Hi there! I would like to take a minute to introduce myself. A few of you may know me as Something The Dog Said. For the last four years I have written about politics, the law and any other issue that came to my attention using that name and the premise that I was taking dictation from a talking dog. It was a fun literary conceit which some folks loved and some folks just as strongly hated. I always promised that if I got a Front Page gig I would lose the Dog shtick. Well that day has come.
Today is the start of my time as a Front Page writer here at the Seminal. I am completely and utterly flattered the editors asked me to do this. I will keep writing about the same issues I always have, rule of law, the Constitution, GLTB issues and rights, politics in general and anything else that catches my eye. I will be continuing my two series, the Weekly Torture Action Letter and First Amendment Friday’s. Beyond that I hope to add value on a regular basis at a great community blog.
Today is Labor Day. Hopefully you will be taking some time off and either are reading this after taking a break from yard work or better on Tuesday. Labor Day has always had a special place in my life. I am the Grandson and Nephew and Cousin of several life long UAW workers. Growing up in Michigan this is not an uncommon experience, but living here in the West, I find it stunning how people view unions and the Labor movement in general. I’d like to take a little time and give a bit of tribute to the Union members in my family.
Grandpa Mike was a lot of things; he was an Irish immigrant, he was an alcoholic, he was the father of 13 children, my Mom being the oldest. He worked in the Ford factories most of his adult life. He was a line worker when the work on the line was much harder, more physical and dirtier than it is today. He was a member of the UAW because he understood the power of the worker could only be exercised when it was exercised collectively. Being an UAW member meant he could have a chance to give his huge family a shot at a better life. I won’t sugar coat it, having 13 kids meant there was not a lot to go around in his family, but without bargaining power of the Union, it would have been far, far less. Grandpa Mike died 23 years ago. To this day the pension the Union negotiated for him helps to support Herself (that’s what we call the Matriarch of our sprawling Irish family). He gave a life of work to Ford Motor Company and for it his wife was taken care of when he died.
I had an Uncle named Otho. That’s right, Otho. He was a big Hillbilly from the coal mines of West Virginia, but when Grandma Georgia decided she did not want her boys going into the mines like their father and moved the family to Michigan, he went into the factory. Otho worked for GM, he worked for them until he could retire. Otho loved the factories. He loved the machines, he loved the people and he loved his Union. Otho was not what you would call the most liberal or enlightened guy in the world. To his dying day he could not understand why I would get spun up over his calling his black friends Ni**ers to their faces, but for all that he was a UAW man through and through. Like Grandpa Mike (the other side of my family) he understood that without Union representation people like him would not be treated with any kind of dignity. He would say of himself “I’m just a dumb hillbilly, but I can build some damn good cars”. The work was hard, there is no doubt. The thing is the reward was fair. It allowed that dumb hillbilly to own a home, to raise a family, to have the kind of things which were flatly impossible for him in West Virginia and he knew it.
I have an Uncle named Pat (big shock from an Irish family, eh?). He is a member of the Communication Workers of America. For 20 years he worked as an economist and strategist for them. Uncle Pat ran Dad’s 1974 primary run for Congress. We got beat, but that was only because Walter Ruther’s grandson got in the race (he got beat too, but he stole all our UAW votes, who is going to vote against the Great Man’s grandson?). Uncle Pat is what you would call a dyed in the wool Liberal. If I can be half the Liberal he is, I will be happy. He has consistently negotiated the best contracts he possibly can for the CWA. He retired because he felt he had been worn down. He told me the only issue he could work on was keeping the good health insurance package the union has negotiated for the last ten years. It killed him that he could not make any progress on other issues like time off or wages or education or pension because the costs of health care ate up all the room for those things. In the end he had to leave it to younger more hopeful negotiators.
Uncle Kenny worked at the Ford plant until the very day he died. He was a plan electrician and had fallen ten feet to a concrete floor about six months before he died. Unknown to him it damaged his heart. Five days after his mother had died; he fell down and did not get up ever again. He held on long enough to say good bye to his wife, then died. Kenny loved to fish and he loved his family. The contracts that his union negotiated allowed him to have a boat, a fishing cabin in Northern Michigan and send both his children to college, the first in that generation of his family. This would not have been possible without the UAW.
