I don’t think historians will have any disagreement dating the long and painful death of America’s most cherished ideals from the events of September 11, 2001.
To be sure, America had experienced troubling eras many times before then, but it had always fought back. The nation’s more precipitous decline came after that event.
Nor do I think historians will blame America’s rapid moral decline on the handful of religious fanatics that shouted “god is great” as they crashed hijacked jets into the twin towers and Pentagon and murdered 3000 people. No, America’s heart-sickening fall from grace happened after that, in how it responded to the event by so easily abandoning every principle of enlightened governance that had made the country seem not just unique, but worth emulating.
Even in the wildest imaginings of Dick Cheney’s neocons, al Qaeda never possessed a tiny fraction of the power to challenge America militarily or economically. The idea that even a well organized and deranged band of murderous fanatics posed an existential threat to the most powerful nation on earth was always ludicrous. So when the nation unthinkingly responded to the 9/11 murders by foolishly declaring a “war on terror,” many Americans knew we were headed in the wrong direction.
It was entirely predictable that a President with the maturity and judgment of a spoiled teen frat boy would lead the nation into revengeful but irrelevant responses. It was even more predictable that he and the arrogant faux warriors surrounding him would exploit the national shock by pulling out their list of “get evens” they’d always wanted to do if only they had the opportunity – and there it was, presented to them with no grownups in charge, no wise men or vigilant media asking “why are you doing this?” — and a shocked nation willing to trust that whatever their leaders did was meant to keep them from being murdered by fanatics.
The President’s men set out to get even for god knows what personal inadequacies, because they’d always wanted to. And they did it, as the quintessential journalist of the time bragged, because he and the child-men he listened to needed to say, “suck on this.” We were led by 12-year-old idiots.
What we, or at least I, didn’t see coming was how relentlessly, efficiently and remorselessly Dick Cheney and his morally depraved henchmen would pull America into the “dark side.” I would never have imagined how easily they conditioned the American soul to first tolerate and then defend a regime that committed felony after felony, including some of the most notorious war crimes perpetrated by military victors on their captives.
The media freely helped in this immoral conditioning. It was so thorough that David Broder, the "Dean" of America’s journalists, who had opposed holding accountable those responsible for crimes while they were in office, pronounced that it would be unseemly for the subsequent Administration to hold them accountable after they were out of office, thus completing the destruction of any principle of accountability for the highest officers in the land. That the man was not hounded from his Washington Post tells us how thoroughly corrupt the official media has become.
The rule of law was now undermined, along with major pillars of the American Constitutional framework — separation of powers, an accountable executive checked by Congress, limits on war powers, and restraints preventing the executive from suspending the most sacred rights against arbitrary government arrest and incarceration. Hundreds of years of legal tradition and precedent, much of it bought with blood, were now gone. Even a Supreme Court whose majority can’t wait to overturn precedents choked on that.
What is left of America is hard to see from these ruins. The news is dominated by mindless teabaggers, unchecked and relentless lying and town hall thugs. The worst are driven by gross stupidity and rage, encouraged by a cynical media and organized and directed by even more cynical interests willing to exploit the mob’s ignorance, racism and hatred. With the official media complicit or incompetent, there is no way to stop these man-made wildfires other than to hope they burn out before they lead to armed insurrections.
There are daily calls for rebellion and threats to the President’s safety, and the thuggery now infects the Congress with only a hypocritical veneer of official restraint. Without principled, courageous leaders on all sides condemning the breakdown, the nation can easily descend further.
I’m 65. I’ve lived through McCarthyism, racism and race riots, the civil rights movements, Berkeley in the 60’s, three assassinations, Nixon and Watergate. I helped kill some people in Vietnam and called in Medevacs for others, for no reason I can account for, and I’ve watched the American addiction to imperial adventures drag us into one quagmire after another. I lived and worked through the rise and neglect of environmentalism, Carter’s hapless energy wars and Reagan’s mindless wars against governance, science and rationality. I’ve watched the zealots of the nation’s self-declared official religion become increasingly detached from reality and its humane commandments.
We managed to survive all that but paid a huge price; I’ve never seen America’s moral and legal foundations crumble as quickly as they have in the last decade.
We are in a dark period of decline, and I don’t know whether we can fight our way out. But I know, deep in my gut, that America is more profoundly sick than ever in my lifetime, perhaps since the Civil War that so many seem anxious to threaten. It is seized with multiple cancers of unbridled greed, concentrated wealth, racism and fears, and governed by corrupt institutions that not only tolerate but facilitate hugely powerful interests in looting the nation.
We remain willfully ignorant of how we got to this point, while we argue about innocuous presidential speeches telling kids to stay in school — they should be in the streets; it is their future being stolen. America’s once hallowed press, most of it not worthy of its guaranteed freedoms, acts as though they’re watching the games at the Coliseum, and perhaps they are.
Today’s America is threatened by cynical opportunists and dangerously ignorant people who believe it’s rational to buy as much ammunition as they can, because they wrongly believe a President who can’t rhetorically disarm his most disingenuous critics is about to seize their guns and destroy their country. They don’t understand it’s already gone, though it’s not one they ever understood.
Insanity is loose in the land, and here we sit trying to counter the craziness by writing blogs.



134 Comments




“Suck on this” – was that Tom Friedman? Sounds familiar, and he is an uber-typical journalist.
What you wrote is similar to something my mother, who’s just a few years younger than you, said. She said the 60s didn’t feel all that strange to her even with all the craziness, but that this decade has just been creepy and scary.
“Here we sit trying to counter the craziness by writing blogs.”
Yes, I think alot about this. How do we extend the blogosphere’s politic into a vaster space? I don’t think there’s time to wait for it to happen gradually.
Thanks for this, Scarecrow.
There really seems to be no clear road for our country to regain its principles. Many of us worked our butts off to elect a President who campaigned on change. The only change we have gotten is one in rhetoric while the worst abuses of our laws and Constitution continue unabated. With the looming SCOTUS decision on corporate political speech, the corporate takeover of our society will have been completed, and it will be time to quietly draw the curtains and turn out the lights.
I’m 10 years younger — You have put it so succinctly, there’s really nothing to add except my thanks for saying it so well. Unfortunately, I’m turning into an angry old man. It seems at every turn I am confronted with sheer ignorance and prejudice. Of course living just south of St. Louis, (the buckle on the bible belt), I am surrounded by “thumpers” who have so totally bought into this rightwing mindset that discourse is impossible. My concern is how low do we have to go before we climb back out? At this point, my only wish is that I live long enough to see it. Thanks for letting me ramble…
It seems so surreal that so many blatant crimes were committed in the name of the War on Terror, yet all I can do is wait for the next attack. Not an attack by an outside terrorist, but an attack by our own corporate owned government. What are they going to do to us next? We are not sheep, we are speaking out. That seems to be all we can do. Thank you for saying all I am feeling in such a succinct and heartfelt way.
