History buffs will recognize The Guns of August as Barbara Tuchman’s classic history of World War I. The reference works now because August 2009 just opened with trench warfare on health care reform. Unfortunately, the right-wing mob is seeing some early superficial success. We need to enter the battlefield immediately to defend the President’s top priority, providing a guarantee of good, affordable health care to all this year. This is a call to arms for the army of activists who powered President Obama to the White House.
We are already seeing the violent excesses of the right. They hung freshman Maryland Congressman Frank Kratovil in effigy, painted Texas Rep. Lloyd Doggett as a devil with horns, and screamed insults at HHS Secretary Kathleen Sebelius. [Edit: Updated with a better link here, thanks Jane. -- Jason Rosenbaum] This is an angry minority, bitter about an America that they don’t recognize, led by a man that doesn’t look like them.
These are the same crazies that applauded calls to violence last fall at Sarah Palin rallies and made a hero of Joe the Plumber. But remember, as the public began to understand what the far right-wingers really stood for, it didn’t take long for a great majority of the electorate to write them off.
But since health care won’t be decided at the popular ballot box, we can’t just wait for the public to recognize the reality behind this nutty minority. There are two prizes in the battle at hand – the national press narrative and Congress’ support. We have to win the press war by making it clear that shouts of "socialized medicine" and "government health care" are from a mob on the fringe of American politics. And we need to be sure that wavering Democrats in Congress see that there is strong popular support for health care reform.
Health Care for America Now is joining with progressive groups throughout the country to out-gun the tea-baggers in August. Members of Congress are spending their time at home trying to gauge public support for reform before returning to Washington after Labor Day. It will be a contest all month long, and we have to take it on with all the urgency that the historical task at hand demands.
We’ve launched a new page on our website to help you take action in August: www.healthcareforamericanow.org/fight. Here you’ll find out how you can join the fight locally. We’ll list town hall meetings and events by Congressman from both political parties so that we can show strong support for reform and keep control of meetings. We’ll also tell you how you can directly challenge those members of Congress who are siding with the far right, often using the same extreme rhetoric of the tea-baggers. And we’ll be organizing our own actions to show how Congressional opponents of reform are carrying water for the health insurance industry. The page includes pointers for how to organize your own action and how to prepare and respond to the right-wing mob.
As President Obama said on the night he was elected, "I know you didn’t do this just to win an election and I know you didn’t do it for me. You did it because you understand the enormity of the task that lies ahead. For even as we celebrate tonight, we know the challenges that tomorrow will bring are the greatest of our lifetime."
Of all the challenges in American history, there is none greater than turning health care from a privilege to a right. We need everyone in America who believes that health care is a right to rise to the challenge that the President laid out before us on Election Day. Right now, this month, is the time to declare that this is our country and that an extreme right wing minority will not wreck our nation’s path to health care justice.
(also posted at the NOW! blog)
Richard Kirsch is the National Campaign Director of Health Care for America Npw



53 Comments




Hey Richard, good to see you taking the time to post here. I’m still interested in getting answer to my question to you about the top goal expressed in your August field plan:
http://campaignsilo.firedoglak…..an-vs-fdl/
How many “commitments” have you gotten so far? What are your goals for August?
Have you gotten Jan Schakowsky, who works closely with HCAN and is one of the lead people working on health care in the House, to make that commitment?
This diary has been up for over 5 1/2 hours. Is it a drive-by?
HCAN has a $40 million budget. You’re spending $25 million on ads. And you want to use progressive blogs for astroturfing.
Richard’s at a meeting right now, but he’ll be reading comments.
It would be better if he responded to them.
That’s his choice, but I’ll make sure he at least sees them.
??????
what rubbish.
good, affordable healthcare has a name, and it is Single Payer.
Obamacare primarily will force people to tithe to the health insurance cartel – the mandate – with or without the paltry figleaf of a ‘public option’ that the cartel will dump all of their unprofitable, sickest patients towards.
privatize profits, socialize losses, just like the massive bi-partisan bailout of wall street.
http://www.latimes.com/feature…..full.story
The RNC is giving the phone number of the DNC to anyone who calls wanting to comment on the abusive tactics being used at town hall meetings about health care reform. The woman/thing on the phone is actually gleeful as she gives the DNC’s number.
I read it on red state and dialed to confirm. Dial the RNC using the number on their web page. The voice gives a list of options with number 1 being to leave a message about the DNC’s web site apparently asking people to call the RNC and ask the RNC to condemn the ugly yelling at public meetings that is organized by DC lobbyists like Dick Armey.
