All I want for Christmas is to watch Hollywood’s Jesus films, like the full cycle of Star Wars movies, the Matrix, or the Lord of the Rings Trilogy, capped off with The DaVinci Code.
I always liked the savior figure Neo, because instead of abandoning the real world to join a spiritual, imaginary one, he has to break with the imaginary to find what’s real. (He also had a much better, loving union concept of Trinity, in which each dies for the other.) The war between humans and machines teaches us about the dangers of inhumane corporate dominance, but I’m not sure I understand or trust the final episode’s reconciliation. Neo’s life must be sacrificed to atone for the original sin of allowing the non-human machine into the garden, but it sounds like Washington’s version of health care or finance reform, where the machines are still in charge, too big to fail, reform or regulate.
Far more entertaining is the Christ as one who must regain his throne, but not just by killing the orcs, but by gaining disciples through fellowship, loyalty, and courage — along with a faith in children. The evil tyrannical regime has an all-seeing eye that is only a modest extension of today’s surveillance state, which is only defeated by using the signal fires to alert all life forms to the need to fight as one against evil. My favorite scene is when nature itself rebels and the forests save men by destroying the military-industrial complex.
I like the Star Wars idea that God is schizophrenic, with Dark Side and Good Side, and that the Force not only represents all life forms but has to both kill and save itself through hope, a belief in justice and the destruction of tyranny. If you see Luke as Jesus, then you have to accept that his birth is the illicit union of good and evil, and he, like the rest of us, must struggle with the duality throughout life. But Anakin and Padme, Luke and Leia also tell us Jesus is both sexes. Salvation requires the children to avoid the temptations of the Dark Side and still kill the dark side in the parent.
And of course there’s the Jesus was a funny kid movies, like Charlie Brown. Jesus as Charlie has no sin, and he embodies the "love your enemies" via Lucy; we know she will always tempt the Christ by holding the football, and Jesus will always try to kick it and fall on his butt . . . but forgive her. And we know that Jesus is never allowed to win at baseball, the saga in which humans collectively try to conquer failure only to lose; Schultz apparently believed there’s still some flaw in the Christ story.
As strange as it seems, there are those who like the mischievous Jesus in the Home Alone movies, though those who do sometimes grow up and make strange alliances with Grover Norquist. The notion of Rahm as a looting burgler against whom all measures are fair is appealing, so if you want to become a progressive activist, this is probably the Christ movie for you.
My evil cable provider — a satanic corporation called Comcast that will eventually try to own and silence the beloved Mary Magdalene — Saint Rachel — cleverly allows all of these Jesus films this time of year even though they’re all just as subversive as the Gospels. I assume it’s because they know that they can sell you worthless stuff, not just during the too often, too long commercial breaks but during the now-censored movie with those annoying pop-ups that used to be just at the bottom corner of the sceen but are now spreading like a cancer into the main picture. Only the remote control and Netflix can save us.



34 Comments




interesting. Thanks.
Not really the same type of movie, but have you seen “The Last Temptation of Christ” ?
Thanks Scarecrow, a brilliant excursion into cinematic interpretation for Christmas. Have you seen “He Who Must Die”? Great movie. Not much interpretation necessary. Merry Christmas.
Scarecrow. Wow. Thanks for this. Wishing you a lovely day, with light in your fine mind and peace in your heart.
Merry Christmas folks. Yes on seeing “The last temptation”(I think), but no on “He who must die” probably put off by the title. I can only handle Jane Austen these days.
Merry Christmas, Scarecrow.
Lots of good guest appearances by Jesus in episodes of Family Guy, including this one.
Great analysis, SC, thanks!
Wish someone would do a decent rework for the silver screen of Michael Valentine Smith and Stranger In A Strange Land.
And, I thought the Dune films were VERY well done.
Both would be great vehicles for your analysis . . . .
Merry Christmas, Scarecrow. Great selection of movies! It strikes me that Schultz also had a bit of a problem with nature, hence the kite-eating tree. I’m a happy camper as long as I’m not subjected to “It’s A Wonderful Life,” and I’d happily curl up with some eggnog and any of your list of movies.
Neo’s Trinity made sense, at least.
Has “Stranger in a Strange Land” ever been made into a movie? Loved the book, and you’re right that it would fit right in with Scarecrow’s list. (I’ll have to disagree about the first Dune movie, however… I thought it bit. The 2000 miniseries, on the other hand, was good.)
A Wonderful Life is partly about what happens if you let CitiGroup and Goldman Sachs win; Wall Street over Main Street. It also has one of the most romantic phone scenes every filmed.
“I don’t want to abolish government. I simply want to reduce it to the size where I can drag it into the bathroom and drown it in the bathtub.”
-Grover Norquist
This is the person Jane Hamsher has partnered with.
I’m working on a story about censorship policies at various political blogs.
I seem to have been censored from posting at Fire Dog Lake and I would like to know what the FDL formal policy is concerning censorship of your comments section.
I used no profane language and I made no threatening statements of any kind. The text below the line here seems to be the post that triggered my being censored by FDL. Can you please explain your censorship policy for me. Thank you,
Chip Shirley
……………………………………………………………………………………
“I don’t want to abolish government. I simply want to reduce it to the size where I can drag it into the bathroom and drown it in the bathtub.”
-Grover Norquist
This is the person Jane Hamsher has partnered with.
I always liked “Bell, Book and Candle” around this time of year. James Stewart, Kim Novak, Jack Lemmon.
Love the Home ALone movies!
