ABC’s This Week didn’t even make a pretense of being fair and balanced, let alone honest, because the truth probably frightens them. In covering the historic labor protests in Wisconsin, ABC stacked it’s panel with the elitist right wing propagandist George Will (left unchecked by his nemesis fact-checker, Paul Krugman), a Tea-GOP freshman from Florida, and a senior ABC reporter apparently okay with deficit hysteria, all arrayed against “labor Democrat” Donna Brazile.
Even the usually sensible host Amanpour wondered if the President’s mild statement about an “assault” on public employees went too far. Heavens, pass the smelling salts!
Ms. Brazile thus got barely one chance in four to push back on the rest of the elitist panel’s defense of why it’s absolutely essential that states balance their budgets on the backs of public employees immediately after Wisconsin’s Governor and the elitists Obama/Congress just gave corporations and the wealthiest Americans massive tax gifts.
So while Brazile was able to note that banksters and their elite friends had caused the near depression that tanked families and state budgets and caused over 400,000 state employees to lose their jobs, she didn’t have enough moments to point our that income equality in America is worse than Egypt, that the richest 1 percent get nearly a quarter of America’s wealth and income and that the wealthiest 10 percent capture more than half.
The ABC panel couldn’t recall that banksters were bailed out with trillions, that they reaped record bonuses, then record profits but face no significant tax on their reckless transactions. Also lost from memory are that Obama and Congress just handed the richest Americans hundreds of billions with promises of trillions more, that hedge fund managers face far lower tax rates for their billion dollar paydays or that many corporations, including those to whom Governor Walker just gave $100 million in tax breaks, pay no taxes at all. And if you don’t know what $1 billion will buy you, see Dave Johnson’s 9 pictures that expose this country’s obscene division of wealth.
In the face of such facts that ought to have millions of us in the streets, none of ABC’s elitists thought it worth wondering why public school teachers or any of America’s labor class should be asked to contribute a dime to Gov. Walker’s partly self-inflicted deficit, let alone make major salary concessions (which they’ve offered) or give up collective bargaining rights.
The set up to this elitist “I can’t hear you!” session was a report from ABCs Bob Woodruff in which he gave prominent coverage to a relatively tiny group of Tea-bots and their leader. The leader’s main argument for stripping employees of their collective bargaining rights was “we won, you lost,” which he repeatedly screamed at the protesters as he walked through the huge crowds surrounding the Wisconsin State Capitol.
Mr. Tea-bot’s message, echoed by George Will and endorsed by Amanpour was simple: This is about power, and we won, so we can do anything we want to screw you, including stripping you of rights that are fundamental in allocating wealth and privilege in a democratic society. No one noticed that this principle — that government should have the right to strip citizens of economic and political rights — is the direct opposite of the individual rights premise the Tea-Party falsely claims to support.
Woodruff had to follow the Tea-bot around, because the story had begun with a high school teacher who found himself a leader when public employees and their tens of thousands of allies showed up every day last week. That’s the biggest story in America, right now, but Woodruff couldn’t tell it straight. The idea that large numbers of ordinary Americans might be disgusted when their right wing government tries to disempower them and spontaneously gather by the tens of thousands to protest the Beltway’s core beliefs about the distribution of wealth is not something an elitist network can handle.
So Woodruff played it safe and hid from us what any third grade math student would have noticed. This was just dueling demonstrations, he said. Here’s Bob talking to group A’s leader, here’s Bob talking to group B’s leader. Here’s a cropped picture of some people in one group, here’s some in the other group. But for heaven’s sake, never show or explain that there were an estimated 10,000, then 30,000, and by Saturday, between 55,000 to 70,000 protesters in Madison alone, opposing Governor Walker’s rights-stripping plans, but only a mere 1,000 or less on the other side who had been rounded up and bused in courtesy of one of Koch Industry’s front groups.
Koch is one of America’s largest oil/gas resources conglomerates and a major contributor to the Walker campaign. These were the equivalent of Mubarak’s paid thugs trying to provoke violence.
As Think Progress and others have reported, one of Koch’s front groups, Americans for Prosperity, is a major funder of the Tea Party; it helps organize and pay for “grass roots” Tea Party events.
