I am a woman of color who has a pre-existing condition…more than one, if you count my high blood pressure.
I have been an adult without health care insurance and I have too many friends to count who do not have health insurance coverage right now.
Should I lose my job I would lose my coverage…and, because of my pre-existing condition, I would not be able to buy coverage on the open market.
That’s not speculation…I’ve looked into it and my black ass wasn’t able to get a nibble at multiple ponds.
So, I’m saying this from a place of vulnerability and I want all y’all who read this to know that.
There must be a line…a wall to hit…or the struggle for reproductive justice is merely a suggestion.
It’s just a request.
A thing that gets mentioned politely whenever health care is being discussed.
"Oh, would you mind not throwing women under the bus while you get your reform on?"
"Could you, pretty please, not mandate that women purchase health care insurance that fails to cover the full spectrum of reproductive health care services?"
"Would you be so kind as to not leave military women uncovered…again…to not leave women uniquely worse off after health care reform than we were before you started?"
There must be a line…and it galls me to even write that because I hate negotiating from a place of “let’s fight like mad for the status quo, y’all!”
But there must be a line…a wall…a place that is acceptable and then the place right in front of it that is unacceptable.
The Senate has crossed that line.
This health care reform bill, negotiated on the backs of women and soon to be presented for a vote with political boots placed firmly on the throat of reproductive justice, is unacceptable.
I’m saying that knowing full well what’s at stake…because women’s health is not worth less than the health of others.
And I’m saying that knowing that there but for my current benefit package go I…because I’ve had to use my insurance to pay for fibroid surgery that would have bankrupted me otherwise or that I would have not been able to have for financial reasons despite the dire consequences.
I oppose the Senate health care reform bill on the grounds that, in its current form, it violates the rights of women.
I oppose the Senate health care reform bill on the grounds that, in its current form, it singles out a legal medical procedure for unprecedented restrictions thus inviting the United States government into every doctor’s office so they can tell women and their health care providers what the Senate thinks is best for them…right for them…healthy for them…or not approved for coverage like it used to be and currently is even though it is legal in this country.
I oppose the Senate health care reform bill because,at the very least, it should not leave women worse off that we were before reform began…because women helped elect these fools to the Senate and, to vary a quote from my beloved Grandmere, “we brought your asses into office and we can vote your asses out.”
I am disgusted…disappointed…not surprised but not defeated either.
So, don’t tell me that we …women…should take one for the team.
Don’t tell me that we…women…should casually allow government to roll back the clock on legal rights people risked their lives to gain because women’s lives were, and should this legislation pass in its current form will once again, be at stake.
Don’t tell me to make a compromise that, in the same situation, you would not make and, funny enough, were not asked to make because it’s never The Man being told his vasectomy won’t be covered or his Viagra won’t be covered or his prostate surgery won’t be covered.
Is it.
No, it’s women…time after motherfucking time…who are told that our reproductive health care must be uniquely regulated, despite legality, by The Man…and that we, despite our needs and that same curiously overlooked legality, must take one for the team…again.
Fuck that.
Fuck it!
‘Cause a team without women is fucked from jump anyway.
There must be a line…
…a wall to hit…
…or all that is the movement for reproductive justice is just a silly social circle of idealistic little children tossing out suggestions to the amusement of their paternalistic rulers.
Take a step back.
And then another.
And then another followed by one more until all of the sudden the only people benefiting from health care reform are the affluent straight white men of power who were already sitting pretty when this reform shit began.
Or the affluent women who can fly elsewhere to access the reproductive health care they opposed for form but would use at the drop of a dime…make that a lot of dimes…should they find themselves in need of the services they would deny the rest of us.
Yeah, fuck that.
I didn’t just work my ass off for an entire year…longer if you count the election…to make "change" that leaves women worse off.
Hold the line, people.
Defend the wall, y’all.
This is about our rights, enforced by law, until it isn’t.
And it’ll be a cold day in Hades when I give them up without a fight…



75 Comments







Shark-fu — good to see you here!
Sadly, I believe the answer coming from the Senate is “Just lie back, close your eyes, and think of
EnglandHealth Care Reform.”Thank you, Ma’am!
I am right beside you and holding the line.
Franken. Sanders. Feingold. Weiner.
To borrow a line from the right: Why do these people hate women? Deep down hate must lie, how else can they make life more difficult for women with no feeling for what they are doing? They need to be confronted; why do you hate women so much? What have they done to you?
