President Obama campaigned for re-election on one central theme: those who’ve done well in America should pay more of their fair share. If you asked the lowest-information voter of 2012, s/he could probably tell you that Obama wanted to raise taxes on people making more than a quarter-million dollars a year. $250,000 was a number woven into every speech he made.

Even Ezra Klein has turned on Obama over the fiscal cliff.
And, now, he seems to have abandoned even this benchmark as part of his ‘negotiation’ on the fiscal cliff.
Ezra Klein, loyal Administration mouthpiece, has noticed:
But after Obama won on a platform that was barely about anything aside from letting those tax cuts expire, it seemed inevitable he’d get it done. It was his due.
To the GOP’s delight, that no longer seems to be the case. In the Obama-Boehner negotiations, the White House offered to raise the threshold from $250,000 to $400,000. McConnell, in his negotiations with Harry Reid and now Joe Biden, has been trying to raise that to $500,000. It’s clear to the Republicans that they will get past the fiscal cliff with a smaller tax increase than they thought. Perhaps much smaller. Huzzah!
This negotiating-with-himself that Barack Obama specializes in has taken us to a familiar place, and Ezra Klein seems unafraid to point it out in the pixels of the Washington Post:
All this raises the tantalizing prospect for Republicans that they could end these negotiations having given up less tax revenue than they ever thought possible — less tax revenue than Boehner offered Obama, even — but still getting their entitlement cuts. Oh, and because there was never a big deal, they won’t have to agree to much stimulus, either. All in all, a pretty big win, and it wouldn’t have been possible without the White House’s baffling inability to stick to a negotiating position.
Ezra Klein could always be previously relied on to cheer the magnificence of the Emperor’s new negotiating clothes as each capitulation was paraded in front of the Punditocracy. For him to acknowledge Obama’s nakedness now may mean that Village Orthodoxy is breaking down, and our Elite Media is tiring, even before his second Inauguration, of Obama’s pretense of not doing the exact bidding of the plutocracy.
When everyone sees, and says, that a better deal is to be had post-Cliff, and the president is racing to make a deal pre-Cliff, the story that he’s working hard for middle-class taxpayers starts to wear a little thin. When Ezra Klein notices, and says so, the president may be in real trouble finding Elite Opinion to back his Deal, Grand Bargain or no.
Photo by LinkTiger released under a Creative Commons license.



85 Comments

Oh, noes! The House has gone home for the night without voting.
What are YOU wearing over the Cliff?
Anyone who thought that President “I’m-Lying-When-My-Lips-Are-Flapping” was telling any kind of truth, ever, needs a wake up call.
What, did voters think the President was being honest just because these lies were campaign promises?
JEESH!
Guess I gave up my right to complain in November. Could not & did not vote for the DLC (aka moderate republican front) candidate. I laugh though when the Dem base calls the tea party the sheeple. Think they should look in a mirror.
grey t-shirt with a pocket, black sweat pants, black house slippers and, occasionally as I lie here, a cat draped over my left shoulder…
… at midnight add 1 margarita.
Green T-Shirt with a grey hoody,
Nothing. Nothing at all….
Tiara and a feather boa.
(Looking for that pic made me go back and reread an old post, that your post here seems to be proving correct yet again. See the end of that post for the explanation of my attire.)
That was a very swell post indeed, Peterr.
Happy New Year, hope your tiara and boa find a celebration worth their wearing!
LOL! I remember that post (snickers).
Since you’re stealing my drag preference, I shall be forced in my attire choice to the trusty speedo – it IS cliff diving after all.
The point isn’t really that ‘anyone’ thought Obama would keep these campaign promises, the point is that Ezra Klein, court stenographer, would mention them in a post about giving up tax ground in the negotiations. Of course Obama is doing what Obama always wanted to do, but the ‘emperor has no clothes’ aspect is uncomfortably close if Ezra is doing the calling out.
