You might have missed the segment in last night’s GOP debate where CNN’s Wolf Blitzer asked carefully prepared questions about what America’s industrial policy ought to be. That’s because he didn’t — not that I’m criticizing Wolf, who did much better than the pathetic Brian Williams and hapless John King — but the candidates nevertheless indirectly gave us their own ugly visions.
First, Newt Gingrich thinks we need to be investing in public works projects, except when he’s called on that before a Republican audience and changes that to mostly privately financed projects. Since we’re in Florida this week, all that investment should be directed at the moon, Newt says, where there will be a colony of real Americans, English is the official language, and the Chinese can visit in envy but not have a colony of their own. If I were the Chinese, I’d be thinking of that Larson cartoon of the dog hoping the cat will climb into the dryer.
Ron Paul figured out the absurdity of Newt’s priorities and proposed that if we are to send people to the moon, it should be our politicians. Score one for Paul.
But instead of using Speaker Moonbeam’s idea as a opportunity to describe a national industrial policy, Mitt Romney tried to use it as a shot against Newt’s pandering. He charged that Newt went from one primary state to the next promising to spend hundreds of billions on public works projects in each state.
There was about a half-second flash of rationality when Newt claimed that, well yes, there are worthwhile things that warrant public investments in every state, and Washington should know that, so what’s wrong with that? But that’s a dangerous notion, like asking whether vulture capitalism is good for people, so the moment was quickly lost.
That was the moment when Wolf Blitzer might have asked, “well, don’t we need massive investments in infrastructure in every state, and isn’t this the perfect time to borrow at record low interest rates and invest in our future and put people to work? . . . and while we’re at it, why not build high speed rail systems between, oh, I dunno, Florida’s major cities? Wouldn’t that do more for the Florida economy than transporting igloos to the moon?”
But this was a GOP debate, so the predictably dead wrong response, both implied by Romney’s question and made explicit by Rick Santorum, was that we’re broke. We can’t afford to spend money, even to invest in our future, and even though there’s never been a better, less expensive time to do it nor the need more obvious. And of course, if you’re Ron Paul and your mission is to cut $1 trillion from the federal budget in your first year, the idea that government should be making public investments in public infrastructure is off the table. Liberty! Score minus 10 for Paul.
It would have been even more implausible to ask this group how they think we’re going to fuel the energy for this century without poisoning our water, our lungs, our oceans and the atmosphere. That conversation is not permitted on a GOP stage.
The fact is, the GOP does have an implicit industrial policy. First, you plunder the planet and cripple the regulatory system to ignore the externalities, because the 1% who fund you can mostly shield themselves from the horrendous costs this strategy imposes on everyone else.
You then structure the tax laws and trade agreements to permit corporations to outsource jobs and put American workers in competition with low-paid workers overseas. Then stash the rents in investments deliberately set up in the Bahamas and Cayman Islands to avoid taxes, and hide part of it in Swiss Bank accounts until — “OMG, I could be running for President, so get rid of that for now!” — and then you make sure that most of nation’s wealth gets funneled through the private financial sector, where you take your cut, all at the expense of public investment.
Finally, you tell the rubes that “we’re broke” so we have to cut their pensions and Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid; fire teachers and let public schools crumble; demonize food stamp recipients; and make sure the rubes think the reason they’re getting their present and futures looted is because all those brown and black people are bleeding you in entitlement programs.
It’s an impressive, breathtaking industrial policy, and that’s what they talked about in last night’s debate, but it was all in code.



20 Comments

I should add that Rick Santorum’s biggest applause line was when he tried to pull a Newt and say we shouldn’t be talking about Newt’s lobbying or Mitt’s looting, but instead talk about the “issues.” But of course, those are key elements of America’s underlying industrial policy and they should be issues.
America’s industrial policy?
What industrial policy?
We don’t have one!
Spot on. I missed the whole f***ing thing and I’m a happier person for it.
Newt has one, he just didn’t have time to flesh it all out on the camera. His plan is to infrastructuralize the moon. To hell, with the USA. Just like all other corporations they just aren’t that into us anymore. Might as well start our own Co-Ops.
Me too. I was trying to find out why our Governor won’t run for a second term. I didn’t want to hear more about Moom rocks last night.
