
Secret Service protect a Mitt Romney rally in San Antonio, Texas. Photo by Kit O'Connell.
As I understand the premise of America’s global military and foreign policy, the United States claims it has the moral right to invade, occupy, bomb, kill, kidnap, imprison and torture anyone, anywhere, at any time, without warning, without civil warrant or any other recognized legal authority. The supposed moral basis for this unilateral right to act globally in what decent humans can only regard as a criminal fashion is that we were attacked by others and they can suck on this. End of argument.
American governments sell this arrogant view to the American people by dressing it up, claiming an inherent moral superiority, relying on a myth sometimes called “American exceptionalism.” Under this mythology, the nation is told to believe that whatever it is trying to do, it is for the best of reasons, and if that requires us to invade and occupy your country, or bomb your citizens from drones, it’s because we are better than you victims at governing and maintaining civility, fairness, protecting women, preserving the rule of law and economic security.
You would think that after observing the massive fraud of the banking system, the refusal to hold anyone accountable, the conduct of the Tea Party, the US Congress, numerous GOP-led state governments, and bipartisan American conduct and accountability failures in the “war on terror,” that some would begin to question this myth. We can’t even protect our own women, our poor, our uninsured, our homeless, our jobless, and our system of equal justice under the rule of law has completely broken down. But we live in an era in which it is unpatriotic to question this myth.
Moreover, from an armed forces drawn from its entire male population during a World War, we have evolved to an all volunteer force, and from that have selected the finest on offer to provide essential security for the most important people and institutions. Our heroes are Special Forces and other elite military units, or Special Branches of the FBI and unknown CIA agents, and at the very top — the elite of the elite — the U.S. Secret Service.
It now appears that the global scope of America’s security mission, given this morally repugnant and clinically insane definition of who we are and what we’re entitled to do, has egregiously overreached our ability to select the most disciplined and worthy defenders. We’re out of control, and the so-called rogues are now defining who we are.
It’s not surprising that there would be an isolated member of the U.S. Secret Service, like some lone rogue from the FBI or CIA or whatever, who would be so undisciplined and moronic as to abandon his/her post and compromise the security of the President. But when it appears that as many as 11 of these men thought nothing of getting drunk and seeking out prostitutes while on assignment in a foreign country, you know this is not just a rogue or a minor breakdown in security or supervision.
Whether our soldiers are going on murder rampages against Afghans or Iraqis without remorse and posing with their body parts or partying with Colombian prostitutes while on duty, it’s clear the United States of America cannot control its own enough to be able to stand behind any statement that it deserves the right to impose our views of security and justice on any one else.



39 Comments

Amen.
This was disgraceful. Petty, stupid, and disgraceful.
Agree. Watch the posed pictures whistle blower get prosecuted though. Also, what makes the SS think that they are above paying their hookers? I don’t get that.
Oops. SS=Secret Service. Freudian slip.
We can’t expect the rank and file to respect ethical limits when those at the top shirk the law and moral standards regularly. The fish rots from the head.
Well, it’s an interesting question. Do the citizens reflect their leaders, or vice versa?
Leaders set the tone and create the culture that rules their followers. I suppose one could argue that a democratically elected leaders are a reflection of the citizenry, but IMO we are far, far away from any system where we elect leaders who *actually* represent us.
I don’t have a lot of knowledge of the Secret Service, just what I observed from my brother’s graduation into the service. I went to his graduation ceremony and watched the newest class of recruits receive their honors and guns (used ones, he was pissed! HA!). I don’t defend any of what they did (he wasn’t there) or even anything he stands for, as far as I’m concerned he’s on the wrong side and is subject to any form of harassment that comes his way. But, what was apparent, was that it’s a clan with its own culture just like anything else. The majority of the graduates (numbering in the lower 20s, I think)were young and either ex-police officers and/or ex-military – those accustomed to violence (or a legacy). That whole culture seems to go together; guns, drugs, prostitutes. In short, things such as these can be expected from that lifestyle. I’m surprised the media has been talking about it as much as they have. Probably an attempt to make people worry about our president. Though, I think it’ll backfire.
