There is a lot of discussion these days about ‘buying local’. There is even a national organization with chapters which promotes it (along with a lot of other local initiatives) Local Economies . American Express just sponsored, for the second year, a national event called “Small Business Saturday” to encourage people to buy with small businesses (not only local; and as an incentive, they offered a credit off the customer’s bill for buying at a small business).
But, when it comes time for us, as consumers, to actually find local businesses, it might not be so easy. Up through the 1970s, most cities of any size had a ‘downtown’, which was usually filled with small, locally-owned businesses. If you wanted something else, or bigger names, or certain products, you traveled elsewhere. When I was growing up, anyone who wanted something other than what was on offer in our little stores and the locally-owned department store (which, looking back, was actually quite wonderful and carried everything from china and glassware in the basement to ladies hats, fabrics and patterns, clothing from infant sizes on up, and they even had a formidable lady in a black dress with a measuring tape around her neck who would take you discretely into the dressing room and measure you up to fit you for brassieres) drove to the next biggest city, about 30 miles away, that had at least 3 much larger, locally owned department stores plus hundreds of other smaller shops in THEIR downtown.
And then came malls. And national chains. And everyone thought that going out to the mall to shop was a big deal and the prices were ‘so much better’. And downtowns in most places just crashed, though some places managed to maintain a kernal of a downtown (especially if there were commercial businesses with employees who needed a drugstore, dry cleaners, banks, restaurants and so on for the lunch hour) and in some places, those small hubs have acted as the ‘tent poles’ for other small businesses which have sheltered next to them. And sometimes those small businesses form organizations and do events and programming to get people to come downtown on a regular basis in the hope that once people re-discover what is actually downtown, they just might find that shopping in those small places is actually more interesting than going to the mall.
(Public admission here: Aunt Toby HATES to shop at malls; with the consolidation in the retail industry, every department store seems to carry exactly the same brands and lines within the brands. The merchandise seems, to my eye, to be universally tatty and no one bothers to have enough help in the stores or to train the help in the stores. No one working the floor knows what they have or don’t have; I’ve always felt that the question posed at the cashier’s desk, “Has anyone helped you today?” is an attempt at irony)
But, when you want to ‘go local’, how do you find local shops, stores and businesses? I realize this sounds like what my kids used to refer to as ‘a no duh’ but think about it. With the fracturing of retail and the evisceration of downtowns, how do we find local stores and shops?
Easy methods:
Always start with what you know. If you have one of the ‘shop local’ organizations, check their website. They will have a listing of their members and use that as your foundation. Unfortunately, not everyone will be a member. How do you find the rest?
If you do have shopping districts in your area, drive there and walk around. Take friends and family with you to break up the job. If you really want to perform a public service, take a big pad of paper and write the businesses’ names, what you see in the windows and the address down. If you feel like a creative type, make a diagram like the one below and fill it in. And, don’t forget to look above the first floor – who knows what little atelier or office is upstairs.
More Work
But that’s not all. You know and I know that there are a lot of people who have businesses that they operate out of their homes and farms. To find those folks, you will need to do more digging. If you have a farmers market (and many are now year round or do special holiday ‘winter markets’), visit the market or find the market contact info and ask the market manager. If you are able to visit the market, ask the people AT the market; explain that you are collecting information and anyone you can find who has a little business, makes things for sale and so on. I can tell you from my experience at our local farmers market that for every vendor who is actually there, there are at least 3 more who viewed themselves as too small to take a booth. If you can find those people, your list will get larger and larger.
Another source of small local businesses is to ask co-workers and friends. “Do you know anyone who is doing a little business at home? Do you know anyone who makes children’s wooden toys? Do you know anyone who is making dolls? Do you know anyone who does ceramics and sells? Do you know anyone who does custom clothing or underwear? Anyone who does specialty clothing for people with special needs? Is there anyone you know with an interesting hobby?” The list of items grows and grows. We have a museum locally which has a lovely shop. That’s a local business. That museum also has a ceramics studio and the people who take classes there and use the facility also hold a big sale several times a year; THAT’s a small local business too.