These are the Union members I have known. They all came from meager means and they all were able to have better lives and make sure their children had better lives because of the Organized Labor. This is the lesson I learned as a child, that Organized Labor is, in the main, a force for good. By allowing the workers to have a more equal say in the work conditions Labor Unions balance the power of capital.
For me, the big take away from the Framers is the conscious intent for their new nation to balance power. This is evident in the Constitution they wrote. Organized Labor takes the Framers intent to balance power and brings it to business. In this sense organizing is an inherently patriotic act, it keeps the Framers ideals alive on a daily basis.
This is why Labor Day is often a sad one for me. We have lost that understanding that the way to get fair treatment for ourselves is to demand it for all workers no matter what the work is. We, as individuals, can not stand up to the power of capital. We, as collective workers, are more than a match for the power of capital. We the People are always in power, as long as we stand together. This is the lesson of Organized Labor, the lesson of the Framers and the lesson of some of the men of my family. On this day, on Labor Day, we should remember this lesson and recommit to it! Tell your friends, your family and your elected officials that Labor built this nation, labor built the middle class and without the EFCA and the right to fairly organize we will lose what previous generations have built.
Happy Labor Day.
The floor is yours.



38 Comments







Welcome Bill, really great to have you. And thanks for sharing the profiles of your family on Labor Day.
Congratulations, Bill. Becoming a front-pager is entirely appropriate for your great work.
The profiles of the union members in your family are wonderful. How many families have had their lives improved through gains made by unions? The sad flip side of that question today is how many families are going backwards because of the loss of unions in many work sites?
Hey! cool.
Hi Bill.
Congratulations!
how forking kewl dog errr bil1!
What kind of dog was it anyway??
And welcome to FDL/Seminal.
Bill, your post reminds me of some of my family members – my plumber Uncle John, my cousin John who is a Teamster rep, my cousin Marian who also drives a Teamster truck and even my brother, a sound editor, also a union rep.
Thanks for reminding me of my salt-of-the earth genes.
Welcome to the front page!
Reminds me of Joe the Plumber. He is related, right?
Bite your tongue! Nothing like!
When the Loma Prieta earthquake hit SF in ‘89, the apartment building they own was undergoing renovation (ironic, huh) and all his tenants were in hotels or staying with friends. He opened teh building up to neighbors and strangers, a kind of mini-evacuation center.
Would Sam have done that?
Happy Labor Day, Bill. Say hi to your dog for me.
Hi All! Thanks for the warm welcome! bmaz it the dog is a 10 year old Springer Spaniel with three legs.
Heh, no wonder he is so chatty; can’t travel at speed anyway! Seriously, welcome and there is a fine and rich tradition of canines here; you will fit right in.
Raven was my wonderful cocker spaniel!
Spaniels are great dogs, no matter what the sub-breed. Tycho is getting a to be an old dog, but he is our dog.
Got ya, Raven fought an incredible battle with cancer with great dignity. BTW, my grandfather spent 30 years in coal in Southern Illinois.
Coal is hard core. Even today it is not something I would every want to do. Grandpa Egnor told stories of his time in the mines, he would ride a little cart back into a tunnel 40 inches by 40 inches 15 to 30 feet from the main tunnel to dig, over his head for coal. That is really hard core. He died of black lung when I was 8. Dad worked with the National Labor Relations Board for the first few years he was a lawyer, specifically on Mine safety issues.
Yep, my old man was a WWII destroyer sailor, 4 years in the Pacific. When he married my mom he went down into the mine with her dad. “Never again”! Do you know about the Herrin Massacre? Gramps knew many of the actors and wrote an “addendum to a book called “Bloody Williamson”. When he died we found all his Black Lung documents, never got a dime.
My family had a springer, Bonnie. Her buddy was Clyde the cat. What can I say, my mother was born in a Louisiana town 6 months outside of which before Bonnie & Clyde came to their violent end.