What is happening in Afghanistan is no different than what has happened in every other war and has been done by all sides. War is always an ugly and dehumanizing enterprise that invariably brings out the worst in people. That is why it should be used sparingly and only as a last resort.
Anybody who is surprised that the Secret Service agents were cavorting with prostitutes when the bosses were not around has obviously never known many cops. As much as we would like to hold them to a higher standard, this is about par for the course. I am a bit disappointed that they apparently tried to stiff the girls.
Of course all this highlights is that America is not particularly exceptional and is no more moral than anyone else and we need to stop pretending we are.
“numerous GOP-led state governments…”
Just can’t help yourself, eh?
Conspicuously absent in you rant are the words “Democratic Party” and the name “Barack Obama.”
“…the United States claims it has the moral right to invade, occupy, bomb, kill, kidnap, imprison and torture anyone, anywhere, at any time, without warning, without civil warrant or any other recognized legal authority. The supposed moral basis for this unilateral right to act globally in what decent humans can only regard as a criminal fashion is that we were attacked by others and they can suck on this.”
Actually, it was Eric Holder, not the “United States” who made that claim.
Leave me out of it.
All of it goes back at least to Bush and at some of it goes back to the early 50s. This is how the US has generally conducted its foreign policy throughout my life. The only difference now is that we are out in the open about it. I am not happy with what Obama is doing, but he is simply following established precedent.
You know, this prostitute thing is nothing new or ‘exceptional’. I used to be involved with upwardly mobile businessmen and this is something that they would have done, given the opportunity. Even the stupidity of stiffing the prostitute. Arrogant, thoughtless, narcissistic male personages who think the world revolves around their desires and aggressions. A big Whatever! Except that one of the dudes might have left the President’s schedule and route on a night table. Stupidity to the max.
It indicates a total lack of respect for POTUS, and for their duty.
Pretty freaking common among LEA and military tyoes.
POTUS wasn’t there and wasn’t expected for several more days. This was the advance team. Won’t excuse their stupidity, but they do not seem to have been derelict in their duty.
There is rumor going around that Newt is willing to get out of the republican primary if he can be appointed to the secret service but only if he can be stationed in Cartaghena permanently without # 3 in tow!
It would appear that he is not alone.
Apparently at least some of them had information as to the President’s various driving routes and schedules….actual classified information. Do you suppose they were protecting such data while getting their jollies? I, for one, do not. Silly “important” men. But we’ll see, as the investigation unravels, whether there was dereliction of duty or not.
“Hey, wow. Any adolescent boys?”
–Rush Limbaugh
Ha!
I also want to say that Cartagena (no tilde) is beautiful and historical and worth a visit. The reputation of this lovely city should not be sullied by the misdeeds of a bunch of men in black. (You really have to wonder why they didn’t just pay up, for god’s sake!)
As I said, they behaved stupidly and irresponsibly, but so far I have not seen or heard anything that suggests that they directly compromised their mission. this kind of thing is all too typical of certain classes of men, which includes cops, the military, and businessmen.
Nah. That is the Dominican Republic and Brazil these days.
And, to be fair, my own marriage was compromised by a business woman who invited my ex to discover himself! Fair play, here. Some people are just unimaginably ‘exceptional.’
Yep. Tends to flourish in those traditionally all male bastions. I forgot team sports, which is another one, as are fraternities.
Yes. But, to be fair, and I am, all of those men had/have mothers. And those mothers might oughta speak truth to their sons about what it really means to be a man……and that every woman they take advantage of also is someone’s daughter. Someday, perhaps…………….
The sad truth is that women are complicit in their own subordination, as they socialize their sons to be that way. It is common for subordinated groups to internalize the values of their oppressors.
What Scarecrow said. We’re in no position to be playing policeman of the world when we can’t even keep it in our pants or show a baseline of respect to the dead let alone the living.
And, uh, Ann Romney? Shut the Fuck Up.