Industrial policy?! This is a contest of manufactured, two-dimensional caricatures to determine which one looks best on TV. They don’t have industrial policies because they have no need to create them. Industrial policies are the purview of those who give them the millions these candidates need to run their campaigns and are indistinguishable from those of their Dem counterparts.
A recent relevant article on what it is and how it is done: http://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2012/01/michael-hudson-banks-weren’t-meant-to-be-like-this.html
Good catch. That’s the great irony: there are no issues to discuss. It’s why we are all only left with the horse race. When one goes looking for the issues and the candidates’ solutions to these issues, there is either nothing there or what is there is verboten. The public as well as the candidates are then left with exactly no issues to talk about, which I suspect is precisely the point–well engineered by the like of Blitzer.
U.S. has an explicit industrial policy to support carbon, finance, PhRMA, med ins corps.
Discriminating against asteroids, huh. This one came 10X closer than the moon. Start colonizing the easy way. http://www.rawstory.com/rs/2012/01/27/asteroid-the-size-of-a-bus-slides-by-earth-in-near-miss/
OT: For those following the Foreclosure Deal:
http://www.americanbanker.com/news/force-placed-insurance-subpoenas-1046159-1.html
Repeating from above, as nested comments tend to get lost:
U.S. has an explicit industrial policy to support carbon, finance, PhRMA, med ins corps.
I would categorize your listing as an recipe for industrial and thus ultimately societal collapse.
So, with that in mind, and with your gracious consent, allow me to restate my premise:
We have no positive industrial policy.
We only have a disastrous anti-industrial policy.
“…an recipe…” please read as “…a recipe…”
Much better: easier on the ears.
I was responding to doremus and the headline. Trying to state the obvious first, to get that straight, before any meaningful evaluation, such as yours, can follow.
For all his faults, Clinton was a New Economy guy. I remarked as soon as W took office, that U.S. had flipped from new to old economy in an eyeblink.
At the time I didn’t see the not-so-hidden agenda (campaign donations from well est old inds are much bigger than those from new econ inds), silly me.
BTW, I left several inds out of my list, like military, prisons to name two.
Whoopsie, doremus would be you. Your response to me was in the right context. The one I originally responded to was factually incorrect.
“…carbon, finance, PhRMA, med ins corps…”
Let’s take a look at your industries.
Carbon: We will farm that out to countries which can best be described as third-world toilets-who cares about what happens in a toilet, unless of course there is back pressure?
Finance: They finance the industrialization of the third world and are involved in domestic usury. Third worlds eventually get rather scare and you can’t get blood from a stone indefinitely.
Med ins corps: Giant black/brown/white/yellow hole which swallows people’s lives for profit. When the people finally find enough vertebrae with which to assume an erect posture, med ins corps will be as relevant to the health of the people, as the world was created in six days is to the enlightened mind.
PhRMA: You can buy your drugs legally or illegally. As soon as they find a drug that mimics the effects of THC, a legal buzz will be available mail order from Canada. Universal health care will relieve us of this ugly parasite.
Once America was an industrial nation.
Now it pales in its own shadow!
We’ve had an industrial policy for the last 65 years: continual war and preparation for war. This includes continued massive government-funded research, development and engineering; continuing parallel, government-funded development of similar systems; test and evaluation of a range of systems; the largest training organization in the world; the largest intelligence capability in the world; constant production, fielding, deployment and use of weapon and related systems; massive sales of weapon systems to foreign countries, both legally and illegally; the largest maintenance organization in the world. It has been THE US government priority since 1947.
Oh where, oh where did our fwee market go?
Oh where, oh where could he be?
With his jobs so good and profits so strong
Oh where, oh where can he be?
Too bad there isn’t a “None of the Above” category on the Florida Republican primary ballot.
The are the RKKK of America or the Rich Ku Klux Klan. They are the Klan, they just cover themselves with money, instead of bed sheets. The KKK are mostly poor ignorant people. If you are rich, you join the Republican party. Every now or then, they let a rich person of another race to join. The requirement; that they love white people and hate their own race, we will tolerate you. If you are a poor KKK member, we will send the FBI after you. If you are a rich KKK (Republican) you get to direct the FBI. The Republican policies have done more to hurt African Americans than all the KKK has ever done.