We are all stunned and saddened by the devastation caused by the dozens of tornadoes that swept through Southern states this week. President Obama visited Alabama today and walked through the wreckage, noting “I’ve never seen devastation like this.” Well, Mr. President, you and Congress need to get out more and take a close look at the rest of America.
Damage from devastating storms is easy to see. It immediately evokes offers of help and commitments to rebuild from state and national leaders. For a few days, ideological differences tend to be set aside, as both parties agree government has an obligation to intervene, to help the victims, and provide the mechanisms for recovery.
At such times, no one in the media would even consider interviewing the clown who said we should be shrinking government down to a size that can be strangled in a bath tub, even though this is precisely the time to confront those who think that way. Instead, the first question people ask is, where’s the government? Where are the services we need? Where’s FEMA? Why isn’t the President here to see the damage, and where’s Congress’ bill to fund relief efforts?
That’s great. Mother Nature’s power has a way of uniting humans into collective efforts whenever her destruction is sudden and indiscriminate. But what about the devastation to communities that plays out over years? Why is it we look differently at the natural processes that cause buildings to weaken and deteriorate, that cause bridges to rust and fail, that cause schools to become unsafe to enter or that cause waterways to erode and flood? Are these calamities not driven by exactly the same laws of nature?
When we promise the government’s help, what is the moral distinction between the devastation the President saw in Alabama and the economic devastation caused by the ongoing recession in Ohio or Michigan? Are the dilapidated homes and schools in those states somehow less deserving than those in Alabama? The former devastation was caused not by storms but by incompetent national leaders. Their actions have destroyed communities and innocent people’s lives even more mercilessly than tornadoes, hurricanes and floods. The victims are equally innocent and equally powerless to stop the forces afflicting them.
Yet the President and his advisers, the Chairman of the Federal Reserve and fellow regulators, and this stunningly irresponsible US Congress don’t even acknowledge their responsibility to address the devastation they have caused to American communities and their citizens.
So, good for the President for visiting Alabama and promising the federal government will do everything it can to help the victims rebuild. Good for the Republican governors for graciously welcoming the President’s attention and offers to help.
The same devastation and neglect affect the whole country, but our leaders are ignoring 99.99 percent of the problem. They need to do their jobs.



25 Comments

Excellent diary. Recommended.
Just one small correction: “Are the delapidated homes and schools in those states somehow less deserving than those in Alabama?”
Should be “dilapidated”.
I appreciate your paying attention to the vast mess that’s been left unattended or caused by our government.
Thank you! Recc’d.
Superb post, Scarecrow.
To the heart and soul of our species “relationship” to environment … to the planet that permits and sustains our very existence.
Highly recommended!
(And it SHOULD be front-paged. It is NEVER “old” news …)
DW
“I’ve never seen devastation like this.”
Oh really… http://www.pakalertpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/09/internat610acb.jpg
…Mr. Goddamn…. http://www.islamabadtimesonline.com/wp-content/uploads/2010/11/M_Id_91981_US_drone_attack.jpg
Peace Prize Recipient? http://www.fpif.org/files/3081/PakistanDroneAttackSite2.gif?width=500
Scarecrow, excellent post.
I have a link that is a little off topic but not really. It seems that anonymous has a new collosal dump of the Chambers docs and what they are planning.
http://fb.me/P5xMY4b3
Excellent post. I was discussing the same thing yesterday.
We know that following a crisis we want to act and that is when the right starts screaming. “They are politicizing the disaster!” When what is really happening is that the STATUS QUO of not doing anything is already a politicizing.
I’m not a legislating crafting kind of guy. But if you can’t get the right to submit anything that shows their actual intent, can you craft something that forces them to vote against something that everyone thinks is a good thing.
The Help Disaster Victims by Creating a Financial Transaction Tax Bill.
“It’s Wall Street being Forced to Help Main Street!”
We are always talking about how Main Street needs help and Wall Street is in Charge. Putting this two things together will put conserative’s in a box where they have to explain 1) Why their isn’t a transaction tax anyway, and 2) How the money from Disasters come from Taxes which Wall Street and big companies don’t pay because they are dodging taxes and headquarters are off shore.
This would be for ALL Disasters so the Coasts and the heart land will love it.
The lobbyists on the right will need to spend big bucks working against it and when the right votes it down we can go back to the voters. “During your time of need, the right said, “No. Wall Street beats Main Street” even after a disaster.
But what do I know, I’m just a brain in a box.
Outstanding post, Scarecrow. Thanks.
“Why is it we look differently at the natural processes that cause buildings to weaken and deteriorate, that cause bridges to rust and fail, that cause schools to become unsafe to enter or that cause waterways to erode and flood? Are these calamities not driven by exactly the same laws of nature?”
Great post.
Exceptional message.
“The maddness of non-governance.”
Compelling idea.
Spocko- you have almost created a “senate speech” sentence. Senate speech is the crafting of sentences where the content is carved out by the chisels of negation. “A motion to table the amendment which restricts the barring of institutions from forbidding these actions…” for example.