Have a brother who helped organize all of the non-faculty professionals in the University of California systems. The UC President used to piss on them.
Congratulations, Dog, er Bill.
Love your family stories.
Down here in the South, I’m afraid people believe that unions are bad in part because they don’t have family members with that history. I’ve met people in Oklahoma and Texas who are classic liberals on every issue–except — they hate unions. Think they’re evil and corrupt. It saddens me.
This labor day, in particular, seems bittersweet. I expected it to be happier, with a progressive in the top job. Sigh. (it keeps coming back to that, doesn’t it?)
Anyway, it’s good to see you here.
Thanks. Uncle Pat would tell us both that we every generation has its responsibility to keep organizing. That work is never done and without a constant push we see what we have now, union membership way down and people like your friends who miss the point about unions.
It is hard to say there is not corruption, there has been and there will be again, but should we through the baby out with the bath water? For me the answer is no.
tejana, my grandpa was a lay minister in Oklahoma in the early 1900s. 11 children. In his 70s he became a Fuller Brush salesman for several years so he could get that new-fangled Social Security.
Thanks for your writing…a great piece of family and American history. I love your pride in “their” story…yours as well.
Coming from a large family like I do, you get a lot of roll models positive and negative. While I have had my clashes with all of those men, they all had something to teach, the core was we are in this together, that is what the Labor Movement is all about, we don’t do this on our own, we can’t, but as a group, there is little we can’t achieve.
Welcome Bill!
We have a beagle who takes me on walks at the same time every day.
Howdy Bill/Dog! Congrats!
You know what?
I think JimWhite is the next front pager – here or somewhere else, cause Jim is frikking cool. Just saying. And good on you both, Bill/Dog JimWhite. I love reading you guys.
Now, the bark has more bite.
No rubber rats. In Akron, the old saying was, the three R’s. Readin, Rightin, and Route 21.
Hey Bill – do you go to the Denver “Drinking Liberally” meet ups? Would love to meet you in person.
I’m not going to next Wednesday; that’s the big speech night, but am planning on going to the following meetups.
Welcome, Bill!
From one Irishman to another: good on ‘ya. And please do pet that talented DOg: he done good.
Wonderful Sory Bill..Glad you are here!!
I am a now retired 33 yr Flight Crew and proud member of APFA…Association of Professional Flight Attendants..and the stories I could tell as well….lol…
Happy Labor Day to all who work to make all our lives worth living!!
I so agree, Bill, with your comment to me above.
Confirming what I said about union attitudes in these parts:
Not the columnist (he’s one of the few dyed-in-the-wool liberals dating back to the beginnings of Chicano activism), but the comments. They are truly depressing.
My brother belongs to the United Steel Workers Union. He’s a machinist and the shop steward.
I told me a story of his workers together after management had them all bickering with each other. After he herded up his members, he pointed to the ties in the offices and told them “They want you fighting with each other. If you don’t stand together, they win.”
I grew up there too. My favorite union member moment was during the Vietnam war when GM was moving some of it’s auto workers into production for the military. My friend, a UAW member, told General Motors “I won’t make guns”. Period.
I eventually became a union member myself, a rare opportunity for a health care professional, and I’m glad I jumped at it.
I heard someone today say that if it hadn’t been for the historic struggle of the labor movement, we not only wouldn’t have a long weekend, we wouldn’t have any weekends. Too many people simply don’t understand that.
Welcome aboard ex-Dog.
Our ancestors fought for the right to organize. This generation tossed it in the trash with their old tie-dyed shirts and headbands.
Greatly enjoyed your stories.
But what I wish more workers would do is call b.s. on the mystification of ‘capital’ that happened in the US throughout the last 30 years, and then exploded into globalization (based on the bogus economics of the Free Marketeers).
Capital is simply a big pile of money.
Time to talk about another key element of wealth creation: employees.