If you press 1, she get giggly and gives you a number to call to voice your concern. And that number is the DNC. I dialed the number, it rang 12 times before the poor young man could get to it. I apologized and told him I was only confirming what I had read.
Anyway, uh, the RNC sucks ass.
Richard, you posted the same thing on the Huffington Post
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/…..51735.html
HCAN’s blog
http://blog.healthcareforameri…..activists/
Daily Kos
http://www.dailykos.com/story/…..-Activists
All your links, however, go to MSM sources — even though blogs like ours have covered these events thoroughly (Jason had the very best posts I saw on the Kratovil effigy hanging).
They probably don’t have a place where you can post for free at the NYT or the Washington Post. Did HCAN advertise there instead? What was HCAN’s advertising budget for those publication?
Teabaggers, meeting disrupters, phone pranksters. Six year olds left without adult supervision.
Far be it for the RNC to politicize a policy decision…/s
Pathetic little men/women.
I spoke to a Republican Representative’s Representative yesterday. The one from OK featured in FDL.
The R R’s R, was name Andrew, a young aid. Very pleasant person.
Because I’m from the UK, I have direct experience of a single payer system.
The points were:
1. The US insurance/claims model requires 3 office staff for every doctor, and probably 3 more in the insurance companies. It can never be cost effective.
2. The UK treats its whole population from cradle to grave, for the same percentage of GDP as Medicare, the UK life expectancy and infant mortality numbers are better than the US.
3. In the UK Children and acute conditions get seen promptly. Chronic conditions experience the about the same wait time in the UK as the US.
4. Malpractice. At 1% of the cost of health Care I don’t see much savings here. CA has tort reform, and I see no effect on my premiums.
5. Doctor’s Greed. Andrew had read the McAllen New Yorker story. I believe we could make progresses and reform the fee-for-procedure system at the root of much cost in the US health care system.
6. My daughter, born in the UK, was delivered by midwives. There was a Doctor in attendance in the delivery ward, not hands on for every birth. Many procedure can be done with medical practitioners with Doctor’s oversight. Doctors need not do the work – unless they are greedy for fees.
7. My son, born in the US in an HMO cost me $1.00.
8. My HMO KP, cost me $150/month and $1 copay in 1980. Now it costs $800/month with a $30 copay. This increase is unexplained. Where’s the research?
9. Big Pharma. Andrew was unaware that most drug research is funded by the NIH. Drug research is a gamble for large corporation, and better done at public cost. We, the public, should receive royalties for drugs developed on Public Money. Other than marketing drugs, big pharma has little value.
10. I lived in South Africa, where the Government had capped fees to doctors. The doctors contracted out because they did not like the cap system.
We agreed we’d stay in contact. I don’t expect to change the R R’s mind. The R R needs to know we are informed, will ask tough questions, and have answers to their objections to root-and-branch reform of Health care, and many other America Icons.
Thanks for the compliment, though I wasn’t the first.
As a note, Richard wrote that post, though I helped him find links, where I tried to go to original sources. Not that blogs haven’t covered the events, I was simply looking for the source that broke the news. If I missed a breaking source, I apologize.
Good Morning America (which I consider right-leaning) this morning reported on Dick Armey and other lobbyists encouraging people to do all that yelling and interrupting.
I was surprised ABC touched that story at all and was happy that Independents and undecideds were presented that information.
Interesting! Point #6 reminds me of the huge Ka-ching sound I heard when my kids entered the world…
Oh! I hope someone here or at C&L will post the vid.
appropriating the language of Single Payer to try to lure support for some terminally flawed, botched from the outset, sellout plan?
ridiculous.
the challenge is all the greater because Obama took Single Payer off the table from the start!
http://www.singlepayeraction.org/blog/?p=1294
Richard,
You are a good guy?
Speaking of reputable media outlets, I’m still picking shrapnel out of my face from having watched about 15 minutes worth of Glenn Beck’s show today. I absorbed the 15 minutes in short bursts, as I wasn’t capable of handling such a large dose in one increment. He was doing his usual inciting, of course. My recommendation is to start a full scale letter-writing campaign to his anchor sponsors. My vague recollection is that such an effort resulted in UPS pulling the plug on Orally. The only thing that works with these cretins is hitting them where it really hurts, their revenue streams.
I wonder if the new health plan would cover Fox “News” face shrapnel?
