One can only wonder what an intelligent, worldly woman like Christiane Amanpour must have thought as she interviewed the Rev. Franklin Graham. Whether it was cynicism or cluelessness about Christianity that convinced ABC’s This Week to feature Graham, I cannot say. What I will say is that Franklin Graham came across as one of the phoniest, stupidest “religious” hucksters I’ve ever listened to. Happy Easter to you too, ABC.
Graham condescendingly said Obama is a “nice man” but then pandered to birthers and those who believe Obama is a Muslim. He insinuated Obama’s claim of being a Christian was suspect because Obama equated it with just going to church, which of course, Obama has never suggested. The interview was clipped, so we don’t know whether Amanpour pushed back on this insult.
He told Amanpour he’s also an end-of-days disciple, as well as a literalist believer in the Bible, apparently without the mental curiosity needed to face its contradictions with acquired knowledge of reality or itself. He tried to explain, using rhetoric and claims that cannot possibly be verified, what the end days would be like. It was all gibberish, a different tongue that conveniently does not have to make sense because it can never be refuted.
Graham’s interview had little to do with Jesus or Easter — we didn’t hear a single quote from the god-as-man who supposedly died for Graham’s sins — but it had a lot to do with defining Right Wing American Christianity as the moralistic arm of the corporate state in its battle against government. In Graham’s theology, as in Paul Ryan’s budgeting, it is a sin for government to serve as a check on corporate abuse of people, its own workers or the planet and even worse for government to function as an instrument for relieving human suffering. According to Graham, I am the anti-Christ for supporting such notions. So be it.
Graham can babble easily in the fact and logic free language used by the Christian right, but he seems more comfortable decrying the welfare state and its effect on churches. Describing an era that no one can remember and historians have failed to discover, he told Amanpour that decades ago churches routinely provided for the poor and the sick, with the implication that everything was fine because everyone was adequately cared for. But since those godless liberals came to power under FDR, government has taken over those functions and churches have become incapable of performing charitable functions and many no longer care.
That would shock most of my relatives, including my parents. It would have seemed absurd to my mom. Though fundamentalist conservative in her politics, she spent much of her life serving others. Without knowing it, she was essentially liberal and socialist at church while helping with the collectivist food pantry and sorting clothes for the rummage sales, and volunteering for about every charitable effort her church sponsored. My dad and I don’t talk politics, but this week, at the age of 92, he would have been down at the church helping out with similar efforts. So what was Graham talking about?
With his narrow blinders, all Graham can see is that God has been banned from our schools and our government. It doesn’t occur to him that Social Security represents the principles of loaves and fishes, that Medicare and Medicaid have helped millions of the lame and the sick, and that Jesus understood the earthly needs of the public had to be served before you can ask them to listen to higher spiritual values. Instead, Graham has conveniently stuffed as much Randian indifference to human suffering as possible into a dogma in denial about the Sermon on the Mount.
Jesus died for his sins, Graham said, and so his debts are fully paid. Well, good for you, Franklin, but it’s time to render unto Caesar and pay your taxes.
I’m not surprised that charlatans like Graham exist. He’s slick and well dressed as they all seem to be, and lots of people are gullible; his is a facile message for the unthinking. But what is ABC trying to say about Easter and Christianity in America that it would feature someone like Graham on Easter Sunday?



68 Comments

Obama says he is a Christian. George Bush said it over and over again. But they are both liars and murders so I don’t know.
I’m sorry ABC featured the Republican Church on Easter. It is a very big church but disconnected from scripture and thin gruel as religion.
The corporate media are the propaganda arm of out Fascist government. Christiane Amanpour is well paid. She probably knows what she is doing.
“What I will say is that Franklin Graham came across as one of the phoniest, stupidest “religious” hucksters I’ve ever listened to.”
That’s saying a lot, given the competition out there in religiosity-land. Frankie’s raising the bar, which undoubtedly keeps his cash register ringing…
WWJS?
He is a Pharisee. Prayer boasted and judgement cast, with a heart of blackness! He has made his fortune by changing money in the temple! I could go on forever, but y’all know.
Being raise in the south I have all the versus bludgeoned into my brain and can tell you it is nothing but a fear tactic to hate on somebody!
He has competition.
Theres rick warrens “saddlesore” church, fred phelps inbred death cult and sarah palins friends in the joels army american taliban movement.