Sorry my comment appeared after citing the good guys. I was referring to those who actively work against women.
This is not about abortion, this is about control, always as been.
The abortion battle has always been about racism from where I see it. It’s a bunch of scared white men afraid that people who look, think, and speak differently than they do will wind up outnumbering their kind and they are scared shitless about that.
It’s kind of like why the Israelis insist on preventing obviously pregnant Palestinian women from reaching hospitals to have their babies or why they indiscriminately kill women and children with their air attacks (something we’ve adapted to quite nicely, oh wait…I forgot Dresden and Tokyo, and Hiroshima, Nagasaki…we knew how to do it all along).
Fear of the other and the ever-present overriding fear of anything female that exhibits any kind of power rather than blind obedience.
You’re pretty good at projecting that fear of others in this little comment.
If you need to opine that anyone who questions abortion is a ill-minded racist your opinion is neither reasonable nor valuable, and none too sane.
forgot Obama, easy to do.
Denying essential human needs is rather Uncle Tomish for all poor African Americans not to mention the whole working or unemployed middle class peoples. Can’t wait for a Democrat to save us…wait I think we tried that, I think?
Thank you for articulating how I feel. I self-aborted when I was 15, before Rowe v. Wade was decided, so I know what I am talking about. This is a human rights issue, not just a “woman’s” issue. I am so angry and frustrated over this bill.Kill this bill! I,too have lived my life with no insurance,having a pre-existing condition.This bill will be so damaging to the American people, especially for women and choice.Get ready for the bloodbath in 2010 and 2012.Great ready for President Sister Sarah.
If you haven’t seen Shark-fu’s blog before, it’s definitely worth checking out.
Amen, sharkfu. Just wanted you to know that I am a pasty white male (PWM) that is just as outraged as you are about women’s rights being pissed on by lesser pasty white males (mainly) in power. I don’t feel that was because “it’s cool”, but genuinely from my core. Have hope, there are a shootload of other pasty white males that are just as incensed over the slow degradation of women’s health rights – now to just get them out on the streets to stop this insanity.
oh hell yeah, now that is some Breakfast of Champions !
thank you Sharkfu
Welcome to Firedoglake
Thank you for every word of this beautiful post. I have been stunned at the relative lack of rage over this bomb dropped on women. It should have been a total deal-breaker.
Yes, where are the editorial cartoons showing Stupak standing on the necks of women?
Well, (OT)I do not know the answer to that, but I am so happy to hear, and to join the chorus of Ron Reagan and Bill O in their great push back against Laura Ingraham….Just wow and keep at it against her hateful, arrogant, rude rants that ridicule everything outside her tiny circle POV…funny company to join, but makes it the more significant.
If you pull back the flaps of the Big Tent, he’s standing over there with that preacher man that’s sayin’, “As president I’ll sign FOCA. That’s the first thing I’ll do.”
A fine piece.
Absolutely goddam right.
I hope I can vote for many, many women in future primaries, hint hint.
Thanks, sharkfu. Of course, corporations are institutions of white male priviledge so it’s not surprising that Korporate Amerika produced this bullshit travesty. But what about the rest of America? The “good liberals” who supposedly care about equal rights and the poor and the dispossessed? Why are they so goddamned ready to jump on board with this fucked up shit? Those wonky policy meisters like Krugman, Kevin Drum and the American Prospect, who despite being proven wrong in the past (Afghanistan, cough cough) are so keen to again hop into bed with the stupid, the craven and the corrupt?
Very eloquent commentary.
I just wish more folks, especially the women, would have noticed these things before they “suddenly” emerged in the insurance bill.
Some of us have for many years been watching erosion by passing power to the States to “regulate,” passive acceptance of the Hyde amendment (how can it be Constitutional? If it is as a pacifist I get to demand my taxes not go to fund war), and plain terrorism by words and violence. But I have found it hard to find a young woman who will even call herself a feminist.
It’s going to be a long road back, but worth the journey.
Do you find a lot of men wearing a feminist badge?
In the current childbearing ages, about as many men as I do women.
Here’s one:
Lay that shit down, sister.
I really wish that there were more women with brains (like Jane) getting on to the TV. I wish they would get you, for example, onto the TV. And sharkfu. And EW. Because these things need to be said, and said again. Also.
Really.
I was gone all day so maybe this thread is over. But I want to say I am baffled by your response. This is the sentence I reacted to:
“But I have found it hard to find a young woman who will even call herself a feminist.”
This resounded in my head as classic blame the victim. The writer appeared to me to be criticising women while ignoring the corollary that it is hard to find a male who will call himself a feminist. Why should it be only up to females?
I disagree entirely with the notion that one needs credentials to comment on any FDL thread. A ‘feminist thread’ as you refer to it should not belimited to feminists with experience.
I don’t know what about my comment stimulated your lengthy and unfriendly response and I would appreciate knowing that. My simple remark was meant only to note that the responsibility to identify as feminist belongs at least as much to men as to women. The poster may or may not share that view, I don’t know.
From your reply: “Imagine now that they think you are a douchebag asshole, because they do, and because you are. You are a douchebag asshole”
If you are obliquely trying to insult me with ‘douchebag’ as a pejorative, it doesn’t work on me. I don’t see anything wrong with a douchebag. I consider the popularity of it’s use as an insult to be a manifestation of the general anxiety about menstruation. I don’t understand why feminists would collude with turning yet another aspect of femaleness into an insult.
With all the insults we have already that abuse female hygiene and genitalia we don’t need any more.
Dude, here.
http://community.livejournal.com/feminist/1362470.html
Oh, there’s many, many of them. I was so happy to know this. Here’s one.
http://fugitivus.wordpress.com/2009/08/25/a-few-things-to-stop-doing-when-you-find-a-feminist-blog/
Thanks for this post… and especially for that sentence above. We’re always have to take on for the team. Lifeboat rules are only for the movies. It’s always men’s needs first. And in this case, they simply must control female sexuality, in order to feel like real men.
Lucille Clifton’s poem “wishes for sons” comes to mind frequently of late.
wishes for sons
by Lucille Clifton
i wish them cramps.
i wish them a strange town
and the last tampon.
I wish them no 7-11.
i wish them one week early
and wearing a white skirt.
i wish them one week late.
later i wish them hot flashes
and clots like you
wouldn’t believe. let the
flashes come when they
meet someone special.
let the clots come
when they want to.
let them think they have accepted
arrogance in the universe,
then bring them to gynecologists
not unlike themselves.
* * *
Under the present circumstances, we might rewrite those last lines to
then bring them to members of congress
not unlike themselves
“‘Cause a team without women is fucked from jump anyway.”
And THAT is what I’ve been talkin’ about for a long time. Thanks Shark, for reducing it to a single sentence.
6000 years without wimmin on the team and here we are.
That being said, Wimmin are always asked/expected to self-sacrifice for the greater good. After all, weren’t we created to be Adam’s “helpmeet”??? Now isn’t THAT convenient for the boys? There it is in black and white; GOD’S WORD!
Even the so-called “liberal” men aren’t talking about this as a problem. No, it’s expected that the little ladies get out of the way of “true reform”.
I’m beginning to suspect this whole THING has been about taking away this right I and many of my sisters fought for in the 70′s. Those old religious white men (or any man( not ALL men))felt their control over the life force that they suck off like vampires slipping out of their grasp and, voila! the religious right wing had a CAUSE.
Words fail.
Thanks sharkfu. I’m glad to see someone talking about more than the public option (though that makes me furious, as do all the other measures that screw low-income people). We need to stop allowing our needs to be sacrificed on the altar of ‘change’. Give those bastards hell.
We must continue to address sexual and reproductive freedom as a human right’s issue, ultimately the right to a private life.
Right now the men are intoxicated on militarism, the ultimate role playing game where winning is dominance through violence and extends into all arenas. Rape is just another tool of war or way to celebrate. Just look at how the more recent presidential elections have been framed.
nevermind!
Thanks for the link. Nice funky site and profound.
To confuse rape with sexuality is to miss what makes us most human.
We don’t need to make war on men but convince them fulfillment lies in creation, not destruction. Most women seem more attuned to that, perhaps because of anatomy, I don’t know. But I also know men as a group are just as creative as women, given half a chance. We saw this during the building of this nation..
Now for a shudder read David Brooks today. Just lie back and enjoy the role customer service has assigned you.
I’m a man, feel free to make war on me, I don’t blame ya. I discovered all these feminist blogs and stuff a while ago. My main reaction was how impressed I was with the depth and articulateness of thought, and I was so relieved by that. It’s a good and true energy that is much needed in our society. I’m not that smart or articulate, sadly. Enough about me, though, I’ll shut up now.