One of the sad reasons why people shop at malls is that they know that shopping is there. One of the really sad reasons why people do NOT shop locally is that they don’t know what is out there or where it is. If you go through this process, you will have a terrific idea of what is happening in your community and who is doing what. So, what do you do with THIS info? First thing I’d do is contact the local ‘buy local’ organization and ask if they want to publish your list. They might – or they might just want to use it to try to get the businesses to join their organization. All well and good. But one thing you CAN do with it, to be frank, is to make a Facebook page with it and call the page something truly obvious, like “(Your town or county name) local businesses” so that if someone searches on the internet for just that thing, they will be alerted to it.
Yes, this is work; I have to admit that. Getting out and driving and walking around, writing down names, asking people for information is a big job. I’m sure there are some readers who are saying to themselves, “This is the job of the local economic development people (or, the downtown business development association, or whatever group you’ve got if you’ve got one); why should we, as community people volunteer our time to perform what is basically a marketing and advertising function?” Let’s put it this way: We will never be able to break the cycle of ‘autopilot shopping at the mall or ‘big box store’/never go downtown or to a small business’ if we don’t get information out there to let people know that there really are alternatives. It’s a really good deed that you can do for your community. There are literally thousands of small towns and cities in this country which, through the ‘Wal-martization’ of America have lost their entire business district. In some places, the loss of just one core store, such as a department store or the town grocery store has led to the death of the entire downtown, which led to people doing all of their shopping far away, which led to the spiritual death of the entire community. Having a core of small, locally-owned businesses if important to our communities and we need to nurture them.
But we can’t help if we don’t know what’s out there.
(photo of downtown Madison, Wisconsin by Jeffmarks.net)



48 Comments

I live near a rural community and do try to shop in local businesses. I much prefer the local pharmacist because I feel comfortable asking questions. The local hardware stores are mostly where we go for those products. Prices may or may not be comparable with the big box stores, but they are 50 miles away and fuel is expensive.
Probably because many in our area do not have internet access, local businesses do not do a good job ensuring someone looking on a Google map finds them. Most new people to the area are comfortable with using Google to find products and if they aren’t listed they might not find them. I just went through and submitted changes to many marked locations in my community as Google is more often wrong as to the specific location than right. I was surprised to how many missed listing their business on Google maps.
Just like Buy American, shopping locally is key to turning our economy around.
Nice work, and I did make the effort to shop at a local small green market yesterday, as a result having lovely sprouted wheat bagel for breakfast. I have noticed that the advertising paper coming into my mailbox does often have a ‘locally owned’ notation on ads there.
Ruth – over the past year, I have noticed several stories – one literally just last week which got a lot of play on tv as well as in the NY Times about the community of Saranac Lake, NY (which is way up there in the Adirondacks and is an hour from practically anything)getting together and over a period of 5 years, sold enough stock to NY residents to raise the $500,000 required to open their own community department store. They’d lost their only department store in 2002 but managed to fight off an effort by WalMart to put in a huge superstore in their area – but they still were in the position of having to drive for an hour (in good weather) up to another city to be able to buy underwear. Another story I read detailed several small towns in the upper Midwest where they’d lost their grocery store, which turned into this downward spiral of ‘people shopping elsewhere for groceries and then finding it convenient to shop for other things on the same trip…which hurt the stores that were left, which basically turned the town into a ghost town’. In one, a high school kid literally put his savings together just to reopen a little grocery store, which stemmed the tide and saved the rest of the much larger stores in town. He’s getting a lot of volunteer help from members of the community. When you lose your core of small local businesses, activity in the town starts to grind to a halt, people start to move, and it makes a lot of things very easy for other people to make decisions – like consolidating your school district away, closing churches and government offices and so on. Small businesses help to keep small communities alive.
I hate malls and chains. Always have, always will. Give me a small business anytime.
OT: Yesterday, Toby, nice job on the book thread. Thanks.