What we all know about the Democratic base could fill a coupla volumes, amirite? But when Ezra sez it, it’s suddenly more true for lotsa people who think their opinion matters.
Going over the Cliff, I’m going to wear Obama’s ‘well-worn’ union organizing shoes, since he’s sure not to be wearing them, along with a Hopenchange bumper sticker or two, strategically placed.
Yeah, when the straight ministers among us start to steal our basic gear, we laddies have to improvise, right?
Oh My /takei
Yeah, man. My “Closets are for Clothes” t-shirt and a kilt just didn’t seem enough if the Rev is going all tiara and boa.
Gosh, the 2008 elections gave us a relatively inexperienced first-term senator without any record of accomplishment, and he’s a huge disappointment. Who knew.
Don’t worry. Ezra will pull an Ed Schultz and return in a few days spouting the party line with no mention of his blasphemy.
If you’re hosting the party, Kelly, I wouldn’t worry about the outfits. The food will no doubt be the star of the night.
All depends on how blow-y the weather is there, when you’re wearing your kilt.
Blasphemy!
Not worry about the outfits?!?!
Man, your honorary gay card is revoked right now. Back to school for you, starting with the entire Streisand oeuvre.
You must wear the reading glasses as well. You must.
Teddy, Teddy, Teddy . . . have you forgotten that clothes are but one element of the gay trinity? It’s not JUST the outfits that matter, but also the glorious flowers and the fabulous food.
I didn’t mean to imply that the outfits don’t matter — just that the quality of the food will outshine whatever Kelly comes up with.
Bifocals.
Very nicely stated, Teddy. Great piece. Given that Klein has been a fixture around MSNBC (most recently sitting in for Maddow), it’s going to be interesting to see what, if any, reaction there might be around that shop. To take it a step further, I wonder how Maddow will present this latest capitulation? She’s also been a pretty reliable cheerleader as regards these bullshit deals. Given that GE / Comcast sign her paychecks and are (basically) her corporate overlords, I ain’t expecting much…
I’m sorry, did I sound cynical?
Hahahahaha!!! Zing!!!
Of all the things Obama should have learned working in the finance division of Business International (true story) you would think using Leverage would be one of them.
“Bi”focals.
Hmmmm.
No, you sound very matter of fact. Not cynical at all!
(I couldn’t call anyone CYNICAL who approved of one of my posts!)
This point of view still works for me. Adjust the copy for the fiscal cliff or whatever latest bullshit contrivance Obama is aiming for.
sonofabitch.
nah. There is no more cynical. Cynical is the new…… I don’t know. Fuck it.Don’t care. Cliff this, I say. No idea what I’m wearing but I’ve got 4 hours and then some to figure it out. I wasn’t expecting to go over the cliff so I mayt have to run out for something. where’s my obama/biden 2008 t-shirt? Did I chuck it?
“sonofabitch at 7:20 est. Commence the NYE potables and we’ll have a “fuck that asshole” by 9.
A rueful smile.
Meanwhile, back on The Hill, from The Hill:
Clearly, the House GOP is concerned that Obama hasn’t negotiated hard enough with himself.
Teddy, great post, thanks. Tweeted. Recommended (FB).
I also heard Ezra speak more heresy, “in the foxhole, everyone’s a Keynsian.”
So for the first time in years, Ezra Klein is able to breath fresh air without using a Tomasky Snorkel.
Isn’t that both funny and sad? Obama surrenders and the House GOP thinks he hasn’t surrendered enough. Now we have to rely on teabagger intransigence to prevent a really bad deal from becoming law.
Just fiddledyfuck.
The fact that Klein fills in for Maddow is a little confusing.
*heh* All the while, the House Gooper Clown Car caroms about…! ;-)
Aloha, Teddy and pups…!
What a Clusterf*ck, thru-n-thru…! *gah*
I will wear my bathing suit – I hope the cliff has some extra melted Arctic water at the bottom.