Nah, I think most women want to make love not war. Maybe that’s what gets us in trouble.(sigh)
Damn, I didn’t expect to wake up to reality with my coffee and blogs.
It sure raised MY blood pressure.
I hear on MSNBC that a pregnant womon was calling for help and was ignored by some men in NYC and her and her baby died. so much for the sacred unborn life
Primitive man is not noted for caring about an other man’s seed.
Neither are apes…nor any other mammal. It’s ALL about breeding rights when you get down to motivations… whether it’s greed or murder.
Just because we have hard wired lizard brains doesn’t mean we have to deny the whole big neo-cortex which should give us more assets to ensure our survival as a species.
It’s even worse, they were EMTs.
Yeah and one was a woman! What IS the world coming to?
FYI. There are many letters castigating Stupak in Michigan, but that won’t make a difference to so many suits deciding this on our behalf. He is representing the Vatican. Any religion seeking dominion is dangerous to laws that protect the rights of all. I am convinced we must look pretty foolish to the rest of the world.
Where are we with equality anyway? Pay? Benefits? Representation? I notice more for a single person by almost 50% is charged in Michigan’s retirement system. How about yours? There are a lot of aging single women.
Profound!
Cogently put, with the napalm-in-the-morning smell of “don’t fuck with us anymore.” Looking at the sandbox rules the Senate have, the moronic attempt at ‘serious’ debate, the infantile reasoning of arguments on both sides, it’s a wonder that Paraguay hasn’t invaded us thinking, with good reason, that these people are too stupid for us not to invade their country.
Then Tom Coburn, that pusillanimous pontificating prick can “pray” Paraguay away…
God I’m disgusted with what pretends to be real public discourse in this country.
http://www.boston.com/news/nation/articles/2009/12/22/woman_dies_after_emts_refuse_aid/
Thanks, Sharkfu. This support-us-as-we-undermine-you bullshit was too much for me, too, and to hear it repeatedly suggested this is the best we can do is making me TIRED.
It’s not just this issue. How many issues are we actually going backwards on? How many lines are we willing to let them cross?
There must be a wall indeed…
Up against the wall motherfuckers!
Thanks for posting this, Sharkfu. I don’t know if anyone heard the piece on NPR last night about osteopenia. It was hardly surprising, but as someone who has been “diagnosed” with what turns out not to be a real health care issue and then dropped/denied coverage for that and “mild seasonal allergies” I have to say we are fucked.
A line in the sand indeed.
A couple of weeks ago I sat in on some presentations by HS Juniors on Supreme Ct. cases. Two of them (women) presented on abortion cases and said, “This was decided wrongly because I oppose abortion.” When I mentioned that I lived through the coat hanger era, they were shocked, never heard of it, I guess. One actually said pregnancy was safer than abortion. When I asked her where did she get that information, she said, “It’s my opinion.” I told her opinion meant nothing, that the fact is that pregnancy is far more dangerous to women than safe, legal abortion. She started to cry. I felt bad, but damn.
Students today are not hearing the truth about anything.
Is it because there are more women patients?
Cecile Richards on Huffpo: Under this new language, anyone — men and women of all ages — who participates in an insurance plan that includes abortion coverage is required to write two separate premium checks each month: one for abortion care and one for everything else. I’m just trying to picture my son writing out his health insurance payment, and then writing another check for his part of the “abortion coverage.” Is this really happening?
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/cecile-richards/women-on-the-verge_b_399895.html
I wonder how many ppl know this. And if they did, how many would care?
Awful. Sign with red ink too. This is not equal treatment under the law for women. This discriminates against a woman and segregates. Boxer thinks this is ok?
So in this way of thinking we separate and choose- hmm, so then perhaps we can also choose to all write all ourchecks in the same way, by conscience- if thats their bottom line policy????? Interesting what they are creating here- the one to the IRS- so much to human services, so much to defense, etc. Then we can see…
it gets better. my son just told me that the federation is saying that not only will the insured need to write separate checks but so will employers.
any wonder that planned parenthood, naral and naf are all opposed to the senate bill?
Glenn talked about it yesterday, on Dem. Now, per Jane above.
How many people actually think they will use this coverage in advance? No one plans for abortion, no one wants to have it in advance. The whole thing is absurd.
