Friday was a busy news day: a presidential press conference in the wake of Japan’s catastrophic earthquake and tsunami, as well as Wisconsin reverberations after passage of the GOP’s union-busting bill. And the ongoing Charlie Sheen background buzz we’ve all had to get used to recently.
So you’d be forgiven for missing this gem in The USAToday, from America’s Transportation Security Administration, the folks who previously waxed positively rhapsodic about the safety of their scanners:
The Transportation Security Administration announced Friday that it would retest every full-body X-ray scanner that emits ionizing radiation — 247 machines at 38 airports — after maintenance records on some of the devices showed radiation levels 10 times higher than expected.
That’s right — they are retesting every single scanner. But the retest is due to a math error, the TSA would have us believe:
The TSA says that the records reflect math mistakes and that all the machines are safe.
Well, math is hard. “Abundance of caution,” and all that, right? No, actually, the retests are because The USAToday and lawmakers started asking (three months ago!) for the tests to be made public:
The agency’s review of maintenance reports, launched Dec. 10, came only after USA TODAY and lawmakers called for the release of the records late last year.
How recently were safety claims being made about the scanners? Just Wednesday, Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano was vouching for the machine’s safety:
As recently as Wednesday, the agency vouched for the safety of the machines, with Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano telling a Senate committee that independent studies concluded the machines are “more than safe.”
“The amount of radiation is approximately (the same as that received) as two minutes in the air,” Napolitano said.
I seem to recall the previous safety claims being something like “one minute in the air” so maybe Secretary Napolitano was trying to prepare the American public for a doubling of their risk.
Concerned Susan Collins is concerned:
The TSA “has repeatedly assured me that the machines that emit radiation do not pose a health risk,” Sen. Susan Collins, R-Maine, said in a written statement Friday. “Nonetheless, if TSA contractors reporting on the radiation levels have done such a poor job, how can airline passengers and crew have confidence in the data used by the TSA to reassure the public?”
The TSA may not be good at math, and they may suck at keeping their own Department’s Secretary up to speed on their planned retests, but one thing they are really good at is media management. “Hey, let’s put this out while the whole world is watching some really important news, not just Charlie Sheen!”



68 Comments

Global catastrophe is the new Friday, no matter what day it happens to be.
Recommended, Teddy.
Tweet:
Miss This? TSA Slips Scanner Re-Testing into Busy Friday News Day http://my.firedoglake.com/teddysanfran/?p=78697 from @firedoglake
They wouldn’t have done any retesting, math errors or no, without the oversight provided by Susan Collins. Knowing her oversight habits, how scary is THAT?
Tales from the Darkside scary.
You know, this TSA scanner business is really beyond reality. We have discussed the radiation dangers over and over. I guess the Traditional Press does not have to fly much for their work. They evidently just take a little dictation and forget about the on the ground view of anything.
You think they will write up a story when the human organ fryers start shooting out deep fried pancreas?
Recc’d!
And did you know they’re working on mobile scanning? Read this from FORBES fercryingoutloud, not some loony blog:
http://blogs.forbes.com/andygreenberg/2011/03/02/docs-reveal-tsa-plan-to-body-scan-pedestrians-train-passengers/
A-yep.
Don’t fry like Beenie Weenie. Recall the
previous safety claimsTSA and Janet Napolitano.thanks for this Teddy. USA Today has owned this story in the TradMed. TSA’s excuse is their employees filled out the forms wrong. That inspires confidence in the qualifications of the employees running and overseeing the machines…
The scientific view:
http://www.scribd.com/doc/35498347/UCSF-letter-to-Holdren-concerning-health-risks-of-full-body-scanner-TSA-screenings-4-6-2010
I would like to see that link every time this topic is discussed. It is a scientific opinion directly contradicts the view that these machines submit you to two minutes of in air radiation. Short and informative read.
Lieberman is her Oversight mentor, so literally The Darkside indeed.
Well, whose side are you on — the mobile terrorists?
Bookmarked; thank you very much for that!
Perhaps more and more of their workers hitch a ride on The Owners’ private air transport, or NetJet. I do wonder, though, what they think about having their families fly.
Heh. Means I have to convert all my undies to those 4th Amendment kinds alla time.
http://cargocollective.com/4thamendment
hot hot hot
That’s a great link. This whole matter reminds me way too much of the 1940s/1950s x-ray shoe sizing machines that were still out in the public until 1981. Folks died from the dosing these machines dished out. Can we purge our society of the psychopathic Edward Teller complex please?
No frills flying, just iodine tablets…
And that may be exactly what’s happening here; with the newly awakened awareness of radiation danger, the sheep could become restless in the chutes.
They don’t want THAT.