He’s used to being the biggest douchebag on the block, but his throne of skulls, blood and bone is being taken from him so he had to up his crazy game.
I understand he thinks Trump is a good Presidential candidate. So what would Jesus say? How about “Forgive him, Father. He knows not what his he is saying”?
We’ve evolved a mutant form of Christianity, which I call the Church of America. Its catechism–a cherry-picked combination of Leviticus, Revelation, and the more misogynistic views of St. Paul–stands most of Jesus’s preachings on their head.
When you think about it, what could be more American than megachurch religion? To start one, there are no barriers to entry, you don’t have to pass an exam or get a license, or even hold a degree from a recognized educational institution. And your success is determined entirely by your ability to market your product.
Watched that, and definitely will never attend church again.
Don’t forget about TBN, which is the largest telegangster operation in the country, if not the world. A criminal enterprise, if there ever was one. Where are the RICO statutes when you really need them?
Graham Junior, like Bush Junior, is a pale reflection of the old man. Both parents were deeply flawed to start with. Graham Senior was a popular, bible thumping racist and friend of Dick Nixon and other power elites. Graham Junior is in it for god and money, whichever comes first, but never apart.
Attending church on Sunday doesn’t make you a Christian any more than standing in a garage makes you a car.
My parents though Graham Sr. was wonderful, as many people of their generation did. Much to their chagrin, I never believed any of it.
I’m with scarecrow: what did Amanpour say to her producers when she got back to her office and Graham’s sulfuric fumes had dissipated enough to breathe without a facemask.
I hope she said: next time, no softball questions: we’ll make him eat every one of his hateful words.
Why didn’t she ask him if he thinks he personally, unlike Mohammad, can lead people to heaven.
I think we should write to ABC and voice our displeasure with their choice of programming. And shame on Amanpour.
Why would you think that she did or would say anything like what you suggest? I don’t watch TV anymore, but I understand that she has been a big disappointment in her questioning of guests.
And I’m here to say that I’ve spent way too many hours trying to be a car.
yes, Jesus was a Pharisee, or at least taught by them.
The people he was speaking against were the Sadducees, who controlled the Temple until the Romans took over in 70CE. (Since they disappeared at that time, the guys who wrote the books got it backwards out of ignorance.)
Just about any megachurch will be heading down that road. It’s how they got so large.
What Would Jesus Say About the Rev. Franklin Graham? Not much. He is not relevant to the teachings of our Lord and Savior. Now what would the Bushes have to say about Rev. Franklin Graham? There would be volumes to be said.
This is my protest vote: “Cthulhu And Cartman Theme Song (South Park) With Lyrics”
Let’s not forget who lent his private jet to Sarah Palin for her first book tour, rollicking around this great nation at his (and Jesus’?) expense: Franklin Graham.
Also.
Many people thought that about Sr. And it may be that the son is a bit bitter b/c many people think it is the daughter who is a much much persuasive heir to the Graham effectiveness.
“According to Graham, I am the anti-Christ for supporting such notions. So be it.”
Scarecrow, you’ll have a lot of company, myself included.
We’ve been tracking Franklin Graham in Alaska for some time, because Samaritan’s Purse is quite active here in questionable ways, and because of the tight relationship (until last week?) between Graham and Sarah Palin.
Anthropology professor, Alan Boraas has been the most indefatigable. He lives near Graham’s public base of operations near Kenai. Graham appears to have built some sort of tribulation times fortress near the headwaters of Bristol Bay, with underground bunkers and lots of food, fuel and ammunition stashed inside.
Hee’s Boraas, writing about Palin’s response to the food and fuel crisis along the lower Yukon River in early 2009 (for which fdl raised money to send Dennis Zaki to Emmonak to get the real story out):
source: http://www.adn.com/2009/03/06/713792/palin-mercy-mission-not-without.html#ixzz1KTUnlT4x
If Jesus came back to earth today He would run the “Christian” Right out of town. These people seem to have forgotten everything they ever learned about true Christian behavior.
ABC knew what they were getting with Franklin Graham.
This headine is from ABC’s website of August 20, 2010:
“The Rev. Franklin Graham Says President Obama was ‘Born a Muslim’”
It was folowed by this story.