Koch is also the founder of a right wing front group called American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC), through which Koch and other corporations fund right wing think tanks and literally buy studies and op-eds in support of legislation for right wing state legislators. Among ALEC’s priorities, in addition to bills like Arizona’s to use the state police to bust undocumented workers, is to bust unions, both public and private. So it’s largely Koch/ALEC’s water that Wisconsin’s Governor Walker, as well as the right wing governors in Ohio, New Jersey, and Florida, are carrying.
One of ALEC’s hacks appeared with the inept Judy Woodruff on PBS News Hour last week. His role was to make certain that the American Federation of Teachers rep who tried to explain why the Wisconsin protests were important was forced to answer propaganda manufactured by ALEC. All of that should have been debunked before hand by PBS. But as usual, PBS didn’t bother to tell us who ALEC is, or who fronts them, and as usual with Judy’s “reporting,” that interview left viewers more misinformed than they were before.
We are overwhelmed in this fight if it’s fought in the elite media. But as Egypt showed us, the real numbers in the street are the counterbalance. If you’re in/near Wisconsin, or any of the other states where solidarity or related demonstrations are scheduled, go.



86 Comments

Very well-written and informative post. I watched the show as well, and interpreted it much the same way that you did, although I do give Amanpour some credit for asking, “Who should be asked to pay for federal and state deficits?”
Of course, she didn’t answer that herself, and Brazile was hopelessly outgunned. I don’t think it a coincidence that Krugman wasn’t on this particular show, either.
And, as my wife noted while watching Amanpour’s interview with Hillary Clinton later in the broadcast, when Clinton said Middle Eastern citizens clearly want more democratic freedoms and economic fairness, “Like they are so different from Americans, how?” and “Yeah, we want more freedoms and economic fairness, too, Hillary!”
Via Howie Klein’s @downwithtyranny :
downwithtyranny Howie Klein
by bmaz
If earnings of 13 [top earning] hedge-fund managers were taxed as ordinary income, revenues would pay salaries & benefits of 300k teachers.
Another twitter: @evale72
AFL-CIO official notes that not a single labor member or official was invited on Sunday talk shows, even though it was major item discussed.
Decades come and go. Presidents come and go. Anchormen come and go. George Will remains at This Week.
Come on, Christiane, if you want to improve the show and give it some real relevance, you got to get rid of these tired old hacks like Will, Brazile, Donaldson, etc.
Scarecrow, I love your talking heads takedowns. I look forward to them on Sundays.
good god, that is a whole lotta alphabets
Thanks, Elliot, but you realize we’ll all probably die sooner because of those shows? The spirit can only take so much. I can’t even watch Gregory’s MTP without losing brain cells.
I watched Anthony Bourdain in Polynesia…and George Soros on Fareed’s show. [http://www.cnn.com/video/#/video/politics/2011/02/18/gps.soros.economy.cnn]
Oh, and read George Lakoff at truthout
[http://www.truth-out.org/what-conservatives-really-want67907].
All of which were better than the composition/conversation of gasbags. Thank you scarecrow for wading in the muck so we didn’t have ot.
Thanks Scarecrow. It is amazing how our media can talk about the need for budget fixes after our federal and state governments deliberately blew gaping holes in their budgets with tax cuts for the wealthy and big business.
Here’s another painful examples of Judy Woodruff’s pro-corporate reporting in an interview with Bernie Sanders:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZiOlXDDqLWc&feature=player_embedded
She asks Bernie what fix there should be for Social Security at least two times after he tells her, citing the fact that Social Security can pay out 100% projected benefits until 2040, that it doesn’t need a fix. Argh they love Pete Peterson at NPR and PBS.
I’ve gotten involved in USuncut in Portland. USuncut is blatantly stolen intellectual property from…
http://www.ukuncut.org.uk/
http://www.usuncut.org/
They’ve been chillin’ about that. They don’t know what chillin’ is, but…
Time to put some boots on pavement, and messing with the minds of some bankers :)
I’ll get something up more formal tomorrow.
