With all the news about the new charges brought against alleged Wikileaks leaker Bradley Manning, the fact of his abusive treatment under onerous Maximum Security and Prevention of Injury (POI) conditions of confinement don’t get enough attention in the mainstream press. Perhaps the latest revelations by Manning’s attorney, David E. Coombs, will make America stand up and take notice.
Besides conditions of solitary confinement, harassment day and night, restriction of reading material, making him walk in shackles if he leaves his cell, inability to communicate with any other prisoners, we must now add degradation and humiliation. Do we need to be reminded that Bradley Manning has not been convicted of any crime?
From Coomb’s report this afternoon:
Last night, PFC Manning was inexplicably stripped of all clothing by the Quantico Brig. He remained in his cell, naked, for the next seven hours. At 5:00 a.m., the Brig sounded the wake-up call for the detainees. At this point, PFC Manning was forced to stand naked at the front of his cell.
The Duty Brig Supervisor (DBS) arrived shortly after 5:00 a.m. When he arrived, PFC Manning was called to attention. The DBS walked through the facility to conduct his detainee count. Afterwards, PFC Manning was told to sit on his bed. About ten minutes later, a guard came to his cell to return his clothing.
As Manning’s attorney says, this kind of treatment is “degrading… inexcusable and without justification.” It comes on top of the imposition of isolation, cynically imposed in the name of protecting the young private, when in fact, it is fashioned to torture him, or at least impose cruel, inhumane treatment, both of which are violations of torture law and treaties.
Manning’s attorney noted that in a Department of Defense news conference the other day, DoD spokesman Geoff Morrell agreed that PFC Manning “has been exemplary in terms of his behavior on the cell block,” leading Mr. Coombs to comment: “Other detainees typically are removed from Maximum custody and from POI watch once they demonstrate, through their behavior, that the conditions are no longer warranted. Under Secretary of the Navy Instruction (SECNAVINST) 1649.9C, Maximum custody and POI are intended to be used sparingly and for a limited duration of time. Despite the Navy Instruction, PFC Manning remains subject to unduly harsh confinement conditions.”
The latest manifestation of the Pentagon’s animus against Manning is the use of degrading and humiliating treatment. Forced nakedness is exactly the kind of treatment meted out in the torture techniques approved by former Secretary of Defense Donald Rumsfeld, and used at Guantanamo, and by the CIA in their black site prisons. We can see now that in their impeccable power, the U.S. government feels it must strip a young accused person totally in their power and leave them naked in their cell for hours. For what purpose? It can only be to demonstrate their power and to psychologically attempt to break down the prisoner.
This latest atrocity should be strongly condemned by all proponents of human rights and justice. This is cruel treatment. It should stop, and Manning should immediately be taken off POI, at the very least. But then, to any thinking person, it makes no sense that Manning is in prison, while the war criminals that killed tens or hundreds of thousands in Iraq, and gave military orders to ignore torture and turn prisoners over to be tortured, walk free.
Update: Alert commenter Mad Dog noticed this important part of David Coombs’ article, chilling in its open avowal of continuing abuse. Referring to the imposition of forced nakedness, Coombs reports that “PFC Manning has been told that the same thing will happen to him again tonight.” Meanwhile, Trudy B. has sent me a link to a Kate Zernike and David Rohde’s June 2004 piece in the New York Times, on the “pervasive pattern” of forced nakedness at Abu Ghraib, at Guantanamo and elsewhere.
It got so bad at Abu Ghraib that in October 2003, Zernike and Rohde wrote that “Red Cross monitors were so alarmed by the number of nude detainees that they halted their visit and demanded an immediate explanation. ‘The military intelligence officer in charge of the interrogation explained that this practice was “part of the process,”‘ the Red Cross wrote in a report in February.”
I guess that’s the case now at Quantico. “Part of the process” is what torture has now come down to, embraced on U.S. soil against an American citizen. Those wanting to do something can contribute to The Bradley Manning Advocacy Fund. 100% of contributions to this fund will be used to pay expenses related to the advocacy and defense of Bradley Manning.



