In case you missed Ezra Klein’s "I feel for Karen" memo yesterday, today is "Hug Your Health Insurance Company Day."
So the New York Times hands over a front page "news" article to urge its readers to be more sympathetic to the health insurance industry and in particular recognize what a nice lady Karen Ignani, head of America’s Health Insurance Plans (AHIP) is for being so cooperative about health care reform.
The title of Reed Abelson’s column, For Health Insurer’s Lobbyist, Good Will Is Tested, tells the story. AHIP, the Times tell us, has already voluntarily offered to change its most egregious practices, like excluding previously sick people, and to stop fraudulently rescinding polices when people get sick. How magnanimous.
And in return for these unilateral concessions, the Times tells its readers, the industry obtained . . . uh, nothing as far as Mr. Abelson knows.
Apparently the clueless Abelson doesn’t know, and the Times editors and fact checkers cannot recall, their own reporting that AHIP’s "concessions" agreeing to stop screwing the American people were offered in exchange for the following modest concessions:
1. We would not displace the bloated insurance companies with a single-payer system; indeed, we wouldn’t even allow that policy approach to be considered;
2. We would enlarge the market for AHIP, by requiring all individuals to acquire, and most employers to offer, (with some hardship exceptions) private health insurance from AHIP members;
3. The federal government would raise taxes to provide subsidies to low- to middle-income Americans, to help pay for the insurance company premiums, without further regulating the amount of the premiums;
4. The reform bills would delay the end of the most egregious insurance practices for several years, at least until 2013 and grandfather existing policies until 2018.
In the meantime, AHIP was left free to spend literally millions each week to buy Congressional votes/influence to stop any effort to force AHIP members to compete against a Medicare-like public insurance plan, which might require them to lower rates, abide by the new prohibitions, or lose market share. That means nothing will disturb the mega insurer’s stranglehold on the market.
As part of its "cooperation" in health care reform, AHIP lobbyists have done everything they can to delete the public option, and failing that to replace it with an ineffective co-op, and failing that to weaken any public-based competition, delay it, and restrict access to it.
But informing its readers is apparently not the goal of the Time’s editors on Hug AHIP Day, let alone the task of the clueless Abelson. Instead, Times editors knowingly hide all of these well-documented facts while delivering a tongue bath to Karen Ignani and AHIP, while telling us how unfair it is for Nancy Pelosi to call the industry a bunch of "villains." Mean Pelosi apparently watches Bill Moyers’ Journal.
Each year, some 20,000 Americans die because they couldn’t afford health insurance or thought they had insurance but their insurers refused to cover them when they got sick. A million people will go bankrupt because they can’t afford insurance or because our private insurance system won’t pay their medical bills.
If you’d like to send your health insurers a message on how much you love them, Jane Hamsher has some ideas, and you can attend a "we love you" event listed here.



45 Comments







I wonder how much AHIP money (i.e., our premiums) has gone
to K street lobbyists who hire astroturfers to organize TeaShirts?
That is an excellent question.
I’d rather know how much went to the Times.
“Hug your health insurance company” day what a hoot.
Keep hoping that Billionaires for Bush or the Yes Men will show up at one of the scream fest dressed up as insurance company executives holding signs that thank the “screamers” for protecting the profit margins of health insurance companies
http://billionairesforbush.com/index.php
Bet the Yes Men will show up at one of the “screamer” events
http://www.theyesmen.org/
We need a contest to name this holiday:
”Kiss an Ass, Hug AHIP”??
Spreading your blog around..it is a real wiener.
“hug an insurance company executive” day. They need their profit margins protected
I sure hope the Yes men show up
We’re Making A Killing !
small government, Big Insurance !
Hands Off Humana !
Eve called this out yesterday. Despite her warnings, I was still stunned at the commercial grade knee pads Mr Abelson was sporting today
Abelson is a she.
Have you hugged your health in$urance company today?
http://bit.ly/4a5xQN
I like your sloshed elephant. Or did it die from lack of health coverage?
wow Scarecrow, just read the Ezra link – uh mah gawd
The people who are against universal health care don’t love their
insurance company. They just see a govn’t run
health care system as a perverse alternative.
It would stifle inovation, not be efficiant and would soon
go broke as is medicare, medicade, SS, and the post office
Sorry but what you are saying is just dumb. Medicare is much better run than private plans, but it has been deliberately hamstrung in being even more efficient and economical by conservative interests. It has also been underfunded by not taxing the wealthy who are able to contribute more. Yet even with these impediments, it still does a much better job of delivering healthcare to an older and sicker population. Social Security is still running large surpluses. Unfortunately, the government is spending these and then accusing SS of being in financial trouble. Medicaid is a mess but that is largely been because it too has been underfunded and left to the states to mismanage further. The post office’s problems are similar to those of Medicare in one way. Private enterprise is allowed to cherrypick the most profitable parts of the system while the public enterprise most deal with whatever is left.
medicare does not deliver health care. Physicans do. The payments are
dispursed by the government. Medicare is going broke because they are not
able to control what they are paying the medical community
While SS currently has surpluses, as the population ages they do will be
in the red. You make my case for why the government should not be in charge of managing our health care, because they SPEND our money
The post office is ineffecient and will be replaced by technology
and privage enterprized as no new inovation comes from public services
Yeah I wonder how quickly Medicare could get out of financial trouble if they could negotiate for, say, prescription drug prices.