We also have a good sort of Neighborhood paper, monthly, that gives a lot of updated info about products, comings, & goings.
I am also interested in what seems to be getting notice that people really are doing less shopping. Certainly I know that about myself and some others as well (Of course, not everyone)
Would be great to get a national “buy local” day along the lines of “move your money”.
I always patronize a local pharmacist. I know Ace hardware is a national franchise, but the local Ace hardware has had the same family working in and running the store for decades. Best service in the world too.
If I go to a big box hardware store, there’s no help with anything and I end up leaving with a headache from roaming the flourescent-lit, airport terminal size building looking for a door hinge.
Several small towns here in Iowa have gotten the community together to open up–or keep open–the town’s only grocery store. I’m talking about towns of 500-1000 population.
What is the best computer to buy as far as if not buying local buying from workers paid a fair wage?
Bev – people really ARE doing less shopping and it’s not just the economy. I hear from co-workers all the time about how they can’t find something they really need, the quality is crappy, everything is boring and so on. So, they aren’t bothering. My husband, for example, looked for several months in every store with men’s clothing between us and 60 miles away for (ready for this?) a plain grey flannel sport coat. Such a difficult thing – so trendy and odd! I end up making my own clothing because I can NEVER find what I need or it’s in a size that doesn’t fit me, or it’s crap fabric or made in a tatty way.
TCU – try here: http://www.computersmadeinusa.com/
Also – another idea — in my town, there is a computer repair group (a bunch of very funky buys) who will also build you a computer from the ground up and I hear it’s competitive in price, too. You might want to check on that in your area.
Great idea, and here something of that sort happened when a community faced with the closing of its local supermarket bought or rented the store site and opened up a one-of-a-kind market all its own.
How about buying used or “reconditions & upgraded” from a local service person? Last year, my computer was getting hinky so I found a local service person and hauled the computer in. He told me he would run ‘diagnostics’ and give me a call. Shortly, he told me that for the cost of a memory chip and some clean-up work, the old one would give me another year or so of service OR he could build me one, to my specs, at a price comparable to a new one (or less). Since I positively hate change (even so much as a new mouse), I opted for repair and upgrade. It’s served me well, now, for more than a year. When (not if) my computer dies, you can bet I’ll go back to see him–he actually LISTENED to me. (And when he offered to return to old, but still functioning parts to me, he said if I didn’t want them, he uses them to build and donate computers for the local schools and/or rec areas.)
toby, tweeted. Thanks.
What a great idea. You’ve inspired me. I live in a small town in California (85K). There are a few small businesses left in our downtown area but mostly everyone shops at the big box stores. I’m going to give this a shot.
But, when it comes time for us, as consumers, to actually find local businesses, it might not be so easy. Up through the 1970s, most cities of any size had a ‘downtown’, which was usually filled with small, locally-owned businesses. If you wanted something else, or bigger names, or certain products, you traveled elsewhere.
Try your buy local game in the inner city not many farmers markets also since there are not many Wallmarts, Jewel big chain stores etc you get more local stores but the only stores (small ones) in walking distance don’t have many veggies and fruit they often have them at higher markups which reduces purchase power unless of course you want to take a bus but how many grocery bags does anyone want to take on a bus?
How many people want to take a bus because they run out of one thing and decide to pay more at a local store?
Are food stamps designed for the higher prices people pay in local inner city stores?
How about rural areas where everyone has a truck or SUV because of the snow there are no busses there and stores might be 10, 20 miles away and the more rural you get the less chance you have a big store nearby so you again face higher markups and maybe buy a can of soup at a gas station at a higher markup?
I’m not challenging you Toby just asking questions about how food stamps are calculated of course cheaper gas in some states like Texas would lower the need for food stamps.
Assuming you can drive poor people lose their license more than rich people in the city you can take a bus in rural areas you need friends to give you a ride or you walk that also limits your ability to go to town and get the cheapest available food.