The failure of Sarumans treason is also good to see, Although in the real world betrayal usually seems to accomplish its narrowly self interested goals.
btw, here’s the alternate ending to It’s a Wonderful Life
There was a movie out when I was young (about the same time as the cave painting) that I still think is the best one I’ve ever seen on the life of Jesus. Can’t remember the name of it however.
What a useless comment – I’ll do better next time.
Figured I’d be the only one to bring up “Dogma”.
Gollum, played by Lieberweasle.
I am ultraliberal Chip Shirley. Never gave a penny to the GOP, I don’t know who the recycling guy is. Google me and “How High Taxes Made America Great”…I’ve had thousands of leftie letters published.
I have also just been notified that I have been censored by FDL for posting the Grover Norquist quote below, that’s why I have to sneak in and post on past threads here. I’m no troll but FDL is a neo-con front site funded by William Kristol and Ben Stein. I know people…Here’s the quote that got me banned.
“I don’t want to abolish government. I simply want to reduce it to the size where I can drag it into the bathroom and drown it in the bathtub.”
-Grover Norquist
This is the person Jane Hamsher has partnered with.
Considering the fact that Christ was a flesh-eating zombie (it’s right there in the scriptures, I don’t make this stuff up) the best of all Christmas movies is Night of the Living Dead.
I’ve always liked “Jesus Christ Superstar”. I first saw it when I was really young, but I liked the personal aspect of it; Judas caught between his love for the guy, and his fears for his people, Mary Magdalene concerned for the human needs & frailties of Jesus. Plus, the comic aspects and that way rad 70′s hair. You don’t see a lot of hair like that anymore. Also, Bell Bottoms. Mad crazy bell bottoms as far as the eye could see. Cool soundtrack, too.
Avatar, Joseph Campbell & you
James Cameron’s film “Avatar” is clearly the next in the Star Wars, Lord of the Rings line of Movies. Avatar’s basic mythic teachings such as resource struggles and honoring our environment is older than the American Indian teachings.
Avatar is a film about humans that look and sound like greedy Americans attempting to use military force to steal a rare resource called Unobtainium, obvious joke, from the indigenous people. How hidden is that? Unobtainium = oil and the indigenous = Iraq . . . duh?. Also, unless I am memory impaired this Unobtainium was not necessary for the invaders simply very highly prized.
Even though Chicago Sun-Times, Roger Ebert noted that “Avatar” “has a flat-out Green and anti-war message” that is “predestined to launch a cult.” I find it interesting that the indigenous begot violence with more violence – where was the Ghandi and Martin Luther King like non-violent change? Oh, yeah, that does NOT sell movies.
Great casting. The Joe the precious.
How about Zardoz – Jesus is sent to disrupt the complacent society, emerging from the very face of God Himself. It’s breaking the spiritual grip on humanity to save it.
But for a real experience, try Greaser’s Palace. Jesus is a zoot-suit wearing sing-and-dance man and the Holy Ghost is literally a guy wearing a bed sheet with holes cut out for eyes.
I’m so glad you commented about Avatar. I thought it
looked interesting and it obviously is. I want to see it.
I just went and saw the IMAX 3D version. It’s beyond my ability to describe. I don’t know about a cult, but I fully expect this movie to seep into the general consciousness in a big way. aepdad is right to invoke Campbell, he would have loved this film. A full 5 minutes of sustained applause after it ended; grown men weeping openly on the way out of the theater. The term “special effects” doesn’t do justice to what Cameron and Company accomplished with this film. Yeah, some of the writing clunks. Trust me, you’ll barely notice it. Oh, yeah, Ross Douthat is promoted from “douchebag” to “souless reptile”.
Hi Scarecrow! I’m watching the Santa Clause, 1, 2 and 3. Last night’s fare, Miracle on 34th Street (the original). But just dropped in to wish everyone a great holiday! Many blessings to my FDL family! Love to Jane for all she does for us. XOXOXO
My favorite Christ movie is “Life of Brian”. It’s about a man mistaken for the messiah. Does that remind you of anyone? Truly, blessed are the cheese makers… and the Greeks, who shall inherit the earth.
It also has full frontal, M & F–which I’m always up for. I watched “Trading Places” a couple of nights ago, Jami Lee-Curtis–ooh-la-la!
Thinking of a movie as allegory of a biblical story. I’m thinking “Conspiracy Theory” with Mel Gibson–he is Christ come to warn us of the end times only to be called a crazy loner.
This year, I’ll watch anything if it makes me cry. Christmas, for me, is a time of mourning.
“He Who Must Die” is based on Nikos Kazantzakis’s earlier attempt to tell an updated version of the crucifixion story in The Greek Passion.
Not a holiday movie, but Amy Goodman’s interview today of Dave Isay is a Christmas keeper: StoryCorps: National Social History Project Records Ordinary People Telling Their Stories to Each Other
http://www.democracynow.org/2009/12/25/storycorps_national_social_history_project_records
The Greatest Story Ever Told?
Christmas Blessings, Scarecrow. You are ever the symbolist, is that a valid term? Thanks for the clever invitation to see the Lord in many places, many persons, many periods, many stories.
Wish you could have been here with us.
Blessings to all the FDL community,
I feel as though Mad Max borders on some sort of a movie-religious figure… Moses leading people toward the right path, but never getting to see the fruits of it. Any other interpretations?
I so very dearly love Mad Max 2 and 3… (part 1 was never campy enough for me LOL).
I’m not sure of the Jesus reference, but Bad Santa is my favorite Christmas movie… At the very least, it is highly entertaining!