Or get the HMOs out of both Medicare and Medicaid. that’s when they started getting in financial trouble.
That’s a big key right there. Medicare works really well and I’m surprised and pleased that it does. It should be for all.
Nice job on MSNBC today, Ms. Hamsher.
How many times do people need to hear Obama and others say “if you like your plan and your insurance coverage keep it” KEEP IT KEEP IT.
Don’t you have a “Tea-Bagger” party to go to?
Hey jag-off, you were obviously home schooled.
So you are satisfied that the U.S. is ranked 37th in healthcare by the World Health Organization. By the way, France is number 1 with Italy number 2. Apparently 37th is good enough for you. What a jag-off.
according to who?
The next time you need an MRI, Buy it from a French company
Hey jag-off, I wouldn’t have to buy an MRI in France, but then I wouldn’t expect you to know that. You really were home schooled.
You don’t get it. My point is that while you think France care is #1
they and most other countries have to buy all their high tech medical
imaging equipment, prescription drugs, from US
Do you know why that is? No I didn’t think so
How very astute! And where is the evidence to back up any of those claims?
http://www.washingtonpost.com/…..04214.html (social security)
http://www.google.com/hostedne…..wD99SRM884 (post office)
An idea that I have begun to put out there is that our elites do not represent the insurance companies or Wall Street. They are the insurance industry, the healthcare industry, BigPharma. They are the banks and the big financial institutions. They are the military-industrial complex. They are our media. When we look at Obama, the Democrats, the Republicans, or media heads like Brian Williams or George Stephanopoulos, it is corporate America that looks back at us.
NPR has been giving Ignagni a tongue bath, too. Yesterday and today they featured her whining about the insurance industry being painted as a villain. Wake up, Karen. The insurance industry IS the villain. Wonder if she’s seen “Thank you for Smoking?”
On the other hand NPR today highlighted John Bolton criticizing Bill Clinton negotiating a release of two U.S. journalists and a critique by David Frum of Obama’s stimulus plan. National Propaganda Radio. If you think otherwise it’s time for you to wake up and smell the coming fascism. To think that NPR represents an unbiased and the highest standard of “journalism” is the height of naivete.
Medicare for All, with a robust private insurance option
It’s what works, what we need, and, hey, the private insurers are still in the picture.
What’s not to like?
That’s basically the Stark Americare plan (HR 193).
So if 1-4 are all true (and I believe you) what the heck are we fighting for?
Other than to demand a total junking of the current bills, demand rewrites that clearly disallows all the endless monstrous abuses of Americans that are now written in to the current bills.
Whose leading that charge?
So what if Jane gets all 40 of her pledges; what the heck have we got that doesn’t guaranteed more of the same otherwise for the bloated and endless profits of the industries to the detriments of the people?
Blessings,
Call the WAAAHHmbulance for Karen. Or maybe AHIP won’t pay for it. WAAAH.
I don’t understand where or why Karen believes the industry has offered to stop rescinding policies. They just had a hearing in congress where all industry reps said they wouldn’t stop when asked point blank. Ezra must be smoking something to believe any offer from AHIP is worth the disappearing ink it was written with.
Did anyone read the comments section on that article? Didn’t seem to me that anyone there was falling for the beneficence of mega insurance.
The way the health bill is shaping up , it looks like only 4% will be able to enroll in a public option if it is there at all and THIS is what the big fuss is all about?
I guess insurance and Phrma are just scared it’s a foot in the door. Which I certainly hope it is
The public option isn’t PHARMA’s issue, because it doesn’t directly affect them. Their main concern is protection for brand name drugs and patent rights, and so far, the side agreements are granting them monopolies for 12-18 years. They also don’t want a monopsonist like Medicare negotiating drug prices, because it could use its market power to bargain for lower rates for Medicare part D (drugs for those 65 and older). That was left out Bush’s drug bill in 2001 or so, but the Dems are trying to get it back in the House Bill. There will likely be a fight over that in September.
Even though I’m slowly getting used to the idea that the print media and the TV news are biased in favor of corporations, I still found this plea for pity for the poor insurance companies by the NYT shocking. Did they forget how the health care players promised Obama to reduce costs by a certain amount over ten years, got him to go on TV and applaud their reasonableness, and then take back their pledge almost immediately, once no one was looking?
I hugged my insurance company but it didn’t hug me back.
*pout*
Your insurance company likes to squeeze you. That’s their hug.
I hope you were wearing a hazmat suit.
That Ezra Klein piece was nine ways to stupid. I think the guy’s following in Tom Friedman’s footsteps: prematurely and erroneously designated a svengali, after which the Villagers can’t stop the pretending for fear of embarrassment.
I rarely read the local daily paper here anymore, but I couldn’t miss the front page blurb the other day which informed us that the insurance companies are bearing the brunt of Democrat’s criticism in the health care debate. Who knew that the insurance corporations are the victims?
Also, I suspect that pjackoff who thinks government can’t do anything right also thinks the US military is a magnificent government program and that we should spend even more on it. And that big pharma is a victim too.
I *love* my insurance company!
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dqd0XiNvtI0
I say, Doctor, is there something I can take to relieve my belly ache?
sp