120 Comments

The sheer audacity of the Quantico jailers takes one’s breath away. They know how to deliver a message, and it is about their omnipotence (as they see it). But what it really communicates is their utter disregard for human rights.
Thanks, Jeff. I wonder why the brig is suddenly escalating its abuse of Manning, especially just as the new charges were announced.
My take: to show the world, and Manning, that nothing is changed. They are in power. Don’t forget it.
I absolutely condemn my government’s treatment of PFC Bradley Manning.
It also reveals their fear. This is damned close to a tacit admission that they have nothing, absolutely nothing, on Manning that would stand up in any legitimate court. So they must try to break him before they’re forced to free him.
It’s kind of the anti-beatitudes: I was clothed, and you made me naked; I was in prison, and you stopped people from visiting me. I wonder what this is doing to the psyche of the jailers, who must know this is immoral.
It has been over a month since the brig commander was replaced, so this new unprovoked punishment either was ordered by the new commander or someone at a higher command level than the brig commander is calling the shots on all of Manning’s illegal punishment. My bet is it’s the latter…
Just thought I’d highlight the fun times they’re having at the Quantico Brig.
Obama is Bush/Cheney on steroids. He doesn’t even bother to hide it.
Why? because he knows the Dem Party has no principles and will continue to support him. He also knows that countless so-called progressive and liberal organizations have no principles and will continue to support both him and the Dem Party.
Evil is not possible without the enablers.
Seems that they have not yet figured out that they are the ones caught naked in the international spotlight showing their indefensible actions of torture.
I’m usually wrong on these kind of things, but isn’t that torture and it’s processes supposed to take place OFF of US soil and in a warzone?
I thought Yoo, Rumsfeld, Bush, etal had to do these techniques away from the US and is the reason for Gitmo and other sites.
The treatment of this man is despicable. This is simple unabashed sadism.
We have a problem with sadism within the police, and armed services, intel and so forth.
The Bush administration made torture okay and Obama seems just as happy to keep on going. Tell me again how “wasting my vote” by voting third party or write in in 2012, possibly resulting in a Republican victory will sooooo disastrous and heinous.
Baby killers and torturers. First they came for Manning. This war against America may never end. But we have to give Manning credit for fighting against lies and corruption. Manning is a hero. Obama is a bloody dictator who should be impeached for torture and fraudulent wars and violating the Bill of Rights.
Just yesterday, ondelette wrote a very relevant diary on “Male Rape, Wartime Rape” that makes for very important reading with Manning’s treatment in mind:
http://my.firedoglake.com/ondelette/2011/03/02/male-rape-wartime-rape/
I can’t wait for the howls of phony outrage from Obillary when word gets out that the Pakistanis are following the USG standard in their treatment of Raymond Davis, or whoever he really is.
I’ve been saying all along that there are two components to this story. They’re torturing an AMERICAN CITIZEN on AMERICAN SOIL. Torture in this country is very illegal, whether or not it’s on a military installation.
It’s not disastrous or heinous.
Margaret 2012!
Who’s your running mate gonna be?
Margaret,
You are never Heinous or however you spell it. Using your vote to go against the insanity is a show of TRUE CONVICTION!
I’mma voting for you.
For any lurking mods, just got this message when clicking the recommend button on ondelette’s post, linked by Jim.
1
Oh yeah, when in office please don’t do the evening robo call townhall meeting like I had tonight. Mmokay?
Hmm, didn’t show up. Interesting.
1 .
And again, didn’t show up. Anywho, there’s something broken over there.
Margaret, I’m with you.
The Dem Party at least gives token resistance to an “R” Repub.
Hmmm, I guess I’d better start thinking about that, huh? There are so many excellent choices.
KrisAinCA,
“I’ve been saying all along that there are two components to this story. They’re torturing an AMERICAN CITIZEN on AMERICAN SOIL. Torture in this country is very illegal, whether or not it’s on a military installation.”
So, I am not wrong/crazy for thinking that! I am often wrong on these type things, I admit it. But, some things should be just common sense.
Oh, yeah. Keep saying it!