Clusterf*ck is more like it, Peg…! ;-)
Seems as if I’ve made this observation a thousand times now, but what people need to realize is that Obama isn’t negotiating against Republicans so much as he is negotiating for Republicans. Obama fundamentally believes in tax cut trickle down economics, and fundamentally believes that holding onto Democratic/progressive gains of the past (like FDR’s New Deal/Social Security and Johnson’s Great Society/Medicare) prevent us from moving forward into his envisioned “glorious” free market future.
Digby at Hullabaloo had the Obama QotD on 12/30:
For folks that missed what it is Obama is actually saying, Digby translated to plain language:
My question for Obama: Why does “cutting programs that are really important to seniors, students” have to be “part of the mix”? Who says it does? The only reason I can see if because that’s what you want, and keep putting on the table since before your 2009 inauguration because you apparently believe in it.
As a Dem, Obama makes a great Republican. Support him? No way in hell.
Yep.
I’m quite surprised his handlers let him go THIS far, but it’s a buried item at the end of the year, despite the cliff’s significance.
Nice catch Teddy P.
I think me and mine are going over in sweats, sandals, warm socks and a crostini of smoked salmon spread with capers in one hand and a glass of Chateau St. Jean (WA) Reisling in the other.
Laffin at the tiara/boa and Kelly’s t shirt n kilt . . . also like the one who commented ‘in nothin’.
Dawg help seniors and those receiving unemployment as this sack of shit nation’s leaders and corporate whores continue to bury us before we’re dead.
Aside from the harsh reality so many face on the streets, broke in homes they are likely losing, sick and lacking healthacare . . . Happy Phreakin New Year’s pups.
May we hang together and trudge on.
Bless all y’all.
Alright, alright! Enough with the gay-insider-double-entendres.
I’m old. I’m straight. I’m un-hip.
You’re making me feel that I’m such an outsider that I might never find my way back to this place ;-)
maybe the village is gonna turn on 0bummer so that he gives away EVEN more! it kind of makes ‘sense’, when you think of it …
all the diaper pissing upper middle cla$$ … ha ha ha … ‘progressives’ who can AFFORD to call bullshit like AHIP-Care a compromise –
they’ll really rally around the latest cat food recommendation if they’re defending their hero!
I was 20 when Raygun was anointed – anyone remember the NYT & MSM bashing carter as weak over and over and over … ?? that incessant bullshit, with the popularity of crap like ‘Happy Daze’, and the staggeringly effective lies of Roger Ailes, no wonder that senile sack of shit won.
rmm.
I LIKE your sound . . . sounds like reality, not the smoke and mirrors kabuki that’s been so obviously revealed for decades now.
Keep banging that drum, please.
Retirin!
We’ll send out a search party for you, Rin5.
Btw, did the “five” ever arrive, or has it been pushed back?
I thought Business International was a front group for the CIA? Sorry if I’m sounding all ‘conspiracy theorist’ about stuff.
4:47 here, I’m ahead of yer schedule, sorry.
Fuck them assholes.
It arrived in ’10 Peterr, and thanks for asking. Obviously I need a new moniker. Retirement is….well, the hours are great but the pay sucks.
Glad you made it — I know far too many folks who were aiming at it, only to have to put off those great hours because of the financial hit they took in 08/09.
As for the moniker, I’d keep it if I were you. It lets folks who’ve been around a while recognize you, and to newcomers it’s a conversation piece.
*g*
*heh* Even the Nobel Peace Prize crew were fooled, don…! ;-)
Aint that the truth. lol. No one shapes up and plays company man better that Ed.
Yeah, you’re right. “Came for the Plame, stayed for the snark.” And then we kicked Lieberman’s butt. If tonight’s a night for reflection, then those events are prominent when I think about FDL. Go Jane! Go pups! (And “keep the faith!” — Adam Clayton Powell, ’65.)
me too
Unforced errors. This guy does it all the freaking time. What in heavens name would have happened if he let this go for a week? The house is not going to vote on it anyway.
