No. It’s not about Democrat or Republican. It’s not about the left wing or the right wing.
It’s about capitalism and corporate power. It is now perfectly clear that BOTH parties, all three branches of government, and the fourth estate are controlled by corporate power.
Corporate power versus ordinary people. For my generation it began with the Kennedy and King assassinations and the Vietnam War. We gained some ground for a few years in the 1970’s with the impeachment of Nixon, but Carter failed in spite of his good intentions and it went viral in the 1980’s with the election of Ronald Reagan. Since then our entire culture has been hollowed out by it. We now have two generations that have been educated under the Reagan/Bush/Clinton/Bush corporatist educational philosophy. Civics, Good Government, and the history of the Labor Movement has slowly but surely disappeared from school curricula. Reading by phonics went away suddenly in the mid eighties and was replaced by Whole Language, a dismal failure, that left a decade of classes of 1980’s and 1990’s school children behind the curve on reading and writing. And with G.W. Bush, “No Child Left Behind” put the failure of our educational system on steroids. I’m a baby-boomer. I was in the high school class of ‘69 (the best class;). We were taught that Government is good. Our kids, and their kids, have been taught that Government is bad. We learned about the Red Scares, the Palmer Raids, the Army/McCarthy Hearings, and the Haymarket Riot. We learned who Joe Hill, and Paul Robeson, and Thurgood Marshall were. Our kids and grandkids have not been taught about those things in school. Thirty years have gone by. The me-first, sink-or-swim, liberalism-is-bad, Government-is-bad, greed-is-good thinking has now been instilled in a majority of our population. It’s assumed to be the norm by two generations who don’t remember the world without computers, internet, and cable TeeVee.
Our manufacturing sectors no longer exist. We’ve gone from the largest importer of raw material and the largest exporter of finished goods in the 1950’s, 60’s and 70’s, to the largest exporter of raw materials and the largest importer of finished goods today. The American middle class experienced 40 years of growth after World War Two. Since the mid 1980’s, wages have declined in spite of the vastly increased productivity of the workforce brought about by the digital revolution, and the stability of the middle class is gone. Seventy-five years of labor protections brought to us by the blood, sweat, and tears of generations of union organizers and labor activists have been broken. Our bread-and-butter jobs are gone and won’t be coming back if the corporatists have anything to say about it.
Why do corporatists worship the memory of Ronald Reagan? Among other things it’s because Reagan and his followers revolutionized the way politicians communicate with voters. Cable TeeVee became widespead and began to replace broadcast. The Fairness Doctrine, which required broadcasters to broadcast content in the public interest was abolished. Electronic media, which was then nascent, was conglomerated and brought under tight corporate control. The News Divisions of the large broadcast networks were taken out from behind the firewall of the Fairness Doctrine and put under the umbrella of the Entertainment Divisions. Roone Arledge, a sports broadcast producer, took control of ABC News. When “Cable News” became popular in the late 1980’s all bets were off. The news was officially canceled and has for the past 15 years been replaced by “info-tainment”, which was once called “bread-and-circuses”. The motion picture “Network”, produced in 1979, was eerily prescient. Our entire population has been dumbed down to the point where they will now seem to swallow any crap that comes out of their corporate TeeVee, including the myth of Barack Obama, who has shown himself to be just another player in the corporate game.
Nothing will change unless there is honest campaign finance reform and corporate money is taken out of politics. But the Supreme Court has ruled that corporations are persons and that for corporations, money equals speech. Corporations have been deemed to be persons and granted protections under the First Amendment, but somehow they can still buy and sell other corporations. I don’t get that. Where I come from they call that slavery. But overturning corporate personhood will require a constitutional amendment and/or the overturn of at least two Supreme Court decisions, and I don’t see it happening anytime soon. Our entire government is now under tight corporate control. And don’t get me started on the environment, the climate, the wars, the torture, the militarized police, and all that other stuff.
Capitalism is a great system when proper tax and trade policies are enacted and the marketplace is properly regulated. We know this from our history. Karl Marx may have been wrong about the scalability of Communism, but he was dead right when he described Capitalism as an unsustainable system when left unchecked. If left on it’s own it will grow like a cancer. We are now in the cancer stage of Capitalism. Our economic and political systems are strangled by it and it is killing itself. It is eating itself from the inside and it will eventually collapse if Government does not take control and make it work.
Hopefully our species will survive to see that happen.