WTF?
Like this would be OK on Main street?
My mind boggles.
I got arrested In San Jose one time and they were notorious assholes. One Sergeant came into a room I was in by myself and told me to strip for no other reason than he was being a dick headed bully.
I pulled my pants down and started scratching my balls right in his face. I ain’t bashful.
What they are doing to this guy is over the top Psychological mistreatment, especially as they are singling him out.
Can’t wait until the next election!! We can finally vote out the evil torturers Bush and Cheney. I hear a guy named Barack Obama is running. He’s promised single payer health care, to close Guantanamo Bay, and to support union members if they go out and protest or strike! Sounds like a real hero to me. /s Americans have no democracy. Refuse to accept this disaster of a government we now have like those in Egypt, Libya, Tunisia, Bahrain, Yemen, and now Iraq, or keep getting fucked and watching others get fucked by the government you indirectly support.
When in office, I fully intend to keep right on blogging here and keep the very same friends I have now. I have no intention of surrounding myself with office seekers and concern trolls or entering into the DC bubble. I still keep going top Beth’s annual fiftieth birthday party, the only difference is I won’t have to sober up before I leave cause somebody else will be doing the driving!
Oh yeah and hell will be frozen over at 3 kelvins before I give an interview to FOX.
OK, what happened to the numbered comments?
Just substitute the word Obama for jailers.
No go in My FDL diaries.
Not in my name.
There’s 3 or 4 different comment styles, for some reason, depending on where the article is published. This one looks similar to the numbered one but instead replies are placed directly below the comment they’re replying to and the numbers are gone.
I hate to be repetitive, but, folks, how close are we to martial law, here?
The people are NOT represented any more.
We, the People, are now only to be looked at as resources to be drained and cannon fodder, to be used and abused as the MOTU see fit.
When the most dangerous military in the world operates unchecked abroad, and now, it appears, at home, what are our options?
You think the American military would hold back like Egypt’s did, if there were protests like theirs? Not a fucking chance. the streets would run red.
This is Obama’s doing. Obama is torturing Manning to obtain a confession. Some day his daughters will find out what he is.
Your last statement induces complacency. Egyptians didn’t know if their military would hold back or not and still aren’t sure (it’s not over). Libyans tried peaceful protest, were massacred, but haven’t given up and took over most major cities. It’s better to fight than allow this bullshit to continue. By staying silent and in fear, you’re supporting the current government. When you vote in any election, you’re supporting the government’s legitimacy, especially if you vote for the 2 main parties. Voting for a third party allows them to ignore the third parties but at the same time use the higher voter participation to claim the government and its elections are supported by x% of the population.
It’s like l’Affaire Dreyfus, only without the trial and conviction.
Yes, although I think this must put to rest all the speculation that the old commander was sent to pasture as a result of this treatment of Manning, or the press it brought, because the ill-treatment has continued, and even, as David Coombs has said, gotten worse.
I have to agree. And for those who were waiting for Dennis Kucinich to meet with Manning, or for Kerry to speak out, I think the latest is an example of where such false hope leads.
More than likely they’ll remain in a bubble or accept it as the way the world works and continue to support their parents, like Chelsea Clinton. There’s a small chance they could wake up and become like Ron Reagan. Though whether they do or not is not relevant to us. We need to call an end to the charade of a democracy we have, used to justify making the wealthier richer, killing thousands abroad, and torturing at home and abroad, and begin fighting like those in NA and the ME.
Cause the Republicans WILL raise Your Taxes Peg all the while cutting Taxes for the Rich and Corps.. You can bank on that!
OH don’t forget They will also destroy SS Medicare and who knows what else.
In addition to venting our opinions here, as cathartic as this is, I hope some of my fellow firepups will join me in going to http://www.bradleymanning.org and volunteering to help out in some way. I’m a writer, so I’ve volunteered to write an article for the website.
Also, please contribute to his defense fund.
