David House is a 23-year-old computer researcher from Boston, Massachusetts. Since September 2010, he has been one of the few to regularly visit Bradley Manning, the soldier accused of leaking thousands of classified military documents to WikiLeaks. He has witnessed a disturbing degradation in Manning’s health.
For over seven months, Manning has been detained in solitary confinement at a maximum security military brig in Virginia. He has been forced to endure widely condemned conditions and could face the death sentence as a result of charges recently leveled against him. He has yet to receive so much as a preliminary hearing.
House, who was born in Alabama, was brought up in a conservative household and was an Eagle Scout as a boy. He admits that growing up he “never really had any big doubts about the US govt or about the fact that people’s due process may be infringed upon.”
Consequently, the detainment and subsequent treatment of his friend, Manning, came as something of a shock and an awakening. He helped start the Bradley Manning Advocacy Fund and has appeared on television and radio talking about the treatment of the soldier. It has been a “very jarring” experience, he says.
Last week, as part of a media conference call with Pentagon Papers leaker Daniel Ellsberg and former Judge Advocate General Jon Shelburne, House spoke at length about his experiences visiting Manning. What he described was deeply troubling.
He spoke about how the severe emotional and physical deprivation forced upon Manning is taking its toll, and suggested US authorities are – by treating him harshly – trying to extract a confession that implicates WikiLeaks’ editor-in-chief, Julian Assange.
It is important that the full story, as told by House, is in the public domain. In this case, a single quote as chosen by a journalist is simply not enough.
Below is a transcript of House’s story, taken from a phonecall on Thursday 3 March 2011. A recording of the call can be heard here.
—–
I’ve been visiting Bradley in the brig [at Quantico, Virginia] since last September. He and I met very briefly in Boston early last year, and I went to visit him in September because there were not many people, not many friends, who were willing to do so.
When I first visited him he was a very bright eyed intelligent young man, very full of life. We had many good conversations in September / October. But getting in to November something started to change, almost like a light switch had switched off or something. I thought that maybe he had just been sleeping right before our meetings or something, or maybe he was just tired because of medication he was on. But around late November his inability to really hold conversations the way he used to – the bags under his eyes under his eyes that were constant from meeting to meeting and his utter exhaustion – was really indicative to me that something was going on.
David Coombs [Bradley’s lawyer] and I talked a little bit in early December, and later that month I went to see Bradley – in late December – and asked him about his confinement after news had came out via Glenn Greenwald and Salon.com that he was indeed being held in solitary. And I hadn’t really pressed Bradley before that point on his conditions – again, I guess my naiveté assuming that the US government wouldn’t stoop to these ends in order to collectively pressure an individual, a young man like Bradley.
But in December I asked him: “What’s it like in here? Are you able to go outdoors? Pentagon spokesperson David Lapan has said you have access to newspapers, you can exercise, you can do calisthenics and running … is any of this true?”
And Bradley kind of didn’t believe that this would be the statement that the Pentagon was releasing – that they were either not telling the truth or they’d had a grave misunderstanding of the situation here.
Going in to January. I published that post on Firedoglake where I talked a little bit about my experience with Bradley … his conditions kept getting worse. There was some physical trembling when I visited him in late January. As I said in an MSNBC interview, there was a point at which he appeared to be almost catatonic and had very high difficulty carrying on day to day conversation. Tired all the time. He seemed to be undergoing a very obvious and very extreme decay from his former self.
So for me this has been like watching a really good friend succumb to an illness or something; like watching someone get very sick. And I do not think that this is normal for people being held in confinement. I think that the conditions he is under, the POI [Prevention of Injury] order which applies a selective pressure to him – locked up for 23 hours a day, denied access to regular exercise and denied access to social interaction – I feel that this has really weighed on him to a high degree.
I’ve done a little bit of learning on solitary based on this, and as you can imagine it has been a pretty emotional process. I’ve been trying to find what exactly is going on. In doing so I found closing arguments from a Guantanamo bay trial by an attorney named David Frakt, who was defending a young man from Afghanistan who was alleged to have killed two US soldiers.
David Frakt, in the closing argument of his client’s trial, said that he did not believe his client had had a fair trial, or could not have been given a fair trial, because he was kept in solitary confinement.
As David Frakt said in his closing argument: the purpose of the solitary confinement was to cause severe emotional devastation in his client ahead of the trial … to make him softer for the trial; to make him sign a confession or a false confession before the trial. In my opinion, I believe this is exactly what is happening to Bradley Manning.
I believe that the delays in Bradley’s trial taking place, I believe the government’s selective and punitive measures on him in keeping him in solitary which is different from any other detainee in the Quantico Brig … this is all because the US govt wants to get a confession – or a false confession – from Bradley Manning. And as we have learned recently, the US government has been unable to link Manning with Julian Assange … and so this pressure, I fear, may continue, as they try to extract a false confession for him.