Update: I wrote this last week and posted it on DKos over the weekend. It got 58 comments, but I don’t think many people saw it there in the rush of diaries that day. Considering what has happend in Left Blogostan over the past week, I thought it would be appropriate to post it again over here.



24 Comments




I just wrote the only route left is a constiutional convention, the “nuclear option” for the people. You need 2/3 of the state legislatures to call for a convention. That means you have to have liberals, conservatives and independents united and demanding it.
The congress won’t act on its own. Too much money involved to expect squat out of them.
True and true, this is about American families sold to rent seeking corporations, abetted by mealymouthed go along to get along wankers in suits (Feingold, Franken, Sanders, Weiner) and a resident so lacking in character there is no point in believing anything he says. I have been a dem all my life, and I was proud of it. No longer. I intend to support primary challengers of anyone who ‘went along’ with this bill, if that doesn’t get it, I will vote for the nuttiest nutjob reps I can find. This is it, I’m done.
Burn!
That is the big taboo issue – hyper financier’s capitalism– that undermines the left and right, progressives and moderates, working folks and poor folks. You are exactly right and we have to name it, see it and explain it with our allies.
The recent hyperbole about Jane’s call to work with libertarians on the Audit The Fed issue was a good example of the ignorance underlying a lot of the mis-understandings in the blogs.
I have admired the libertarians strong anti-war, anti- corporate stance, but have a hard time explaining this to progressives. I’m NOT talking about ‘tea baggers, which is the other issue of misunderstanding in the recent blogs. Coalitions don’t agree on all issues, but understand there are critical times when you have to join together to stop the beast. See the Antiwar.com for great commentary on the industrial/military complex and the empires reach.
Recently reading a lot about the Revolutionary War era and there are great lessons in coalition building and effective compromises based on individual liberty, rather than the current lowest common denominator process in this health care legislation.
Lastly, this is the precise moment when Feingold and real progressive MUST VOTE NO and put Obama/Ramn on notice. Carry it forward!
Sangemon, a good analysis that pulls a lot of threads together. As you point out (and most people miss) it is ALL interrelated beginning with money and influence in our government. What the health “insurance reform” bill has done is to show this clearly: our government representatives from the President down to the lowest congress critters, are usually bought and paid for by huge interests that have nothing in common wih average people. This problem is in turn linked to increasing concentration and monopoly control of the media and the gradual killing off of public education. Note that Obama has never been in a public school in his life and that Arne Duncan is a corporatist too, just like Obama. We are in far deeper trouble than most realize. I do not believe it is reversable at this point since the huge corporations control everything. It is also becoming increasingly clear that they have sold out America and the American people. The concept of “free trade” pacts was simply one that alowed corporations to pick up and move their manufacturing to 3rd world countries (China) that have no labor movements, no laws controlling anything. Those pacts and the legal fiction of corporations being people then allows these same corporations to take advantage of our laws but base their production elsewhere. This sellout started with Reagan. You are so correct when you identify Reagan as the key figure in all of this: he really did change America far more than anyone else. George W. too in the sense that he didn’t need to control Congress to get anything done.
The most interesting thing to me about the health care debate is that the conversation has been only Democrat vs Democrat, Republicans have hardly registered. Folks are beginning to see the real differences within parties.
Same cohort. I graduated in 1971. Remember taking civics? Yeah, me, too.
I doubt that many others do.
edit:reply to Jason
Yes, but there seem to be no differences in the senate, the leftiest of our dems voted to sell us out just like Baucus and Nelson. I find it very irritating for them to be casting blame on others when they voted for it. This is why dems are seen as weak. I tellya, the progressives in the house have a historic opportunity here to vastly increase their power, if they spike this thing they will be the ONLY unmovable force in congress or the WH not available for the right dollar amount.
I want to see it!
Marx was right. Capitalist systems must be justly and tightly regulated or they will simply devolve into organized criminal empires, like the contemporary US. Crime is the natural way of life at the upper reaches of the Federal government.
Unfortunately, the now defunct Soviet Union doesn’t say anything better about the fate of communist or socialist governments.
If an honest history can be written of America in say fifty to a hundred years, I think it’s title and theme will be: the one that got away.
I learned labor history too, starting in grade school. It helped that my teachers were nuns, and many of my schoolmates were children of labor families. It seemed real to them and so to me, even though my family was not a union family.
Who’s to blame for all You present?
The American people have been, and are still wrapped up in the two parties.