Recommended. Thank you, scarecrow, for this excellent summation.
In that final sentence you express the futility that so many of us feel when we view the mountain of corruption and evil which comprises that mass insanity. But, scarecrow and all who visit here, I maintain that the only way to counter the craziness is by every means of communication there is; IMHO the most important being the written record.
Young people of today are very computer oriented. If only one in ten of them read your fine article, just think what an advancement for Truth that can make toward the survival of the America we once thought we lived in.
I’m ten years older than you, scarecrow, and only learned within the last five years that my view of reality was ignorant of the insane realities being created daily by a warped, pathological few who one day in Dallas took over our democracy and set themselves up as all-knowing gods intent upon ruling the world and owning all its riches.
What woke me up and started me on this most difficult journey of my life? Bloggers!! Yes, it is fine writing such as yours that will reach the hearts and minds of young Americans who will determine whether our country stands or falls; so keep writing and revealing the Truth as each of you perceive it. There’s more of us than of “them”.
Tremendous piece, thank you.
Astounding “write”, scarecrow!!! To be recommended and passed on all day! Truly one of your best works, thank you.
Our goose may be cooked, but in true American spirit, the least we can do is go down fighting. We begin by accepting the fact our representative democracy is broken beyond repair, a bitter pill most of us are not ready to swallow. Things like whips, letters, petitions to representatives and phone calls won’t change things. This is, of course, my perception. I may be wrong.
If we get this far, we use the internet to organize on a town by town basis putting each town’s check book on line so people see where local taxes go. The point is to agree on a topic, common to all communities, sufficiently interesting to attract people to the site. The sites use the same format so people easily navigate sites of other communities.
It is an enormously difficult undertaking requiring technical know how and money for servers made more difficult because many don’t want to be responsible for public business. Also the communal aspect of the undertaking will not sit well with people who prefer to see themselves as individualistic entrepreneurs rather than as members of a group. Should enough people join the network, we do something, legal and non-threatening to demonstrate the network’s power. Gives you an idea of how far we have to go.
Wonderful piece on this sad day, thanks Scarecrow.
Best post ever, Scarecrow.
It’s been a pleasure to read your work all these years.
“It was reasonably predictable that a President with the maturity and judgment of a spoiled teen frat boy would lead the nation into revengeful but irrelevant responses. It was even more predictable that he and the arrogant faux warriors surrounding him would exploit the national shock by pulling out their list of “get evens” they’d always wanted to do if only they had the opportunity – and there it was, presented to them with no grownups in charge, no wise men or vigilant media asking “why are you doing this?” — and a shocked nation willing to trust that whatever their leaders did was meant to defend them from being murdered by fanatics.”
Would Jefferson have considered the “frat boy” and “fuax warriors” as the irresponsible aristocrats not capable of controlling their passion to exploit circumstances for financial gain, opposed to the responsible, though imperfect aristocrat who protects law the rights of others from tyranny aka leveraged economic servitude??
well well done scarecrow
in commemoration we recognize and recite the history of the fall of that enlightened govrenment
may she rise again that her constitution awake from the depths she has been buried, spread her mighty wings and proclaim that she will NOT die.
we can pray, this day is better then most for that prayer
MSNBC is “replaying” their 9-11 coverage. The videos of hijacked planes crashing into the WTC were shown repeatedly. For some reasont hey did not show the actual moments of collapse. Could it be they did not want people to see the obvious upward and outward explosions. Here are views of the North Tower exploding, and the South Tower also.
Amen. And we are still here, still trying.
Good post, but I would argue against the notion intimated that anyone apart from a portion of the American population and others caught up in their claustrophobic provincialism were surprised by the events of the day in question.
What followed in the hands of Cheney and the rest was indeed monstrous by comparison.
The general decline of American influence and power on the other hand goes much further back, probably with the decision to save Britain from herself at the end of the 2nd WW. (World War seems a bit pretentious and inaccurate, like the World Classic — fast approaching. But I digress.)
This is why I keep coming back to FDL. You are a truthteller, Scarecrow.
So has our mainstream culture ever answered the question, “Why do they hate us?” Of course not.
I despise the 9/11 anniversary. It’s a wallowing reminder of how much this country has lost at the hands of the neocons, and it has nothing to do with the people killed. I don’t begrudge the victims’ families having memorials, but the pornographic behavior of the media and our politicians just makes me puke.
I’m 59. FDL and the blogosphere are the only places one can get sane and balanced information. Thank you for contributing to that effort and especially for sharing this piece of your mind and heart. Just last night I was talking with a friend at work and you have written what we were trying to say to each other. It is very frustrating looking back over the history of our country during that period in which we have grown only to realize that it so poorly resembles anything we were lead to believe it was or could be. Should we fight on? Yes. Do we have hope? Less, but some. Will we ever find leadership that will lift us out of this cesspool of political weakness and real moral decay. I, regrettably, have my doubts. If it is to happen, it will be because of voices like yours. Thanks again.
I don’t think I’ve read a better summation — Thanks
And this quote, pretty much expresses it all: “Insanity is loose in the land, and here we sit trying to counter the craziness by writing blogs.”
I know it’s not fashionable these days, but I’m still waiting for an investigation, though I’m not holding my breath.
Mr. Snap feels the same way. We have a virtual news blackout the week of 9/11 just so he doesn’t have to watch the crappy jingoistic propaganda.
The left lacks all conviction while the teabaggers are full of passionate intensity.
Well said Scarecrow. Here’s another soul-searching take on what’s happened:
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/…..78188.html
- Tom
Your words flowed, written from your mind, heart and soul, Scarecrow. Thank You.
I, too, think often of Yeats’ poem
“And what rough beast, its hour come round at last,
Slouches towards Bethlehem to be born?”
Sadly Scarecrow, you have summed up the passage to the dark side succinctly. I am even older than you and can recall our involvement in WWII as well. It was considered an honorable war, yet an examination of the precedents to WWII shows the bottom line even there was greed, as individuals and corporations in this country moved to the support of Axis powers because they could make money.
It’s hard to really identify the start of the downhill slide, but at least, for a moment, America did respond wholly to the need to defeat that black cloud. We took an upward tick, then…..
Were that our country cared about truth in anything, but we do not. We haven’t since the television arrived. We have been told lies on a constant basis because the people we choose to represent us are stuck with two conflicting requirements. To convince voters, and to raise cash. The second being the primary goal.
Since we are still being fed lies by the bucketful, why should we not consider those important issues our government either ignores, or refuses to report on?
Imagine a future where doctors are held hostage by the people of their community, forced into servitude to help everyone? Imagine a situation where all the police, with their steroid ravaged bodies and minds, having tried to do what they perceive their job is, and being eliminated by angry mobs that don’t care why they are blocking access to the food or the medicine supply. There are a few police personnel in my town that clearly don’t take steroids. Perhaps 3% of the force?