A number of people in the military, even ex-CIA, who worry about this kind of thing, have made just this very point. In fact, besides the basic morality of humane treatment, it was one of the primary arguments for following the Geneva Conventions. Perhaps the U.S. authorities got so full of themselves, they couldn’t imagine they would never have any prisoners, or at least none that SEALs, Rangers, and JPRA-types couldn’t parachute in and save right away. Or maybe they just didn’t give a damn anyway about their soldiers/special ops guys… told them it was a badge of honor to be sacrificed… this is the kind of dilemma that Barry Eisler’s Special Ops specialist Ben Treven was working out in Eisler’s book Inside Out.
Yes, please, if you are reading this, please give to Manning’s defense fund.
Thanks, bluewombat.
…Because the Democrats won’t… Sorry, I know that’s not true. The Dems caving on…well everything…has shown anybody with open eyes the reality of the situation.
I was thinking the same as I was reading Gildea’s “Barricades and Borders this AM.
Funny, some voters thought that by electing a constitutional scholar from a minority race, who might have familial, racial, class, intellectual and rational reasons to understand the harm such treatment causes its victims, its perpetrators and their society, would mean the US stopped committing the abuses for which the CheneyBush administration was widely disdained.
All that’s necessary for evil to prosper is for good people to do nothing.
Is there a link for that?
Well, the joke was on them.
Jeff, thanks for this post.
Have you heard any news about what, if any, action John Kerry has initiated, who made a statement in public recently that he would check into Manning’s conditions of confinement?
I don’t really think anymore that the Dems cave, I think they’re role playing. Well, I might add. As long as most voters buy into the two party myth, they’ll continue to role play too.
“The military”, even in the United States, is not some monolithic bloc of automatons. The services represent every element in society, conservative, liberal, apathetic, black, white, brown, male, female, religious, agnostic, atheist, indifferent, gay, straight, bisexual and transgendered. IF they were ordered to fire on protesters, (which I won’t deny would be very likely), some would, some wouldn’t. Some would side with the protesters, some would simply refuse, some would enjoy the hell out of the order and carry it out with vigor and still others would cut those people down. Anybody who thinks that “the military” would behave as some mindless programmed army of robots just demonstrates their lack of knowledge of the services and the members employed therein.
true DAT!!
Whatever happened to Dennis Kucinich’s inquiry into Bradley Manning’s treatment?
Anybody have an Air Force One sighting?
Maybe Obama took Kucinich on another plane ride, a ride for his life.
Motherfuckers. Somehow the names and photos of these jailers should be obtained, posters made and distributed in the town outside the base, and in their neighborhoods if they live off base. Make these fuckers uncomfortable for a change.
But I’m NOT silent. Not really in my character.
I’ve literally called every senator and rep at one time or another. I mean it. 535 calls, sometimes on one single issue. I’ve written, protested. I donate to groups I feel ‘get it’. I send out emails and links to a large group of people who appreciate my passion.
I don’t feel there is much else I can do as an individual.
I am not the complacent guy down the street. I am the guy in my circle of friends and acquaintances known to speak his mind and say what needs to be said, damn the tact at times.
Since Obama’s election, it has become abundantly clear we are fucked as a democracy, that party no longer matters, at least between R and D.
So, please enlighten me. With big money in charge, and the media doing their bidding. What next?
This is bullshit. Outrageous bullshit.
This. shit. has. got. to. stop.
Torturing is bad enough, torturing an innocent man is indefensible.
USA! USA! USA!
*spit*
That’s a nice thought. But, IMHO, since most of these folks signed up since the US has gone off the security-state deep-end, I believe they are more likely to follow orders first and ask questions later. I don’t see any dearth of people willing to sign up for killing brown people overseas, all at the behest of a lying imperial government.
The longer we stick with the belligerent military forays, the less likely I am to respect the troops and their motivations. They’re being use and brainwashed, but, if you didn’t believe in the mission at all, I don’t see you signing up.
Yes, shunning or atleast allowing the peaceful among us the chance to know we shouldn’t let our children play at their house!
The guards are losing their humanity
For the record. If this is a format change to replies going only under the original comment, I’ll voice my disapproval.
I think it changes the nature of the discourse on this site, something which I appreciate greatly.
