Complete and utter cowardice on display here from the marriage equality advocates among Big Gay Inc. First of all, Respect for Marriage Coalition chose war criminals, and Laura Bush, to demonstrate the broad acceptability of marriage equality in America.
Not a good idea to include war criminals, first of all. No one cares what Colin Powell and Dick Cheney think. They aren’t going to bring the majority of Americans in to the marriage equality mainstream; they are followers, not leaders. And they should be consulting with their war criminal defense attorneys, not being used to illustrate the broad acceptance of marriage equality in America.
But not getting the permission of the people whose images are used in the ad? Priceless.
The former first lady, along with Colin Powell, Dick Cheney and President Obama, was featured in a new commercial from the Respect for Marriage Coalition. The ad was supposed to run for weeks, but Bush asked to be removed, and the group quickly agreed: Instead of editing her out of the 30-second spot, which has aired on CNN and MSNBC, they’ll stop running it altogether after Friday, a coalition spokesperson told us.
Oh, did we tread on the former First Lady’s toes? Oh, pardon us, that must have offended AFER fundraisers like Ken Mehlman. Let’s drop the ad completely and pretend it never happened.
Courage. And while you’re at it, please leave the ad on the Respect for Marriage website, along with the press release announcing it, as if nothing has changed.
The right thing to do would have been to challenge the First Lady’s request to have her image removed: “Oh did you not mean you supported full legal equality and recognition for same-sex couples? Because that’s what it sounded like you said to Larry King. But maybe you could clarify your views for us, please?”
Instead, the entire ad campaign is dropped. Without any explanation, except to The Reliable Source at the Washington Post, as if it’s a gossip-columnist item. This ad was a serious stumble by a coalition of organizations dedicated to making marriage the central LGBT issue of our time: they spent donor money making the ad, and they haven’t accounted for their choice of “leaders” in it, or their decision to end the ad’s run.
If you’re going to pre-empt every other LGBT issue, as marriage has done to fair employment and housing laws, you need to tread carefully and act transparently. Time for some explanations from the Coalition, and its chairs, Freedom to Marry and the Human Rights Campaign.



24 Comments

Really a missed opportunity here to challenge the former First Lady: “So what DO you believe, then, if not what you told Larry King?”
Scaredy-pants.
craven, sadly.
Unbelieveable.
How odd. Hard to believe that they just dumped the ad. Not a good idea.
Hey, Teddy, fuck Laura Bush!
With all the free publicity the controversy generated, they may have seen this as an opportunity to save money for an entirely new ad.
Hate runs deep. OK they’re all for it, till they ain’t.
or, they may have gone to the Karl Rove school of political fleecing and money-grubbing….
Quite.
Isn’t is weird?
No, thank you.
Perhaps. There’s another ad coming, anyway:
LOL
I’m thinking they’re all for it while it’s politically expedient. Since Georgie will never work again, Laura is now free to be herself,.
And that’s not pretty,.,.,.
Having run down and killed an old boyfriend, I’d say Laura’s family-friendly bona fides are somewhat dubious.
Who really care what they think? How about we ask Charles Manson?
Yes, exactly.
Why put these suspicious killers in a Marriage Equality ad anyway?
I agree that Dick Cheney is a war criminal and therefore a very highly inappropriate choice. What really bothers me about using him or his daughter Mary as gay role models is that Mary defended herself in the narrowest way possible. She treated the whole issue as one of privacy, not one of rights. Basically, she climbed up the ladder and then pulled it up after her, leaving her fellow non-heterosexuals stranded.
Then again, with so many truly admirable women and men who do believe in equal rights, who actually gives a crap what a StepBushford wife thinks? Remember, her judgment was to marry Dimson.
That reminds me, call the nursery, order a laurel tree.
And lives in a state with no recognition of her relationship whatsoever, Virginia.
Cheers…who cares? And why?
When President Obama sent me an email asking for yet more money immediately after announcing his ‘evolution’ on ‘marriage equally’ (the money grubbers couldn’t wait a New York minute) all I wanted to know was, Why should I give him money for saying no more than Dick Cheney said eight years ago?
http://open.salon.com/blog/f_arouete/2012/05/11/obama_on_marriage_equality_eight_years_behind_dick_cheney
Also too, don’t mention November 6, 1963, when Laura Welch ran a stop sign, causing a fatal car accident that killed her “friend” in another car. The driver of the other car was reportedly a previous boyfriend, Michael Dutton Douglas. She was not charged in the mysterious incident, of course.