One last thing about the research I did on solitary is a quote from [US Senator] John McCain about the effects of solitary. John McCain said: “It crushes your spirit and weakens your resistance more effectively than any other form of mistreatment.”
And for those on the call who are interested, I also found the case of a man named Bobby Dellelo, who was held in supermax [at Walpole prison] under similar conditions. Bobby Dellelo was also kept for 23 hours a day, allowed exercise for one hour, allowed access to visitors and television for an hour. Bobby Dellelo developed a form of psychosis after six months in these conditions.
This is consistent with EEG studies going back to the 1960s which found abnormalities consistent with brain trauma on people held in solitary confinement for six months or longer. I do not think that these are facts the US government is unaware of. And I think that Bradley Manning is being punished in this way because the US government wants him to crack ahead of his trial. For that reason I believe that his due process, his right to a fair trial, and certainly his right to a speedy trial, is being infringed upon.
David House can be followed on Twitter here. You can support Bradley Manning by donating to the Bradley Manning Advocacy Fund (US) or the Bradley Manning Defense Fund (International).
Cross-posted at openDemocracy



55 Comments

*
bootcut
4 March 2011 9:04PM
This paragraph is right out the code of military justice; 813. ART. 13 PUNISHMENT PROHIBITED BEFORE TRIAL
No person, while being held for trial, may be subjected to punishment or penalty other than arrest or confinement upon the charges pending against him, nor shall the arrest or confinement imposed upon him be any more rigorous than the circumstances required to insure his presence, but he may be subjected to minor punishment during that period for infractions of discipline.
The commander in chief is personally doing this and is not fit for office or the commander in chief has no idea what the hell his military goons are doing and is not fit for office.
This is the where unitary executive met his moral Waterloo. Fail.
Apparently PFC Manning has not been softened up enough yet for his ultimate persecution, er, prosecution. He’ll be ready for trial when he reaches the mental state of Jose Padilla. His treatment is also sending that proverbial message to any future whistle-blowers, Abu Ghraib come home to roost. If only we had a Nobel Peace Prize winner/constitutional scholar for President, these things could never happen! (Sorry to take this tone in context of your serious diary, no disrespect intended to you or PFC Manning!)
Manning is nothing more than a tool for the gov’t – they really want Assange and are waiting for Manning to say something that will implicate Assange. And it’s all illegal and disgusting.
“Abu Ghraib come home to roost”
Obama already tipped his hand at bringing Abu Ghraib stateside with his proposed Gitmo North. One way or the other Obama is getting his own little Gitmos in the COTUS. Petreus et al got rewarded for leaking because their leaks supposedly made Obama look good, but if you make Obama look bad it’s off to the gulags for you!
House? Who’s House?
Same thing they did to Jose Padilla…..they are now doing to Manning….how long before they get to us,you & me,those who disagree with our corrupt Govt.
It’s only a matter of time folks….
What’s the story on Manning’s parents? I understand they don’t visit, but why?
His name is David House.
David House is the loyal friend who has been visiting Bradley Manning in the brig at Quantico.
Manning is never far from my mind…. He needs all the good energy any of us can send him. Call it prayer if you will. But send it.
We need a campaign to stop this treatment of Manning. We need to get as many people as possible to call their representatives in Congress and get an answer to the following questions -
1. What is your position on torture?
2. What is your opinion about the treatment of Pfc. Bradley Manning, currently confined in a Marine Corps brig in Quantico, Va.?
3. Will you support Congressman Dennis Kucinich’s request to visit Bradley Manning in Quantico? His request was made more than a month ago.
That’s for sure. The U.S. government spent millions of dollars in the 1950s and 1960s studying the effects of isolation, sensory deprivation, sleep deprivation, and other forms of coercive treatment. Major government researcher, Dr. Lawrence Hinkle, gave a presentation at a psychiatric symposium (held the Group for the Advancement of Psychiatry at the Berkeley-Carteret Hotel, Asbury Park, NJ, Nov. 11, 1956), which had many government-linked psychiatrists, psychologists, and neurologists. He presented what researchers had learned about torture and indoctrination from a study of Russian, Chinese, and East European Secret Police systems, as well as from observations and experiments done by U.S. psychiatrists, psychologists and social scientists.
Another link to an article by Hinkle and his associate, Dr. Harold Wolff, was published in the Bulletin of the New York Academy of Medicine in 1957, discussing research done on “The Methods of Interrogation and Indoctrination Used by the Communist State Police,” conducted on behalf of the U.S. Army and Air Force. Of course, the CIA as also a benefactor of these kinds of research, and they ran their own programs.