As for causing cancer, well hey, that’s a “growth industry” in the US. They couldn’t give a rip about citizen’s health
That will be really good for tamping down those pesky protests, won’t it.
http://www.care2.com/causes/politics/blog/hundreds-of-thousands-rally-in-madison/
I really do wonder when coming into our homes will begin
“As for causing cancer, well hey, that’s a “growth industry” in the US. They couldn’t give a rip about citizen’s health.”
TWOOPH!
We happen to have some excellent Oncologists in the US. The problem is that Big Med tells them to stick to the program and not allow alternative treatments to their dying patients. What or Why would a caring doctor advise against those treatments to a patient with no time left?
Normally, he wouldn’t. But the Rock Hard associations that guide him, say NO, NO WAY! Why? Because the rest of the industry may miss out on the insurance payments. Why force the patients to take TCB tablets instead of eating or smoking MJ so they can feel a little better and actually feel a little hungry? Oh, because we have to keep that stuff illegal. Otherwise, the PTB might lose out on some bucks!
Okay, back to the Pancreas fryers.
Do the TSA scanners need to start asking if you’d like fries with that ticket?
Did you know that nuclear physicist/Nobel prize winner Linus Pauling cured cancer with 10 grams of Vit C a day? Of course, since they don’t WANT to cure cancer, they all ignored it and treated him like he was losing it.
Vitamin C is the life vitamin
HA
This letter was written almost a year ago. I wonder what kind of response (or not) they’ve gotten.
“Hey, let’s put this out while the whole world is watching some really important news, not just Charlie Sheen!”
Good catch, Teddy. So TSA went for the oldest trick in the book, the Friday news dump…
What a cesspool of corruption we live in.
And O/T, but still vexing to me this morning: Idiot Daylight Savings Time. Accordingly, it’s still the middle of the night, even though the clock says 07:30 on teh clock. Bastards!
“Step into the scanner. Would you like to super-size your does of radiation?”
Recommended. Thank you so much for bringing this forward, Teddy. It’s so important for people to know this.
No, thanks. I’m on a diet. Can’t have it on my plan. ;-)
Yes, but I thought it was 100 mgs. I’ll try to look it up.
Wait until I REALLY need it!
Not where I live, so it’s OK since it’s ALL about me ;^)
“Never let a good crisis go to waste” – Rahm Emmanuel – the proud new Mayor of chicago
Here we go! Notice he also went up in grams, where as we use recommended micrograms:
Ever since proto-humans moved out of fruit-and-vegetable-rich habitats, Pauling said, they have suffered great deficiencies of vitamin C. Pauling has forthrightly recommended that people make up for this deficiency with daily doses of vitamin C much greater than the 60 mg generally recommended.
“He said our vitamin C consumption should be on par with what other animals produce by themselves, typically 10-12 grams a day. Pauling practices what he preaches, having gradually upped his daily doses of vitamin C from 3 grams in the 1960s to a hefty 18 grams today.”
That’s been pretty much debunked, Kassandra.
High-dose vitamin C: Can it kill cancer cells?
I personally like DST a lot! Although I’m retired now so it’s less important, it gives everyone who works during the day a LOT of evening hours for recreation.
Sorta wish it was year-around, though.
10 times higher than expected.
That’s right — they are retesting every single scanner. But the retest is due to a math error, the TSA would have us believe:
The TSA says that the records reflect math mistakes and that all the machines are safe.
My Sister who is pregnant drove to California rather than fly because of FDL posts on this 10 times the radiation is not what ANY pregnant woman wants to hear.
If the scanners don’t get you, the cell phones will.
So you are in AZ or? I’m in CA and we need to adopt your rules.
Daylight Savings Time: Where people trick themselves into thinking they’re getting up at the same time, when (as a matter of fact) they’re getting up an hour earlier. If people wish to get up an hour earlier, I have absolutely no problem with that. What does piss me off, however, is the fact that the government mandates that I must also participate in this idiot clock trickery.
Grump…And…Harumph…
The TSA “has repeatedly assured me that the machines that emit radiation do not pose a health risk,” Sen. Susan Collins, R-Maine, said in a written statement Friday. “Nonetheless, if TSA contractors reporting on the radiation levels have done such a poor job, how can airline passengers and crew have confidence in the data used by the TSA to reassure the public?”
The TSA may not be good at math, and they may suck at keeping their own Department’s Secretary up to speed on their planned retests, but one thing they are really good at is media management. “Hey, let’s put this out while the whole world is watching some really important news, not just Charlie Sheen!”
Uh maybe government should regulate more and do their own test because we Obviously can’t trust the Free Market to regulate itself where their own profit is concerned. We might as well ask little kids not to eat to much hollween candy
When encountering a scanner, simply decline. It happened to me.
Me: I decline.
TSA: Why?
Me: Doctor’s orders
TSA: (loud voice) We got an opt-out!