I absolutely agree with your interpretation of the show, Scarecrow. I was a little dismayed that Donna Bazille didn’t know the issues in Wisconsin, though. George Will was even more astoundingly arrogant than usual, totally pretending that the law was about dollars and nothing else. And no one really disputed that.
I was ashamed of Bob Woodruff’s piece; he should have known better.
George Will is the Mini Me Conservative spokesman to Bill Buckley’s full size Conservative.
How does watching the show discourage them from doing again what you don’t like about the show?
How does watching the show discourage the sponsors?
The show is unbalanced, is really nothing but propaganda, but I watch it anyway, just because. Yes, I know a transcript is available but that doesn’t permit me to feel sufficiently self-righteous.
“But as usual, PBS didn’t bother to tell us who ALEC is, or who fronts them, and as usual with Judy’s “reporting,” that interview left viewers more misinformed than they were before. “; and that’s just one reason why I’m not concerned about PBS and NPR being shut down.
They’ve become just like the other corporate controlled networks.
But I think something the predates the current situation needs to be remembered and that is Tommy Thompson:
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tommy_Thompson
He got elected 4 consecutive times and IMHO, that says something about the Wisconsin electorate.
They are socially conservative and have a long history of Republicanism from its founding and when it they were progressive and liberal economically. My guess is many really haven’t noticed how the party in most of the country (and now Wisconsin) has changed.
Maybe it is just because I am in need of a big bucket of hope but I have some optimism this issue is not going to go away and ordinary people are ahead of the politicians and pundits.
I pray the protesters in Wis. endure and keep rubbing the country’s face in it. The media will come around.
Amanpour wondered if the President’s mild statement about an “assault” on public employees went too far.
jfc – she’s an AFTRA union member ferchrissakes !
what in bloody hell
agreed,she is pathetic
email her
she needs remindin
why would corporate media do anything other than defend corporations? turn that shit off.
Here is a link to SEIU events this week: http://action.seiu.org/page/s/solidarityaction
Attend a solidarity event in your state
There are events happening across the country and we’d love for you to join us. Find out where one is taking place in your state and sign-up to join us
Donna is definitely a light weight which is probably why she was chosen to be on the show.
I got the SEIU email sign up form as well. It think its critical for us to attend these events. I can understand why many people took a pass on the ed shulz faux TV protest, but this is much different. Those workers in Wisconsin are just the beggining. We need to resist with everything we have now.
all over her twitter right now :D
she is the worst by far
tepid brown noser
we’ll be sportin’ red tomorrow night in Austin at 6:45 !
Amanpour Reportedly Gets $2 Million Contract as ABC News Cuts Payroll
By Matthew Balan | March 25, 2010 | 14:44
The New York Post reported on Thursday that CNN chief international correspondent and anchor Christiane Amanpour, who was recently hired by ABC, will apparently be receiving a $2 million a year salary for her upcoming gig on their This Week program, just as the network is laying off hundreds from its news arm
Brazille is a Clinton democrat. shes as much on board with with the “austerity” attack on workers as any mainstream corporate democrat. it was an outright lie to even call her a “labor democrat”. she just drew the straw to stand in for that role play.
It has been demonstrated that 94% of libs/progs who watch the show suffer from either Stockholm syndrome or battered wife syndrome.
have i told you lately that i love you?
keep wondering what all those union camera people and tech folks on the production floor must be thinking
Beck & Hannity have also rec’d some cbl twitter love today :D believe it or not firedogs, they too are card carrying commie union members
It speaks volumes that the Democrats’ spokesperson on the panel was Donna Brazile, who has a very long pedigree as a Beltway hack and is a deplorably bad debater.
Unfortunately Sacto is 2.5 hours away and with the price of gas $3.45 a gallon here makes it out of the question for me.. But I will be there in spirit!
keep my mouth shut,glad to have a job,somebody out to slip her some truth serum in her diet coke
Definitely a graduate of the Alan Colmes school of milquetoast talking heads.
willfully ignorant,and light as a goose feather
surprise, surprise. the first thing we need to do in our revolution is to take down our state media
hahahahahahahahahah
lol ed
Par for the course for our celebrity-worshipping society. I read this week that Jessica Simpson is worth $1 billion (which works out to $333,333,333.33 per brain cell), and that the Kardashian sisters are worth over $60 million despite having a complete and utter lack of talent.