OMG – I’ve been tweeted. I’m a new woman!!! This has never happened to me before. Thank you!!
hahahaha. 85,000 people is a ‘small town’? OMG. I grew up in a county that had all of 28,000 in the entire county. With 85,000 people in the town, you’ve got a great population to get going on local businesses. Off you go!!
TCU – I don’t think anyone at the food stamp program ever figured in the cost of travel for the folks who actually use them.
Thanks:) Bookmarking this
Great idea now I just need a job:) thanks
That sounds like a great second diary topic:) I know a person they can see enough to work but not see well enough to drive her friends either drive her or she walks she gets stuck with the higher prices too even though she does not get food stamps. What other groups besides her and people without a license are also stuck paying higher prices and how big is this group?
I strongly support these efforts and have for years tried to follow a policy of buying local and small, willing to take some hit financially. The one thing Wall Street listens to is money and it doesn’t take that much to make them listen. I would love to see the public go on strike against the big chains and multinationals. They are the ones who have destroyed the local economies. Let them pack it in and do something useful with their wealth and power. Looks like US Imperialism is a good investment.. Buy some drones.
That said I find the White House messaging buy small and local, the height of hypocrisy even for this president.
One of the problems about buying local for us organic vegans is that not all locals farm organically.
Also time how many people maybe on food stamps but have kids maybe they got a job but have kids got a job and don’t have the time, knowledge and or skill to eat healthy?
How many think they eat healthy by eating at Subway for example or think campbells veggie soup is healthy? I know finding those numbers would be hard the GOP would say they are making a free choice and assume they don’t care about health but if you are to busy to make a healthy meal, don’t know how, think you know but you don’t can you really be said to have a choice?
I worked on a farm that claimed to use minimal chemicals last year Nipsip after the rain heck during the rain ( a little rain never stops an ex Seattle person) I never saw a worm in the soil.
I never saw a chimpmunk eat the tomato or a bug even after I left the bad tomatoes on the ground for 3 days. A bad tomato might just have a split skin its still edible but you can’t sell it at stores but the farmer had a local farmstand and people thought it was healthier.
The cult classic Night Of The Living Dead was filmed at the Monroeville Mall (near Pgh PA), built in 1968-69, which I worked at doing general construction in the summer while in grad school and made a ton of very useful $$. It opened in 1969, and I worked part-time there in a ‘better’ men’s clothing store, which had expanded from one downtown store in the 1950′s to a second urban neighborhood store, and by the 1970′s also had three stores in different malls. That’s the way the malls began, as conveniences to distant suburbs by extending the downtown and urban retail stores, including the department stores that anchored the malls. By the end of the 1980′s, most of those ‘local’ stores failed, being over-extended, unable to recover from the 1987 crash, and unable to compete with the national chains, which had become part of multinational corps. Malls (thanks to cable TV becoming national after Super Stations in the mid-1970′s) had discovered the economic benefits of offering the same stores everywhere with essentially the same merchandise. Hence, retail hegemony.
As the local though expanded stores disappeared, so did the huge revenues that malls generated. Instead of the money being recirculated at or near the POS, it left the area electronically, as customers swiped their credit cards, the transactions winding up in NYC, London, or Hong Kong by morning. Dribbling returns went to store ‘managers’ and a few associates. Probably the ‘housing bubble’ extended the illusory growth during the later 1990′s and early 2000′s. But here we are, complicit in our own victimization.
I remember trying to buy or order two recently published books. No chain bookstore had them, nor would they order them b/c their distributer didn’t list the titles (on their microfiche). I went to my neighborhood independent book store, but it wouldn’t order them either. Its microfiche list was identical to the chains. The owner wouldn’t order directly from the publisher. Independent retail, but dependent and wholly-owned wholesale. Anyway, a personal friend was the ‘manager’ at the mall’s B. Dalton, she risked being fired by ordering the books from the publisher, which were left for me at the desk as a special order.
Be grateful for local radio and pizza.
So often you see people using food stamps that are buying junk. A friend helps at a local food bank and is amazed when they can’t give away quality artisan bread and can barely give away whole wheat bread, because the folks coming for free food only want white bread.
