Ed Schultz is certainly not universally loved in Progressive circles, his concentrated stand on behalf of the American worker in both private and public sector perhaps made unnecessarily irritating to listen too under a blast of bloviating vocal cords and a bullying personality: even though the bully was on our side in the class warfare billionaires started and, without talking heads like Ed, would have likely won by now. Nobody—and I mean nobody—in all of the cable news-as-entertainment universe has stood up and, yes, howled at and fingered those in state governments and the money-exchanging halls of Congress who are engaged in a national security threatening crusade to obliterate the upper, middle and lower middle classes quite as fearlessly as Ed Schultz. Though we may have had to cover our ears from time to time, Progressives needed this guy.
I’ve not been much of a fan of the Huffington Post since the AOL sellout (except for its books and writing page,) but, looking for some immediate commentary after Schultz, at the close of his show Wednesday night, announced that MSNBC’s The Ed Show was moving to the 5-7 PM Saturday and Sunday MSNBC slots, I was particularly struck by Anjali Sareen and Jack Mirkinson’s take on Schultz’s vacating of the 8PM desk:
“The change may be one of tone rather than numbers. Schultz’s ratings have been solid — he was the second-highest-rated host on the network in February — but his barnstorming, Midwestern, labor-friendly brand of populist liberalism has come to look more and more at odds with the increasingly elite and wonkish tone taking hold on the rest of MSNBC.”
Bold emphasis is mine. It is where Sareen and Mirkinson cut straight to the heart of why MSNBC/Comcast would shift the number two of its ratings bounty to the Siberia that is its weekend late afternoons. Schultz had made some striking headway in stripping the class war of its taboo and opening the minds of the once massively propagandized and brainwashed American worker that class warfare was not at all a dirty word, but a real war of some of the richest people and corporations in the world against anyone who must labor to make a survivable living.
MSNBC/Comcast, like all the corporate-owned media, exists on behalf of the oligarchy to tamp down this class warfare talk, to demean it unworthy of polite discussion. Schultz pulled off that duct tape and the dried crusted scab it clung to, likely elevating the fear of the elites in management that the oligarchy’s divide and conquer final solution, already deteriorating, would collapse altogether against the onslaught of millions of private and public workers, Tea Party and Occupy Wall Streeters, and unemployed and underemployed uniting in demand of the restoration of all of FDR’s New Deal and more, just when victory of the billionaires and GlobalCorps was within sight.
Exit Ed, enter, oh, say (best guess) the more polite and elite Ezra Klein.
I like Ezra, but he’s no Ed Schultz. MSNBC/Comcast and the oligarchy, no doubt, are counting on that.



15 Comments

Ezra Klein is establishment all the way. Even Charles Pierce called him out the other day.
Ed Shultz a bully? Never thought of him that way. In fact, my major complaint about him and the rest of the crew at MSNBC was that they were way too soft on Democrats, especially the Obama administration.
Ed did call out the White House more than others, though, when it came down to it, he would end up supporting the Democrats, especially if a vote was involved.
Networks exist to generate revenues and revenues are tied to ratings.
MSNBC has struggled for ratings for a long time. Ed had the second best ratings on MSNBC. I find it hard to imagine that MSNBC cut off its own revenue nose because The Ed Shultz Show was some kind of indirect threat to the 1%.
I am not saying it’s impossible, only that I am having a hard time seeing it.
On the other hand, Ed’s criticisms of the White House and Obama, mild and brief as they were, may have drawn some fire from that direction. If so, it wouldn’t be the first time.
Allegedly.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2011/07/21/cenk-uygur-msnbc-leaving_n_905415.html
MSNBC claimed that they had been working on a plan to develop Cenk into an even bigger media personality than he was. Odd that Cenk saw it as a demotion. He is not stupid.
Oh, well, I suppose no one will ever know for sure, except NBC news.
P.S. I believe that Shultz was the only one at MSNBC to lash out at Obama over “chained CPI.”.
Less prison time? That’s a good thing. I’m hoping Martin Basher gets the spot.
So MSNBC has now removed or castrated Keith Olberman, Cenk Uyger and now Ed Schulz.
I’d say its pretty obvious that forceful, truth-to-power opposition to the ruling class that appeals to mainstream voters is not allowed to grow too loud on a major network.
Now they can discuss more details of every elected Republican and potential Republican candidate’s policies, thoughts and bowel movements, as has become the standard fare.
Chris Hayes is taking over the time slot. You can add D Ratigen to the list of MSNBC shows that have been crtical of Obama that moved on
They are all sell-outs.
You let me know the day you hear Ed Schultz criticizing General Electric on national TV and that will be the day I say that I am mistaken.
NBC and MSNBC may actually be the biggest hypocrites of all yes, the network that is home to Lawrence O’Odonnell, The Ed Show, Rachel Maddow and Chris Matthews. They are owned by GE the largest war contractor in the world. They regularly censor stories even on PBS that tell the truth about who they are. Unlike Fox News who are so outrageous with their “news”, NBC AND MSNBC propaganda is much more subtle and pervasive.
You let me know the next time you hear Rachel Maddow, Lawrence O’Donnell, Chris Matthews or Ed Schultz on the air telling us that it is a damn crime that General Electric paid no income taxes for 2009 and 2010 even though they reported billions of dollars in profit. Then and only then will I say that I was wrong.
It will never happen because the fortunes of these people are tied to the fortunes of GE, just as are 82 members of our Congress who own millions of dollars of GE stock and see no conflict of interest in approving military allocations to this corporate war profiteer who pays no US income taxes in spite of its billions of dollars in profits that it makes from the US taxpayers–not to mention tax refunds.
Yep, it’s Chris Hayes. Billiant guy, but, as I said about Klein in my replacement guess, Chris is also in the mold of the polite and elite. He also is more cerebral than Maddow, so notch up the long-winded vocal essays and hope to not be lulled to sleep before Rachel….
Ed Schultz, meet Phil Donahue. You may remember Phil was once on MSNBC? I think you two have a lot to talk about.
(And, MSNBC is a much in the tank to the Powers That Be as CNN and the Broadcast Three Plus. FOX does have a whole niche to itself. But, MSNBC is perhaps starting to look more and more like the a good weaselly pol.
Again, not for nothing is the media referred to by some as the MCM — Mainstream CORPORATE Media. And the middle word is the operative one.)
I’m old enough to remember when Bill Cosby tried to buy CBS, I wonder how CBS would have evolved had he managed to do that….
But in the end he’ll support fucking over retirees and the disabled like he folded and supported BarryCare when all along he’d been stumping for the public option.
Schultz, like Maddow, is a Democratic Party stooge and a buffoon.
Hayes’s wife also works directly for the Bush Three administration.
Must make for some interesting bedtime conversation….
And Markos Moulitsos. And Marcy Wheeler.
agreed