Interesting that with the exception of names appearing in the “news” items, only “russell” is named as being a part of the site. While a single payer advocate I’m highly suspicious of anonymously run sites even if they do qualify as a 501(c)4 org.
“I’m highly suspicious of anonymously run sites…”
Seconded.
Obama is peddling dipshit vaccine.
Palin is priceless.
Let the doctors do no harm.
Not sure you want be using all the “gun” metaphors (”…to out-gun the teasbaggers…”).
Considering MANY of the Screamers and Baggers actually publicly express their desire to kill the Socialists, this is dangerous stuff. Just a thought…
The latest “news” item is 6 days old, none of them have any comments and the comment section is turned off. No cred with me.
from singlepayeraction:
Editorial Board:
James P. Donahue
Ivey Doyal
Matthew Hahn, M.D.
Jason Kafoury
Russell Mokhiber
Angela Petry
John Richard
Matthew Zawisky
but, so what? Dr. Margaret Flowers, Katie Robbins, Public Citizen’s Dr. Sidney Wolfe. there are some names.
Responding that only ‘Russel’ is on there is like disputing a statement based on what font it is written in – really a non-dispute, or an acceptance with caveat.
the entire WWI metaphor is stupid. that was a horrible, pointless war in which hundreds of thousands died for the pride and stupidity of unelected, far from the front lines, royalty.
maybe, on the other hand, the metaphor is unintentionally revealing, in which case, cannon fodder would be advised to stay well away.
The Kratovil link from the Washington Post references a Politico article. The Politico article hat tips Dave Weigel from the Washington Independent, where I first saw it:
http://washingtonindependent.c…..ng-im-high
Wiegel got it from Chuck Cook’s Daily Kos diary:
http://www.dailykos.com/story/…..d-our-help
Cook took the photos.
Those “news” items by “russell” are nothing more than blog posts. I don’t see any writings done by those you mentioned on the blog, just their names mentioned within. Sorry. Buhbye.
and what about their font?
doesn’t that make you and Shoto suspicious, too?
such trivial cavils just mean you cannot seriously dispute any of the actual points made.
It didn’t make any points that haven’t been made elsewhere in more credible venues for months. Any fool can be a parrot.
On edit: One more thing. Just because I choose not to comment on something doesn’t mean I don’t or can’t dispute it. It means I don’t find it worth my time to do so. My time, not yours.
>chuckle/
“The Guns of August: A Call to Arms for Progressives and Obama Activists”
————————————————————————
I assume this is an call to arms for angry mobs of progressives funded by the Tides Foundation and their affiliated groups.
Now lets talk health care. If you will insist on the following I will lead a movement to support single payer:
1. Everyone in the US part of the single payer system, NO Exceptions for Congress, the President and Government workers.
2. All the requests for service have the names of the patients redacted from the request so that Congress, the President, and Government officials get no special treatment.
If it is good enough for We the People, it is good enough for All the People.
I would like to see some responsed to this compromise.
howdy SD! i was looking for you… to ask how is gigi? (please forgive me if i got her name wrong).
p.s. what do you have against russell mokhiber? i think he’s been a hero with the work he has been doing these last few months.
nope – its a call for low-information Obama supporters to come out in support of a terrible plan that will draft them into mandatory premiums to the profit driven insurance cartel.
the only good that came out of WWI was some poetry:
WILFRED OWEN
My friend, you would not tell with such high zest
To children ardent for some desperate glory,
The old Lie; Dulce et Decorum est
Pro patria mori.
8 October 1917 – March, 1918
1 DULCE ET DECORUM EST – the first words of a Latin saying (taken from an ode by Horace). The words were widely understood and often quoted at the start of the First World War. They mean “It is sweet and right.” The full saying ends the poem: Dulce et decorum est pro patria mori – it is sweet and right to die for your country. In other words, it is a wonderful and great honour to fight and die for your country .
Hey, I just responded to you in another post. Would be great to get your response.
http://campaignsilo.firedoglak…..ment-35788
Hey, selise!!! Nice to see you. Didn’t know who he was. Why couldn’t this person above just give a link to him? I’ll check it out. Sure don’t like the site, though.
Gigi. Went into hospital this morning. Renal numbers are up, creatinine is up, white count is up, weight dropping like a stone. Vet wants to see if he can get her renal numbers down via renal diet and IV fluids over the next 48 hours. I’m not optimistic. Even if we can reverse the renal numbers that doesn’t take care of the underlying problems, I’m afraid. I’m really dreading noon Friday. Vet doesn’t want to say the word cancer and since she’s so weak he can’t sedate her to look for the brain tumor we think is there. Just kinda bouncin’ off the walls.
