Shawnee Mission East (Kansas) high school principal Karl R. Krawitz bravely stood up to the office of Governor Sam Brownback over a visiting student’s joking tweet about the Governor. Brownback’s communications office, reviewing social media scrupulously for messages related to the obviously thin-skinned governor, took great offense to high school senior Emma Sullivan’s Monday tweet from the back of a student tour group as Brownback delivered an anodyne greeting about public service and civic engagement:
“Just made mean comments at gov. brownback and told him he sucked, in person #heblowsalot”
She made no such comments at the event, of course: Emma Sullivan provided her light-hearted (and fictional) Twitter take on a typically ho-hum event featuring the right-wing governor, to her few followers. Later, speaking to a reporter, Emma Sullivan made clear their politics diverge sharply:
“We all are liberal, and we are opposed to a lot of his views,” she says. “I’m just an 18-year-old girl who knows what I believe, and I know what he believes, and we disagree. That is not going to change.”
Luckily, Emma Sullivan’s high school principal values her free-speech rights and stood up for her when contacted by Sherienne Jones-Sontag, Dear Leader’s director of communications.
“That wasn’t respectful,” responded Sherriene Jones-Sontag. “In order to really have a constructive dialogue, there has to be mutual respect.” [snip] “It was important for the organization to be aware of the comments their students were making.” Jones-Sontag says. “It’s also important for students to recognize the power of social media, how lasting it is. It is on the Internet.”
When contacted for an apology, Emma Sullivan’s high school principal told the governor’s office that his student’s free speech rights were more important than whatever offense his appointed functionaries took at an obviously humorous response to their boss.
Except, oh wait — not really:
Sullivan says things developed quickly: She landed in the principal’s office for a scolding that lasted nearly an hour. She says she was told the “not so nice” comments had embarrassed her school and the district and that “damage control” with the governor’s office was the next step.
So Shawnee Mission East is forcing her to write an apology to the governor’s office, with the principal even giving her talking points to hit.
Of course, the principal’s response — requiring a dictated apology from a voting-age high school senior — has brought more attention to the overly sensitive governor’s office, Principal Krawitz’s own servile compliance with a political appointee’s demands, and student Sullivan’s ability to stand up for herself in the face of the governor and her principal:
The whole episode left Sullivan’s 19-year-old sister, Olivia Sullivan, who is a political science major at Wichita State University, flabbergasted.
“I think it is embarrassing to the governor and to the administration of the school and the school district to waste time and taxpayer money on something so petty. And it’s discouraging to children when they are told they can’t speak their mind.”
This Kansas principal could have been a hero among educators, administrators, students, and free speech advocates across America. Student free speech is a core value of American public education, as the right move here would have reminded the governor. Instead, Krawitz is the new poster boy for craven apparatchiks everywhere who bow to the whims of unelected authority-worshipping courtiers, when they should instead educate their student charges about their civil rights versus the state’s heavy-handed reach.
As even social-media-monitor Sherriene Jones-Sontag advises us from her office near Governor Brownback’s pouty place:
“It’s also important for students to recognize the power of social media, how lasting it is. It is on the Internet.”
Apparently, it’s also important for directors of communications and high school principals to recognize the power of social media. The internet is indeed forever, and now they are both immortalized online, as is Emma Sullivan’s tweet; that never would have happened without the free speech suppression they initiated and complied with.
Well played, gubernatorial director of communications Sherriene Jones-Sontag and Shawnee Mission East High School Principal Karl Krawitz. These two will both go far serving Dear Leader Brownback and his New Authoritarian State, the Republic of Gilead-Kansas.



61 Comments

This sad high school principal coulda been a free speech defender: instead, his currying favor and suppression of his student’s rights has branded him yet another handmaiden to authoritarianism.
Brownback made a BIG mistake doing that: http://trendsmap.com/local/us/topeka
LOL – and I nominate for truest/funniest tweet: https://twitter.com/#!/revfajita/status/139760968044523521
Emma should refuse. And then write a blog post about what a dick her principal is.
LOL. I wholeheartedly agree with the first part. Not so sure about the second. Maybe instead of a blog post about what a dick her principal is maybe she could write some history of why the first amendment came about and what it means. Sounds to me like the principal and the governor need that information.
