CNN, The Most Trusted Name in News, called the Supreme Court’s ruling this morning on its website and in broadcast: with both a bright yellow BREAKING banner and a huge headline, CNN informed its viewers and web-readers that “The Supreme Court has struck down the individual mandate for health care” and “Mandate Struck Down.”
Wrong.
They even had the sub-head wrong on their website splash page: “High Court Finds Measure Unconstitutional.” And then provided readers more (wrong) detail in the article:
Justices’ ruling overturns requirement that Americans buy health insurance. The decision will affect you, generations of Americans and this fall’s presidential race.
Wrong. (Screencaps here, courtesy of Eric Wemple of the WaPo)
“The most trusted name in news?” Not today.
Wemple:
Someone needs to tell CNN: There is no such thing as fashioning a scoop over something that’s released to the public. Here I cite New York University professor Jay Rosen, who repeatedly chants about how cheap it is when news outlets brand as “exclusives” bits of information that everyone will know in a short time anyhow. This afternoon, one day from now, one week from now: No one will notice, care or otherwise take heed that your outlet was the first to report on a Supreme Court decision. There’s not an outlet that’ll own that news. But much heed will be taken of a quick and mistaken interpretation of such a decision.
Let’s have a slogan contest to help CNN more accurately reflect their performance? “First with the news, but wrong!” “CNN: when you care more about getting the news fast than getting the news right” “CNN: We inform AND misinform!”



28 Comments

Would you say this is more or less embarrassing than Wolf Blitzer ending up $4300 in the red in Celebrity Jeopardy last year? Probably his humiliation at Alex Trebek’s hands was more public.
Also: Fox
“CNN: Better to be first than right!”
CNN: We Suck at Jeopardy and getting it right but WE’RE FIRST!
David E provides a tick-tock of all the times CNN got this wrong today. It’s fun to read, and has pix of Chief Roberts with his delightful family.
Thanks, Editor — this video is simply precious. Wolf just says the words they put in front of him….
Blitz Unrecht!
Candy Mehr Unrecht!
Correct? Not Necessarily!
not sure if this is correct but under Article 1, Section 7 requires all legislation that raises revenue originate in the HOUSE OF REPRESENATIVES.
Didn’t this bill originate in THE SENATE? So if this is a tax then it is not enforceable?
The biggest problem with the ACA is that it does nothing to promote doctors going into general family practice. I predict that 2015 many doctors will simply say I have no room for any more patients. Think of it like this a gp that works 10 hours a day and spends 20 min with a patient can see maybe 27 easy patients a day. Any complications and that reduces that number. 27 x 5 days = 135 patients/week * 48 weeks/year = 6480 patient slots per year. If each patient uses 1.5 slots/year that is 4320 unique patients/year. ~350,000,000 people in the US. = 81015 gp’s to cover the patients in the US. There are not that many GP’s and LNPs in the US. You better hope that everyone does not use all their benefits. Otherwise we will have rationing by availability. You are going to have to entice docs to become GPs and that means paying off their 100k loans and that is not in the budget.
CNN, along with all the other major news networks, are not in the business of reporting the news. They are in the business of writing the news. Their collective job is not to reflect but to produce, to manufacture an audience that they can then sell to advertisers.
Some doctors are in it to help their patients rather than maximize their profit making potential.
One doctor in NY that I am a distant acquaintance of complains that the time he spends fighting with insurance companies and dealing with paperwork cuts way back on the number of patients he can help.
The biggest problem with the ACA is that it does nothing to eliminate that burden.
Considering he is only an actor, I’d say they two incidents are about the same.
CNN: The Most Rusted Name in News
Yes, I thought it was a tremendous blow to Wolf’s credibility to go on the Celebrity Jeopardy episode at all, but then to lose to Andy Richter, Conan O’Brien’s sidekick? Shameful.
… speaking of which — I’ve had cablenews gasbag shows on all day, but now that we’ve reached the 1pm hour (4pm east coast) and my choices are Neil Cavuto, Wolf Blitzer and Martin Basheer? CLICK goes the remote!
ooooh, yes!
Yep… A news organization will never be lastingly remembered for reporting something five, ten, or even 30 minutes ahead of the competition.
But they will remembered always for having gotten it wrong — which means they were never reporting the news, but only the manufactured content of their own imaginations.
That right there is a massive breach of journalistic ethics. A sad day for CNN…and a demonstration of just how far they’ve fallen.
But hey, did we all honestly expect anything different from Fox News? Next up, they’ll run a chiron that reads, “Chief Justice Roberts – Democrat.”
CNN: First in misinformation!
CNN: Once the flagship of cable news, now a garbage scow…
CNN = Contains No News or CNN = Constant Nonsense Network
ha ha
My rightwing friends – victims of the Fox-Rush continuum – still tell me that CNN = Communist News Network.
If I don’t laugh, I’ll cry & tear my hair out.
This is like CNN trying to be the “frist” blogger who responds to a new post at Sadly, No!
Me likey Sadly, No. CNN, not so much.
I like both of these mottoes.
Funny:
CNN! CNN! CNN!……..
I don’t know if they still do this, but it’s sort of like when a “Republican” politician is “busted” for some wrong-doing, but Fox “accidentally” puts a “D” by their name.
I can only guess that Fake/CNN had “decided” that the SCOTUS would go against Obama bc he’s a horrid “Democrat,” they had their talking points all typed up and ready to go.
Figures… they were wrong. Kind of tells you just how frickin’ phony & unfactual both of those stations are (not that we didn’t already know that).
My first and only post of the day.
Go, Teddy. Call ‘em on it.
Okay, I feel better, thanks.
Heh! I watched that Jeopardy. This was my favorite:
Answer: Jesus was born in this city.
Blitzer’s question: What is Jerusalem?
Classic.
Huh. I didn’t see it but it comes as no surprise that he was beat by Richter. Richter seems far more bright. Bitzer seems to have no sense of humor which is a sure sign of a wea mind