Since we have nothing but imagination and lies about the events 8 years ago, we may as well try to envision situations that we may find out selves a part of. If you need any help getting started, consider New Orleans. No one has held anyone accountable for the murder of a city by neglect, so it is now acceptable. Not only acceptable, it was so easy, there will be plenty more to come.
We’ll remember this day as the end point of freedom. Our government acted in a way that shows they are scared of every one of us. They instituted numerous rules that were written by the code of fascism, many just borrowed and renamed. No one would agree to do this except a fascist, would they?
Thank you posting these links. The analysis of the events by many critical thinker leads away from the notion that the events were what we were told they were by the 911 commission and toward an explanation which is frightening to contemplate.
If the events were not as we were told they were, and something else happened the revelation could be worse that what we have been dealing with for the last 9 years. How would we deal with that scenario?
Can we, as a nation handle the truth? I don’t think so. We have, as a nation, been in denial of so much of reality over the past 8 years, that I think evidence suggests that we are easily led.
Excellent post Scarecrow. I just had to say that…
Great post Scarecrow
“I would never have imagined how easily they conditioned the American soul to first tolerate and then defend a regime that committed felony after felony, including some of the most notorious war crimes perpetrated by military victors on their captives.”
That conditioning has been going on for some time. “we’re number one” using up much of the worlds resourses. Throwing our weight around the world like a drumken and depraved nation. Ignoring going along economically fueling w the illegal and immoral Palestinian situation. Building our military bases in parts of the world to protect our access to their oil. Going on for a long time
The only thing we learn from history is that we learn nothing from history.
–Friedrich Hegel
The people are slowly being squeezed down and having a very hard time now coping with their lot. Will they continue to accept such oppression, or will they come to realize that they have nothing left to lose by direct action to take back their own government which is now in the hands of a few who care not for the good of the people, but for the comfort, power and wealth of a very few who we serve and toil for.
When will we have had enough?
Nixon. The decline started with Nixon.
Well put.
I trust so little in the public, media version of things though, that I have to wonder how much of this decay exists outside the Beltway. Maybe I’m just trying to be optimistic and maybe the institutions are so corrupt now that it doesn’t matter. But the day after 9/11, I don’t remember panic and fear and a rush to find heroes to save us.
I remember a can-do, Flight-93, “we’re-all-soldiers-now” attitude, with one middle-aged lady business traveller trying out the effect of swift blows from her shoe heel on her desktop in a neighboring cube. I remember being stunned that the so-called President did not highlight this, to me, inherently patriotic and near universal sentiment, creep though he was. When he didn’t reassure the nation and tell us all to be vigilant, be brave, and be ready protect each other, I knew that something was rotten about the whole thing, like a fire in the Reichstag.
Somehow government–executive, legislative, and judicial–has developed a self-sustaining, self-perpetuating, boardroom culture that seems to have less and less to do with what the country thinks. It is parochial and self-absorbed and instantly assimilates anyone that joins it.
What’s the solution? Just keep trying to throw bums out? Like flushing repeatedly until the blockage clears?
You write so well Scarecrow, and your voice would not be heard by us all if it wasn’t for this new media that we have at our disposal.
I for one am thankful that we have bloggers like you who expose all of this. Between the new media and the cult of personality that has invaded our pop culture, the crazy is given a platform for all to see. The new media allows for Bachman and Schmidt and all the others to be exposed in a way that would have never happened when there were just newspaper, radio and a national nightly news cast on only 3 networks. An invisible opposition is much more dangerous.
The new media also give us the tools to fight them, and the entrenched interests in the government. I for one am profoundly disappointed that we are where we at, however I am thankful for the work and dedication that activists like you, Jane, Christy and many others who use the new media to expose what is wrong and engage people in activism. The power of wisdom and energy are untied by the new media for us to fight them, while they choose to expose the crazy about themselves with the same tools.
You make a lot of sense, but I’m not ready to give up yet.
I live just west of Purdue Research Park, where amazing new science is being used for a wide array of new products.
There are more minority students on campus than ever before and the over all quality of the student body rises every year. My wife and I are fortunate to have daily interaction with these amazing youngsters.
My grandchildren are bright and alert and excited about learning and serious about taking over my place in the family.
Currently we have half a dozen non US working professionals living in our rental homes…four doctors and two engineers with bright children. These families are from Asia and Africa. The children have mastered English in a very short period through interaction with other children and the public school’s good work. These families are making a valuable contribution to this community and want to stay here as permanent US.
We have an intelligent, thoughtful and compassionate President, respected around the world, if not by the ignorants amongst us.
There are many, many positive signs.
GWBUSH et all were merely a bump in the road, something to shrug off and walk away from.
My mother always told me not to let evil rob me of my joy. Even today, thinking back to the horrors of 9/11, my heart is full of joy because I survived much of the same that Scarecrow experienced, and have still been able to surround myself with wonderful people, …people who will endure.
Scarecrow “The media freely helped in this immoral conditioning.”
And the media continued and continues to do so by allowing endlessly repeated and unsubstantiated claims about Iran’s alleged nuclear weapons program to go unchallenged.
I have a long list of how many times I have heard David Greogry, Rachel Maddow, Chris Matthews, Stephanapoulous, Keith Olberman etc allow these unsubstantiated claims to be repeated by guest on their programs.
Obviously the MSM learned absolutely nothing from their fuck ups in the run up to the illegal and immoral invasion of Iraq. Christ all they have to do is challenged these unsubstantiated claims. They do not.
Hell I have heard NPR’s Terri Gross endlessly repeat these claims herself
This a very moving post.
I’m a Canadian, so it’s been interesting to sit up here just on the outskirts, watching an empire struggle for its soul.
I am sort of obsessed with rooting for the ‘good guys’ (bloggers, ha!) in this morality play and hoping they prevail over twin threats that include the corrupt powers that be (the oligarchy of CEOs that really seem to control your country through various figureheads with different styles–including Obama and Bush) and the small pockets of ‘nativists’ whose ignorance is being exploited by these interests.
I also study the late nineteenth century and the decline of the British empire, the years just before World War One, which I can’t help but compare to the climate of today’s America. The delusions of grandeur, the posturing, the unexamined feelings of superiority and inexplicable narcissism, and above all, the navel-gazing.
In my own Canadian opinion, America has been doomed from the beginning, as has every other empire, by its blind belief that they are at the centre of history. They are not. You are not. No one is. This is also India’s moment, and Thailand’s moment, and Iceland’s moment. These countries might not be as powerful and destructive as yours but they are just as important and influential. They have writers and artists who are doing important work and who will be remembered. Alas, military power isn’t everything.
It is fascinating for those of us on the outside to watch America’s fascination with itself. Even Jon Stewart seems to find it inherently funny that other countries exist! Yes, we are fascinated with America in a way that it will never be with us, but we don’t care. We can focus on some place else other than our own country or countries that we perceive to be threats to our own country, and perhaps this alone is good for countries and good for our souls.