Now, that isn’t everybody. I will always remember being at the local grocery store. The clerk was ringing each item up slowly. She and the customer were looking at the total each time and then doing the next item. There was no junk food in her selection. I planned on covering anything that she couldn’t afford, but she was a few pennies under. It looked like a church food voucher. I was impressed with her shopping skills and thankful that was not me. I didn’t mind waiting.
It’s hard to buy locally if you don’t produce locally, and that’s as true of manufactured goods as it is of food. There’s a lot of people out work, and Christmakwanzukkah coming up. So, maybe this year, we go back to where we were in grade school: make presents, sell them to each other, then give them to our loved ones? There are worse models for an economy. Like, um, the one we have now. :-)
Pineywoodsfats, I agree. We should push:
Buy local
Buy Union
Buy American
Move your money.
If your raised on junk you want to buy junk maybe a free taste should be offered? Schools should teach healthy eating more. An is your kitchen healthy thing where kids list the foods they eat all week and then report it to the teacher and then compare it to to what they should eat would be a great homework assignment.
This bread thing must have something to do with habit. I leave in a neighborhood with at least five first-class bakeries within a ten minute walking radius. Several themn are better (IMO) than the best in Paris. Yet I see people buying the local equivalent of wonderbread all the time in the supermarket. I wouldn’t feed that stuff to my dog (if I had one). I think a lot of people are afraid of bread that has a crust.
My home town (Bremerton WA) was destroyed by malls. Literally destroyed. The downtown simply evaporated, and hasn’t come back. It was always a small downtown, but it had a Penny’s, three cinemas (four at one time), a music store, a couple of pharmacies, a Woolworth’s and the usual array of haberdasheries,shoe stores, and professional offices. It seemed like a lot at the time. No more.
Yesterday I went to an upscale urban mall — for the first time in months. We had to get photos made for our Russian visas. Almost every store there now is a chain. It was depressing, not to mention the stock, which was also depressing, though I’m getting to old now to buy new things. It’s easier to take the old stuff to our dressmaker and have them brought up to date.
Big Thanksgiving thank you to Aunt Toby for saying out loud that she hates shopping in malls. I do, too. It’s an alienating experience. It’s emotionally and spiritually enervating. And besides, I really don’t like it.
On rare occasions, I do go into a mall. That happens when I cannot think of any way around it. When I leave, I feel somehow manipulated, used, condescended to and trashed. Sorta like I feel after listening to a political speech.
Maybe there’s a connection.
Many of us at FDL do look for local sources for most things, and I had always considered it the natural and responsible thing to do. Got into a conversation with an ex-pat Texan who now lives in NY city, on my trip, and was surprised to find that he had no idea anyone at all does that. This was not an ignorant person, either. We probably need a higher profile, and more like Toby’s post.
You probably already know this, but just google “food deserts” for info on the lack of decent groceries in some urban areas.
This might be an urban myth, but at some point I read that the city of Detroit had no major supermarkets within the city limits–primarily just local corner groceries which carried junk.
Just beyond those suburban malls of the 1960′s and 1970′s were the coal mining towns, steel mill towns, farms and ranches. Many first-generation Americans of immigrants who owed their souls to the company store lived and worked in those towns. If they ‘shopped’, they went to a general store for dry goods and food supplies, and made whatever they wore and ate. Or they ordered from a Sears or Montgomery Ward catalogue.
The malls changed their lives. People with few teeth and less learning could go out in public where they would be anonymous, and where their cash was welcome. They didn’t have to know the complexities of urban life, charge accounts, and parallel parking. They could be entertained by professional show-biz people for free (I saw Buffalo Bob Smith in his buckskins talking about his Howdy Doody days at the mall). Their children could work there and attend the local community college (which got chartered and built at the same time, and to accommodate the same demographic).
It was wonderful while it lasted. Sic transit gloria malls.