Are state tax resources paying the people who monitor social media scrupulously for people saying bad things about their boss? Is that a valid state function? Or should that be handled by private supporters of the governor, or perhaps his political campaign?
The career-limiting nature of the role Karl Krawitz chose to play in this drama, given his much more American options, may be its own reward. I’m sure there are employment opportunities for loyal and diligent Gilead servants in Kansas.
But Karl will now, and forever, be the guy who made Emma Sullivan apologize for her free speech.
Didn’t Amendment One grow out of the desire of our Founders to free themselves from the authoritarian crackdown of a thin-skinned oligarch who didn’t like what folks wrote about him?
Yeah, that’s a lesson all the adults (Emma and her sister excepted) need to learn.
Also: write the apology YOU want to write, Emma.
Perhaps Brownback has been asking Rick Santorum for pointers in protecting his online reputation.
The back story, though, is that this is playing out as Brownback is pushing for a new school funding formula that would result in more inequity among rich and poor school districts. The politics of school funding are going to be big in 2012 in KS, and it’s probably in the back of the principal’s mind as he’s dealing with this. (That’s not to excuse the principal, mind you, but to give some context and a possible explanation.)
So Sam Brownback likes to intimidate teenage girls. My, what a courageous governor Kansas has elected for itself.
Emma Sullivan needs to learn that women, in general, are prohibited from expressing their views in the Republic of Gilead-Kansas. Just like their wombs, their voices are not their own.
Excellent point, Peterr. Follow the money: it’s been a great shibboleth since Deep Throat’s advice to Bob Woodward. As a high school senior who had to knuckle under to a principal being pressured by bigger players than Brownback will ever be (Ehrlichman and the White House) over our graduation speaker, I really sympathize with Emma Sullivan.
She should run for school board. They do still have elected school boards in Kansas, don’t they? And do they continue to permit Vaginal-Americans to serve on them?
My guess…well, my hope, is that she leaves Kansas for college, does very well for herself, and never looks back.
Right.
“Dear Governor Brownback:
I would like to apologize. For my high school principal, Mr. Karl Krawitz. He is a dickweed and, like you, #heblowsalot. Quite frankly, if narrow minded fundamentalist social conservative asswipe politicians like you would actually pay attention to public education, perhaps we could have higher quality teachers and administrators. Ones who understand the First Amendment and who both teach and protect it with vigor.
Very truly yours,
Emma”
#karlkrawitzblowsalot
Excellent! *applause*
Gotta keep up with his former Senate colleague, Tom Coburn, who once proposed principals monitor young girls’ bathroom trips to avoid rampant Oklahoma high school lesbianism recruitment.
Now, this is funny:
She didn’t think much about it, Sullivan said, because her Twitter page – @emmakate988 – had only about 60 followers and was “pretty anonymous.”
Brownback’s office discovered the tweet via a Web search for his name, officials said.
Read more: http://www.kansas.com/2011/11/24/2114760/disparaging-tweet-about-gov-sam.html#ixzz1eg0oGE5N
Emma had SIXTY followers, when she sent her Tweet!
Emma now has 685 followers. Brownback is an idiot
Teddy:
Someone RT’ed her Tweet today. Jim White(of EW) fame and I had a lot of fun at Brownback’s expense this morning. I included Brownback’s handle so he, or his minions, have no problem finding it. I want his lackeys to see what an asshat he is. And he’s a Catholic, so I even asked WWJD in this circumstance.
As I Tweeted to her this morning, she shouldn’t let the bastards grind her down.
Those theocons had a big meeting in Iowa to settle on a candidate to stop Mitt from winning the caucuses — maybe Sam needs a way to raise his profile online. Not exactly Santorum-quality publicity, this, but it might get his Director of Communications a raise anyway.
They live in a wacky world.
The plot thickens! Yes, casual bullying by neo-con Governor Sam Brownbutt is a feature not a bug, especially against women and children. There is the war on women who want Planned Parenthood services. And Brownbutt is also cutting mental health assistance for children so billionaires get to keep more of their money. Bullying an 18 year old girl is an automatic.
Brownbutt is also demanding more than ONE letter of apology. Emma has to apologize to the moran warmonger Governor, apologize to Youth in Government, Social Studies coordinator, and “others”. Otherwise, there will be consequences. How did they find her tweet? A “search” on the internet? The Twitter Twits might explain if it is easy to search “personal accounts”.
But it is funny that the Principal blames Emma. Now he has to do “damage control”.
Emma has not removed the Tweet that the morans in the Governor’s office find offensive. I find Gov. Brownbutt offensive.
http://www.kansas.com/2011/11/24/2114760/disparaging-tweet-about-gov-sam.html#ixzz1egNk67je
She needs to submit a written-out copy of the text of the First Amendment to Governor Sam, and then cc: all his other intended recipients. She could actually tweet it, I suppose.
His minions are bound to find it; apparently their workdays are taken up scouring social media for offending mentions of their boss.
Damn him to hell for all eternity over a loophole for not following every minute ritual in the religion?
gooood one.
685 followers..go Emma go.
Great post, thanks!
Way to radicalize about a thousand more young people who were only free thinkers and having fun before !
(p.s.) “morans” are the young men of the Masai tribe who are the ones we see in red with great hair, watching the cattle. “morons” are thick headed stupid people of any race.
And now everyone knows why I appreciate how bmaz thinks!!
Love it.
You are a good man bmaz.
Hope you had a Happy Thanksgiving.
This is a clear violation of her free speech rights. A tweet is pure speech. The fact she was a high school student is irrelevant.
In its landmark 1969 ruling in Tinker v. Des Moines, the Supreme Court found that students do not “shed their constitutional rights to freedom of speech or expression at the schoolhouse gate.”
It’s true she should refuse. But she may have to go to the Supreme Court to get a remedy, like heroine Savana Redding, who was strip-searched in middle school by school officials in a search for ibuprofen.
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2009/06/25/savana-redding-strip-sear_n_220717.html
At least she won. The “bong hits 4 jesus” kids weren’t so lucky.
Face it, we can’t rely on officials and administrators to fix things any more. We have to do that ourselves. *ugh* Lots of work ahead.
Not bad. How about this?
Dear Governor Brownback:
My principal, Mr. Kravitz, has ordered me to apologize to you. Although I think he is a complete douche-bag for ordering me to write an apology, on reflection I am willing to do so.
Governor Brownback, I’m sorry that you are a conservative p.o.s. who sux. Who sux a lot. I’m sorry that your policies bear closer resemblance to the dystopia pictured by George Orwell in Animal House and 1984 than to the world envisioned in the Declaration of Independence and the Preamble of the Constitution of the United States.
Governor Brownback, I’m truly sorry that the education system of the State of Kansas failed you so badly. And I’m really sorry that the consequences of that failure are being visited on my generation by you and your lackeys.
Governor Brownback, I’m sorry that Mr. Kravitz apparently also failed to understand the lessons taught in Civics class. I’m also sorry that the Shawnee Mission School Board sees fit to leave him in place as a principal in our district.
Finally, Governor Brownback, I’d like to note that I am 18, and eligible to vote in the next election. I’d like to assure you that this experience has guaranteed I’ll never vote for you, even if the alternative was a stuffed monkey. We’ve tried you, and stuffed monkey has to be better.
With great sincerity, I am
Some more context for those who don’t know Kansas. Shawnee Mission is definitely one of the has districts.
I hope she ends up with 6580 followers.
The Eagle-Beacon cited below quotes her as hoping to go to University of Arkansas. She’s getting out of the state, but it’s unclear to me that adding an Ar on the front improves the situation much.
Well, I stand corrected. You were right, that IS the appropriate response. LOL
What absolute Dipshittery is on public display by the Governor and his cronies. Unbelievable.
The funny thing is that if the student had joked about Obama, both Brownback and the principal would have given her a medal.
He may be thinking about his job, since it depends on the local school board. I remember a case back in 1960 when students at my high school sent a telegram to President Eisenhower demanding that he apologize for the U-2 incident. The decision to do so was done out of class, but the classmates all had the same liberal civics teacher. The school board was split and the Superintendent of Schools supported the man, but he eventually lost his job, his wife, his home and his sanity. When he died he was working as a janitor at the University of Washington.
1,262 followers now
Great news clip, thanks Editor!
A-yep. It’s very much an upscale exurb of the Kansas City, MO/KS metro area.
By the way: Shall we do for Brownback what Dan Savage did for Santorum? What reprehensible concept should be assigned the name of “brownbacking”?
Unsurprisingly, a somewhat popular blogger next door also has an opinion. Don’t miss:
http://tbogg.firedoglake.com/2011/11/25/butthurt-brownback/
Emma Sullivan owes no apology, to anyone. As for the principle the less than esteemed Senator, pathetic. I as a parent would tell these pathetic human beings quite simply to fuck off! They deserve no such apology and if fact should apologize!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
I just discovered Sherienne is married to a KochRoach Teabagger. That explains why Sherienne is a B_I_T_C_H.
http://www.hutchnews.com/print/huelskamp-and-staff–1
I think she wants to go to Arkansas. I’m not sure that will be much better.
Replace the “back” with “shirt!” A better fitting name for this un-Americana circumstance over political speech….
You got there first, Countertenor …. 8-)
Brownback, brown shirt, let’s call the whole thing off. Who could have anticipated . . .
JJ, timing is everything. For a second’s hesitation, I accrued the duty to buy you a beverage.
correction….. governor, lees than esteemed….
These folks are cancer to a free society. Call out the “fascist bastards,” from the mountaintops!
Me believes politicians need be tazed for negative reinforcement, behavior modifications from jerked knee, “fascist behavior?” Just like Pavlov’s dog……….
Jawohl Mein Herren, Landeshauptmann Braunbach und Schuldirektor Krawitz!
Thanks Teddy for this post. I live nearish that high school and have for over 25 years. I’ve found Sam Brownback’s policies, for as long as he has been in politics, to be profoundly misguided and dangerous. I envision a day when enough Kansans start to realize what a disaster the leadership of this ALEC tied neocon and theocratic megalomaniac (aka Governor Sam Brownback) is for our state and vote him out of office – ASAP.
Maybe someone, like Dan Savage, will a little bit of permanent internet name building for our awfully awful governor.
Teddy you are on a heckuva roll today!!! Mr HOT-FONTS!
Brownback shows true genius for his small-government fetish.
And for canvassing the youth vote…
don’t mention hispanics
or women.
I call Sammy “Governor Goldbacked”.
Is he a central pillar of what’s now known as ‘C-Street’, an American Dominionist or just a common self-righteous moralist who regularly takes away more than he shows that he can give?
What a petty insecure moralist can’t stand is a difference of opinion. Some governor.
He was probably making more money, at least, working as a “custodian.” I know the custodian at my elementary school in Seattle made more than I did as a classroom teacher.
Coming in very late…but it seems to me this is just what worried me when I read that Google was going to start including tweets in its searches. That is probably how a web search turned it up.
Makes it way too easy for brownshirts like the Ks governor and his minions to find free-thinkers to intimidate.
I’m afraid that if I ever get a job I might have to give up Twitter for just such reasons.
there you go. he just proved what at least myself has figured all along. and he did it all on his own by his own free will. proof positive… BROWNBACK IS A JACKASS. oh… can i say that? too late – already did. of my own free will…… ooops…. on second thought, that was GOD’s will.
agree
always follow the money.
there you go. republicans – like the ohio nazi stormtroopers in practice brigade – are a bunch of psychopathic malfits that can only handle one thing… orders. self-righteous morons like rick scoot, scoot walker, john kasick, rick snidley, jan boozer, are just a lot of weakers who calculated that if they “hold” themselves out to a paymaster, they might get an attagirl and feel better about themselves rather than having to tackle real difficulties and challenges to make real differences and accomplishments. so they took the shortcut being the lazy cowards they are.
Is there more to thie story? Are her parents supporting her here? Telling the principle to go pound sand up her toady ass? Emma is a hope for our future, a person who knows what they believe in, which is just and moral, and isn’t afraid to say it. Fuck Brownback and that principle.
The problem here is we are so conditioned in our society to tolerate the intolerable. It has to stop. NOW!