Time for me to toddle off as I have to talk about this kind of thin in my gender class at 8:00am. Take care all.
There were allegations or rumors of allegations that some of JFK’s Secret Service unit had been hung over when he was killed, having spent the night before at Jack Ruby’s strip club. Anyone have clearance for the classified reports fro the Warren Commission? I don’t.
Yeah. That’s right. You got a problem with that?
Before that commie Kenyan came along and froze pay for federal workers, those guys could afford to pay full price for their hookers; since he (unfortunately) hasn’t before, now it’s really time for Obama to apologize for America.
Maybe David Vitter ought to teach a seminar on the proper care and feeding of ladies of the evening. These girls aren’t doing what they do for the fun of it, after all, even if they have the defenders of American exceptionalism leave their sunglasses and earpieces on for effect.
Seriously? Nobody else knew the moniker “Secret Service” refers to their penchant for prositutes? Unfortunately, one agent didn’t understand which goods are covered by the free trade agreement.
Vitter certainly gave the expression “keep the change” a new meaning.
Dearie! I see you’re getting annoyed by the mispronunciation of “Cartagena” too, aren’t you? (no tilde, indeed!)
Ratfood! So this is where you’re hanging out, hmmm?
I thought of you and Bob when I read a piece in, of all places, the fancy real estate section of the Times the other day. a main character in the piece was a rescued cockatoo…he’d been used as a breeder his whole life and lived in a small cage. Now he lives in and between two houses and a very large cage (whose door is apparently left open for him to feel free.
American exceptionalism has come to mean the ability to celebrate freedom and democracy without really having either.
I live in Bangkok, Thailand, and remember vividly when President Bush came here several years ago to attend int’l meetings, that several weeks prior to his arrival, seeing members of the advance team of Secret Service around town – in restaurants and bars – and would find it difficult to believe that those fellas did not enjoy the infamous Bangkok night-life during their stay here.
This story is nothing new. My dad, who was a Foreign Service Officer from 1945 to 1975, used to complain bitterly about babysitting extremely arrogant US officials and businessmen who visited the country where he was stationed without their wives on so-called business trips. Snapping their fingers and yelling “Hey, boy (or girl),” to waiters, waitresses and bartenders when they wanted something and pinching waitresses’s butts whenever they strayed within reach, they displayed an incredibly obnoxious sense of aristocratic-like entitlement among what they viewed as the masses of unwashed who were put on earth to serve their baser instincts. Night after night they partied late while cavorting with prostitutes and drinking heavily until they passed out.
This behavior was not exceptional. It was and apparently still is standard operating procedure for Americans visiting foreign countries on business and it is but one of a very long list of reasons why Americans are despised and regarded with abiding contempt.
Refusing to pay a prostitute is not unusual and I am delighted that the woman complained to a cop who rousted the asshole out of bed and ordered him to pay her. Even then, she was not paid her full fee, but at least she got something.
BTW, I believe prostitution should be accepted and brought out into the open and legalized. Male and female prostitutes should be treated with respect and paid in full before the festivities begin. We need to stop concealing sexual proclivities in closets of our own ticky-tacky and immensely hypocritical construction.
Nice article, Scarecrow.
Recommended.
We all remember “The Ugly American”, right?
_________________________________
The WAPO story I read about this mess [ http://www.washingtonpost.com/politics/secret-service-scandal-ousts-two-agents/2012/04/18/gIQACPbXRT_story.html ] mentioned “The Secret Service has a $1.5 billion budget, 3,500 agents and 1,400 uniformed officers. ” The story lamented how stressed out the agency was, especially because Obama travels a lot. My thought is that with around 5,000 duty staff, we must be protecting too damn many big wigs asses; or too many protectors per big wig. Fits in with the surveillance society we have spawned, I suppose. I imagine even more of this “duty” will now be outsourced to private contractors to get it off line.
I remember reading that Secret Service were often LDS (Mormon) because they were so well versed in answering unquestioningly to authority.
Either way, this is great news for Mittens.