Twitter is the bomb. @JaneHamsher doesn’t tweet as much as she used to, but she’s still a “must follow.” @emptywheel‘s tweets are “to die for.” @michaelpollan @marionnestle are both excellent.
Toby, icymi above, “Twitter is the bomb. @JaneHamsher doesn’t tweet as much as she used to, but she’s still a “must follow.” @emptywheel‘s tweets are “to die for.” @michaelpollan @marionnestle are both excellent……….”
Hey, Aunt Toby. Reccd. I often see you on the same FB Made in USA pages I frequent. Always a pleasure. One of the charms I discovered there – http://www.fractiles.com/ Made in Boulder, Colorado. Reminds me of the Spirograph I had when I was a kid.
Lovely job, Aunt Toby! I love buying local and am so lucky to do so in two blocks from my front door. Among all listed above, except a bakery, we have so many small merchants to choose from including a hardware store, bookstore and even a toy store! http://bigfunbigfun.com/
This might be an urban myth, but at some point I read that the city of Detroit had no major supermarkets within the city limits–
I think it is a semi-myth as far as the present day goes, but the city is considered greatly underserved by food and other primary retail sellers. On the “no major retail” point, seems possible that the story spread out from reports back in 2007 or so when A&P, those old friends of the worker, pulled its last two stores out of Detroit. Those stores were taken over by a local grocer (Mike’s, who I think is operating there still), so the immediate loss to the city as a whole was minimal. Here is a 2009 version of the same story, with little actual new information.
While tracking down a particular, much-cited 2003 UofM study on Detroit’s grocery retail scene I happened on this apparently well-maintained summary at wikipedia. And strong exception to the “no stores” story is taken in this blog article.
I generally either walk around downtown or neighborhood commercial streets (which is easy because I live in the city and have no car). My big resource, which works in most places is http://www.yelp.com.
People review everything and the bias is definitely toward local small business (it’s a cultural thing on there that discovering a new local place makes you cool and writing the 100th review for a chain makes you dull).
Add the word “owner” to your search and it’ll usually tell you not only if the owner is onsite, but if he/she is a nice person.
Also, write a review of your favorite small businesses while you are there. If the owner hasn’t created a Google location yet, this will help make sure it comes up.
Another way to buy local (and often organic)is to take advantage of CSAs. Right now it’s planning season for next year for most of them, so there are big discounts for early sign-up.
I like how it forces me to try new things and eat enough veggies before they go bad. It’s kinda like gardening. I use http://www.localharvest.org/ to find them near me. If there isn’t currently delivery in your area, but you are able to get enough critical mass among friends and neighbors to participate, you generally get a discount for being a new dropoff point. As a single person, I generally get the every other week deal, because there’s no way I could eat an entire bushel of veggies every week.
Many big cities also have provisions for community gardening within their park districts. It isn’t really shopping local, but it’s eating local and it’s a great way for cities to reclaim abandoned land. Because of this, many of these urban agriculture centers are located in the middle of food deserts (this does make them harder to find though). I remember hearing about one where all the workers were ex-cons, the homeless and others facing employment challenges. So it’s good in more than one way. Also, the guy who was the speaker at the event I went to was extraordinarily good looking, though he will try to evangelize you into composting in your apartment which is a wee bit more than I think I can handle.
Oh, the urban garden in Chicago which has the CSAs and hires the transitional workers is http://www.growinghomeinc.org/ I’m sure they’d be thrilled to advise how to set up one in your hometown.
This is the page for the “shop local challenge”. It’s been very helpful for me and the comments pages are full of good stuff.
Also, consider resale stores and Craigslist for used stuff. As my niece says, “when someone else wears the clothes first, it washes the taint of slavery off.”
Geez: http://communityblog.yelp.com/2011/11/ready-for-a-challenge-take-the-yelp-shops-local-30-day-challenge-.html
One other suggestion is that local charities often do silent auctions to raise money. The goods and services are generally donated by local businesses to build awareness, and the purchase is tax deductible.
Museum, zoo, symphony, and theater memberships or tickets also make nice gifts that support your local community. Support live theater!