Case closed. Go over to pat-down.
The GOP is bringing Mitch from Indiana as proof cutting budgets and destroying Unions work Chuck Todd is blowing him.
Unless FDL pays me I can’t be expected to watch more of this crap There is a reason I sleep late on Sunday.
I apparently forgotten it today:(
Math errors or no, one would hope that the administration is also concerned about the thousands of TSA and airport staff who are exposed to such machines to a much greater degree than the traveling public.
I realize that a lot of those TSA staff might be minimum wage high school graduates with basic weapons training, who might be prohibited from unionizing and whose jobs might be outsourced at any time. But hey, they’re somebody’s friends, neighbors, sons and lovers and they deserve as much respect as the traveling public. Wouldn’t you agree, Mr. President?
My sister swears she was told it was sonar in Wisconsin’s airport if only I had that on tape I would make FDL’s and the MSM’s front page.
We need an FDLer with a gieger counter at the airport!
And just for giggles and comparisons, there was that little dust up in Japan in 2002, cited on one of the threads about the problems in shutting down the nuke reactors.
The president of Japan’s top power utility and four of his lieutenants resigned in 2002 amid allegations that their company had falsified nuclear power plant safety records.
International business practices being as fungible as they are, the old Obama adage of “trust, but verify might” be a useful thing to actually do and not just repeat on a stump speech.
AND …
* The air in lower Manhattan and at ground zero after 9/11 was safe …
* Swimming in the Gulf in the midst of an oil spill was safe …
* The dispersants used in the Gulf were completely safe …
* Gulf seafood is safe …
Riiiiight.
So Lead underwear is Victoria’s New Secret?
If he were still with us, Dr. Hans Geiger might agree.
30% beef Taco Bell is claiming they have PACFIC shrimp taco’s in Illinois any bets its Gulf Shrimp? Pacific Shrimp is the new sure I got a condom, don’t worry babe I’m sterile.
Touche.
Got to delurk (first post in over a year) for this. Are these the same machines that come to us from Skeletor Chertoff? If so, we should keep those dots connected.
Touche, too.
A-Yup.
The president of Japan’s top power utility and four of his lieutenants resigned in 2002 amid allegations that their company had falsified nuclear power plant safety records.
Details were they filling in cracks in concrete and at what size were cracks actually being filled as claimed how many cracks were there before they got big enough to be filled?
OK these details might not make an engineering report but they should.
:-)
“Pacific Shrimp” won’t be a sure thing either the way things are going in the Japanese nuclear power industry …
Not to mention, for those deficit conscious legislators out there, that should the TSA be overconfident and inadequate in its testing, government employee health problems will be paid for on the government’s dime.
Turnover being as rapid as it is, by time radiation-induced illnesses arise, affected TSA staff might be former TSA staff, letting the government legally but not ethically off the hook. Those staff, of course, will have not trouble affording insurance on their local exchange. It will, of course, cover such obviously pre-existing conditions, and its overall limits will at least exceed the cost of premiums. Right? I thought so.
Every sea food place in Illinois swears by it so of course I don’t believe it…now.
It was reported in the Independent in a front page article out today. It didn’t cite any further details. Ritual resignation is still de rigueur there, no matter where up or down the chain such problems might have occurred. It would be unheard of here. The CEO would outsource the activity and hire a lobbyist and lawyer to fight it all the way to the Supreme Court and the next election cycle.
Given the social and business traditions in Japan and the liability for doing that, if falsification took place, it involved quite a few people, few of whom were junior.
Prolly made by GE and never correctly calibrated from the git-go!
I think they’re made in India. Remember the recent deal when obama and chertoff or his rep went there?
Contrarian alert: Flying is both bad for the environment and exposes one to significant radiation. Without minimizing whatever risk these scanners may incur, flying frequently enough to make cumulative scanner radiation a significant concern is bad environmental practice. If your lifestyle involves frequent air travel and you aren’t employed by an airline as flight crew, maybe you should reassess that lifestyle.
meanwhile, back in D.C. last night our Masters of the Universe were making the funnee about the “enhanced patdowns” at the Gridiron Dinner:
Yeah that’s great. BUT the pat down is a total bullshit situation too.
It is wrong wrong wrong. Unjustified, unwarranted, unConstitutional, etc.
Don’t submit to either, I say.
Yeah, right.
Isn’t it sooo funny that the proles have to go though all those invasive searches?
Isn’t life grand and the view sweet from the ivory tower?
that Obama, what a card. more from his “act”:
“America’s favorite voyeur, TSA Administrator John Pistole is in the house. No hard feelings, John. I mean that literally. Please.” (Laughter and applause.)
You are welcome. It simply seemed to slide right by, given that everyone’s attention was understandably elsewhere. A friend alerted me to it on Facebook, otherwise I would have also missed it completely.