The Washington Examiner is reporting that Judge Russell Canan of the D.C. Superior Court has dropped all charges against 27 (some reports say 24) defendants arrested at the U.S. Capitol on January 21 in a demonstration called by Witness Against Torture. The protesters were demonstrating peacefully on the steps of the Capitol, dressed as Guantanamo prisoners in orange jump suits, and with banners reading “Broken Promises, Broken Laws, Broken Lives,” calling for President Barack Obama to shut down Guantanamo prison. Police say they refused to disperse as ordered.
Inside the Capitol Rotunda, at the location where deceased presidents lie in state, fourteen activists were arrested performing a memorial service for three men who died at Guantanamo in 2006. Initially reported as suicides, the deaths may have been — as recent evidence suggests — the result of the men being tortured to death (see Scott Horton, “Murders at Guantanamo, March 2010, Harpers).
One of the protesters was contacted by cell phone after the judgment for acquittal, according to a story at MassLive.com:
[Patricia] Wieland, contacted by cell phone outside the court house, called the ruling a major victory because it upheld the First Amendment, namely the protections for freedom of speech and freedom of peaceful assembly.
“We did exactly what the First Amendment tells us to do,” she said. “We actually exercised the First Amendment and won.”
SCOTUS Stiffs Arar Complaint, While RCMP Investigating U.S./Syrian Officials in Arar Rendition
According to a press release by Center for Constitutional Rights (CCR), the U.S. Supreme Court "decided today not to hear the [CCR] case on behalf of Canadian citizen Maher Arar against U.S. officials for their role in sending him to Syria to be tortured. I discussed last November the en banc decision by the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit, where the court made it clear that victims of extraordinary rendition, i.e., kidnapping and being sent to be tortured, as Arar was, right from JFK Airport in New York City. (File this in the "it could be you" department.)
Glenn Greenwald castigated the Supreme Court’s decision in his column today, "The U.S. wins the right to abduct innocent people with impunity":
The Canadians, who cooperated with the U.S. in Arar’s abduction, conducted a sweeping investigation of what happened, and then publicly "issued a scathing report that faulted Canada and the United States for his deportation four years ago to Syria, where he was imprisoned and tortured," and made clear he had done absolutely nothing wrong. Then, Canada’s Prime Minister personally and publicly apologized to Arar, and announced that Canada would compensate him with a payment of $ 8.5 million.
But what has the U.S. done. Nada. Zilch. Nothing. Really worse than nothing, as the Obama administration actively sought to prevent Arar’s suit, including filing a brief arguing against the Supreme Court taking up the Second Circuit ruling. Furthermore, the U.S. has refused to allow Arar into the United States, even though it admits he never did anything wrong. The only reason for this is to keep his story from being heard.
Meanwhile, according to CCR, the Royal Canadian Mounted Police are investigating U.S. officials involved in the rendition of Mr. Arar.
According to Mr. Arar and his attorneys, the Royal Canadian Mounted Police (RCMP) has been conducting a criminal investigation into U.S. as well as Syrian officials for their role in his rendition to torture.
To their knowledge, this is the first time the existence of the RCMP’s criminal investigation of U.S officials has been made public. Mr. Arar has met with the RCMP in conjunction with the investigation.
Said CCR Senior Attorney Maria LaHood, “The U.S. should be conducting its own criminal investigation of the officials responsible for sending an innocent man to Syria for a year to be interrogated under torture, not covering for them. Again, the Canadians are doing the right thing by criminally investigating not only Syrian officials, but officials from the U.S. as well. The Obama administration should look to the Canadian example and do what’s right – apologize to Maher and hold his torturers accountable.”
It’s a good thing (for certain people) that the United States is quite large, because as this country sinks into the status of an international pariah, intent on protecting its torturers, if not the right to torture prisoners it considers outside the pale of national and international law, U.S. officials involved in these crimes against humanity will soon find they cannot go to even Canada, as they would fear arrest and prosecution.
Other Links
Those more interested in Maher Arar’s case should check out this CCR link.
Those, like myself, who could not attend the Culture Project’s "Blueprint for Accountability" shindig at Skirball Center for the Performing Arts, NYU, on June 7, with Valerie Plame, Ron Suskind, Jeremy Scahill, Robert Kennedy, Jr., Vince Warren and others, can now watch the unchaptered video of the event online here.
The full text of the Physicians for Human Rights (PHR) complaint to the federal Office of Human Research Protections (OHRP) is now online, offering the opportunity to sign on to complaint itself. The official petition draws upon findings by PHR that the CIA experimented on detainees in its custody, based upon the following evidence of wrongdoing detailed in declassified government documents. See PHR’s full investigatory report here.
PHR’s filing has been joined by other major human rights and civil liberties groups, including Amnesty International, the Bill of Rights Defense Committee, the Center for Constitutional Rights, the Center for Victims of Torture, Human Rights Watch, International Rehabilitation Council for Torture Victims, the National Religious Campaign Against Torture, and Psychologists for Social Responsibility.
ACLU reminds us that June is "Torture Awareness Month," and is using the occasion to publicize many of the torture documents it painstakingly won via hard-fought FOIA lawsuits. Now, if they would only sign on to PHR’s OHRP complaint. Hey, ACLU, what’s up with that?



23 Comments




Jeff, have you spoken to Amrit Singh & Jaffer at ACLU about this ? They’ve been here several times and are well known to the FDL community.