Call the white House tomorrow morning 202 456 1111. If you have to, pretend it is not futile.
PFC Manning is in the military.
He is being charged by the military through their laws, not ours.
He will be tried by military attorneys in front of military judges.
The judges will give him a fair trial and then convict him.
The poor chap doesn’t have a chance.
I think he’d have a better chance if he were tried in a civilian court.
I am ashamed to be part of this country right now. The $$ mongers and power brokers have made a mess.
I hope it can be turned around.
Protest. You’re appealing to the corrupt to do the right thing. They don’t care how many times you call or write them, except perhaps Bernie Sanders or some really local official in a small town. I’m not being negative for the sake of it. A recent study showed the politicians only show noticeable change to the desire of the wealthiest.
The real power we have is ourselves. When we stay home and plead to those in power, or rant at the Internet or TV, we are powerless and mean nothing.
It’s from Coombs’s report linked in the post.
1
***Mod Note: There is a bug with the rec’d button. The techs are working on it. Refresh several times.***
I pasted in what was displayed, and when I posted the comment, it disappeared and left only the 1.
The latest iteration of the reader diaries inflicted these nested, unnumbered comments on us. We complain, they ignore.
Much of the military is made up of the poorest of Americans. They join because they’re promised a lot of benefits. They’re not all gun nut psycho-paths who eagerly join to kill other people. No doubt some may fit this profile, or become that way after training and duty, but as Margaret said, they’re far more diverse than you’re giving them credit for.
Like a lot of people I am finding it extremely hard to digest what our government is doing to an American citizen. It could happen to any of us. Not that it matters. What matters is that it is happening to Bradly Manning.
It is futile. Go out and protest instead.
I have a question re: the defense fund. Does he have a right to outside lawyers, or does he have to accept somebody from JAG? I don’t understand how the military justice system works.
Those are the words for a White House telephone call. It must be made personal. It is morality.
You’re flat wrong. Period. I have served but it’s evident that you have not. People also join for as many reasons as there are recruits. It’s not simply because they “want to kill brown people overseas”. Though certainly some do, for the most part those are weeded out because a sociopath has no more regard for his/her “buddies”, than he or she has for any other life. The world isn’t black and white and the wise only speak about that which they know.
What little rule of law existed in the US over the last 70 years of permanent war went out the window a decade ago and has been replaced by the state of permanent exception, the executive’s existence above the law, and the invention of the non-person, enemy of the state who exists outside the law (why the term POW had to be replaced with “enemy combatant” for the GWOT). Anything can be done to this last group by the state because technically their existence and rights are not recognized or protected by any law. The only condition for ending up as such a non-person is that they state categorizes you as such. This is what many of us have been talking about lately: the meaning of the classification “enemy” and who it applies to. Well, it applies to anyone the state says it does. They, being the creators of the category, are the sole arbiter of who falls within its definition. Remember when the category Communist served the function of the category Terrorist? Manning is one of these unfortunates. And potentially so are any of us.
Thanks for the update, Jeff!
It’s the way diaries are set up and it’s been like that for months. Not very many people like the nested comments but I doubt your voice is going to have much of an impact on the format. The front page posts still use the chronological version in the comments.
msmolly I had the error message earlier as well but after I refreshed the screen a bit later, my recommend had tken.
The code is not displaying though because the less than and greater than symbols are HTML commands so the browser is looking for a command rather than something visible within the comment
Then make him the hero he is. Make everyone know his name and what is happening to him. Make everyone in power know you know. Talk about it in the grocery line at the playground. Bring American torture out of the closet and into polite society. Jeff Kaye, Jim White, Marcy, Jane and all the others- here given the facts now make them audible beyond our choir.
BHO IS A SHITWEASEL…..that is all
personally all their wars have exhausted me…good bye america
“For what purpose? It can only be to demonstrate their power and to psychologically attempt to break down the prisoner.”
Indeed. Manning is about fucked nine ways to Sunday. What he is being subjected to is worse than degrading. It’s destruction. They are trying to get his mind right, and by extension, the rest of ours as well.
