What I’ve learned about the occupation movement is that there are three groups of people:
One group is solely interested in occupying public space and making that public space a community within a community, regardless how organized or chaotic that community may appear to others. This is all they want to do: occupy public space. Occupying public space is critical because it’s a place where we can establish the commons and create a true democracy, and setup all the social systems needed to support a fully human society.
However, I’d say that we are operating on limited information. The people who are well informed about how to properly setup encampments aren’t helping us. They are leaving us to our own creativity and ignorance, which could be nonproductive. For the most part, we act and react on limited information.
Just imagine if technicians and social engineers came to our encampment at Military Park located in Newark, New Jersey (Occupy Newark) and taught us and participated with setting up a fully sustainable encampment with today’s knowledge. This would create a totally different environment. Then people who are well informed in social psychology and social management would teach us how environment shapes behavior and how to manage our resources. This too would create a different environment. If all of this would happen attitudes and this movement would change drastically. We would be able to evolve into a resource-based society where money isn’t needed for survival.
Dr. Wayne Dyer stated that “when you change the way you look at things, the things you look at will change.” I agree with him. Our society needs to undergo a serious rehabilitation. I see encampments as a way for people to remove the labels that have been placed on them by society and a means to become rehabilitated from our addiction with money and the negative effects of the monetary system. Andrew Lo, Professor and Director for MIT Laboratory for Financial Engineering, stated in the award winning documentary Inside Job directed by Charles Ferguson that “recently, neuroscientists have done experiments where they’ve taken individuals and put them into an MRI machine. And they have them play a game where the prize is money. And they noticed that when these subjects earn money, the part of the brain that gets stimulated is the same part that cocaine stimulates.” We are living in a sick society.
So encampments could be this rehabilitation process. It could be the start of a new society, a community within a community, a subculture that gradually becomes the dominant culture. But the people who are well informed are not working with us because they are working for the 1%, or should I say, enslaved by the 1%.
Then there’s the second group, people who respect the symbolism of occupying public space, but is more concerned with operating as a working group that bring awareness about our society and work collectively with others to create tangible solutions. This allows this group to meet and organize any and everywhere.
For instance, one solution that I’m developing with others is a global public school system that’s nonaffiliated with any political or religious organization: Alinkage Public School System (APS). Our goal is to update our education system with today’s knowledge. Albert Einstein stated that technology has far exceeded our humanity. For the most part, our education system is stuck in the Industrial Revolution. We have people living in space, but we still have billions of people living in poverty, millions dying unnecessarily from starvation.
Police officers are paid through the taxation of the working class, but they protect an establishment that doesn’t pay taxes. This is because they are simply instructed to follow orders. They aren’t trained to be think tanks. And just like most working people, they want to keep their job. Well, if APS has anything to do with it, all correctional officers and police officers will be sent back to school, free of charge, to learn more about social psychology and social management, so they can become think tanks. We would do the same with soldiers, who are simply designed to be killing machines.
The truth of the matter is as long as we continue to support this system it will continue to exist. We can complain about gas prices but as long as we are filling up our tanks nothing of any significance will change. The 1955 Montgomery Bus Boycott should’ve taught us that much.
Lastly, there’s a third group, the agitators who just want to stir things up, piss the 1% off, and show how ugly this system really is through civil disobedience. The people in this group are willing to give up their lives and freedom for this movement.
And we have to respect all three roles, but we also have to determine what is being effective and what isn’t, and how we can make them all more effective because each group compliments the other. Each group is needed.
This is the moment where we can create the “golden age” for all life on this planet. This is our opportunity to make the history books.
Let’s continue to lead the way……
Peace and Solidarity,



35 Comments

Been busy with family issues so I haven’t had a lot of time to participate in any conversations, but I had to sign in to recommend this
Nice points
Welcome tobiasfox. Keep posting, and let us know what’s happening with Occupy Newark.
Love this:
It is an amazing moment. And sorting out what is effective, and what isn’t, is going to be the big challenge.
Thanks so much for posting this. We are really looking forward to working with Occupy Newark. You are doing great work and it’s an honor to have you here on FDL.
Recommended & tweeted.
Tweeted: https://twitter.com/#!/janehamsher/status/154950325541945345
love the idea of encampments as part of the rehabilitation process. great post, keep them coming! rec’d & tweeted.
Great post, tobiasfox. You have done an amazing analysis of the Occupy movement as it exists today, while pointing out a way forward. A ‘three legged stool’, so to speak. Highly recommended.
Excellent post. Thank you.