Your narrative that America is the greatest country, blah, blah set the trap from the beginning. It is still feeding itself now, on all sides the political spectrum, from the most rational to the most irrational of people. If America were the first country to see itself as unexceptional, now then we would have a country that was truly exceptional and worthy of emulation.
At least that’s how I see it from up here.
im still with you….that this was a; happenstance strains credulity
The rise of fascism in America was made possible by a few “staged” events which proved how a narrative could be created an used to manipulate public opinion. Between these major events, a slow erosion of the democracy was made possible by the perversion of the law, ie using the laws to oppress the people, deny not protect their rights.
Bernays understood how to manipulate people and his principles have underscored the consumer economy which turned us uncritical wage slaves who spend our lives trying to define our self image in the basest most materialistic terms.
We are denied the choices to free ourselves from this situation and are bathed in the ignorance that allows this abuse by our unreachable masters.
Jeanne Meserve at CNN is sticking to her story this morning:
The Coast Guard created panic in the newsroom by using radios to do their daily training exercises ON SEPT. 11th!!!, she suggests. Media people listen to those radios. Media people are naturally paranoid, she says, because it’s 9/11. Therefore, the CC should have known that panic would result when Jeanne (or whoever) overheard them rehearse a boat interception. So its all their fault that CNN screwed up and created a tempest in a teapot.
And there was Fran Townsend, Bush’s Homeland Security advisor, live on CNN within minutes of the “crisis” to join in this uninformed panicfest and berate the current administration for such an “obvious” fuck up.
It’s as if they WANTED another terrorist attack!
Even after the Coast Guard press conf where it was explained that, no, the media reports of gunfire were incorrect (someone said “Bang Bang”), that the media misunderstood the radio transmissions, misinformed each other, panicked over nothing.
I am SO sick of these lousy journos with no integrity whatsoever blaming everyone else for their mistakes.
here was the TURN OF THE CENTURY BEGINNING
http://jtaplin.files.wordpress…..s-riot.jpg
Try this:
http://wedemandtransparency.com/schedule.html
That thought came via Krugman, in this blog post. He said:
.
very well said
Hard to read, but a wonderful piece.
Best 9/11 memoriam I have read.
In my own Canadian opinion, America has been doomed from the beginning, as has every other empire, by its blind belief that they are at the centre of history.
————————-
we are simply doomed,by 2 human things,greed,and stupidity,nothing more
Well, you wouldn’t have. People don’t live that long.
I think the closest historical parallel is the period 1875-1900, which also began with the disputed Presidential election of an authoritarian. A reactionary Supreme Court enabled the South the reimpose slavery in all but name, and the Senate, dominated by reactionaries then as now, supported it. But the following period, 1900-1960, despite global war, depression, and war again, was one of unprecedented economic expansion, with the USA leading the world. This growth enabled the flowering of the period 1960-75. We aren’t going to have such growth again; in fact we probably face global contraction in response to environmental problems.
It’s hard to say what comes next, but at least there is no harm teaching the values of the flowering, and we can prepare the ground for the relaxation of authoritarianism. It may come more quickly than we fear; it is going to be hard to maintain the authoritarian system in the face of all the changes that will come.
Thanks — it’s important to hear these other stories, to help keep a perspective.
Thank you. I’m 65 years old today. I want to add to your fine piece the notion that persons of good will can
change the perceptions of others. When I was in 10th grade one day our fine history teacher told us to put our books away because he was about to speak his mind about us becoming a nation of sheep…..He spent the entire
hour speaking out about how Charles Van Doran was fed the answers for drama and tension on the quiz show
” 21″. He felt -rightfully so- betrayed. He was of good will and we were taught well.
thank you!
Thanks, Scarecrow. Kurt Vonnegut had some thoughts about historical inevitability. Wish he were still with us.
These people are like mindless brainwashed bots who are incapable of dealing with truth. They are the shock troops who will do the bidding of their masters and be tossed aside in an instant.
Just look at how we ACTUALLY treat the soldiers when they come home – who are manipulated to kill people, mostly innocent ones as that who are not warriors in any sense – in the name of patriotism and protecting America.
America is perverted. It is a caricature and her founding fathers are turning over in their graves. This is not what our revolution was about.
America has always had its wackos from witch hangings and early indian massacres to fears of slave uprisings, to sand creek massacre, to Tulsa Race riots, to Japanese internment, to today. Unfortunately these wackos are also capable of linking together.
Outstanding post, Scarecrow. Thank you.
I think there’s a lot to be said for being born in smaller country, proud of its own traditions, but not not so taken with itself.
Here is what some people learned from 9/11…Peace, Diplomacy and basing decisions on facts not myths or a “pack of lies”
“Deepest sympathies to all families who lost beloved family members on 9/11. Two dear friends Bev and John Titus lost their treasured daughter Alicia that day she was an airline stewardess on one of the flights used as a deadly weapon and rammed into the twin towers.
Bev and John along with other 9/11 family members and hundreds of Vets led the anti invasion March in New York City in Feb of 2003. These people had the intellect and reason to know from experts such as former Weapons inspector Scott Ritter and the head of the Iaea Mr. El Baradei that the cherry picked pre-war intelligence validity was seriously questionable.
They knew that the attacks on 9/11 were in no way tied to Iraq
8 years after 9/11 many many innocent people in the U.S., Iraq, Afghanistan, Pakistan and elsewhere are injured and dead…..Dead
How can we all extend and cultivate the reasoned thinking of those brave people who led the anti invasion March that wintery day in New York to future situations?”
This is the site that John and Bev put together for their beloved daughter.
Sweet Alicia Titus
http://www.sweetalicia.org/
Oh Jeez, I remember that. How could it be that television show would lie to us? Those were the good days. And “A Nation of Sheep” (Burdick?) was a popular political book back in the day. Being interested in politics at the time, I may have written a book report on it, but don’t remember.
true
What have we learned from 9/11?
http://seminal.firedoglake.com/diary/8044#comments
My sense is that we do not possess what it takes to fight for our rights as a nation.
Our only chance will be in the total breakdown of civic order brought on by the coming total economic collapse. We cannot legislate America back. We cannot take her back by protesting on the mall, or writing letters or blogging. All the many good things some people are doing will not rule the day and save America.
America will be saved when she collapses and the power that oppresses also disappears and possibly a ethical just society can rise from the ashes, long after I am gone.
We get to witness the the great collapse and it did not begin on 911.
Mr Scarecrow,
I must say, even as a spoiled rotten Scarecrow reader, this is really somethin’ – thank you.
ya got me riffin’ on another poet
In the citys melted furnace, unexpectedly we watched
With faces hidden while the walls were tightening
As the echo of the wedding bells before the blowin rain
Dissolved into the bells of the lightning
Tolling for the rebel, tolling for the rake
Tolling for the luckless, the abandoned an forsaked
Tolling for the outcast, burnin constantly at stake
An we gazed upon the chimes of freedom flashing.
may i say …a lot of that exists around here , they go to church and learn this exceptionalism
they give crumbs to the poor,and exploit them for their contributions
9-11 and Bush/Cheney didn’t seem to change anything in terms of what the government got up to. Obama has endorsed their policies and continued them so its bipartisan now. Since I wasn’t in the US last century I don’t know if there was a change in the feel of politics but the impeachment of Clinton suggests to me otherwise.
