Update: At his press conference today, in response to a question from CBS, President Obama implied he did not order the firing of MMS’s Director; he said he only heard about Director Birnbaum’s status today and had not had a chance to discuss it with Secretary Salazar. He also said that further drilling at 33 previously permitted rigs would be suspended.
p>MSNBC (and now CNN) are reporting this a.m. that Elizabeth Birnbaum, the Director of Minerals Management Service, who testified before Congress only yesterday, will be fired. But the question is: is she just a scapegoat? Birnbaum has only been Director since last July, while most of the deficient environmental and safety reviews for the Deepwater Horizon permits occurred before her tenure. Why her and not Salazar?
Meanwhile, the White House has told various news agencies that President Obama will today extend for another six months the partial moratorium on new offshore oil drilling permits in the Gulf. In addition, he will cancel proposed new leases off Alaska and Virginia and part of the Western Gulf. All these measures will remain in effect, the reports say, at least until the President’s commission investigating the BP oil disaster completes it’s work.
From the New York Times:
President Obama plans to announce Thursday that he is extending the moratorium on permits to drill new deepwater wells for six more months and will delay or cancel specific projects off the coasts of Alaska and Virginia and in the western Gulf of Mexico, a White House official said.
Mr. Obama, who will discuss the decisions at a midday White House news conference, is taking the actions in response to the initial 30-day safety review of offshore drilling ordered after a BP rig exploded in the Gulf of Mexico, killing 11 men and opening a gusher of oil that has yet to be stopped.
The latest moves come amid deepening frustration and criticism of the administration’s handling of the crisis. The president’s order is intended to halt further permits for new wells for six months, delay planned exploration in the Chukchi and Beaufort seas off the coast of Alaska, cancel the August lease sale in the western Gulf and cancel the lease sale off the coast of Virginia, the White House official said.
As the Times reported last week, the previously announced moratorium in the Gulf, which apparently was not put in writing, allowed Minerals Management Services to continue issuing permits to drilling rigs that had already received initial permits but required what the Administration called "modifications." It was just such a permit "modification" to change its drilling plan that the Deepwater Horizon rig had just received and was using in the weeks before the blowout.



39 Comments







Thanks for this. Have been wondering about that “30 day” announcement by Obama a while back. Also wondering about the alleged inspections in the Gulf of existing rigs?
Updated to note MSNBC report that MMS Director Elizabeth Birnbaum will be fired.
0ver at cspans front page
The imbedded wingers that the worst administration ever pushed through before they could be dislodged from the WH will haunt the country for some time to come.
Change we can believe in: picking away a little bit of the flakes and putting a fresh dab of paint on the house of cards.
Obama’s Midterm Elections Drilling Moratorium
Transparency, indeed.
Birnbaum does seem to be the sacrificial lamb.
I want to see prosecution of oil companies for bribery of Federal employees. I want to see the corrupted employees prosecuted also. Then I want to see what deals Cheney made with the bastards.
which is number one reason it should have been Salazar
remember, MMS was so fetid w/corruption, they were indicted and prosecuted by the Bush DOJ – Salazar was too busy handing out leases to take a peek
Chris Matthews keeps pushing this “Cheney needs to testify under oath and under the lights” on energy policy deals made
I think Congress might wonder why Birmbaum.
Obama never had the wingers, he’s lost progressives, independents are moving away leaving him the Democratic equivalent of the Bushbots. It would seem the smoke is beginning to clear and the mirror is getting fogged up.
Federal law doesn’t allow removal of an employee without cause. Sadly, this means that real malfeasance is necessary for the steps to be taken that will protect the public from a huge number of leftovers of the recent reign of anti-public interest executive branch members.
http://bp.concerts.com/gom/kentwells_update24052010.htm
The guy looks genuinely concerned and says “It’s all about people.”
No engineer, it’s about lack of preparation, lack of oversight, lack of regulation, lack of enforcement, lack of attention to warning signs, and a lack of accountability. It’s about corporate malfeasance.
Thanks for your dedication to prevent the giant mess you made from becoming even more catastrophic. Screw BP, Haliburton and whoever else was negligent enough to enable it.
Yes – why isn’t Salazar being fired? Interior is a mess – and it is his fault for not making any significant change.
yes. guess I need to do some googling to see what/whom prompted the latest IG report – Salazar ?, something left over from the Bush era ?
Salazar has never been a friend of the environment but he’s always been the friend of the corporations. Obama’s kind of guy. Birnbaum will be the sacrificial lamb and tonight out of view of the camera’s Obama and Salazar will exchange high fives.
When in doubt, blame the chick.
But he won’t reinstate the ban???
I see Obama has learned nothing from ignoring the largest oil disaster in US history.
Slightly O/T: Will FDL be liveblogging the prez presser?
How much of this new action is smoke and mirrors and how much has actual real teeth? Speaking for myself, I won’t be happy until some high government officials and BP execs are brought up before a judge…a buncha judges, for that matter. And speaking of judges…
These MF’s are gangsters, straight up.
Democracy now has a couple of pieces up about sick oil workers etc
Question: can not career employees be moved, or reassigned, to less impactful offices and duties? Aren’t there ways to defang the moles other than firing them?
