Finally, they took me back after I wouldn’t leave, about three hours later, and a mean doctor was yelling at me while he had his hand up me and saying nothing is wrong with you in a horrible mean voice like I was a total piece of crap in his opinion. Then he Told me to get up and leave and he left. I was still crying and I couldn’t get up. I got up finally after a really long time because I simply couldn’t get up.
I finally made it from the table to the phone and called 911 but their switchboard wouldn’t put the call through. They came running in and this doctor started yelling some more. What do you think you’re doing. This scared them and they admitted me and called an obgyn. I lost the baby and it scared me really really bad. Sometimes when I go to the ER with people I start having a PTSD reaction and I start crying.
To f with someone when they are in this kind of state is really super traumatizing. I was really affected by it and those nurses actually called my boss and got me fired from a job I moved across country for and went into serious debt to make possible. I should have sued them all. I was too young to know my rights and I was really weakened by the whole event so I didn’t handle any of it when I could have. All I know is it was as scary as a horror movie for me and I was scarred for life.
thank you for sharing what happened to you. i’m guessing it wasn’t easy to write that.
(((testynn)))
I had no idea that half our hospitals are Catholic.
That is really a good way to put it. I actually think that this might very well be an actual crime. The fetus wasn’t going to make it. I think someone at this hospital was enjoying this woman’s suffering like a serial killer might or someone who makes snuff films.
I know that sounds horrible and out there, and my apologies to the family, but there are people in this would like that, absolutely. I wonder how many women have died while these particular people were in charge. If it was my family, I’d get my investigation, and not by some Catholic BS authority. Damn right I would.
“What does it say about a society when it leaves a woman to die in the name of “life?”
Where is the respect for women’s lives?”
First, to be clear, I fully support a woman’s right to control her own body/life. Abortion is one of those rights, guaranteed by law.
And, as you implicitly note, the essence of Roe v. Wade has survived the attacks, through Reagan and both Bush presidencies, that have been routinely trotted out at election time by the GOP (nothing new there, huh?) during my entire adult life (38 years).
Nevermind that Obama’s ACA extended, permanently, the Hyde amendment (http://www.slate.com/blogs/xx_factor/2010/03/21/the_executive_order_about_abortion_for_health_care_reform.html)
Now you tell me…
What does it say about a society that re-elects a man who has been killing innocent civilians, both women and children (and a lot of men, including a 16 year old American boy) with both drone and conventional warfare, with no plan to stop, indeed, with eager bravura to continue his war crimes and who, along with his Sec. of State – a woman – vigorously supports Israel’s “right” to do the same? Are those victims “worth it?” Is this child dead enough for you? http://www.chris-floyd.com/component/content/article/1-latest-news/2295-dead-enough-the-reality-of-the-qlesser-evilq.html
What does it say about the “liberal” Democratic voters who have blithely accepted NDAA and the end of Habeas Corpus in favor of the extra-judicial and utterly opaque assassination/extermination agenda – the kill list – by their beloved and fearless leader, Barack Obama?
Where is the respect for “The Rights of Man?” Who killed the Magna Carta and 400 years of humane jurisprudence?
What does it say about an American public which ignores its nation’s war crimes and showers the criminal with cult-like affection while awarding him the highest office in the nation?
What does it say about voters who have re-elected the man personally responsible for the Simpson-Bowles Commission and who, now re-elected, is totally committed to egregiously harming – and by extension, killing through austerity and grand bargains – poor women and children (and a lot of men and boys), whose existence he couldn’t even bring himself to discuss during his wretched campaign?
Am I expected, amidst all the killing, horror and heartless politics, to distinguish Savita’s tragedy from the ghastly bigger picture?
Excellent comment, bigchin. I wish I could recommend the comment.
In 1996, a woman of my acquaintance was diagnosed with cancer. The doctor she consulted refused to order a radiolgical procedure she needed because radiation might harm a theoretically possible, but in fact non-existent, fetus. Threats and lawyers followed and she did have the procedure. The cancer was determined to be metastatic but it was treated and cured. Today, she is alive and well.
There are people among us who would allow a woman to die a terrible and preventable death to preserve the rights an entity that does not exist. I doubted then, and doubt now, that this has anything to do with religion. Is has to do with sadism, misogyny and a terrible lust for power.