When we consider the supposed importance of voting in our alleged representative democracy, we might ask ourselves why none of our “leaders” have stepped forward to champion the civil rights of a citizen and the equitable application of the rule of law.
“Under the spreading chestnut tree, I sold you and you sold me.”
I live close to a large Army base, so I frequently see, as I perhaps many of you all do, bumper stickers with such Fascist nonsense as, “If you enjoy your freedom, thank a soldier.” The US soldiers in the Middle East aren’t dying for our freedom. But Pvt. Manning sure as fuck is.
What puzzles me is that 70 thousand demonstrate in Madison but so few seem interested in the treatment if Manning. He has only one regular visitor after all that has happened.
There should be hundreds if not thousands lining up to get arrested to show support for him.
Why aren’t the anti-war military groups involved?
http://my.firedoglake.com/normanb/2011/02/26/meeropol-on-political-prisoners-john-sinclair-manning-torture-victims-manning-whistle-blowers-assange-thomas-paine-press-freedom-jane-hamsher-paine-iglo-alternative-political-convention/
Unfortunately, under the US’s current Fascist state of exception and its creation of non-person enemies outside the law, Manning has, by the definition of his categorization, ceased to be human, and therefore those rights don’t apply.
Here’s a couple — send them a couple bucks.
http://www.couragetoresist.org/x/content/view/897/1/
http://www.veteransforpeace.org/news_detail.php?idx=3
the streets will run red
fixed it for you…
The application of the anti-beatitudes is a strange position to take for a self-proclaimed Christian nation. If such glaring contradictions can produce psychosis at the individual level, what affect might they have at a societal one?
It was in a posting here at MyFDL. I’m afraid I don’t have time to look it up, but a search should find it readily enough.
This says it all. Being a politician is their career. Their loyalty is to their party and the interests of the government and the institutions that keep it powerful. America’s “democracy” is one party away from being a one party state and when both parties operate near identically, aside from some domestic social issues, they essentially are. The game is over. Time for us to join those who have fought with their lives, day after day, week after week, for a better life in NA and the ME.
One of the negatives is that you have to reread the entire comments section to see any comments posted after you read any post. Does this make sense?
At best they probably won’t care and at worst they’ll want to be like him. Like I used to feel sorry for Chelsea when she was a kid, but now it looks like she’s grown up to be just like her corporatist parents who is out to profit by her political connections.
You all can also contribute to Manning via Courage to Resist:
http://www.couragetoresist.org/x/
From what little I have of relevant personal experience, Manning should be able to hire his own lawyer outside of JAG to represent him in a court martial.
Under the UCMJ, Manning can hire civilian counsel at his own expense, but such counsel must be qualified to represent defendants in a military trial. Not all lawyers have that qualification – most of the ones I know are prior service. But it’s been a while since I dealt with the MCM, so I dunno what revisions may have gone into it.
“This latest atrocity should be strongly condemned by all proponents of human rights and justice.”
Well – that would apparently exclude Pres. Obama.
Thanks!
the sick perversion of the military,reminds me of something Palin would do
WARNING: WHISTLEBLOWERS WILL BE TORTURED.
SHITWEASEL…
…if the shoe fits.
On second thought, anyone accused of whistleblowing will be tortured.
Charlie Savage now has a New York Times story up about this development, and it confirms Manning’s lawyer’s account:
Who should be acting, in our names, in response to this news?
These people:
Upcoming Hearings:
United States House of Representatives Armed Services Committee:
Committee Chairman: Howard P. “Buck” McKeon, California
Ranking Member: Adam Smith, Washington
The other 60 members (34 Republicans + 26 Democrats) are listed here.
“WP Super Cache is installed but broken. The path to wp-cache-phase1.php in wp-content/advanced-cache.php must be fixed!”
Caligula Reincarnated As Obama
Anyone thinking of whistleblowing will be tortured.
Villiard says he can’t comment more because it “would violate the detainee’s privacy.” (per the Savage NYT article)
Oh, they’re so concerned about his privacy they stripped him naked, where he’s observed all night, then had him stand naked outside his cell???