Beautifully written piece, Scarecrow. I’ve admired your work ever since you hit the front page here at FDL. Thanks.
I’m a relative whippersnapper at 50, with two young kids (10 and 13) so I’m not quite ready to give up. although I am overwhelmed at the thought of all the work, and time it’s going to take, to get our country back to place of relative sanity.
My neighborhood is currently struggling with a local issue concerning a water pumping station, preservation of green space and the wishes of one person versus the majority of the community. Who was it that said all politics is local? Maybe that’s where we start to fix things-from the bottom up.
There’s more at stake now. It’s just not about me anymore, and I don’t want to leave my kids to deal with all the work ahead by themselves.
I do believe that we all have friends, neighbors, family members, and co-workers who are beginning to work through the hangover of the intoxication of the Bush years. Why else has a minority, ever smaller, become ever louder, ever more shrill about ever more insignificant things? We can start talking to those friends, neighbors, family members, and co-workers to the extent that they have become disenthralled. But most of all, beyond policy discussions and debates over ideas, we must lower the fear threshold, the mind-killing fear threshold and the doubt that we can cope. We can because we must. It’s that simple. When we successfully talk folks in our personal network off that ledge of fear, then we can begin to have honest civil conversations again.
Now talking our folks back is not going to be easy with the distractions of a hyped-up media pushing the latest shock and scare. Calm deliberation in this environment is a revolutionary act.
Most of us, truth be told, blog because we find others that see what we see going on; we fight the marginalization of traditional American values of freedom, dignity, equality, good governance, respect,…; we gain courage to deal once again with those who are still under the paralyzing grip of fear, uncertainty, and doubt.
We have our job to do as citizens in an environment that approaches the chaos that first responders faced on 9/11, but with fewer of the dangers. If we are to step back from the cliff, we must work methodically, calmly, an with purpose to ensure that (1) there is a make-or-break progressive minority in Congress that will hold firm, (2) that we ensure that RahmCare does not become the change, (3) that every Democrat has the opportunity to vote for a progressive candidate in 2010, (4) that every American voter has the opportunity to vote for a Democrat in 2010, (5) that none of the 192,480 precincts are left without a organized progressive presence, and (6) that the relationship between the government and the governed is rebuilt on the basis of honesty, accountability, trust, and transparency, (7) that we are able to operate in shifting coalitions to get things done.
Like being a parent, being a citizen requires some skills and role models. And the government or any other organization, aggregatively, like children, keeps requiring attention in order to learn, to achieve, and to avoid destructive behavior.
We must become the stillness in the midst of the insanity around us. Otherwise, we will be sucked into the insanity born of fear, uncertainty, doubt, and panic.
Blogging isn’t a “merely” sort of activity. At least not here.
Thank you also, but most of all we need to look at FACTS. Tom Ridge in his book admitted Homeland Security was just a political tool for neo-cons. I asked him about well documented reports that Saudi Arabia financed 9-11. Ridge insulted me and did not answer the question. Who are the real terrorists?
scarecrow, this would make quite a dillon or richy havens song let me tell you
that is powerfull stuff and should be set to a song for the times
sorry about your loss
close ears
THIS COUNTRY DOES NOT CARE ABOUT ITS OWN BROTHERS AND SISTERS DYING FROM LACK OF HEALTHCARE…tens of thousands a year
AND THE KILLIN’ GOEZ ON AND ON AND…
Citizen Scarecrow and the Firepup Freedom Fighters:
“We are in a dark period of decline and I don’t know if we can fight our way out.”
Brother Scarecrow, I weep now because we have lost faith with those brothers and sisters who were left behind in forging our history and fighting for our character…a character that is now lost. Maybe that we live to experience this terrible corruption of history and values is our punishment for failure and living when the heroes died. Or maybe we are offered one more chance to do right by those we left behind…maybe we must give what little we have left, to fight back, to be willing to call the liars and murderers out, resist and not let our children suffer the hell we were too weak to extinguish.
I for one must put it out there again…I can not look my children and grandchildren in the eye knowing the terrible suffering that waits for them because we failed to give what was left to us.
KEEP THE FAITH AND PASS THE AMMUNITION, THE WAR IS OURS… IT WAS PAID FOR LONG AGO!!
Thanks for the reflection brother.
The insult to the 3000 dead done by Islamic terrorists who had nothing but contempt for this Nation and its ideals, led by people who have the money and atomic capability (e.g., Pakistani fanatics) is outrageous. This is a day of infamy, similar to Dec 7, 1941. You dishonor the dead and heros like Todd Beamer. President Bush responded in best way possible: you attack the enemy and destroy him. This Nation is still at War whether you and your compatriots agree. People are in harms way. We will only win when we destroy the Islamic terrorists. And we will. It may be after this weak and unsure President but we will prevail. It’s very possible that Gen. Petraeus will get the 2012 nomination and dispose of the current occupant of the White House. And then we’ll finish the job.
The progressive “wing” of the democratic party needs to really step up the PR campaign and issue a manifesto of change.
They need to announce that they intend to vigorously support primary challenges to every single non progressive held seat in congress.
We are trapped with a 2 party system. We must destroy the reactionaries and neocons, the blue dogs and the moderate dems.
We must take over the dem party and turn it SHARP left. We must become the party of the people not the party of the wealthy people.
What have DAvid Gregory, Rachel Maddow, Chris Matthews, Terri Gross, Katie Couric etc learned from the media’s failure to ask challenging questions about the false pre-war intelligence that was being shoved down the throats of the American people.
Absolutely nothing.
They allow the claim that the Iranian leader said “Israel should be wiped off the map” and that Iran has a nuclear weapons program…ENDLESSLY.
Prolfessor Juan Cole debunked the purposely mis translated statements of Ahmadenejad years ago
“The precise reason for Hitchens’ theft and publication of my private mail is that I object to the characterization of Iranian president Mahmoud Ahmadinejad as having “threatened to wipe Israel off the map.” I object to this translation of what he said on two grounds. First, it gives the impression that he wants to play Hitler to Israel’s Poland, mobilizing an armored corps to move in and kill people.
But the actual quote, which comes from an old speech of Khomeini, does not imply military action, or killing anyone at all. The second reason is that it is just an inexact translation. The phrase is almost metaphysical. He quoted Khomeini that “the occupation regime over Jerusalem should vanish from the page of time.” It is in fact probably a reference to some phrase in a medieval Persian poem. It is not about tanks.”
http://www.juancole.com/2006/0…..chens.html
The former head of the IAEA and the present head of the Iaea have stated that there is no “hard evidence” to back up endlessly repeated claims about an alleged Iranian nuclear weapons program. Yet the talking heads allow John Bolton, Cheney, Bill Kristol, Ledeen, Gaffney, etc to repeat these claims.