It’s important to note that Walker’s bill does not attempt to break all public employee unions. For the time being, he’s only busting those who oppose him politically. for those WI unions like Fire, Police, etc., he is leaving them be. This is what makes the solidarity being shown by the favored (by walker) (so far) unions so remarkable.
This wasnt on the SEIU list of actions, but for Philly people, there will be a mid-day rally this coming Thursday on Thomas Paine Plaza (across from City Hall).
I think most of the talking heads, even if they are “card carrying” members of AFTRA, would be among the first to cross an AFTRA picket line and scab on
Glad I didn’t watch. Sundays are for better things, like reading FDL. Thank you for doing it for me, Scarecrow, and saving me the heartburn.
I totally agree on the funding of NPR and PBS. It might as well go.
However, “Left, Right and Center” gave a pretty good fistfight on Saturday over the fact that government was plenty eager to bail out the banks, although come to think of it, Blankley got to have the last word…
Yep, tank ‘em.
amazing
Orlando FL NPR Program Director Republican Jose Fajardo pleads with his listeners for funding because the mean old feds (who’s boots he’s been licking for years) are going to cut the funding.
He’s a Republican. He should have seen it coming. He’s a free market guy and he begged for it to happen!
Who could have imagined that Repubicans would infiltrate NPR, pack it with Right Wing Warmongering Free Market Propaganda with Hannity Opinion and Teabagger Worldview and then shutter the whole operation like a Mafia Bustout?
Go To hell NPR. You’ve sucked for Ten Years too long.
Other than irritating us and allowing the Village to get back to normal after the revolution in Egypt, why is this important enough to waste bandwidth on. We all know how these characters perform.
And Amanpour has to get back in good graces with he Disneynauts for positively gushing about the revolution in Egypt and her role is getting Mubarak to admit he wanted to go. (Whether he did or not is immaterial, it gave a signal of the regime’s weakness.)
Sounds like Mr Fajardo thought they were talking about some other group and just couldn’t have been including him
I am so fucking sick of millionaires being paid by billionaires to trash the 98% of this nation who haven’t a prayer of living their lifestyle.
Meanwhile, those Mad City residents who actually have been at the Capitol have a somewhat different take from the pampered lapdogs of the Village: http://tbogg.firedoglake.com/2011/02/19/civility-my-ass/#comment-71687
Ah, well, fug them. They know they can not rest easy at night, haunted by nightmares that their security is not ensured, that ever more measures of oppression are needed, that more blood will be shed far, far away, in foreign lands, long before it reaches the shores of their island mansions. They do not have to watch directly the bullet from the security officer enter the brain of the nobody who opposes them. Their bank balances are secure. The world is all right for them, and the stench of corruption is impermeable to them, mistaken for the fragrance of eternal youth and god’s blessings.
And maybe they are right, but nothing in history or in human logic will guarantee that, and they know that, the smarter of them, deep within their minds, and there is something grimly satisfying inside them that they are playing out their role in this endless comedy, that they will make it to the end, die a full and satisfying life, with tears wept over them, and eulogies pronounced in newspapers and by pundits like them, their names emblazoned, if only for a moment, on network TV. A sniffle, and then they are gone, and their riches, their estates, passed on to their children and their children’s children, world without end. And who will know it was robbed, or the payment for some dirty deed? No one remembers crimes.
Ah fug them.
More “reality” tv, huh? Rich representatives, on tv, spouting their master’s language. No real shock. Who you gonna defend when you are paid millions to pretend your views are real?
OT– Remember Jane’s post, “Linda Sanchez: Obama’s NAFTA-Style Korea Free Trade Deal Will Send Jobs Overseas” (Dec. 4, 2011)? Well, it looks like a bank run is beginning in North Korea: “There Are Fears Of A Massive Run On The Banks In A Country You’d Never Suspect” (by Joe Weisenthal, Feb. 19, 2011, 8:49 AM)
They wanted to go, go gracefully, and then patch the whole, corrupt, violent system back together. They, too, of my generation, listened to the rock songs, to the Who, to lyrics about the boss, “same as the old boss”. “We won’t get fooled again…” But they will be fooled, Amanpour and her bosses believe. And will they? Only time will tell.
