It had such a bright future.
It enjoyed luminous media coverage, from such equally luminous visionaries (or is it visionless luminaries?) as Tom Friedman, and news organizations like Nice Polite Republicans (NPR).
But in the end, Americans Elect – the supposed online “movement” toward a centrist third party – became exactly what it deserved to become, and, I contend, what its founders always meant for it to become: Dead.
Maybe it’s because the Democrats readily fill the need for a centrist party.
Maybe it’s because Nutty McNutt nuts like Ron Paul and Buddy Roemer were among those drawing most of what precious little interest AE’s “nominating process” was attracting.
Or maybe it’s because the shady organization refused to reveal its funders.
Of course, AE mentions none of this in its online death notice:
“Americans Elect, from the outset, has been a rules-based process…”
Yeah – so rules-based, the founders made damn sure it was set up to legally avoid fiscal disclosure.
As the autopsies roll in, what I find most striking is what’s not being said: That it is entirely possible – nay, likely – that AE was never intended by its founders as anything but Internet-enabled veal-penning.
Think about it. If you’re a one-percenter – say, a junk-bond financier bent on protecting your liveilhood, like AE founder Peter Ackerman – what better way to maintain the status quo than to get a few friends together and pitch $35 million into a carefully orchestrated strategy for doing so? In the grand scheme of things, isn’t that a small small price to pay in ensuring the happy continuance of politics as usual? Sure it is.
And guess what?
It worked.
Despite its claims that participation in its online “nominating process” never reached the thresholds AE established, the organization claims about 4 million Americans chimed in on their Web site in one way or another since its founding. Even if this number is inflated – and given this “rules-based” organization’s aversion to disclosure, it likely is – it was worth their funders’ investment.
AE’s “failure” after all, has surely convinced many who visited the site a year ago, at the height of its hype – brimming with enthusiasm and that four-letter word (hope) – that resistance to the corporate parties is just plain futile, darn it all!
How sad is that, in terms of Americans’ political intelligence?
Those who believed AE would even put forth a candidate in the first place apparently never considered that people with $35 million to pour into such a dog-and-pony show could also afford research and surveys. Research and surveys which were crucial in ensuring the organization set a participation threshold that could not be met – even if we leap off the cliff and believe the numbers AE reported were real.
So, where does AE go from here?
Who the hell cares?
What matters is whether the carp who took their bait have learned from the experience.
Learned what? you might ask.
It’s simple, really: The last thing America needs is more centrism. We are already, and quite literally, too centrist for our people’s own good.
As the Occupy movement shows, Americans are responding in greater and greater numbers to the plight of real people – a plight created almost entirely by venture capitalists and financial industry types like those who set up AE.
The notion that an electoral effort – let alone a self-described “centrist” one – created by the vulture class would have any positive impact for working people at all was laughable when AE’s media onslaught first hit.
It is – but for the early AE enthusiasts who are now even more hopeless about creating an alternative to our corporate UniParty – all the more laughable now.
The model we need to follow is easy enough to find: Canada’s NDP has shown us the way.
Yes, it’s a huge mountain to climb, and that runs strongly counter to our immediate-gratification mindset.
But if we refuse to follow the trail the NDP has blazed, we have only ourselves to blame.
Anthony Noel is facilitator of the New Progressive Alliance.



19 Comments

Great post. Good obituary.
Maybe they could still use the AE organization/mechanism to push the candidacy of Bloomberg – if he’s a funder of it.
Sounds to me like an opportunity for NPA to go completely transparent, above and beyond the rules to be, you know, completely transparent.
Unless of course, it doesn’t want to.
Because if you look, like any interested party might, you can find all this yourself from Der Google:
For instance perhaps AN could explain that searching OpenSecrets.org that Anthony Noel and Metallix Refining come up as the sole donors to the NPA, except for the “Aggregate Below Threshold” bit.
Which totalled is considerably less than the donations one sees on the OpenSecrets page at the provided link. Why is that?
And Metallix Refining? Decide for yourself.
The video is precious though, IMO
When earth extractionist enablers tell me they’re working for good? My inclination is to cry “Bullshit.”
Good job, BS detecting.
New Profit Alliance? More bullshit for the rubes?
[takei]Ohhhh myyyyyyyy![/takei]
Kind of explains a lot, it does.
OHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHHH MYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYYY More baseless – libelous? – attacks by the MyFDL Goon Squad.
Kelly does a good job of pretending he knows everything about disclosure. He doesn’t. Either that, or he prefers to manufacture falsehoods in an effort to keep this criminal president in office. Either way…
“Aggregate below threshold” is the IRS’s REQUIRED REPORTING DESIGNATION for donations from individual donors which do not meet the minimum for disclosing their identities. It is not the NPA’s choice, but the IRS’s RULES that we not disclose those donors’ names.
As for my donations, they are mine alone. My employer is Metallix Refining, the Industrial Division of which reclaims materials produced in the manufacture of everything from automobiles to medical devices, when those materials contain gold, silver, platinum, palladium, or rhodium. I am proud to be a buyer for this company which RECYCLES this material. We don’t mine virgin material. I spend most of my time traveling much of the US and Canada working with firms who use these elements in their processes.
Metallix has no involvement with the NPA, and again, this is totally clear from our reports – no matter how much Kelly may wish, or groundlessly claim – otherwise.
Centrist? Center of what? Issue by issue, the population is well to the left of center. So, when people speak of “the center,” they are not talking about the center of public opinion.
Maybe they’re talking about the center of the money. The center of the 1%, who have the money. Ya think?
We already have. Anybody can check our website at http://newprogs.org/ or the IRS website. It is easy to make up demonstrably false lies, but hard to understand why people do so.
You are questioning the good faith of Kelly Canfield and PhoenixWoman vis a vis third parties? Oh, my, where is my fainting couch?
Pretty shitty to attack someone’s livelihood; especially when there is no wrong-doing involved.
These attacks do tell us a lot about what has been going on here as far as silencing people through censorship, the bullying and intimidation— and now this kind of cheap crap… especially when the attacks are done by cowardly people using pseudonyms to hide their dirty work behind.
I wonder what this attack on Tony is going to do as far as ensuring open discussion, dialog and debate when it comes to people feeling free to express their views and opinions?
As for me, from now on anything written on FireDogLake by Kelly Canfield, Phoenix Woman or SouthernDragon gets flushed right down the crapper.
The Bullying Commenter strikes again!
Please join me in pointing it out every time he does it.
The Bullying Commenter strikes again!
Anthony, thank you for this Diary, and for bringing NPA to this community and this country. Good work.
The Annual Reports for 2010, 2011, and so far for 2012 are also on the website. God bless Anthony Noel for bringing into existence such an open, transparent, and noble organization. He is a true patriot!
Thanks Norman. (Actually, it’s the LYING commenter, and I’d ask him to apologize for his LIE, but having been down that road with him already I won’t waste my breath.)
Lying and Bullying both bad, and documented before. Interesting who he chooses to assail.
Ed (and normanb), your kind words are appreciated, but I didn’t bring NPA into existence – firepups did, right here, on this blog. And I think that very fact is what so rankles the Goon Squad.
But it’s all good. The Mahatma knew:
Given the attacks on NPA this week alone, we are close indeed to winning.
I know, right? :)
Right on, it’s the whole Overton Window thing. The Democrats used to at least get pulled through it by the Republicans. Now the Dems open the window FOR the GOP and guide THEM through – they even make sure they don’t bump their widda heads!