The CIA used what it had learned in its own interrogation manual, published internally in 1963, and released via FOIA only a little over ten years ago. Here’s what the CIA said about isolation, which they accurately understood as a kind of sensory and psychological deprivation:
It’s not that the government hasn’t treated people before the way they are treating Bradley Manning now. It just hasn’t been shoved as much in people’s faces.
This entire situation is due to cowardice and/or ignorance on behalf of the U.S. media, which has done an insufficient job educating the public about the actions of this government for lo many decades now.
This will only get worse unless Americans stand up against this tyrannical abuse of power. Today it’s Manning, tomorrow, I promise you, it will be you or me.
Yes, it is
I don’t know why so many people are shocked that the U.S. is doing this. I was raised in a predominantly Native American community so I always had a healthy cynicism regarding the government. Read Howard Zinn and Noam Chomsky. The Constitution is just a piece of paper people! It means nothing. It was written by a bunch of hustlers and hypocrites.
Despite all the above, if you go over to DailyKult, you still come across deluded Obots that pooh pooh Manning’s situation…………. a man still to be found guilty of any crime.
‘The One’ must be protected at all costs.
So why go there?
Waste of time and keystrokes, in my view.
Since the liberal bloging community got involved Manning’s treatment has gotten worse. It is a large FU to all of us. We seem incapable of organizing ourselves in a meaningful fashion to resist.
After the Gov is done with Manning, no one will ever leak again. That is the lesson being attempted to be taught here.
I keep asking in this forum, where is his family? Why isn’t his family out in front on this? If his mother or father were in front on this then it would be far more difficult to keep it out of the mainstream. It’s one thing when dirty liberals who barely know him are banging the drum for him but family is another.
Now I always end up losing the thread where I ask this so maybe an answer has been posted but I think it deserves perhaps an entire article. If his family has abandoned him so be it. Somebody should ask them why directly. Somebody like the FDL crew because the MSM isn’t going to do it.
Friends, lets understand…This is the political elties who cater to the Corporations doing this,in other words the leadership of both political parties ,Dem & GOP are doing this.
This is us against them folks none of us are immune from this kind of treatment,not a single one of us.
‘Cos the dead-enders make for fascinating reading.
Pretzel logic that would defy any philosopher.
Forgive the asking, for I haven’t followed this nearly close enough, but where exactly is this young man’s family? I haven’t heard anything about/from them?
You could answer your own question with teh google.
http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/8169292/WikiLeaks-family-unable-to-see-suspect-Bradley-Manning.html
His mother lives in Wales.
I made a picture. Obama visits Bradley Manning at Quantico:
http://six-pack-jack.blogspot.com/
This pic has gotten me tossed off of several (supposedly) liberal websites. It tells a hard truth that few seem to care about. I remember when noone cared about Abu Ghraib… until there were pictures. Well, this picture is probably the best we’re gonna get out of Quantico. Feel free to disseminate.
Our House? /s
“He’ll be ready for trial when he reaches the mental state of Jose Padilla.”
That’s it — the full Padilla treatment.
Some f***’ing change we can believe in.
All reading this thread please go to:
http://www.bradleymanning.org
…and help out in whatever way you can.
Please act before the Obama administration succeeds in destroying Bradley Manning.
That is just superior. Nicely done.
You can help change that by going to “Quantico, VA: Rally for Bradley! March 20.” Bring your friends. It’s only a $10 round trip bus ride from Union Station.
I gave up after Kos memorably observed “Fuck Nader and fuck anyone who voted for him.” He’s personable in person, but there’s something about the internet that causes one’s inner boor to come out.
Consider bringing your attention, time and money to “Quantico, VA: Rally for Bradley! March 20″. Also you can always donate to FireDogLake.Com here. They’ll use that energy extremely well.
You can do these things and more.
It isn’t Manning they are softening up, it is the public.
“Slow boil” as they say.
Last year terrorists in Cuba, this year traitors in the US, next year the rest of us?
Punishing/torturing an innocent person.
How un-American can you get Mr. Obama??
And how un-American must you be to support such a President that allows such un-American actions to take place?
His mother lives accross the big pond, in Wales. Kinda tough to travel that far to visit I would guess.
I don’t really know the deal with his father.
For a long time I hoped that he had really good lawyers and that would bring an end to this injustice in court.
Now I realize he could have the best lawyers to have ever walked the face of this earth and it wouldn’t matter. The United States of America is no longer a country that lives by the rule of law.
So sad that so many have sacrificed so much for this great country only to have it turn out this way.