What kinds of people are these?
Hm. Just noticed, a little o/t.
Connecticut has two senators on Senate Armed Services committee, who together represent 3.5 million people.
California, which has a population of almost 37 million, and a good amount of the nation’s military installations and defense industries, has… zero members on the committee.
Oh, in case anyone thinks that’s unfair, remember that New Hampshire, with a population of 1.35 million people, also is represented by two senators on the committee.
Democracy in action.
Maybe if the country got attacked the senators from little bucholic back waters would have a better chance of survival, and live to rattle sabers another day.
Fienstein and boxer are already too busy, what with I don’t know.
How come the spanish inquisition continues to be the bottom line @ 7:51?
Nah Obamma’s a nice kid, they keep him in a bubble, to listen to that hill billy preacher goin’ on about the mau maus, that just shows about how good an idea “democracy” is in America… De Tockville, fortold.
The replacement of Chief Warrant Officer James Averhart with Chief Warrant Officer Denise Barnes might mean that the former was hesitant to engage in the kind of torture that the latter seemingly approves of. Is this the the reason Averhart was replaced?
I hope America deserves the service Pfc Manning is giving us. He needs all the help we can give.
Exactly. The whole reason the Geneva Conventions are such a powerful tool is because most nations follow them scruplously. When a nation as powerful as the US does double-talk of this nature, it seriously damages the power of the Geneva Conventions.
The entire US Senate should demand an end to the abuse of Bradley Manning. I reject sending a dime to Attorney David E. Coombs. Coombs should have filed a Habeous Corpis to demand normal treatment meaning Manning should be allowed to be in open population before his court martial.
I just called my Senator, Richard Blumenthal and sent this story to him. I asked Blumenthal to speak directly to the Senate and demand fair treatment for Manning.
Marcy Wheeler has written a post documenting the run-around DoD has given Congressman Kucinich. It’s must reading, so here’s the link:
http://emptywheel.firedoglake.com/2011/03/04/dod-passes-the-buck-rather-than-let-kucinich-to-visit-bradley-manning/
From Kucinich, quoted in Marcy’s article, with her emphasis:
I called my Senator, Levin and left a message with a staffer, I e-mailed a blistering letter to the WH, but people WE NEED BOOTS ON THE GROUND!! Bodies and voices and signs!!! Can we get a group to go to DC?
Oh, and my message to Levin via e-mail also:
Comments: Why are you not investigating the TORTURE of an American soldier on US property?? Bradley Manning is only charged, not convicted, and being subjected to heinous, midieval treatment, on a par with that of dictators. Have we no honor? No shame? This should be your main concern, the RULE OF LAW and conforming to the Geneva Convention IN OUR OWN COUNTRY!! How quickly we forget the lessons of Nuremburg, or is decency only expected from the conquered?
Sacco and Vanzetti were put to death; all the hundreds of thousands of union workers, Socialist, Communist, Anarchist, who flooded the streets could not save their lives. If they were “high-born” say like Patty Hearst they may have lived to see the sun another day. Bradley Manning like Sacco and Vanzetti picked the loosing side.
Wasn’t David Frakt once here for one of those salon interviews? He’s at Barry University in Florida.
http://www.barry.edu/law/future/Faculty/dFrakt.htm
Czar Nicolas and Czarina Alexandra, Louis XVI and his famous queen, Charles I, they chose the wrong side, too, and each of them had a full, national army to protect them. So did Mubarak. So did Batista, and a number of others.
No one knows what the future brings. One engages in struggle based on a certain set of values, and the rest follows from the correlation of forces at the time.
Do not throw Bradley Manning’s fate under the bus, due to historical pessimism.
The Communist Georgi Dmitrov accused of burning down the Reichstag and tried by the newly Nazified German courts in a huge show trial was found not guilty. Dreyfus was finally cleared and released. Of course, the number of frame-ups and juridical lynchings are legion. One could mention along with Saccor and Vanzetti the early 20th century Scottsboro Boys case.
History is funny. You just don’t know what will happen.