The Corporations have bought our Government, and by that us.
We still re-elect and keep in office people of both parties we all know are owned by the Corporations.
We sat back and never even bitched while our Government sold us out, and rewarded those who did it to us, by voting again for them.
We thought our vote was all that was needed to keep our Government in check, and it would keep the Corporations in Check. In stead it gave itself, and the Corporations our checkbook.
We know the answer on how to fix our Government, and break the Corporations hold over it and us.
A third and forth party, and never vote for either of the two partes again.
Won’t happen, because the people aren’t smart enough, or willing to put the effort out.
It certainly appears to be the case.
Zero accountability.
Zero social responsibility.
Zero means of assessing whether — like Enron — these are legit employers, or simply elaborate Ponzi schemes made respectable by social connectons, hype, and an ADHD public.
Here’s a Republican you could probably enlist.
Hollings is a Democrat, but yes, He gets it.
http://www.publicampaign.org
Read, review, volunteer.
If this is posed as an anti-capitalist argument, it is lost before it starts.
I sound like a broken record here: the problem is that we have a coalition government. There is a difference between the parties, but their objective is the same – preservation and protection of the old industrial/corporate economy. Same as it ever was.
The solution: reformulate the coalition from Red/Blue to Blue/Big Green.
This does not require ‘revolution’ or a constitutional congress. It does require destabilizing the party apparatus so that it can realign to where the society actually is.
I agree with some of your points and disagree with others. but I think
that we are hovering in the same universe: neither party is representing the best interests of the average American. Corporate Americas team A (Dems) are playing Corporate Americas team B (Repubs). Result: Corporate America team wins the Game – always. If I were to be pigeon-holed by a pollster I’d probably be called a fiscal conservative and a social liberal – if only it were that simple! Take healthcare reform. I’ve been opposed to all legislation thats been proposed not because I dont think people deserve healthcare but because I knew that politicians from both sides would make it needlessly complex because they are motivated by forces that have nothing to do with what’s right and what is not. What’s right is that any human being should be able to access healthcare without regard to their financial situation. We pay taxes to government and they should use our money for our health and well being ( healthcare and defence )and they should pretty much stay the hell out of the rest of our lives! Seemds pretty simple, but it makes sense to me. This healthcare legislative process has pretty much disgusted Americans on both Left and Right( Left and Right is too simple of a way to categorize people, but thats another letter ) andf maybe thats something that people with good hearts from both sides can coalesce around. I myself am thouroughly disgusted with all branches of goverment in this country. Something is deeply wrong with America and those of us who care need to start flexing our muscle.
What precisely do you mean by this? And how does this happen? Serious questions.
What’s deeply wrong is that Corporate power has taken control of EVERYTHING. Our entire culture. All of it.
There is a ripe populist coalition left and right and center that opposes financialism hollowing out our job producing economy and Wall Street owning and running the government.
We need to put the divisive issues aside for a moment, same sex marriage, abortion and the like, issues that are dribbled out to make us hate parodies of each other, so that we can focus on taking democracy away from the kleptokrats.
We are at a point where demanding the promises made us in high school civics class is radical.
Our public school system has been systematically dismantled. We all watched it happen. Intellectuals attacked, artist attacked, mediocrity leading the way. People putting their own children above the good of all children. There are plenty of people that know better and actively participated or turned a blind eye. Of course everything that you pointed out has devastated the country. It is so inter related it’s hard to know what is the best plan of action with no leaders and no movement. I know we all want something different and I mean all of us. I am a liberal and I believe in the essential goodness of man however I’m not stupid so it may require some arm twisting or brain twisting.
Thank you for doing so. I agree 100% with all of it.
Campaign finance reform can still work regardless of the SCROTUS: if corporations are “persons” then, fine, treat them as persons by creating a hard individual donation limit to parties, candidates, and campaigns. Make it, oh I don’t know, something like $2000, period. That’s it.
Then corporations, regardless of how much money they have stolen from the real people can still only donate the same amount as any actual person.
Excellent idea.
To paraphrase Emma Goldman, under our current corporatist system, if voting could make a real difference in its workings, it would be illegal.
Government cannot do anything to make things work differently as long as government remains under the control of accumulated capital which has a strong vested interest in making sure that nothing substantive changes. I don’t know how to destroy the cancer of corporate control that has spread throughout every branch of government and the media, but refusing to compromise where no principled compromise is possible would be a good start.