My lord,it’s surely been five since we heard from you!
Are you retired now? How’ve you been?
This is what I don’t understand. Why didn’t he stay in Hawaii and let the Beltway Media blast him for vacationing in a ‘foreign’ place? I mean, what was the point of coming back early?
Congratulations.
When asked by disillusioned listeners why Obama has volunteered to cut Social Security, Shultz speculates that it’s to get a deal passed and, don’t worry, Obama will get rid of those cuts sometime in the future when we elect more Democrats.
The pure masochism of people who believe this gasbag.
Before the election an article in Atlantic suggested he of do nothing until the new year. Great advice.
I’m principally a lurker now, Teddy, and now retired some two years. (See No. 49 above.) Thanks for asking. We old-timers appreciate the recognition.
It sets up CIA front companies sometimes, most known for involvement in providing intelligence to corporate sector on labor unions. But it also has a financial services division which Obama – according his memoirs – worked in.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Business_International_Corporation#Barack_Obama
Thanks for de-lurking to say hello!
…”Came for the Plame, stayed for the snark.”…
*heh* Noobs…! ;-)
Hey — it’s the night to acknowledge old acquaintances from the past, no? So I offer up a toast (Seagram’s VO) and a toke (some very good herb that my neighbor got for me). Here’s to the FDL veterans — we’re too old to be considered Firepups.
About to head out to hang with friends and reminisce about a time when I had an actual tolerance for alcohol. But I’m stopping by to wish all my FDL friends a Happy New Year and Joyous Cliff Dive.
Interesting about Klein’s little moment of clarity. It’s at least a little encouraging when cracks, no matter how tiny, appear in the media edifice.
Encouraging too that after these last few years, the PTB still haven’t figured out how to get away with taking the axe to SS and Medicare.
This all probably strikes too inappropriately optimistic a tone, but what the hell, hope springs infernal.
Have a happy Happy, everyone.
*ding*
you too.
Well, ‘ding’ to you too Peterr, but I don’t have sufficient mental acuity (nor the ambition) to read through 189 responses from ’07. I got as far as number nine, though, and it sounds right — here’s to you, Peterr.
(8:00 p.m. CST): MSNBC announcing (via a “senior Dem source”) that a deal has been struck between Senate Democrats and Republicans. I figured Senate Democrats and Harry Reid would cave under pressure from the neo-liberals in the Obama administration. Gotta cut a deal, gotta cut a deal, can’t let all the Bush era tax cuts expire, can’t let the Bush era tax cuts expire…just like two years ago!!!
So, what happens next? House Republicans reportedly have gone home until next year, meaning that the Bush era tax cuts WILL expire at midnight due to House inaction (unless House Republicans “magically” reappear on Capitol Hill in the next hour or so). IOW, Senate Democrats will have given up their advantage by locking-in terms even as the Bush era tax cuts expire, leaving House Republicans with the advantage, because House Republicans on Wednesday will come up with their own plan, one with outrageous and demented cuts in spending and taxes, deficit-exploding budget-busting ones, which when taken to the conference committee between the Senate and House will end up being part of the final bill, screwing tens of millions of Americans while giving even more money away to the multi-billionaires. Or maybe I’m wrong? But this was one scenario I didn’t foresee, an end of year spanning move with the Senate first passing something in 2012 and the House passing a bill in response in 2013. IOW, if House Republicans really are gone for good, and the Bush era tax cuts WILL expire at midnight, then a Democrat in the Senate better put a hold on this legislative holiday turkey, because indications are that the Senate Democratic leadership (at President Obama’s urging) were willing to cede a whole lot to the Republicans just to get a deal done, no matter what. This “negotiated” Senate “last minute deal,” therefore, should be scrapped until both the Senate and House come back after New Years, with Democrats laying out what Harry Reid was supposed to do earlier today, introduce legislation just extending tax cuts for less than $250,000 and unemployment insurance for millions of Americans…and use reconciliation, if necessary, to pass it…maybe with a few more progressive ideas thrown in, daring House and Senate Republicans to hold tax cuts for under $250,000 hostage. Incredible, Democrats have done it again…if this Republican turkey legislation sees the light of day, tomorrow.