Interesting little side note:
McPherson Park (home of the DC occupiers) is named after Union Army officer James McPherson, an ancestor of Newton Leroy McPherson who is better known to the nation as “Newt Gingrich”.
The descendant of James McPherson is going to have time on his hands soon. Maybe he and the Mrs. can pitch a tent in the park in honor of his ancestor.
That’s a very accurate breakdown of the three distinct groups associated with the movement. Spot on that As Eclair states, it is a three-legged stool and each group is essential.
Yeah maybe, I hear there are plenty of empty tents already there to choose from.
The empty tents are for guests from neighboring occupations in town to participate in actions. Until Newt and the Mrs. demonstrate their cred, they might have to provide their own canvas.
Excellent analysis. As a concrete example of:
“Just imagine if technicians and social engineers came to our encampment at…”
Starhawk, an activist with many years of experience in that kind of group process, did some traveling around in the fall and early winter, attempting to share some of that skill set and facility. From her blogposts at http://starhawksblog.org/?p=622 and similar posts. From the postings it sounds like that kind of work was fruitful…
Which explains why so many of the permanent protesters seem to be sleeping somewhere else at night.
There is and has been so much noise about the movement needing to form a cohesive demand, to coalesce around a specific set of goals, and agendas and a means through which to bring things about. Yet the beauty of the movement is this multi-layered, 3 pronged mix of the movement’s expression.
Thank you. I look forward to reading more from you, TobiasFox
Tobiasfox, I really appreciated your sociological analysis and hope you and others will expand upon the concepts introduced here. They are greatly needed by many people: those of us with intellectual curiosities who were once “trained” to think in typologies; those who want to support the evolutionary potentials of groups one and two; those of us who don’t identify with and/or are disgusted with the “anarchism” the third group represents, but which we need to understand and nevertheless affirm.
Thanks to John of Sacto above for his comments and for getting the FDL winter supplies delivered a few weeks ago to the group of 30 or so gathered at a planning meeting. Bless you John.
Thanks to Jane and Brian for your hard work in providing winter supplies and for the countless ways you’ve encouraged the Occupy movement over the months. Bless you and all others involved in that mission.
For many reasons I’ve not been able to be really involved with the OccupySacto group beyond being an intermittent observer. But I’ve
been fascinated by my very superficial periodic watching its evolution and seeming quasi disintegration over time. The social organization that evolved in the first 4-6 weeks was quite surprising and extraordinary. I know that the overnight occupation efforts ended some time ago with many arrests and city council confrontations, etc. There was a small group of Jewish folks who attempted to do an overnight sabbath occupation one weekend but were arrested when the curfew came.
I don’t know what the current numbers of committed folks are, but certainly far smaller than the large concentrations of all kinds of people in the early days when I would periodically mingle with the crowds on sunny afternoons, passing out brochures promoting California’s third attempt to get a single payer health care bill passed and signing up supporters for that cause.
A few weeks ago I participated in a march to the Cal AG’s building protesting the horrific bank foreclosure crisis in our region. We were some fifty at most in that leg of the event. I don’t know how many marched on to the major banks that had been “occupied” numerous times before, as that trek was beyond my physical capacity. It was interesting to note that the Sacramento Bee carried lengthy articles the following day reporting on AG Kamala Harris’ developing partnership with the (hispanic, I think) Nevada woman AG pursuing in depth investigations of both the region’s moderate-sized servers’ and the big banks’involvement in the seemingly endless fraudulent foreclosure proceedings. Sacramento area foreclosures were at 80K some months ago, with tens of thousands more waiting to be fully implemented in the coming months.
Because of the bank’s failure to really cooperate in the state programs’ use of $2B funds for alternatives, there are some state/regional housing agency remedies being considered that have great promise. I hope to be able to write about these at some time in the future. But if there are any Illinois housing activist folks among the FDL family, I hope they’ll do some research on a proposal being developed there and write about the program design and political processes underway. That model may or may not become implemented here in California, as our CA decision makers are reticent to approach it seriously unless and until the Illinois
proposal proves viable and successful. My superficial reading of the proposal concludes it has much promise.
Yesterday’s Sacramento Bee carried an article on an interview with “Brother Carter” who had led the above mentioned march. He is a very spirited, but serious black man whom I understand is a paid SEIU (?) organizer. He was reflecting on the group’s uncertain future as it looks at alternatives ranging from direct engagement with specific issuea in demonstration actions (such as the above)or occupying a foreclosed home, etc., to involvement in the upcoming electoral political process. I’m hoping to talk with him and others in the continuing group in the near future to learn more in relation to my own personal involvements in housing and health care
remedy optons. I’m also hoping we can get him to speak to my church’s Forum group as part of our congregational education process to support our own community organizing efforts on the housing issues.
