By now you have probably seen the web ad from the Fiorina campaign. It was featured prominently on the Rachel Maddow Show yesterday as well as at Talking Points Memo. If you have not seen it, well you are in for a 3 minute 22 second treat! It is really, really bad in terms of production values as well as costuming, but that is not why I want to point it out.
First, take a minute to watch the video:
Sure, the whole demon-sheep thing is funny, but let’s look at what the Fiorina campaign is hammering Mr. Campbell for. The gist of this attack is the man is not fiscally conservative enough. He is being pilloried for supporting raising taxes in a state have has a 20 billion dollar budget deficit.
Right now California is in the midst of cutting social services left and right. Because the hard core Republican Minority in the Senate consistently balks at increasing income taxes on the wealthy or at all, the state is going to cut 2 billion in social spending that will cost it another 5 billion in federal dollars. It also takes Mr. Campbell to task for what the California Legislative Analyst office writing “Multi-billion dollar operating budgets will persist, even in the best of times”. What this commercial fails to note is that it is Campbell’s plan did not increase revenues enough to close that gap!
Now, there is an argument to be made that increasing taxes on everyone in a recession is a bad idea, however, California is home to many of the richest people in the nation. An increase on the top earners, even a temporary one would go a long way to solving the crisis. But that would assume that sanity is a major trait in the Republican primaries in the Golden State.
Sadly California is home to many of the most insane anti-taxers. The commercial hits Mr. Campbell for failing to sign the Americans for Tax Reform pledge. ATR is Grover Norquists group and the pledge reads:
I, pledge to the taxpayers of the state
of , and to the American people that I will:ONE, oppose any and all efforts to increase the marginal income tax
rates for individuals and/or businesses; andTWO, oppose any net reduction or elimination of deductions and
credits, unless matched dollar for dollar by further reducing tax rates.
This is what Republicans think is the most important thing of all, opposing all increases in taxes, under all circumstances as well as keeping all loopholes open.
In a way, it is really sad. Mr. Campbell, who is no-ones dirty freaking hippy, is being hammered by others of his party for failing to be completely insane when it comes to governing. It is a trend we have seen more and more in the last few years as groups like the (Hair) Club for Growth and Norquist’s Americans for Tax Relief have insisted on this straight jacket for all Republican candidates.
Still, we may be in the end days of this insanity. As more and more states face the realities of having to cut billions from their budgets or raising taxes, it may finally become clear to the majority of the voters that you can not get something for nothing. If you want streetlights to be on, if you want cops and firefighters to be available when you need them, if you want your parks to be maintained, this costs money. The place where that money comes from should be the wealthy.
For the last 25 years, the rich have received tax break after tax break with the number of brackets decreasing and the percentage of the top bracket going ever downward. It is time for the people who get the most benefit out of being Americans start to pay their share again. The middle class is afraid of tax increases because they are already squeezed to the breaking point. The rich do not have this problem.
In the end it is up to us. The people of California and elsewhere have to say “Enough!” this insanity. If there is no room to increase revenue when a state desperately needs it or the nation needs it, then we will become a nation like we had at the beginning of the 20th Century, with a small percentage of very wealthy and a vast majority of working poor.
Until then, we will see this kind of thing from the Republican Party. Yes, it is funny in how strange it is, yes it is gob smacking that any campaign for senate would produce and run something like this, and yes it is tragically sad that this is the state of debate in one of the two parties in this nation.
The floor is yours.



10 Comments




Can anyone tell me why such patently insane stuff is allowed to go unchallenged?
The ad says to me that genuine conservatives are sheep. Where can we contribute to the ad?
Yeah, I saw this yesterday. It’ll probably kill Campbell.
This is exactly the kind of crap that will work with the
(R) insane base in Cali. They WILL vote against their own
interests every time. I just can’t wait till they’re done
rewriting the Bible.
Yeah, and what is with the “Purity” stuff at the beginning? Creepy pure sheep?
“Sadly California is home to many of the most insane anti-taxers.” Too right, and they’ve basically ruined this state. I could go on & on but won’t.
I had heard about this idiotic ad, so thanks for the laugh. too much.
One thing that will probably work against Fiorina is that she is quite despised in Cali for how badly she screwd up Hewlett-Packard. Dave & Bill still tend to be pretty revered in CA, even the age of Google, and the way that Fiorina nearly ran that highly functioning business into the ground still burns up a lot of residents, even those who never worked there.
At least I’m hoping that’s what happens. I think her opponent should run ads that are simple and just say something like: do you want Carly Fiorina to run CA? Remember HP!
I was all in favor of Fiorina when she first got the job at HP(breaking the glass ceiling and all that), but what a lousy, lousy manager. And she walked away with a giant golden parachute, and now she wants to be gov of CA?? Ohmigawd… well this ad gives you an idea of what her skills are like… bloody pathetic.
I’m all for raising taxes on the hyper-wealthy and the very wealthy. But I am old enough to remember quite well when the CA legislature sat on its hands and smiled as Californians’ property tax bills shot through the roof in line with supposed property values. Back then people were losing their homes because they couldn’t afford to pay their property taxes. Hence, Prop 13.
California has a state income tax, a property tax, a very high sales tax, the Lottery and fees for everything. I simply do not believe their is insufficient income. I DO believe there is a raging surplus of corruption and foolish spending. As an independent medical contractor I have worked for and within the state system. It is wasteful in the extreme. It is corrupt. Nauseatingly so.
I am a card carrying Progressive, but sometimes wrong is wrong. I will not support indiscriminate tax increases without a commensurate increase in governmental responsibility.
I’m not holding my breath on that one.
“It’s my considered opinion that they’re nesting.”
Heh. Crash’Em Carly brings the same skill set she used to destroy HP and turns it onto her own political career.
I agree and thanks to the joys of outsourcing I am now a retiree of HP. WTF Shit I was working for Xerox, got outsourced from them to EDS(Ross Pero’s company) Took early retirement(made me and retiree of Xerox, EDS & GM(EDS was owned by GM), Then Low and behold HP buys EDS and now I am their retiree… Shit how did all this come about??? Unfortunately I don’t get 4 retirements…..sigh..
It would appear that you have elicited the interest of the “Redundancy” Department, Department.
You have managed an astounding feat, and I only wish that you had gotten gold or platinum “parachutes” (which you actually deserve) like those further “UP” the money-chain at HP received.
But, would you have gone into politics, or done something useful, with your booty?
Now, nahant, everyone here knows what you would have chosen (and, one suspects, what you chose anyway, even if ya ain’t feeeeeeelthy rich).
;~DW
waaaay too many farm animals, sheep AND pigs?