“I think the president’s problem is that he was born a Muslim, his father was a Muslim. The seed of Islam is passed through the father like the seed of Judaism is passed through the mother. He was born a Muslim, his father gave him an Islamic name,” Graham told CNN’s John King in a televised interview that aired Thursday night.
http://abcnews.go.com/WN/franklin-graham-president-obama-born-muslim-pew-poll/story?id=11446462
Franklin Graham has hateful problems with Islam and with Obama, and sometimes they coincide because neither one is like Franklin.
Franklin Graham, Aug 2010: “I think the president’s problem is that he was born a Muslim, his father was a Muslim. The seed of Islam is passed through the father like the seed of Judaism is passed through the mother. He was born a Muslim, his father gave him an Islamic name.
“Now it’s obvious that the president has renounced the prophet Mohammed and he has renounced Islam and he has accepted Jesus Christ. That is what he says he has done, I cannot say that he hasn’t. So I just have to believe that the president is what he has said.”
Which is a good thing, because shortly after the terrorist attacks of September 11, 2001, Graham called Islam a “very evil and wicked religion.”
Of course an “intelligent, worldly woman like Christiane Amanpour” would never lower herself to ask Graham any tough questions, like what he thinks about Christians dispatching large numbers of non-Christians to their non-heavens, and how about that talking snake in the bible, and stuff like that.
Im pretty sure I missed the ’til last week story. A few details?
Heh. In statistics, there is a phenomenon called regression toward the mean, meaning a tendency to go back to the average.
In sons of famous men, regression toward the mean would mean a reduction in the son’s humanity, toward spite and meanness.
Book Salon up with Ha-Joon Chang’s 23 Things They Don’t Tell You about Capitalism hosted by Jon Jeter
ABC, Graham, Palin and Russian Mission just doing their part to starve off the indigenous if they won’t work destroying their environment for the oil and mining companies. What a heart-warming story. /s
Graham is America’s preacher now, courtesy of ABC and Amanpour (sold her soul to the devil).
Obama is a lot like Jesus.
Obama, sole revivor of the once dead Rethuglican party (all street cred destroyed by Dubya Bush) has raised it from the dead. Like a Black Muslim foreign-born Jesus, Obama gave them new life and new hope – the way Jeebus did for Lazarus – who surely by now stinketh! Obama like God – sacrificed his own Party so that the Republicans could live.
Obama will go under the bus in two years, because the only thing that can save us from the Tax and Spend Godless Abortion-craving, Anti-Gun Liberals is another god-damned Republican.
Amanpour and ABC Disney are paving the way.
Tax the churches! With all the tax breaks both pastors and their churches enjoy, for Graham to say they don’t have the money to do good works (like they used to) makes one wonder – what are they spending all their money on? Tax the churches!
What any pundit should do when faced with a biblical literalist, is ask them why they choose to go to services on Sunday rather than on the Sabbath. The early church, since it was completely comprised of Jews, observed Saturday as Sabbath. Even Jesus in the Easter passion, died on the cross early enough on Friday that his followers were able to do the work of taking him down from the cross and burying him which they would have been forbidden to do after Sunset. He stayed buried all Friday night, Saturday and Saturday evening. He rose after Sunrise on Sunday fully observing the true Sabbath. There is no liturgical reference that moves the Sabbath to Sunday. The change to Sunday was made by Constantine when he made the Christian religion the State religion of the Roman Empire. That means that Franklin Graham, as a fundamental literalist has been missing the Sabbath celebration as required by God in the 10 Commandments.
“Whether it was cynicism or cluelessness about Christianity that convinced ABC’s This Week to feature Graham, I cannot say”
Orders from above, or rather, below (speaking of antichrists) …
He claimed that Donald Trump is quite viable and that he doesn’t think Palin will run. As she obviously is running – “game on” – he was dissing her.
These people want a corportist-theocratic government.
What a combination.
Of course the tea partiers will march hand in hand down this road to hell singing hyms all the way.
On Christianity’s most holy day, Easter, something called Scarecrow chooses to repeat a slam piece against a major Christian leader, Franklin Graham.
One has to really ponder the judgment of Firedoglake moderators as well as the Wizard of Oz’s brainless Scarecrow to intentionally insult a major segment of American Christianity by attacking one of its leaders.
Christiane Amanpour’s judgment likewise is suspect as to timing.
Dumb, meet Dumber.
On Easter Sunday. GREAT timing!
That’s just a coincidence?
Besides being the son of one of America’s most revered evangelists, Franklin Graham has a sizeable following of his own, and his charitable organization Samaritan’s Purse does relief work worldwide.