As always, I praise God for FDL and thank Him for his blessings on the community that identifies with FDL’s multiple missions….
Recommended.
Good diary, Tobias. I’m interested in the Alinkage Public School System concept, if not global, at least here to start.
The idea I’d gotten was that the various Occupies were actually finding ways to accommodate all three groups, but that’s just from reading, not being on the ground.
Some group has put together an Occupy organization so that they can facilitate phone link-ups among groups nationwide. But damned if I could find it to drop in a link here, or remember who spotlighted it.
Awesome post. Solidarity from South Jersey!
Yeah. Upon further reflection, I’m going to go with ‘the professionals don’t always have the best ideas’. They often operate within the theoretical, like architects designing buildings that builders…can’t build.
Just a thought; the ‘employed by the 1%’ folks may not be the true architects of a wholly different kind of social movement.
Thanks so much. I appreicate the love
So true. Thanks so much for weighing in.
Thanks for the kind words. I agree, we can definitely begin Alinkage Public School (APS) here. Please check out the following links below and let me know what you think. I welcome the support.
Tobias A. Fox
Alinkage Public School, A Holistic Approach to Learning
https://sites.google.com/site/alinkagepublicschool/
http://www.facebook.com/apsglobal
http://www.twitter.com/alinkageschool
“In order to change an existing paradigm you do not struggle and try to change the problematic model. You create a new model and make the old one obsolete. That, in essence, is the higher service to which we are all being called.” —Buckminster Fuller
“The paradox of education is precisely this: that as one begins to become conscious, one begins to examine the society in which he is being educated.”
—James A. Baldwin
Wow! Thanks so much for this comment. You definitely shared a lot. Food for thought for sure!
Thanks so much for your kind words. Let’s continue to move onward and upward….
Peace and solidarity
Wow! Beautiful! I have to check out her blog. Thanks so much.
So true! Couldn’t have said it better myself
Thanks for the kind words.
You’re quite welcome. Thanks for the comment.
Much love appreciated and returned. A three legged stool for sure!
Thanks for the kind words. I will definitely share more of my experience. Onwward and upward….
It is a challenge we accept with open arms.
We are looking forward to working with you, FDL, and all occupations as well.
Thanks so much for your kind words.
I most certainly will!
LOL Thank you kindly!
Onward and upward….
How big do the GA assemblies get in Newark? Also, has Occupy Newark and People’s Organization for Progress done any actions, together? POP expressed solidarity with OWS, but their proximity suggests joint actions should be doable.
I wonder, too, if Occupy Newark has attempted any form of reciprocity for their warm welcome by mayor Cory Booker and 2-3 of the Newark City Council? I was in Manhattan, yesterday, and the “crowd” inside Zuccotti Park was down to about 5 people. Yes, you read that right. I remember after my first visit to Zuccotti, on the PATH train home, speaking to an idealistic young supporter, but thinking to myself, “You have no idea how fragile their presence is.” I did tell him that, while Bloomberg was horrible in the treatment of protesters who protested the Republican National Convention, he really wasn’t too bad wrt OWS. (This was well before he threw them out of there.)
Supporting non-partisan efforts of the Newark government would be a good way to show reciprocity. E.g., when Booker spoke to Occupy Newark, he mentioned that mentoring programs are very effective, but under-manned. It wouldn’t kill Occupy Newark to spend an afternoon, here or there, pamphleting Newark to ask for volunteers for the mentoring program. Reciprocity is a human norm.
BTW, I’m working on a program to facilitate legal, but ubiquitous, public ‘marches’. Part of the idea is to make it easy for disparate groups to converge in a public area (e.g., an Occupy location). I will present first to POP, and then Occupy Newark, for beta testing.
Occupy Newark is in Solidarity with POP. We’ve participated in rallies organized by POP. We are a small but growing occupation. The size of our GAs are usually about 30 people. However, there is a group of occupiers (the second group mentioned in the above article) that meet away from the encampment to discuss and move on various social issues.
Mayor Booker has expressed his warm welcome and visited our encampment but it was the city council who has allowed us to become an overnight encampment. To learn more about Occupy Newark you can visit our encampment at Military Park located at 93 Park Place, Newark, NJ or visit our website http://www.occupynewark.org.
We have a list of events planned for 2012.