The only one of those unions to support Walker was the Milwaukee police union. Walker is trying to position the bill as not affecting first responders. Folks he might need if the protests (as in his fantasy world) get violent.
He knew he could hang out the office employees and DMV. He thought that he could hang out the teachers, but the public still supports them strongly. He thought that the first responders would be at least neutral. And he thought that unionized workers at private plants would cheer him. After all, a certain percentage of them voted for him.
Yes indeedy. One no one is looking, the same old types of players if not the same old players get back in power. I have no idea what Amanpour believes except Iran is not a good place to be for her. I read her gushing not as cynicism but narcissism.
I have been impressed however with the maturity of the Egyptian movement and its consciousness of how easily it can get co-opted.
Episodes like these in which people like Will spit on their fellow citizens make me sick at heart. It happens a lot to me.
behind every great fortune is a great crime
anon
Honore de Balzac…scuse please
Knut, politically it makes me furious. But personally it’s nothing. People like Will seem to think that they are different but they’re not. They are subject to the same problems we are, like diseases etc. and there’s nothing they can do about it. In the end of your life which would you rather be – Will or yourself? He has a lot to remember about the disgusting attitude he had in life.
Amanpour, to her credit, is better than David Gregory. But that’s like saying David Frum is better than David Brooks. They both completely suck, tho one is slightly better than a dogpile. Whatever happened to journalists reporting the facts and following them to their logical conclusions? Unions made up about 25% of the workforce in 1979. Now, only 12%. Even Obushma called it correctly, dubbing it an assault, and Amanpour says it went too far? Pathetic.
The public employees have offered to give Walker and the Republithugs every concession they have so forcefully demands. Everything. Collective bargaining, a right enjoyed by Wisconsin state employees for 50 years, is the only issue they won’t back down from., That’s it. And Walker hasn’t even responded to the offer. This is about radical right-wing ideology, not budget savings…
http://www.sunstateactivist.org
The Wisconsin protests are getting considerable press attention in Minnesota. I think we have to start fighting our battles at the local and state level where you can get press coverage and make an impact. It certainly doesn’t matter here in Minneapolis if the pundits in DC didn’t cover the protests if when people tune in to get the local weather they see Minnesota reporters reporting on Wisconsin protests and the Minnesotans who have gone to join them.
As the saying goes, all politics is local.
Book Salon up with Eric Alterman’s Kabuki Democracy: The System vs. Barack Obama hosted by Will Bunch
I’d love to PIE Will, he’s such a horse’s ass.
I missed one. Walker was also supported by the State Troopers Association, which has now distanced itself from him and regrets their endorsement.
I watched the show, but didn’t get as much out of it as you did.
Thanks especially for pointing out that wealth inequality in the USA is worse than Egypt.
I usually go by the Gini Index, which is 40.8 for the USA and 34.4 for Egypt.
A society that scores 0 on the Gini scale has perfect equality in income distribution. Higher the number over 0 higher the inequality, and a score of 100 would indicate total inequality where only one person corners all the income.
I thought they were the same thing…….
I stopped being able to take any of the Sunday shows years ago. Just turning them on turns my stomach
The USA is turning us into a Third World country. we must stop it somehow.
Someone has to take one for team libertarian. Might as well be me.
The handle “scarecrow” is appropriate. There are a dozen states that have only been able to maintain their employee pay and benefit packages for the past few years because the federal government is passing through massive transfer payments. That’s right, you too Dorothy in Kansas, are helping to pay teachers making $80k a year in Wisconsin. Using your own example, the richest 1% have a quarter of the wealth and pay 39% of the federal income taxes. The richest 10% pay about 60% of the federal income taxes(IRS.GOV). Now after you’ve gone and executed all those rich people, which sounds like is on your short list, whom will pay? If you want income equality, just keep working on ways to grow the government and one day you will get your wish.
