Please see update below. — selise
************ ************ ************
The Honorable James P. McGovern
438 Cannon House Office Building
United States House of Representatives
Washington, DC 20515
Dear Representative McGovern,
My name is xxxx xxxx. I am writing to ask you to take a leadership role in resolving the unnecessary federal budget debt limit crisis.
Thank you for your statement, “any cuts to Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid should be taken off the table” and also for recognizing the grave risk an unnecessary default poses for our Country.(1)
However, it is past time for you to do more. An unnecessary crisis has been allowed to develop that threatens not only Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid, but also the economic well being of our entire Nation.
The current debt limit crisis is unnecessary because the Administration has the power to prevent a default. There are at least two mechanisms by which the debt limit deadline can be circumvented: President Obama can invoke the 14th Amendment, a method former President Bill Clinton has endorsed(2), or President Obama can instruct the Treasury to mint a $1 Trillion dollar platinum coin to be deposited at the Federal Reserve.(3)
The current debt limit crisis is based upon false premises about the nature of Federal Government deficits. Many innocently false statements have been made and these statements must immediately be corrected in order to properly and accurately inform both your Colleagues in Congress and the American People of the basic economic facts.
For example, “a responsible deficit reduction plan is vital to our nation’s sustainability,”(4) is a false statement when applied to the Federal Budget. The Federal Government’s deficits are not something bad — they are savings for the rest of us. We don’t need increased tax revenue or less Federal Government spending; on the contrary, we need tax cuts and/or increased spending.(5)
For more information on these issues, please see the enclosed:
1. Online references notes.
2. A copy of Warren Mosler’s book, The 7 Deadly Innocent Frauds of Economic Policy (forward by James K. Galbraith)
I urge you to contact James K. Galbraith, Warren Mosler and L. Randall Wray for expert advice. Conventional wisdom is profoundly and dangerously wrong.
Please use all possible means at your disposal to educate yourself and your staff and then to communicate to your Colleagues and to the American People how unnecessary the debt limit crisis is and what must be done to end it.
Representative McGovern, this may very well be a once in a lifetime, “whose side are you on” moment. Don’t let your Country down.
Sincerely,
xxxx xxxx
……………..
1. U.S. Rep. McGovern, Progress Caucus members issue letter to President Obama demanding for Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid to be off the table in debt ceiling talks.
http://mcgovern.house.gov/index.cfm?sectionid=15&parentid=168§iontree=168,15&itemid=529
2. Exclusive Bill Clinton Interview: I Would Use Constitutional Option To Raise Debt Ceiling And “Force The Courts To Stop Me”
http://www.nationalmemo.com/article/exclusive-former-president-bill-clinton-says-he-would-use-constitutional-option-raise-debt
3. Why Matt Yglesias and Felix Salmon are Wrong About A Legal Way to Circumvent the Debt Ceiling Impasse
http://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2011/07/why-matt-yglesias-and-felix-salmon-are-wrong-about-a-legal-way-to-circumvent-the-debt-ceiling-impasse.html
QE3, Treasury Style—Go Around, Not Over the Debt Ceiling Limit
http://neweconomicperspectives.blogspot.com/2011/07/qe3-treasury-stylego-around-not-over.html
Obama’s Top Secret Plan to Solve the Debt Crisis
http://balkin.blogspot.com/2011/07/obamas-top-secret-plan-to-solve-debt.html
4. U.S. Rep. McGovern, 69 other House Democrats send letter to President Obama urging no cuts to social safety net
http://mcgovern.house.gov/index.cfm?sectionid=15&parentid=168§iontree=168,15&itemid=530
5. Hawk Nation: A Guide to the Catastrophic Debt Ceiling Debate
http://www.newdeal20.org/2011/07/11/hawk-nation-a-guide-to-the-catastrophic-debt-ceiling-debate-51211/
A Progressive Approach To Federal Budgeting
http://my.firedoglake.com/lrwray/2011/07/06/a-progressive-approach-to-federal-budgeting-or-can-one-take-billionaire-pete-peterson’s-money-and-remain-progressive/
The 7 Deadly Innocent Frauds of Economic Policy
http://moslereconomics.com/2009/12/10/7-deadly-innocent-frauds/
************ ************ ************
************ ************ ************
UPDATE: Message and Warren Mosler’s book delivered this morning (Wednesday, 7/20/11).