Scarecrow, if you only had a brain…..
Christianity: capitalism’s morbid little sidekick.
Easily exposed hypocrites like Franklin Graham should expect invective. They really don’t deserve anything else, regardless of the day on the calendar.
Scarecrow’s gone and ruined Firedoglake’s chances to use Reverend Graham’s Private Jet.
And after this barrage of insults from Godless Libruls, Reverend Graham may withhold all future Samarian’s Purse Charity giving forever!
On Easter Sunday! Tsk Tsk… Perhaps Your Loving God (acting thru our Christian Warriors) will smite more Muslim children in Iraq or Afghanistan for payback for this blasphemy.
Mr. Graham, like his predecessors stretching back millenia, took what he inherited and corrupted it to his own ends. That’s why it’s important not to confuse Christianity with its churches.
Billy Graham was the Pope of the New World (Order).
It’s amazing that one person could put himself so far on the wrong side of so many of the Beatitudes in one sitting, but the fact that he loudly claims to be a Christian goes far in explaining that feat.
What, you finally realized they are phony, hucksters?
You don’t need organized religion to worship god. You only need it take your money and your liberty.
None of the people you mention are Christian, because they support war and are warmongers, only for starters.
They play to the masses that use their myth (of the masses) to support war, and the rape of the needy (just to skim the tip of the iceberg).
Amanpour has been a tool for years.
Just saying. Peace.
Touche’.
Amen!
Look, it’s true there were a lot of unanswered questions when Vince Foster died, but who is it you’re claiming Obama and Bush murdered again?
It is true that many media outlets are propaganda peddlers – you got that right. Also the part about Obama being a liar, but what did you expect when you voted for him?
Teddy Partridge is upstairs!
Sunday Late Night: Rabbit Havoc
Why not reduction in spite and meanness towards humanity?
Or is the reflection of yourself you see that overpowering?
“What would Jesus say about______________ fill in the blank?”
lets see, say we went back in time 2,000 years;found the Jewish carpenter and assuming poor guy did not have a heart attack when we jumped him and stuffed his ass into our time machine; all we would hear during the trip back to our time is Aramaic profanities. When we finally get your lord and savior to 2011, pull the hood off his head, ask him the question, his response should be something like HAAA, HAAA, YAAA, HAAA, AAAAAY, WYAAAAA, ….
Curious why you brought up Obama’s race…
I mean, what does that have to do with anything, other than he’s been a long time disciple of liberation theology.
What would Jesus say about this phony money grubber that prays to the “god” of monetary wealth?
And Jesus went into the temple of God, and cast out all of them who sold and bought in the temple, and overthrew the tables of the moneychangers, and the seats of them that sold doves, and said unto them, It is written, My house shall be called the house of prayer; but ye have made it a den of thieves.
— Matthew 21:12-13
Thanks for your Easter meditation/sermon.
I’d just read a mini-article about the interview and wondered why the heck would ABC have him on? Oh yes, of course, to celebrate the Republican/corporate church.
Lord have mercy. Christ have mercy.
Thanks for celebrating the parents and their Christian commitments, past and present, as well as their influence upon their children, each in their own way of service and seeking integrity.
Blessings,
Was not aware of an Alaskan Samaritan’s Purse involvement, but I have read several articles of how they are used and abused their “charity work” in Haiti, breaking all kinds of American laws vis a vis “separation of Church and state” principles. The do “acts of mercy” only as a means to build churches to evangelize and manipulate their mercy recipients into their versions of the Kingdom that keep their charges dependent upon their generosity.
Graham and others like him are pathetic.
Interesting reference to Alaska vis a vis this week’s Frontline’s focus on the Catholic abuse of indigenous children over many years and the present bishop attempting to make amends.
I think that Jesus weeps over the sinfulness of most churches and most church members and friends.
Blessings,
I agree that it was an odd panel for a religious discussion (CNN did a decent panel so the contrast is fresh)
“what the end days would be like” refers to John’s “Revelations” which was not initially in the cannon because the Bishops though that once you got beyond the main message – Christ wins – the interpretations were “unclear”. The Book of Revelation is the only book of the New Testament that is not read during services by the Eastern Orthodox Church which rejects attempts to determine, before the fact, if the events of Revelation are occurring by mapping them onto present-day events or making predictions, using it only to say that one should be always ready for the 2nd coming. Indeed many Roman and Episcopal Catholics say the same, albeit there is “diversity of opinion” in both of the latter Churches.