“Now after you’ve gone and executed all those rich people, which sounds like is on your short list, whom will pay?”
Well, lets see. If the income was distributed downwardly then that is were the taxes would come from. Right? It ain’t rocket surgery.
you left out the fact that Wall St. tanked the economy and got tax cuts for doing it, plus the fact corrupt state governments have for years been renegading on pension and other obligations that have made things much worse. (see Texas) So let’s make them damn teachers pay?
George Will was, is and always will be a geek that no one listens to anyway….
It makes me very sad that Wisconsin public employees will probably lose their collective bargaining rights. The whole climate is impossible and painful. Thanks for a good article but really makes my paranoia meter rise when so many news outlets and shows veer to the extreme right. abc news this week is off my list for watching
Well, lets see. If the income was distributed downwardly then that is were the taxes would come from. Right? It ain’t rocket surgery.
Oh pray tell, what is your method of downwardly distribution?
Why don’t you state the fraction of total federal taxes, including FICA, excise, etc –not just income tax– that the top 1% and 10% pay?
I predict you will never answer.
Misleading statistics come naturally to conmen and libertarians.
~~ModNote: Best practice is probably not to lead with your elbows. It seldom results in anything but one in return.~~~
I have never understood why FDL promotes these shows every week. Maybe it’s time to stop.
Walker forgot that a lot of those first-responders are married to teachers, postal workers, or other public employees. He just told their other half to eat crow. These Establishment fools think the police are some kind of insulated praetorian guard. They are not. They are fellow citizens. Who will stand or fall with the rest of us. As one of us.
progressive tax rates for starters
I think the tax system is a drag on our very lives and needs to be tossed. In regards to “progressive tax rates”, the bottom 40% of wage earners have an effective federal income tax rate of zero. They pay no federal income tax. Seems pretty fair to that 40%.
Yet that 40% pays excise taxes when they put tires on their car, they pay gas taxes, they pay all the communications taxes for their phones, be it landline or mobile, they pay all the same taxes as everyone else and those taxes hit them harder as a per cent of total income than the minute income taxes (relatively speaking) of the rich.
We were quite well off and progressing well as a nation in the ’50s when their were 27 tax rates maxing out at 90%
“We were quite well off and progressing well as a nation in the ’50s when their were 27 tax rates maxing out at 90%”
Funny isn’t it, that the tea-baggers and libertarians seem to want to return to the ’50s but balk at returning to ’50s tax structure?
I say yes, let’s get back to Ike’s America, the one where everyone was expected to pay their fair share.
that is an old and tired argument that is now outdated. The bottom 40% do pay taxes. They still have to watch a percentage of that $400/week paycheck leave their pockets for a period of a year or less before ever having a chance of seeing it again.
They also are wiped out with inflation, which is a silent killer that the top 25% don’t have to contend with nearly as much. Its easy to “cut the household budget” when your budget involves whether to pay for 5 cars or 4, whether to buy the second boat or whether to upgrade the flat screen tv.
Its not so easy when the budget already has slashed health insurance premiums, the family lives in the cheapest rental unit they can find, and the kids are on the school lunch program and the dad is working 2 jobs and the mom is working weekends, with both of them taking payday loans just to pay for the surprise medical expenses or spike in food prices.
Factor in a layoff due to Wall Street gambling, and you have your bottom 40% right there.
stop giving tax breaks to companies that offshore the jobs and then store the money in tax havens and engage in tax evasion is another good way to “distribute downwards.”
Reclassify hedge fund managers’ income as Ordinary Income and put them in the 35% bracket instead of the 15% bracket. Right now, hedge fund managers can earn 1 billion dollars and pay a lower tax rate than the bottom 40% of Americans. That’s sick.
Change the law allowing employee pensions to be liquidated in Chapter 11 bankruptcies. Give those employees a super-priority on their deferred compensation instead of allowing business owners to trash the company into bankruptcy and use that money to pay off creditors only to then emerge from bankruptcy to start a new company…
**Change the current law which allows that to happen and instead prevent the liquidation of those pensions**