You’ll be glad to know that Obama scored a massive win by masterfully conceding that true wealth only begins at $400,000+ a year.
Warning: some comments at the following link is not suitable for the irony-impaired or those with heart conditions…
http://www.dailykos.com/story/2012/12/31/1175236/-A-Deal-has-been-reached-says-CNN-Biden-on-way-to-brief-Democratic-Senators-before-announcement
The House will vote tomorrow afternoon. they need their beauty rest.
At 10:10:17 I acquire a cat blanket…
They’re really useful at warming one’s feet on the couch ….
Hey,anybody still here? Retirin’inFive — great to see you! You’ve already been retired for two??? Seems like just the other day we were chatting about how it was still a few years off….
And you were planning to move down here to Texas, I think? So, did you? Are you close enough to Austin/San Antonio and environs to come to a meetup, should we manage to organize one? (See OverEasy in the mornings)
I’ve wondered about ya, and if you were somewhere nearby. Let us know; don’t be shy!
i’m here tj
Hey there, BfL. So, here we are on the computer at 10 pm NY Eve. Does this mean we have no life, or we are too mature to need to go out on NYE?
Just after midnite….my first EPU of the new year.
Happy New Year to any other stragglers!
Hey, SharonMI! Good to see you! Happy New Year back atcha! (not quite here yet where I am in Central time)
I’m so old I’m already sleepy….
NYE is for rookies. It’s best to walk in the shadows, tonite. Be safe.
How did you give up your right to complain by not voting for him?
Are you under the impression that you can complain only about the guy or gal you helped put in office?
That seems to me like a very odd notion.
If anyone gave up his or her right to complain about Oblahblah, I would think it would be the people who did vote for him.
Unless you are saying that you did not vote at all. In which case, I wish you had voted to his left.
As it turns out, his promise apparently was to raise taxes on the portion of income that exceeds $250K a year. Not a very meaningful amount in dollars and certainly not a return to Clinton era tax policy.
Then, a few weeks ago, while negotiating against himself, he put on the table both amounts over $400K (instead of $200K) AND a lower rate than the Clinton era rate.
So, apparently, Boehner gave him more than that.
Say it with me.
Fucking Third Way Trojan horse (with all due respect to “the office” occupied by Dimson and now by the guy to Dimson’s right),
Remember, all Dimson’s tax cuts would have expired December 31, 2010. However, with his Party still in control of both Houses of Congress and the Oval Office, Trojan extended all of them and now is extending most of them.
And please remind me what we got in exchange? One year of unemployment benefits each time. Wowza. And we still have not hit the real negotiation because the debt ceiling will expire again in two months.
As someone on MSNBC said, “No way a Republican President could cut welfare or ‘entitlements.’ It had to be a Democrat.”
Bingo.
Lesser of two evils, my ass.
Ummm, to stick it up our ass?`
The obvious question is, why did it take Ezra so long to figure out Obama could not be trusted? If FDL had a moral platform it would have used the Presidential campaign to strongly and regularly remind its visitors to the countless times Obama sold out its base during his 1st term. Let’s hold off rewarding Ezra for finding a backbone when there’s little personal cost. He’s doing what all cameleons do (including FDL), pretending he/she/it cares after she/he/it’s amply demonstrated he doesn’t.
Oil and gas companies, which are raking in record profits, certainly don’t need $4 billion a year in subsidies, and even the oil company CEOs admit they don’t need it!
Why are cuts to Social Security and Medicare even being discussed while literally billions in corporate welfare are constantly spilling out of the Treasury?
White House petition to end corporate welfare here: http://wh.gov/Qa6f