((((((SD and gigi))))))
i’m so sorry. gigi is very lucky to have you to watch out for her. hugs to both of you. and hugs also to all my fdl friends.
p.s. probably won’t be around that much but if you want more sp info, i can be reached via email (gmail.com) or at the link for my name (upper right link to contact page)
Sign these healthcare petions for single payer HR 676
http://bit.ly/HR676
http://bit.ly/single_payer_ross
Thank you Jane. I saw this diary when it was in the top ten box at Seminal, and I was just so po-ed I decided not to write the response I would have written.
The author did not disclose his status with HCAN, which even though many probably figured that out, it seemed a breech of etiquette at least.
I’m sorry to say this, but my first thought was why has the Seminal turned into a site to further HCAN propaganda? Okay, that’s extreme. But, the optics of this do not reflect well on FDL, imho.
Now that I see who “russell” is, why couldn’t you have come here as a supporter of sp without all the comments of how fucked up we were for not climbing on your bandwagon? There are a lot of sp advocates here. It’s a lot easier to get people to support your cause when you don’t tell them they’re fucked up if they don’t. Selise, for one, has spent a lot of time on this issue and taken a lot of shit for it but she didn’t have to resort to behaving like a troll to get her point across. Very few of your comments don’t contain some negative comment about the Lake and its community.
My guess is that was an oversight. But good to see you, VG.
Thanks Jane. I’m having a tough time with this, because I really value the kind of critical analysis that FDL has done on many other issues. So, I’m trying to figure what’s up, because some of my research indicates that HCAN has had a history of an agenda that, well, is an agenda to drive discussion in a particular political direction, by framing data in a less than neutral way.
selise is a star, that is true, and her style is different than mine, also true.
other issues you raise are valid, but a can of worms, not simple.
hopefully single payer will get its day in the the sun after Obamacare goes down, and then I will be on better behaviour, because then it is game on, for real.
Patterns are telling, aren’t they . . *G*
Good on ya, and Selise, too.
Vigilance.
The game has been on for a long time. There are a lot of us who have been bustin’ our ass for years trying to get things changed. I read your last statement as since you didn’t get what you wanted the first time around you’re just gonna throw rocks at those who do things or think differently. Not a good way to get me on your side, regardless of your stance on issues, because I’ve seen your act when things aren’t to your liking.
The best predictor of future behaviour is past behaviour.
I’d like to remind Spork that HR3200 is not done, no where NEAR finished.
And that DK’s HR676 has allies in both House and Senate.
And that ANY final bill can be handled with 50 votes if Obama chooses so.
And that Obama CA veto, without compromising 2010.
Basically, this game is barely half started . . . . keep an eye on it all, nudge it how ya want it.
FDL is doing a FINE, fine job as is its leader, Mz. Hamsher. The progs positions are in the light of day.
And we progs/libs have allies in both House and Senate.
This is the FURTHEREST a nearly normal state of mind (prog/lib = barely left of center in the OLD days) has come in 30 years. And we can go a lot further, too, if our ‘enemy’ continues to kill itself and reduce its appeal to only white, male, balding, racist, misogynist and homophobic asshats.
As we tear into the GOP and it shrinks itself, the NEXT big battle, and HEALTHCARE REFORM IS THE LEADING EDGE, the next battle is wresting corporate feudalism from our government, and from our lives.
THAT’S gonna be one hell of a fight.
For now, I’d say we’re doing fine.
Lighten up, some of yas . . . . as Norske said (albeit I disagreed with him on the topic) STOP FUCKIN SHOOTING AT PEOPLE IN YER OWN DAMNED FOXHOLES!!!! *G*
I like that Norske guy, even if he and others WERE wrong about KO and GE . . . . *G*
Now go play nice with each other, there’s more work to be done tomorrow, and the next day, and the next day.
As to HCAN, I distrust their overall goals and where their support comes from, and who their agenda is best for.
Corporate 1% meddling in the stuff of progressives goals and ideals is merely wolves in sheep’s clothing.
Nuff said.
I remain the only exception to that rule thru out the history of mankind . . LOLOL
Thanks Jane. I originally saw the Kratovil piece in WaPo, but used Politico as a link because it had the AFP response. Updated the diary, though.
I’ve added a bio line, indeed an oversight.
I don’t know if we can win the national press narrative, since companies own it (hi, GE!), but we can try!