War… what is it good for”
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Cv5BYEOQYLo
I hate 9-11 anniversaries.
Lots of Kumbaya about events never properly investigated and reeking of high government complicity.
Frank, anyone who wields power in this country has been read into the program. They know the deal, the marketing plan and they have been paid to play their parts.
Ridge is a lying sack of sh*t.
S
C
R
O
L
L
Karl Rove organized the entire federal government in order to protect and re-elect [sic] his client, George W. Bush (and to destroy the prospects of his rivals).
Dick Cheney did something more radical. He organized it in order to protect his ego, his family and his political ass from the personal liability he would face should there be another terrorist attack on his watch. He did it to weave the curtain behind which he could concoct the wizardry that persuaded the country that George Bush was president.
If God made man in her image, Dick Cheney attempted to remake America in his. God help us all. Now let’s help each other while we’re waiting.
Thanks for all the comments, everyone, and welcome to many who may be new.
We are not done. We’re still here, and we’re still trying. And somewhere behind the scenes, up on another thread soon, that Hamsher woman, that crazy Marcy person and their pals are kicking someone’s ass. You gotta love it.
the day after the attack I had written something for my friends and family, months later it came back to me in one of those mass emails that said “please forward”
it was crude because I did not want to polish what I put to paper the moment I decided to write as escape
here it is;
the day in the middle of September ;
These are now the new days of the rest of out lives
We, from here forward, must join our brothers, and our sisters, around the world, in everyday anticipation, at what might happen, to those that we love, or care about, on this day, or tomorrow, or the next day.
Yes…I remember the day that Kennedy died…
And I remember the day that Martin Luther died…
And I remember all the days that loved ones…died
But this day…the day in the middle of September, will live in the marrow of my soul, all the waking, and sleeping moments, for the rest of my time.
perris
To have the honor to march against the invasion of Iraq (fall of 2002 and winter of 2003) behind and with people who had served in WWII, Korean, Vietnam (many friends marching), Desert Storm and with many family members of those who were murdered that day…sends chills up my spine and tears to my eyes.
John and Bev Titus and many other 9/11 family members continue to work for Peace and Diplomacy
http://kucinich.house.gov/Photos/?PhotoID=34587
One of the old dudes that I pushed in a wheel chair in the march in Feb 2002 in New York City had served in WWII. He was 90…completely against the invasion…based on what he had heard Scott Ritter and others say.
To repeat myself, Saudi Arabia financed 9-11. I agree we should wipe out that corrupt petro-state.
he is a shamefull excuse of a man
Bless you for hanging in, for saying it like it is, for nevertheless saying it with an elusive hope that somehow sustains you in the mist of the endless insanity, immorality and contempt for anything of true value and integrity. Thanks for this and all the rest. Thanks to FDL for giving you a platform.
Maybe there’ll be some good news today and we’ll have the caring hearts to see and hear it and be able to say Thank you, Lord, for this fine day of renewed hope and grace.
We live in an age of propaganda. Our media is not better, actually WORSE than pravda during the period that the USSR was in existence.
If any mainstream media person actually questioned the accepted narrative they would be off the air pronto.
Marching, calling, emailing ,lobbying pushing right behind and beside these “crazy” intelligent and brave women.
I have a list (not on me) of how often I have heard this horseshit (unsubstantiated claims about Iran) allowed to be repeated and go unchallenged by Chris Matthews, Gregory, Rachel Maddow, Terri Gross…Neil Conan…etc. It is absolutely shocking
hats off to them and everybody here………….well almost everybody……….g
profound Scarecrow
The civilized veneer is very very thin, is it not? All it takes is a demagog type leader and a few like minded people to pull an entire country into the abyss. Now we have even members of congress shouting that torture is fine. Of course the sheeple are in the middle shouting for torture.
It really does not take much to rip off our vision and ignore the very principles that were the foundation of our country.
I think that very deep down we-as a country-believed ourselves invincible. Our oceans protecting us from attack. When our image of ourselves was shattered by 19 people using commercial airlines, terrorists with no home country or land. When our president(who according to the voters was just like us)panicked. When the VP(who had had several heart attacks and strokes, I believe that changed his personality, made him paranoid)took control of the govt from a slacker prez and convinced the sheeple that torture is fine. When you get rush, glen and shawn along with faux news all screaming the same message of hatred then you get what we now have. Our nation, a nation of idiots. A nation of easily led sheeple who regurgitate what they hear without understanding. You get, 8 years later, what we are now faced with. Our ideals and principles in tatters, a new dem and a dem congress, afraid to open up the past, to force us to face ourselves because they all fear-and rightly so-the sheeple. In the end,even tho the rethugs lost in 06 and again in 08, the sheeple have very short memories, and the rethugs in their authoritarian boots march thru the land endlessly repeating the same lies to the gullible sheep. Startin on the day after the 08 election the rethugs started planning their return in 10 and 12. They lie, they enflame, and they pray that Obama and the dems fail. Mindless robots, that is all the sheeple are. It does no good to refute them with facts. Their minds are closed. They believe what they are told, they are working to get the rethugs back in power. All my years in govt we worked on the external threat. We should have been working on the worse threat, the internal. The rethugs are working hard to subvert our military. Unless the high ranks do something, our military will not be the mailed fist of the govt, but the mailed fist of the rethugs, the authoritarians, the fundamentalist religious.
Ms. Hamsher never sleeps. She’s upstairs.
Orwell may have been prescient regarding the thought processes of those who followed the zealots to the precipice:
And so it goes, to the age of rule under the cowardly callous.
;>)
how could these peeps think money is the complete and utter answer to all
In Politico, Manu Raju writes about how the rabid elements of the repub party are dominating the image and argument of the party. When he compares same elements existing in the dem party, which, naturally, is true, he uses dem lawmakers who protested during the run up of the Iraq War:
Nor are Democrats strangers to having their crazy uncles take center
stage. During the run-up to the Iraq war, for example, Reps. Jim
McDermott (D-Wash.), Mike Thompson (D-Calif.) and David Bonior (D-Mich.)
famously flew to Baghdad, where McDermott asserted that he believed the
president would “mislead the American public” to justify the war. The
trip made it a cakewalk for critics to describe the Democratic Party as
chockablock with traitorous radicals.
This is a stupid example to use to illustrate the fringe element of the dems, because it turns out that these lawmakers were right on the money. And aligning the efforts of these lawmakers to the recent rabid behaviors of the repub fringe is belittling the enormous cost in American lives and tax dollars that the unnecessary Iraq War caused. Where has this writer been if he can’t remember the numerous writings about all the evidence that clearly show Bush and Cheney misleading the public about invading Iraq? Where was this writer in the 2006 election? Where the hell was he in the 2008 election?