I don’t know how many plans actually cover it anyway. After all, if one would need it, wouldn’t the insurance company have to pre-approve it? And wouldn’t they deny it if “elective?”
These fuckers don’t know anything about it. They are stepping on us, shoving us under the bus, and, when we are dying while giving birth, well, they have their priorities: bagels and coffee.
Lady, and I use that word lightly, ABORTION is not health care. It is “MURDER”. And by the way you have health care, you just said you had it paid for by your employer.
This health care bill needs KILLED for the right reasons it takes away our freedom. Gov should not be able to tell how to live my life, to tax me if I do not want to buy insurance. To give tax breaks to those who are not married. And these are your words I should not have to pay so your “BLACK ASS OR WHITE ASS” to can KILL a BABY. And the Gov. should not controll how long I or You live by with holding medical care.
[Mod Note: let's keep both the sexism and racism out of our comments.]
ha ha, it’s a KOSling trying to impersonate a libertarian, so that we all recoil in horror. Hi, little one, enjoying your irrelevance yet?
I know. Somebody needs to tell the pro-PhRMA crowd to vet their would-be rodent fornicators. Donald Segretti would be embarrassed at their amateurishness.
I’m in. Proudly and defiantely taking my place on the wall next to Sharkfu.
UH, we gay men had to fight like hell to get a seat at the table 20 years ago when HIV/AIDS began to ravage our communities.
The fact is that so long as there are churches that get tax exempt subsidy to attack women and queers every given Sunday, then we are cannot let our guard down and need to organize similarly to hold our gains.
Amen, marcos. But it is no longer holding our gains but getting back our gains or better yet enforcing the 14th Amendment. Passage of the ERA would do that for women and us queers. Both issues are about getting the Church off our Civil Rights. Legislating morality is what needs to be killed.
Saw a quote the other day: If men got pregnant, abortion would be a sacrament. (Boston cabbie to Gloria Steinem back in the 70′s.) D’N'A =Dominate ‘n’ Abuse.
Thanks for the feedback all y’all.
In America, where abortion is legal and a constitutionally protected right, legislation that seeks to deny access to it shouldn’t make it out of committee.
This is not about whether abortion is health care…it is.
This battle is about whether the current health care reform legislation will remove abortion services from a new definition of health care that does not include the full spectrum of women’s reproductive health care services.
And that “my taxes for your blah, blah” dawg don’t hunt….but I know that a lot of antis would like it to. A lot of antis would like this hcr victory so they can move on to pass legislation at the state or federal level to deny access to birth control too. I live in Missouri where that “my taxes for your blah, blah” argument isn’t isolated to the topic of abortion within reproductive health care and where anti choice forces seek to restrict access to emergency contraception and all forms of contraception and sex education knowledge and so on and so forth because the only choices they want for women are the ones they make for women.
I never thought I’d live to see the day when patriotic Americans worked, sweated, and donated to elect Democratic majorities in both Houses of Congress, and put a Democrat in the White House, only to have CHOICE at risk! It is shocking. It is appalling. It means that everything is optional — no right is actual if this one can be taken away.
Thank you, sharkfu, for your contribution here today. Your voice is welcome. I hope this is the start of a beautiful relationship. Looking forward to more from you!
“. . the only choices they want for women are the ones they make for women.”
You said it.
Coming in late, but thanks for being here!
*standing on chair clapping wildly*
thank you sharkfu for writing this. i visit your blog regularly and was hoping you would tackle this.
recommended.
What Suzanne said.
Great to see ya here at The Lake, Sharkfu!
FunnyWheelieDiva
More.
: )
http://geekfeminism.wikia.com/wiki/Resources_for_men
Thanks for the links. I know all those suggestions or at least have heard of them. Keeping them in mind is something else again.
Talkingsticks’ comment sounded to me like it came from a male. I thought I was in accord with Suggestion #10: Interrupt men when they……
I just didn’t think it likely a woman (in a thread about womens rights) would find it “hard to find a young woman who will even call herself a feminist.”
Taking her comment literally it is surprizing to me that identifying with that word is still so difficult, or that it has gotten more difficult in recent years.
http://www.vaiden.net/rascals_files/image009.jpg
If Obama signs this into law with reduced rights for women’s reproductive health care, he is going to loose my vote and the vote of all of the women who got him into office.
We will see who is thrown under the bus next.