I spoke with a very nice Legislative Aide who works on issues involving Medicare and Medicaid.
On the issue of ways to avoid the debt limit ceiling, she already knew about the 14th Amendment and that Bill Clinton had endorsed it. I explained the alternative work around of the $1 Trillion dollar coin.
We also talked about how wrong it was to hold Social Security, Medicare and Medicaid hostage to cuts in other parts of the budget. We discussed the counter intuitive issue that our government sector deficit is the non-government sector savings and that the only responsible deficit reduction plan is the one that addresses private sector debt.
************ ************ ************
NOTE: x-posted from my blog — selise



17 Comments

Appreciation and applause Selise.
Go selise!
events, including a dying (yesterday) and finally dead (today) laptop, conspired to prevent me from being able to deliver this letter (and book) to representative mcgovern’s office today — so it will have to be done first thing tomorrow morning instead.
therefore, corrections and suggestions are most welcome, at least for tonight. assuming, of course, the computer i’m nowusing continues to work reliably for at least the next few hours!
thanks ubetchaiam and elliott! i’m hoping we can break through the deecee bubble to let our representatives know that 1) we know the crisis is manufactured and 2) that we know they’ve got the macroeconomics all wrong.
it’s time for real leaders… if there are any… to work to end the crisis without a penny of fed govt deficit reduction and without decreasing by even a penny the benefits of social security, medicare and medicaid.
Nice job selise. I can’t wait to hear how your visit goes… Good luck!
Ditto
Heres what I received from my congressman, I changed my name.
July 15, 2011
Dear jo6pac,
Thank you for contacting me to share your thoughts about Social Security. I appreciate learning your views, and I welcome your input on this important matter.
Social Security is a program of critical importance to millions of senior citizens and families throughout the country. Although there are significant concerns about the long-term solvency of Social Security, I strongly believe that Congress should focus on strengthening the program through careful planning and proper budgeting instead of cutting benefits or risking seniors’ retirements in the stock market with privatization plans.
Our country faces significant budget deficits, and tackling the debt is an important national priority. As discussions about the debt continue, some proposals have included changes to Social Security. I have heard from many people who are upset by discussions to privatize Social Security or otherwise limit benefits. I have always voted against such proposals, and I believe that there are other more reasonable measures Congress can take to address the deficit. We must preserve Social Security for generations to come. As the House of Representatives addresses this issue, I will keep your views in mind.
Thank you for expressing your views on Social Security. Please visit my website at http://www.mcnerney.house.gov to access my voting record and get information about important public issues. If I can be of further assistance, please do not hesitate to contact me.
thanks, jo6pac, for posting that…
your congressman needs a copy of warren’s book too!
Yep, he ran as anti-war then went to the betryus dog and poney show and has been pro war since. I don’t think he’s going to be much help.
still good to let them know we are on to their manufactured crisis.
Great! Thanks Selise.
Thanks, it’s amazing is the citizens of this nations are saying No to cuts in the safety net and yet both parties move that way. The beltway cool aid ($$$$$$$$) is winning how sad. Yep, I’ll send another email/call to my rep see if I get the same reply. Thanks for your time and effort in getting to your reps office.
Well done, selise.
Nitpick. The correct phrase is “which side are you on” but he got the message.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Which_Side_Are_You_On%3F
that’s an important point, not a nitpick. thank you for the correction!
Gotta watch out for them Marists/anarchists over at the IWW. *g*
just fyi: warren mosler has a post up and will be around this afternoon to chat in the comments. :)
Well, shit, I just might not get much work done this afternoon.