How about a book titled “The Sheep Look Up” a Scifi book written way back in the 60s.
Revolutionary War,War 1812
OCEANS never protected us
Scarecrow I understand exactly what you say, and you put it very well. I’m a year or two older than you, but we’ve shared some of the same experiences. Daily I find myself dismayed that people can put up with and allow some of the criminal behaviour that has been foisted upon us by our leaders. Our elected representatives show no shame as they accept bribes, commit pedophilia and other shameless acts of depravity, even though their actions are blatant and deplorable, and no inclination what so ever that I can see to fix the problems. They are without honor or any ethical sense of what’s right or what’s wrong.
I am thankful that we do have blogs and ways to communicate that allow us to bring these actions to light. Fortunately the people in charge do not yet understand how to stop this free flow of information that’s taking place on the internet. They are politicians and notoriously ignorant of the technology that surrounds them. Unfortunately, it’s just a matter of time until they are able to fetter this means of free access.
Just as in the 60’s they didn’t understand real crowd control and how to shape the stories that the media were displaying. But they learned. They learned the secrets of divide and conquer on a national scale. It would never be possible for some of the public outcry and dissension that happened then to take place in the atmosphere that prevails publicly today. That is not by accident.
If the draft had been instituted prior to the Iraq war, that war never would have happened. They knew that. That war has been fought by stealth methods, and mercenaries, and hiding the true cost through supplementary budgets.
Thank you again for your article.
I shall to my dying day stay and defend and TAKE BACK the Republic I grew up in from the shrieking Communist Islamo-Fascists attempting to take it over now.
Holy smokes, I thank God that I don’t have your attitude.
That’s a marketing model. Effective change does not come out of marketing; it comes out of conversations with peer networks.
Who is this “they” that you are waiting on to do something?
You don’t destroy coalitions, you present something better and they collapse. It is only within the context of Congressional process that these folks can be obstructionists. When the opinions of their constituents change, they change or are replaced.
We must become the party of the real, flesh-and-blood people, not the party of some philosophical abstraction of “the people”. The real people includes folks from Oklahoma and Utah, New York and Oregon, and South Carolina. All of them deserve to live in a society governed by a much better political process in which they are contributors, not cheerleaders for a team. The movement conservatives gained power through marketing, short-circuiting that process. To duplicate that approach to gaining power is to undermine the progressive principles that we advocate. “Left” is an ambiguous term in politics; I’m not sure what “turning sharply left” means, but I know what restoring civic debate means, what opening up government to sunlight means, what accountability means, what accurately assessing existential threats means, what providing equal opportunity and expecting equal sacrifice means, what allowing no institution to dominate individual people means, what an informed citizenry means, what a productive economy means, what just compensation means, what respecting human rights means.
They TELL us they are working on nukes! Even the toothless IAEA says they will not cooperate. What more do you need? If we don’t take the nukes out, the Israelis should immediately!
isissqueeker, my congressman, Mr Boo-your, is holding a teabagg event in Lafayette, IN tomorrow. Come on down! They’r your people!
I’m going to another one, one that will be huge, I guarantee…
*Sigh*
“Trying to have a conversation with you [is] like trying to argue with a dining room table.”
Citizen isissqueeker:
Now I am heartened about our prospects of overcomin’ the fascist beast that threatens us because you and those like you are all we hafta beat. If that’s all you got, the future of democracy is secure!
So as Tom Ridge, you want to cover up that Saudi Arabia was behind 9-11.
There’s nothing like a big movement.
;>)
Aid to Israel should be cut…Now
http://www.bdsmovement.net/
Scarecrow – thank you so much. This is one of the finest pieces I have read, ever.
“they tell us they are working on nukes”
Proof?
You must have the massive stockpiles of nuclear biological and chemical weaspons that go undeclared and unsinspected in Israel with Iran. Israel has refused to sign on to the Nuclear non proliferation treaty while Iran signed on long ago. Just a bit of hypocrisy there
http://books.google.com/books?…..38;f=false
I dissent.
Having now read the comments too, and again, not as American but a foreigner, I have to disagree with all this pessimism and incipient palingenesis. The past was not that great, the present is not so bad, the future will continue to get better.
The stuff that is bad was always bad. Wars? There were always wars. Iraq is not nearly as bad as Vietnam or Korea. Bush dropped the ball on Latin America where there has been a burst of lefty democratic victories. The UN says war overall is way down, genocide is way down, massacres are way down.
Torture? You always did it. “School of the Americas” anyone?
Lawlessness? bet on it. All these things that are new are not new, and although it’s disappointing to many that Obama won’t change any of it, that’s not a regression but the absence of improvement.
All these evils stem from the ability of men to manipulate others on the basis of their tribalist identification. All the pointers on prejudice are improving. Racism is not defeated obviously but it’s equally obvious that those who defend or seek to use racism are on the losing side of history. The main prejudice that is still important to government is patriotism (prejudice of foreigners). How long can this attitude continue when other prejudices are under attack so swiftly? How fast did gay marriage get turned around? Didn’t you elect your first Muslim congressman not before but after 9-11? Attitudes towards Israel’s apartheid have hardened despite the “war on terror”.
The stuff that is bad you always had, the stuff that is good is getting better, and that is more obvious again in the newest generation, which points to the future.
I will not be beaten on cynicism but this pessimism is unfounded.
Israeli nuclear capability and threat to Peace in the middle east
http://docs.google.com/gview?a…..#038;gl=us
The power of Rome didn’t control the mob, it was the mob. It threatens anarchy and thereby justifies the unchecked power to check it. It threatens instability and thereby justifies the taking of any measure to restrain it. It is a herd, easily turned against the least cynical opponent. It drowns out reason and rationality. Frustrating those, it both recruits new members and leads others to flee.
Beck and Limbaugh are no accident: they are the whips used by others to control the mob. They, like tentacles, are dangerous, but the counterforce Americans face are those behind them.
Wow. Most sincere thanks Scarecrow. I will certainly save this and pass it along.
The future won’t get better on its own, except for those who make it so.
Very thoughtful, thanks.
I think most folks here are optimists and do think things will get better. I don’t see Scarecrow, Jane, Christy, or anyone else quitting.
But 8 years ago today…well, we lost much of that optimism.
Thanks. In absolute terms when scarecrow says,
I cringe a bit because he’s lived through eg forced labor for blacks down coal mines, setting dogs on civil rights activists, taking away the babies from Native Americans, the Tuskegee experiments as well as far worse wars.
Obama is attacked by racists today, OK. But are we really pretending that a black man who was president in 1960 would not have been attacked? They assassinated MLK for much less.
Worse things happened but the times seemed better because nobody much cared back then, or rather many people did care passionately of course (which is why things changed) but everyone’s level of expectation was so much lower because of where society was at. When nuclear bombs first came out, Americans cheered!
And improved attitudes are evident even over the last 8 years. Gay rights, the largest anti-war rallies in world history and so on. We’re even talking seriously about socialism again.