Thank you for your family stories. You have me thinking about my dad, who died last year at 96. He grew up dirt poor in Oklahoma, quit school to work in the fields so his family could eat, got married in 1935 and he and my mom were sharecroppers. Bad timing, as 1936 was one of the hottest and driest years on record. They had borrowed from the bank to plant their crop, which dried up in the fields, and sold all their farm equipment to pay off the debt. He was always a farmer at heart, but at that point he became an ironworker.
He was a leader in his union in the early 1960’s—I remember what a big deal it was when he got to go to a national convention in Baton Rouge one year. Then, in 1964 or 65, a guy in his 20’s, charismatic and arrogant, came in and promised the younger workers that he could get a lot more money for them from the company than my dad and the other ‘old guys’, and he took over the union presidency.
The new guy decided that he didn’t want African Americans in the union and was going to kick them out. My dad, then in his 50’s and only 5′6″, was beyond furious and confronted the new president….who was young and over 6 feet tall. My dad said it was not going to happen and if the guy tried it, he would ‘cut his heart out’. The new guy backed down.
The next year, the new guy failed in his contract demands for large wage increases and the new battle began. My dad gave speeches trying to tell the workers that they weren’t going to win if they struck, and that the ones who didn’t have savings would lose their houses and cars if it was a long strike, which he expected it would be. But the new guy was full of brash promises, and the membership believed him. The strike was long, and I remember the fear….I went to the store with my dad (my mom was very ill in the hospital, to make matters worse) and when I went to get the cat food for my cat off the store shelf, Dad said we couldn’t afford that anymore. That’s when it really hit me…that we could be in real trouble.
But my parents saved more than they spent, and we lived very frugally, so they had a cushion (and after the Depression experience with banks, the house was bought with savings because they refused to borrow money), so we were okay even though the strike lasted two months or more. But a lot of the families–many of them neighbors because most of the workers lived within walking distance of the iron works plant–lost their houses or cars.
When my dad died, I got an e-mail from a guy who as a little younger than my dad and worked with him. He said how much he admired my dad, because when he was in the union leadership, he took care of the men and got them the best deal he could and that they were all better off because of him.
Thank you, Bill, for bringing back those wonderful memories of my favorite union member, my dad.
Congratulations, Bill and thank you for this wonderful post. I’m so glad to learn you’re a front-pager now–a place you richly deserve. My father was a member of Engineers and Scientists and hated it. He felt he ‘had to’ join and–being oppositional by nature–didn’t like doing something he felt obliged to do. But it was clear to me, even as a young ‘un that our lives were different than those of my friends–many of them farmworkers’ kids whose parents were striving (so very, very hard) to make UFWA a reality in the lettuce bowl of CA –because of the benefits my father’s union fought for. When I was finally able to join my first union (United Professors of CA–I still have the poster my professor/union organizer gave me, of a Professor holding a book, chains falling from his wrists), I cried with joy and pride. Whenever I had the option of being a union member, I took it. The better half still is now, and we’re both thankful for it. Great stories today, great beginning. Thanks again. (And glad to meet you!)
woof!
man, I am sorry I missed this thread, congratulations bill, always one of my favorite writers hear at the lake and never had me barking up the wrong tree
now my comment on unions;
companies have to bargain for every product and service they use, the don’t tell the steel mill what they are paying a ton for steel, the steel mill tells them what they pay
then the manufacturer can try to demonstrate how they need a lower price and the negation is on, however it is NOT the supplier of that good or service that decides the price it’s the supplier
however manufacturers have convinced us that’s not the case when it comes to people, with people they get to say what they pay for the service not the provider
all a union does is create the environment whence the supplier can negotiate for the proper value of the commodity they have to offer.
manufacturers don’t want to pay proper value they want to pay lower then proper value and pocket the difference
so the union puts labor on proper footing for negation of proper value/vs performance
often the manufacturer negotiates terms that are not profitable, for instance a term like that might be;
“if a person is incompetent you can’t fire him”
clauses like that are counter productive to both the labor force and the company that needs to purchase their service and contracts must be negotiated so that all benefit not just the provider or the buyer
once people understand the real purpose of a union public opinion will turn back in favor of the system however big business have managed to make people actually believe unions are bad for the economy and bad for them
pity