What’s happening is:
Obama:
“Now that there’s a political shitstorm breaking on my head, I will
set about the very republican process of finding the price-point for just how little I can do to inflict some real regulatory change on Big Oil, while also sacrificing a few oil-company approved appointees who should never have been hired in the first place, without sustaining too much political damage. Wish me luck, everyone.”
Supposedly, states have emergency response plans in place. If Louisiana’s included creating sandbars to shield their coastline, how is it that they were blocked from implementing for NOT HAVING ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT REPORTS?!
Or did they think that, in an emergency at least partially caused by a private entity getting waivers for EIRs, that they’d be given the same treatment? Were the situation not so dire, their naivete would be charming.
Not to defend Birnbaum or Salazar, but more important than firing people is revisiting the notion that privatization and de-regulation are presumptively good. It should be obvious by now that in key sectors – such as finance and energy – government should have control over the private actors.
The fisherman from the Gulf that Goodman interviewed ( Clint Guidry) just ended that interview by saying “if the oil company is such experts. Why are they trying to kill my fishermen”
This was after he suggested that the oil clean up should be government controlled. And his comment is in reference to BP not allowing clean up workers to wear respirators
Over at Democracy now
Coast Guard Grounds Ships Involved in Spill Cleanup After 7 Fall Ill; BP Reportedly Preventing Fishermen from Wearing Respirators
At least seven fishermen involved in the cleanup of the BP oil spill were hospitalized on Wednesday after reporting nausea, dizziness, headaches and chest pains. The fishermen were likely exposed to both the leaked oil and chemical dispersants. As a precautionary measure, the Coast Guard has ordered all 125 commercial ships helping with the cleanup to return to land. For weeks, cleanup crews hired by BP have been reporting health issues, but their complaints have largely been ignored. We speak to Clint Guidry, president of the Louisiana Shrimp Association, and Albert Huang, an environmental justice attorney with the Natural Resources Defense Council.
Birnbaum Fired? Isn’t that looking backward? WTF?
Because Interior has always been the big piggybank for corporate spoils. Salazar was not put in to reform Interior. Afterall, where has Obama shown the least interest in real reform? He was put in at Interior to keep the spoils system going.
Obama can’t possibly think that Salazar can stay. If for no other reason than self-preservation, he must dump him. Where the heck is his much-lauded political instinct? Oh, yeah, that was bs.
Here is what PEER said on May 20:
http://www.peer.org/news/news_id.php?row_id=1349
PEER points to the erratic leadership of Sec. Salazar who has repeatedly said that “energy independence” is his “top priority” at Interior, sending the strong message that protecting natural resources is secondary, contrary to the statutory mission of the agency. In late March, Sec. Salazar ignored both internal and external warnings about deficient spill prevention and response capabilities in endorsing major expansion of offshore drilling in the eastern Gulf of Mexico, the Atlantic and Arctic Oceans.
Significantly, specialists within MMS with firsthand knowledge of the breakdowns have not been consulted. The key Interior decision-makers have extremely limited experience with the issues, a deficiency rationalized as “bringing fresh eyes” to the situation. Sec. Salazar has been resistant to seeking out former whistleblowers or other reformers who know “where the bodies are buried” in the deeply dysfunctional Interior Department.
So it sounds like Birnbaum was the “fresh eyes” part of the Plan – and is now sacrificed. Salazar put her there, and was carrying out that Plan. But she gets fired.
Forgot to add that I’m extremely happy about the cancellation of the Virginia exploration-not that McDonnell and his handmaidens Warner and Webb will give up. Does give us more time to fight though.
I don’t think it matters much if she is a scapegoat. We have way too many people in regulatory agencies that come directly from the industries they are supposed to be regulating. This is definitely a case or cases of foxes guarding hen houses. You might as well legalize incest because, this is what you have, in effect. Same as the situation where our treasury secretaries come right off of Wall street or from the federal reserves. There is “NO WAY” that these people are going to say no to their “FRIENDS”. Why not fire them all and put in “legitimate” scientists and engineers who have no ties to these industries? Like an FBI of the energy industry that could not be bribed. Of course there is the problem of the congress that doesn’t want their buddies discredited.
Birnbaum wasn’t PART of the Industry – she was from outside Industry. She was to be “fresh eyes”. Read the PEER article.
Finding “cause” should be no more difficult than finding a “pre-existing condition.”
As they say on the street, “You may beat the rap, but you won’t beat the ride. Treat them with the same legal deference that we treat drug offenders.
James Carville attacks Obama spill response as politically stupid. Why aren’t there more Democrats who’ll say the simple truth about Obama’s “I ain’t gonna get my hands dirty, I ain’t going down to the Gulf” non-response?
http://latimesblogs.latimes.com/washington/2010/05/now-even-more-democrats-slamming-obama-for-gulf-oil-response.html
Yup
I am sickened by this man’s useless performance on this.
Does Obama think people have forgotten this?
New York Times:
Published: March 30, 2010
anger some residents.
He’s Brilliant. absolutely brilliant.
Times like these you remember what America needs: an authentic ‘left’ to hammer the right-wing Democrat in the White House.