Here’s my favourite quote from the hunger site (which tells us that the number of people dying of hunger in the world has about halved in the last two decades):
Helen Keller
Like Farenheit 451, we form a community and promise eachother to carry bits of our lost culture until we can reseed the rubble.
And then there’s this, too:
If
If you can keep your head when all about you
Are losing theirs and blaming it on you;
If you can trust yourself when all men doubt you,
But make allowance for their doubting too;
If you can wait and not be tired by waiting,
Or, being lied about, don’t deal in lies,
Or, being hated, don’t give way to hating,
And yet don’t look too good, nor talk too wise;
If you can dream – and not make dreams your master;
If you can think – and not make thoughts your aim;
If you can meet with triumph and disaster
And treat those two imposters just the same;
If you can bear to hear the truth you’ve spoken
Twisted by knaves to make a trap for fools,
Or watch the things you gave your life to broken,
And stoop and build ‘em up with wornout tools;
If you can make one heap of all your winnings
And risk it on one turn of pitch-and-toss,
And lose, and start again at your beginnings
And never breath a word about your loss;
If you can force your heart and nerve and sinew
To serve your turn long after they are gone,
And so hold on when there is nothing in you
Except the Will which says to them: “Hold on”;
If you can talk with crowds and keep your virtue,
Or walk with kings – nor lose the common touch;
If neither foes nor loving friends can hurt you;
If all men count with you, but none too much;
If you can fill the unforgiving minute
With sixty seconds’ worth of distance run -
Yours is the Earth and everything that’s in it,
And – which is more – you’ll be a Man my son!
Rudyard Kipling
It did in a way. Nixon brought the lying-style into American Politics with the character assassination of Helen Gahagan Douglas in 1950. But I think things really got going with Lyndon Johnson when he lied about the Gulf of Tonkin incident and thereafter about the course of the Vietnam War. It was LBJ, a very successful President in Domestic Affairs who first created extreme distrust of the President and the Presidency, which then combined with the development of marketing and media manipulation to undermine rationality and honesty in American Politics.
Yes. Keep flushing. Eventually, those elected will get the message, i.e. if they fail to deliver the money they get from the Corps won’t save them.
And that’s the way I see it from down here, too. When you tell yourself: “America’s the Greatest Land of All;” America’s the most prosperous country in the world (or the wealthiest); “America has the best health care in the World,” and other expressions of uncritical boosterism, you are in a very bad place to adapt to challenges by learning from others. And America has been in that bad place for a very long time now. The pragmatic country I was born into too many years ago than I care to admit, was dedicated to solving problems and making things work any way we could.
Now, when someone says well, look at what Canada’s done with its health insurance system, look at Australia, New Zealand, France, Germany, the UK, Singapore, Japan, etc. Many of us say, we can’t talk about that to Americans. They won’t accept “foreign solutions.” They need something “uniquely American.” That’s a load of crap. The Americans of the 1930s would never have said that. They would only have asked, “will it work better than what we now, and will it work well? Yes? Well, then what are we waiting for.
It’s ironic that the Japanese manufacturers have been destroying the American car industry with a system developed from principles first brought to Japan by W. E. Deming who developed these principles from American Pragmatic Philosophy beginning with C. S. Peirce, and running through James, Dewey, C. I. Lewis, and Walter Shewhart. Deming’s PDCA and prediction methods he developed along with Shewhart led to Japanese quality management methods and eventually to Toyota’s “lean” methods that have been so successful in undermining our manufacturers. We’ve tried to introduce quality management in our industries too. But we’ve been unwilling to adopt the management architecture and culture that goes along with them, so we’ve met with limited success. We’ll borrow only so much from those who are more successful, because “that’s no the American Way.” This kind of rigidity is the mark of a rigid culture that can no longer adapt.
The trouble is, that method often floods the bathroom. At some point, you need a closet auger or even a power rooter to grind the blockage up small.
Thank You, Scarecrow. I really resonated with this one.
A germ of truth in all the Victoriana. It was as much about the blood and guts of average Tommies in Victoria’s imperial army in India as it was about the elite – who could walk with king’s “nor lose the common touch” – both of whom risked all in a single battle, turn of the dice or parliamentary political maneuver.
Would that that sense of balance and common touch were more common along the Potomac.
That’s encouraging. I have always thought that liberals didn’t pay enough attention to the business community, so we weren’t there when the rules got made. The likes of Krugman and Brad DeLong make that participation more likely and more effective. Pieces like this one make sense of the day to day struggle, and make it possible to keep going. It isn’t nothing. I hope it’s enough.
letsgetitdone, Nixon was a protege of Prescott Bush, father of GHWB. And then there is this document dated November 24, 1947 on the letterhead of the FBI:
There are a lot of dots between 1947 and November 22, 1963, but they do connect up.
It occurs to me that JOB ONE toward reclaiming our democracy involves reclaiming our national airwaves and media.. The TOXIC FILTH being beamed toward all corners of the US by right wing cultural criminals under the auspices of ‘newstalk’ must be shut off.
Well, then, it’s a good thing I am already on record for Petreaus’ arrest.
Well, then it’s a good thing I am already on record for Petreaus’ arrest and imprisonment. I doubt you know anything about the man or you wouldn’t be clamoring for him to be our Saviour (I mean President).
Scarecrow there has been no “rapid” moral decline in your nation. It’s been slow and insidious – beginning with FDR who created WELFARE. Now you have a country dependent on GOVERNMENT support for every single aspect of your lives. Cradle to grave dependency. Welfare to support your illegitimate children spawned by immoral couplings by unmarried welfare recipients. Your offspring is educated in GOVERNMENT institutions run by UNION members and Affirmative Action assures those same students an Ivy League education – whether they qualify or not. And now – the greatest gift of all – Healthcare provided by the GOVERNMENT. That very same GOVERNMENT that failed at providing Social Security to all, that failed at Medi-Care – the same Government that has bankrupted the Postal System – that faulted on Cash for Clunkers – that forces Achievers to work the first 4 months of every year FOR THE GOVERNMENT. The achievers of the world are saying STOP. STOP to bankrupting our children by spending trillions of dollars that DO NOT belong to the GOVERNMENT- STOP to supporting welfare loafers – STOP to immorality -STOP to corruption in the administration – STOP to any more infringements on our God given freedom. STOP to BIG GOVERNMENT taking over every aspect of our lives. Unlike you – I have infinite hope. It’ll take more than this cocky rock star of a president and his corrupt czars to destroy this country.
Oh Jeebus, another effing conspiracy theorist.
Definition?
other nations have been forced to pay a much bigger price for America’s vengeful irrelevant responses.
Why are Americans so fearful?
Articles like this one are why I return to this site daily.
Scarecrow, just wanted to say that I enjoyed this post. Well, maybe it’s better to say that I agree with it wholeheartedly. It’s hard to watch something you love reduced to what our country is becoming.