“An injury to one is an injury to all!” Will you stand with Bradley Manning? You can do it March 20 with a whole lot of other folks. There’s a billion ways for you to take action if you can’t be there.
184 Ways: “The Methods of Nonviolent Protest and Persuasion</a (Feb. 28, 2011)
More:
"Washington Nurses 24-hour strike” (Mar. 4, 2011)
“Ray McGovern Calls Out Robert Gates as a “Consummate [Political] Windsock” (Mar. 3, 2011)
These jireens are going to have to live with the fact they didn’d tke responsibility for their action/inaction.
I feel sorry for them for being so calous.
When I was with Greenpeace, we borrowed a phylosophy from the Quakers.
It is called “bearing witness.”
We went out in little zodiacs and filmed the killing of one of natures most beautiful creatures being slaughtered. We returned with said film and turned it over to the media, who, in turn, showed it to the general public.
Viewers of this attrocious slaughter could turn away and ignore it, but not in ignorance. They saw what was happening and could choose to do something about it or not.
Such is the case with the jireens “guarding” PFC Manning. They seem to be ignoring his situation, but they cannot turn away in ignorance
If only we could get such a scenario happening with PFC Manning.
This issue alone is reason enough to refuse to vote for that psychopath Obama.
Recommended. Very, very recommended.
Why is your position on afffermative torture?
Fixed it for you…
Done.
Thanks. As soon as I heard about the forced nudity, my mind went right to Abu Ghraib, and this image popped into my head. I think it captures the awful truth quite nicely.
Ain’t that the truth…almost everything that GWBush implemented is still in place,when many us of us voted for Obama,it was to change these hideous policies…..well Obama is GWBush & nothing has changed except for the in your face bravado of GWBush.
Knowing what I know now,I can never vote for Obama again,I refuse to endorse 4Th term of GWBush with my vote.It’s 3rd party all the way for me or stay home.
petraeus could very well be the american pinochet…
As I’m fond of saying: “Obama promised change. But then he didn’t change anything. THAT’S THE CHANGE (suckers)!”
Christians have always been into torture. It’s part of their belief system, hell being eternal torture. I wish I could say that I’m surprised.
There’s where I think you’re wrong. We need collective action, not individual action and it has to be broad based, not something happening at Quantico. That matters, but lots of people can’t get to Quantico. It needs to be continuing, not one shot.
Yes Gulag, the term Sen. Dick Durbin used about Bush’s Guantanamo but now would shit before he would dare repeat that about Obama’s Devil’s Island! Indefinite detention, approved assassinations, trial by torture: what a model our Nobel Prize winner is!
I’m not shocked either, but I do feel outrage and will protest this, and other nefarious activities, as loudly and as much and as often as I can.
Your comments, though, are duly noted, and I totally agree with you said. The Constitution means nothing, esp if you’re an elite with tons of money and big-time connections.
The treatment of Manning is being shoved in our faces in order to make the rubes “accept” it as “normal” or “ok.” I refuse to “accept” it.
Agree. Has to be ongoing and collective, albeit individual actions are encouraged and can be helpful… as long as the ongoing collective actions occur.
I agree the primary purpose of abusing Bradley Manning is to get “evidence” against Julian Assange. The other purpose is to punish Manning’s “treason.” In any case, what this means is that if the US gets its hands on Assange, he’ll never see the inside of a federal courthouse. He’ll go straight to Guantanamo and at best he’ll get a military commissions trial, where illegally gained evidence from Manning will be admissible. He’ll be convicted, then he’ll disappear further into the American Gulag. If we let it happen.
RH
You’re not the only one who *immediately* thought of Abu Ghraib, but I’m glad there are others out there who felt the same as I did. I believe that Dennis Kuchinich has used that comparison, fwiw, as well.
It is, very sadly, all too true of a comparison.
Caveat emptor: this could happen to you and me. Never think it couldn’t.
Thank you for your detailed post. I’m not surprised to learn about Manning’s deteriorating state, but I did wonder about that. To say I’m sorry about this egregious situation doesn’t begin to cover how I feel.
I encourage everyone who can to attend the protest at Quantico on March 20, and otherwise to take other actions to protest this obscene and disgusting and quite frankly *illegal* treatment of a fellow US citizen.
Recommended.
Agree. They want Assange and want him badly. And yes: he’ll be sent straight to the Gulag called Guantanmo… make no mistake about that.
That’s why documenting his decline is so important. I hope people are paying close attention. They will of course eventually get what they want from him, whether it’s true or not. And that information will be used to indict Assange and will be used to convict Manning.
Tortured…testimony. By the time he tells them what they want, there will be no sanity left in this poor man.
This is tragic. I believe only international pressure is going to have any effect. If you have friends in Europe, get them to put pressure on their government to act.