In that ABC panel I did not see the main 3 Catholic Churches at the table – perhaps there is better viewership when Al Sharpton and Frank Graham duke it out. Even then, a clear battle between the wealth or prosperity Gospel folks and the Catholic variations, would have been a better discussion.
But Christiane Amanpour did try to get Frank Graham to explain why Christians should have right wing policies – and I thought interesting that he said there should be no automatic benefits to all the people – there should be only specific benefits doled out based on need – killing Social Security, Medicare, and highway maintenance.
“He rose after Sunrise on Sunday fully observing the true Sabbath. There is no liturgical reference that moves the Sabbath to Sunday. The change to Sunday was made by Constantine” ??????
True that in the 4th century (321 AD) Constantine did degree Sunday for services – and it is true that the 1st century church (50 AD) held services on the 7th day – but it is also true that 1st day (Sunday) services were held from the beginning as a festival in honor of the resurrection of Christ (albeit on a day of “recreation” and not a day of rest).
The Church in Rome was a Sunday Services operation by the 2nd century. So Constantine can not be blamed for moving services to Sunday. There is a bit of discussion as to when Sunday became more common that Saturday for “10 commandments” services (rather than a “festival service”)- with Bauckham who argues that Sunday worship must have originated in Palestine in the mid-1st century, in the period of the Acts of the Apostles, no later than the Gentile mission, contrasting with Protestant scholars R. Beckwith and W. Stott and W. Rordorf and Paul King Jewett saying that Christian Sunday worship traces back to the resurrection appearances of Jesus, with Samuele Bacchiocchi saying Sunday only worship was introduced in Rome in the 2nd century.
The resurrection would seem to be the “liturgical reference” that moves the Sabbath to Sunday.
“Besides being the son of one of America’s most revered evangelists, Franklin Graham has a sizeable following of his own”
Luke 6:26 — “Woe unto you, when all men shall speak well of you! for so did their fathers to the false prophets.”
Liberation theology is that like that Christ fellow feeding 5000 who didn’t work for it or pay dollars for the “privilege” to eat?
A simple, very simple note about history which Rev. Graham needs to grapple with and face as a Christian…
Christians pushed for the Faith Based Initiative.
There has never been a time in human history when Christians have been able to fully care for the poor and those in need. Graham forgets that the church is part of humanity and humanity is part of the church.
Nail meet hammer, amen.
Graham Senior was a fascist and ALSO totally in it for the money. Graham junior is a willing nutbar who didn’t fall far from the tree. I doubt that either Graham gave much a hoot for God or other religious claptrap, other than that the Christian religion could be used to wring money out of the rubes.
Same goes for all the other usual suspects, such as Doug Coe (the Family/Fellowship), Rick Warren (Saddleback Mega “Church”), Pat Robertson (700 Club), etc. They’re all in for the money, and have been used by the corp Repubs to manipulate and brainwash their parishoners (many of whom are trying their best to be “good” people and do what the Scriptures say. Too bad they’re misled by a band of crooks).
Why bother? Amanpour is in it for the money and has less than zero interest in trifling piffles, like truth or reality or asking “real” questions of her “guests.”
Interesting. Thanks for that. I think the PTB are distancing themselves from Palin… as they always have. IMO Palin’s just another pwn in their game, but thanks for the insight. I was aware of the (at least previously) tight rel. bet Palin & Graham.
Yeah, I like how Graham Jr threw out that bald-faced LIE… that the churches have “no money.” Well perhaps if their greedy “pastors” spent less money on themselves & their salubrious lifestyles, perhaps their “churches” would have more money to use on assisting the poor and needy. Ooops, can’t assist the poor & needy, though, cuz that might reek of teh dreaded socialism… let those poor & needy get offa their lazy butts & get some jawbs so that they can *donate* moar monies to the Frank Grahams of this world….
Doesn’t matter when lying hypocrits with double-standards are revealed to be lying hpocrits with double-standards. Easter Sunday is as good a day as any, methinks.
Besides which, FDL had no say over when Amanpour was going to interview this scumbag, so… go wag fingers at Amanpour, if that makes you feel better.
Graham’s a liar who’s only interest is money – ripping off lotsa money from silly rubes who’ll send it to him. The end.
They are all in it not just for the money, but for the power. Never forget that. These men are all about maintaining patriarchy.
They’ve created god in their own image.