I agree with others here- poignant post. “Wreckage” isn’t just a broken building.
My wife used to wear a patch on her jacket that to me describes mother nature.
It read:
51% sweetheart
49% bitch
Dont push it.
Maybe someday we will figure it out.
Spocko, you’ve just delineated a substantial and very critical fulcrum – and, as well, the leverage of a compelling and effective “change” narrative.
Your brain may be in a box, however, your wisdom roams most effectively outside of the cultural boxes that, by their very nature, generally preclude the recognition and understanding of solution.
And, you’ve got it honed down to graspable “sound-bite” size.
Fantastical good on ya!
DW
Has he forgotten BP, Katrina, Iraq, Gitmo, etc. This is a bright man, so Ive heard. He’s seen disasters and has the information that government action can make a difference….or NOT.
Ah, greatdogs, when humankind realizes the “connection” between Mother Nature and Father Time as being the “place” where we ALL really EXIST, then the species may be said to have begun, finally, to …understand.
;~DW
You took the words right out of my mouth! Lack of any environmental action by this Administration, and now the President is lamenting the devastation?
Also, does this remind anyone else of FEMA’s handing out money to Florida hurricane victims in the summer of 2004, right before Bush’s second election? I certainly don’t begrudge any victim the right to payment, but it shows Obama for what he is — a campaigner.
Mother Nature’s destruction is a photo op. I see that Mr. Obama is as good at getting his as Mr. Bush. I’ve never understood how the panoply of a presidential arrival and departure, with its hundreds of journalists and camera operators, its aids and lobbyists, an attendant Congresscritter or two, and its immense and unwieldy pre-, during and post-speech security detail, is ever a net positive event in the midst of chaos, disorder and loss. Politicians seem to think its a freebie, like kissing babies.
Mother Nature’s deeestruction is also a rare example of god’s will affecting the rich as well as poor, though the pain of its aftermath and recovery is not spread so democratically.
Man’s will, as you say, spreads death, destruction and despair just as readily, but more insidiously and persistently. It’s a daily occurrence, with sunshine sometimes as intermittent as an English summer’s. Politician’s shy away from it because they benefit from it, or their opponents do, and observing either would be rude.
Mr. Obama, please walk the talk. Keep yourself and your security detail out of harm’s way so that ordinary people without your wealth and resources can get on with the task of grieving and rebuilding their shattered lives and torn communities. Govern the country more competently, openly and fairly. That will provide more hope, optimism and opportunity than shaking your hand, listening to your sermon or admiring your photograph, if not for you, for your people.
Katrina wasn’t his problem, although he certainly should have seen pictures that he can remember without difficulty.
It reminds me way too much of Bush visiting NOLA after Katrina.
I hope the results are a lot better.
With sincere and genuine condolences to the citizens who suffered this nightmare & lost loved ones & property, but isn’t AL an esp red state? Aren’t they the ones constantly railing against taxes and “big gubmint”? Aren’t they the ones, in particular, who are both science deniers and climate-change deniers?
Hey, I’m all for helping citizens in need, as I’m always for helping citizens in need. Just saying that I find it also highly *ironic* that this particular group of citizens is currently holding its hand out and asking for help. They deserve and need help, but I really wonder what most of ‘em said when the levees broke in NOLA… about all those godless minorities who *deserved* their fate???
Obama’s a tool, *exactly* like W Bush. Obama, like W, could give a sh*t about these or any other citizens, much less environmental issues. This is just a campaign stop for him. Out on the hustings, he is.
Perhaps the tornadoes coupled with the Fukushima disaster will wake people up. Two of my bils are right wingers who every time there is a heavy snow storm or the temps are unseasonably cold come up with the tried and untrue talking points about global warming. After letting them have their say, I correct them with the fact that it is climate change we are having, that in some places it is warmer and in other it is colder etc. I have finally come up with the short question that they have yet to answer.
Just how long do you think we can continue to shit in our nest, and still expect to be able to live in it?
They for some reason don’t talk so much about the weather as they used to.
My experience confirms yours, greatdogs, time IS telling, and the question you pose is getting through. What is happening in Japan has had a sobering effect and the “spill” in the Gulf is not forgotten, despite what the media would have people believe.
The violence of the recent storms in the South, the consquent flooding and wide-spreading drought is not going un-noticed either.
DW
They will never do their jobs and Obama will finish his tour with pretty speeches then go back to ignoring the nation’s ills as it disintegrates around him. Want to help force politicians to do their jobs? The run third party candidates against them until we win or we send the message of what will happen to any politician that fails to do their job.
I’m shocked Obama left the confines of the WH to
feign concern for some lowlife peasants.
Pretty out of character.
Weeks passed before
party bigs felt compelled
to go public and urge him
to get his ass down
to Louisiana after BP
blew up the Gulf.
But he’s in campaign mode now.
If he appears truly concerned it could
mean support from a nice chunk of red state voters.
If Alabama was a blue state I’m confident
he wouldn’t have bothered.
He would have expected gratitude
for everything he’s already done
for them or they can STFU.
Absolutely.
Great diary and great comments.