Mary asked us over at Marcy’s blog, what we Canucks thought of the RCMP investigation and while I think it’s all smoke and mirrors, I’d love to be proven wrong. Please update us when you find out more and thanks for all the great work !
Recommended. I’m glad the protestors were acquitted.
No, I’ve not spoken to ACLU or PHR about this. It’s only an observation by me from the outside. I think both are great organizations, and without them we’d all be so much the weaker, less protected. If their supporters find this incongruity on this issue to be a problem (as I do), then I would hope they address it with their organizations. I have written to an ACLU person with whom I’ve corresponded in the past, and if they or the organization wish, I’ll report on what they say. — I have written about it this way, because if I’m someone who notices this, then I know I’m not alone, and others will be noticing, too, and drawing their own conclusions. I don’t know what it’s all about, and the article otherwise says all I wish to say about it right now.
As for the RCMP investigation, I don’t hold out great hope, though I suppose I let my optimism for a good outcome be expressed in the article, re U.S. officials fearing entering Canada someday. Who knows? Canada’s response — at least on this issue — has been much better than that of the U.S., as Greenwald pointed out.
contemplation of torture is: contemptable!
Admittedly I often feel the urge to design a way to put them torturers under the same, but that is not good.
We torture prisoners… with life in isolation.
There should be a rethinking of these things, a rethinking of these items, and a rethinking of encarceration.
Torture: willful administration of pain to helpless others.
A proclivity to torture is a requisite trait to be a proper devil!
Jeff, thanks for the update on the protest trial — Fatster had noticed it earlier and it caught my interest, I was hoping it would be covered. (The protestors were spearheaded/organized by Frida Berrigan, Phil’s daughter… besides, how can you not look forward to a peace protest trial where the judge plays guitar in “the world’s only almost-all-judge band,” Deaf Dogs and The Indictments? :-) And at least now we know, per the Washington Times, what the charges were: Unlawful entry.
Nuts to Elena Kagan, can’t this guy be the next Supreme Court justice? I think I like him.
Also re the Gitmo “suicides” that prompted the protest, a memorable quote –
(at 30:35)
In other impressive news, Maher Arar just recieved his engineering doctorate from the University of Ottawa at their spring convocation.
I am immensely surprised about the RCMP investigation. I guess there is at least a need to *appear* to be following the rule of law here in Canada. IF they had wanted to ignore these matters, I doubt they would have proceeded to initiate an RCMP investigation. We’ll see what comes of it. The RCMP is under some scrutiny these days.
As far as I know, the US state department STILL maintains that there is some super secret special information they have that Arar is a danger, hence he is still on the US watch/no-fly list. They may have even have had to show this to a Canadian official and they still maintain it is credible – this may be the product of Khadr’s torture. US officials were clearly acting out their lust for revenge – lashing out at shadows. This is how we end up with a torture state.
What I find *most* galling is that the US broke all of their own prescribed immigration and human rights procedures in Arar’s case. And there is no case? Of. course. not. Arar’s wife did not know where her husband was for (as I recall) 3 weeks. The whole manner of the thing left her lobbying Canadian officials in the face of skepticism and smears from elected officials and (official and secret) RCMP sources alike. She is a most remarkable woman.
Thanks for following this, Jeff.
omg.
But these were the terrorist plotters who killed themselves in the exquisitely hostile act (as reported at the time) of “assymetric” warfare. While imprisoned at Gitmo. While under 24-hour surveillance.
edit
Darn, what happened to those surveillance videotapes?
Thanks, Jeff! This is a great round up of recent news.
They were here *somewhere* … just the other day. *g*
Oopsies … I recorded NCIS on them … my bad
That’s crazy about “Top Dog”. Great catch. I’d also wondered about Frida, if she were related to the Berrigan brothers, so thanks also for that. Phil’s daughter… that’s great.
Yes, what did happen to those “tapes,” some of which were recorded to hard drives? I think we used to believe that if something were down on tape, that ultimately it would have to surface. But that doesn’t appear to be true at all.
Speaking of tapes, I’m going to be hosting the FDL Book Salon on Saturday, July 3, when the guest will be novelist Barry Eisler. Barry will be talking about his new book, Inside Out, which is a fictionalized tale about what happened to the CIA’s torture tapes. It’s a great read, but it’s also a well-researched telling of the torture scandal, complete with bibliography.
The book itself won’t be out until June 29. But interested readers can bone up by checking out its predecessor, Fault Line, which revolves around computer cryptography, or any of the excellent novels in the John Rain line (Rain Fall, etc.). Barry also has a political blog, for those so interested.
Hope I “see” all or many of you at the Book Salon.
Another terrific diary, Jeff. I’m going to attach a little more hope to the Canadian criminal investigation. After all, the Canadian civil investigation came out with the right decision.
[That's great that you're hosting the Eisler Book Salon. I hope to have the chance to drop in. It's a very good book.]
See you there, Jeff !
With NCIS… was that a Gelles/King reference?
I was expecting “24″ — much more appropriate.
Probably his “confession” under torture by the Syrians. But everybody knows (or should know) that torture is designed to produce confessions — of whatever the torturer wishes — whether they are true or not.
Yuppers. :-(
Oh… I forgot… NCIS was a TV show.
antiwar radio podcast: