According to information at the Reprieve web site, “Chadian citizen, Mohammed el Gharani was the youngest prisoner in Guantánamo Bay, arrested when he was just 14. In January 2009, a federal judge ordered his release and he was returned to Chad in June 2009.” (Reprieve attorneys represented Mr. el-Gharani.) At the time of his release, a Pentagon spokesman gave the Reuters the U.S. mea culpa regarding the teen’s incarceration — they thought he was 16 years old, and not 14 when he was captured and rendered to Guantánamo.
After his release, Gharani told the Miami Herald that after Barack Obama became president, his treatment did not get any better, including being beaten by a rubber baton and tear-gassed. During the years of his detention, he was subjected to solitary confinement, sleep deprivation, stress positions, and suspension from his wrists at least 30 times.
The U.S. government made nonsensical claims about el Gharani’s supposed “terrorist status.” A Washington Post story by Del Quentin Wilber noted, “The government also accused Gharani of belonging to a London-based al-Qaeda cell in 1998, an accusation that Leon questioned. Gharani was 11 at the time, living with immigrant parents in Saudi Arabia, his attorneys said.” According to the article, U.S. District Judge Richard J. Leon ordered Gharani’s release because of the two informants the U.S. based its case on, one’s credibility was “directly called into question” by government officials themselves, while the other informant’s credibility could not be determined.
[For the record, Farah Stockman, in a July 2006 Boston Globe article, originally broke the story about U.S. charges that Gharani was in London and working for Al Qaeda at age 11.]
In the video below, from an interview with Al Jazeera the month he was released, the former child prisoner — one of at least a dozen minors held over the years at Guantanamo — describes his captivity and torture, including the fact that Guantanamo interrogators tried to get him to spy on his fellow prisoners.
Gharani’s tale of coerced attempts to make him inform is an all-too-common one, repeated by many if not most of the freed detainees. The program of recruiting informants through torture and mistreatment was part of the overall policy of “exploitation of prisoners,” revealed in a recent Truthout exposé by Jason Leopold and Jeffrey Kaye, which showed that the program “reversed-engineered” by the CIA and the Department of Defense was specifically meant to produce false confessions, propaganda compliance and recruitment of informants, along with whatever intelligence they thought they could get via torture.
Andy Worthington wrote about Mohammed’s subsequent fate in an article in December 2009:
In a telephone interview with the Associated Press, El-Gharani explained that he relied on “handouts from friends” to support himself. “I’m still not free,” he said. “I have no job. I have a hard time to find somewhere to live.” He added, poignantly, “I’m innocent. I have done nothing to anyone. I should be able go to see my family”….
A week after El-Gharani’s release from Guantánamo, as I reported at the time,
Chris Chang, an investigator with Reprieve, and Ahmed Ghappour, an attorney, returned yesterday from a trip to Chad in which they had hoped to celebrate Mohammed’s freedom, but were “dismayed and disappointed” to discover that he is now a prisoner of the Chadian authorities, “sleeping on a cot in a police station while his family waits anxiously outside.” They added, “Mohammed cannot leave the main police headquarters without authorization from the Head of the Judicial Police, and even after obtaining that permission he is accompanied by a police officer wherever he goes. He has asked on several occasions to be released and reunited with his family but continues to be told, ‘Just another night, Mohammed.’” They also said that there has been no public announcement in Chad regarding his return and that he has been forbidden from speaking to the media.
Perhaps due to pressure from Reprieve, he was then released, and handed over to his uncle, but as the AP reported, without a passport or an identity card, it was impossible for him even to enroll in a class to study English. He was then mugged by a group of armed men who, ironically, thought that he had received “a multi-million dollar settlement as compensation for his imprisonment.”
Here is a PDF link to Judge Leon’s unclassified opinion. And here is a short January 2010 video of Mohammed el Gharani thanking those who supported him. I could find no updates on his situation from the time of this last video to today. Another former victim of U.S. torture, a child kidnapped and sold to the Americans to be exploited for propaganda and intelligence purposes, drifts off into the misty haziness of neglect and forgetfulness that obscures the truths of our time, courtesy of a President and Congress insistent on burying U.S. crimes as deeply out of public consciousness as possible.



32 Comments

This story may seem old to some, but is worth going over not just because of its innate human interest, but in order to help readers review what we know of the U.S. torture program in the light of recent evidence showing that the totality of that program was not about interrogation for intelligence purposes, but had other aims in mind regarding the total “exploitation” of prisoners.
Thanks, Jeff. What a sad story.
Washboarding Good!
Thanks, Jeff! The poor guy. And the morally impoverished country that did this to him.
Rec’d
Watching the reddit up and down ratings is fascinating. While everyone has the right to their opinion, and as author of the piece, I’m certainly biased, but one wonders about those who would down-rate an article about the torture of a child. What kind of rock bears down upon their souls?
Jeff Kaye April 8th, 2011 at 9:52 am
A chauvinist one.
markfromireland
Thanks, Jeff. Yes, it’s completely worth our while to review these cases in light of what we learn thanks to the ongoing investigative efforts of our true journalists like yourself.
So. very. very. sad.
And criminal.
I would assume the same “rock” that compels some people to claim whistleblowers have “blood on their hands” for exposing actual killings.
Will the American people vote for a candidate who is known to have murdered and tortured children?
Yup.
Would President Obama (and his DOJ) be willing to “look backward” if criminal activity–torture and child abuse–happened on his watch? There are serious allegations of crimes being committed during Obama’s presidency. Surely he must take responsibility to see to it that these matters are investigated and prosecuted accordingly? No?
That kid simply needs to pick himself up by his own bootstraps. Guantanamo is a part of America. America is full of equal opportunity for all. the City on the Hill. A thousand Points oF light. New World Order. Gooder service. Is our children learning. Yes We Can.
Obama is a fraud. Impeach Obama, C Thomas, Roberts, Alito and Scalia.
retytrn in yutit retrfygygygygygygygygygygygygygygygygygygygygygygy
Probably not. See the Bradley Manning case for clarification. I’m about to unregister as a Democrat.
This is why you can’t let these people go. The fucking tell on you. Every. Damn. Time.
Now the CIA has to waste resources finding him and killing him.
/Cheney/Obama/BushCo/Rahm/AnyoneInOurGovernment
I can’t see how Obama can faithfully execute the duties of his office if he does not. I don’t see how he has a choice in such matters. If he refuses to act as President, why in the world does he want four more years?
‘Saudi Arabia has denied him return to join his parents…he doesn’t know where he belongs.’ Displaced and in Limbo. Poor man.
Thanks for making us bear witness, Jeff.
“At the time of his release, a Pentagon spokesman gave the Reuters the U.S. mea culpa regarding the teen’s incarceration — they thought he was 16 years old, and not 14″
Well, THAT makes all the difference in the world: they thought they were torturing a 16-year-old, not a 14-year-old.
There are times when my government makes my flesh crawl, and this is one of them.
Damn, this kid has really had a rough life. It really puts things in perspective when you read things like this. Thanks for the story.
“After his release, Gharani told the Miami Herald that after Barack Obama became president, his treatment did not get any better, including being beaten by a rubber baton and tear-gassed. During the years of his detention, he was subjected to solitary confinement, sleep deprivation, stress positions, and suspension from his wrists at least 30 times.”
Where’s my CHANGE I CAN BELIEVE IN(TM)? Can I get a refund or something?
Jeff, I hadn’t heard of this story yet.
I’m as cynical as most, but every new story of an individual I hear wrenches my stomach yet again.
Thanks for continuing your work on this depressing but essential subject.
Oy.
Now what exactly is the USG doing in Pakistan and why? Meanwhile, the US (2008 report), European countries and the Chinese government are doing a sizable amount of oil and other resource extraction in Chad, and, if are Chadian you are good enough to work in Saudia Arabia but you can never become a citizen? Seems like a geo-political recipe for problems.
yah, and someday despite all his trials and tribulations he is destined to become a millionaire who lives the American dream. That’s what happens to all people who have had a rough life…we just work our way up the pay scale.
sickening…and in my humble opinion a symptom of a sick and dying society.
Obama and Holder were for trials in Federal courts before they were against them. What is it that the public isn’t supposed to see and hear?
New Nation by Mark Fiore (video, Apr. 6, 2011).
More semi-secret prisons in Afghanistan:
http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20110408/ap_on_re_as/as_afghanistan_gray_sites
(They hate us because we’re free.)
Torture is a War Crime PROSECUTE! I hope they pick up ‘W’ when he goes to Switzerland, even if he’s trying to escape the collapse of the U.S. by heading to a Swiss Chalet. Those lifer dogs down there in GITMO aren’t doing anything to defend this country, or keep it safe. Of course they’d be afforded a standard Nuremberg defense. GITMO is a big waste of time, and money; nothing there can’t be done at Rooseveldt Roads Puerto Rico. Fartblossom khaki klad kocksucker Army/Al CIA da shitbirds need a congressional austerity budget awakening.
Sometimes it’s just very difficult to even breathe.
Andy Worthington has this up now:
On Guantánamo and Torture, Campaigners Send A Letter to the Justice Department: “US Democracy is in Far Sorrier Shape Than We Feared”; Andy Worthington; 4/8/11
Scott Horton writes about that, here:
More on JSOC’s Secret Prisons in Afghanistan; Scott Horton; 4/8/11
Among the 64 children reported at Guantanamo, a younger prisoner was Mohammed Ismail Agha, aged 12 or 13, as reported on page 157 of Michael Haas, “George W. Bush: War Criminal? The Bush Administration’s Liability for 269 War Crimes” (Praeger 2009). The book documents approximately 100 war crimes in the treatment of prisoners of which 25 are about the mistreatment of children.
Thank you, Michael, for your comment, and your work. I will certainly check out your book. I had not known the number of children was as high as 64. I am familiar with the case of Mohammed Ismail Agha. He was held with three other young minors at Camp Iguana, the only three youths held at this facility specially built for holding juveniles. The rest of the minors were held in the other facilities, Camp Delta, etc.
Camp Iguana was Gitmo’s version of Potemkin village, but for kids. Even so, Ismail and the other kids were kidnapped and kept incommunicado from their families for a year or so. Some in their families presumed they were dead. Others spent all their money searching for their children.
I recently wrote about some of this in an article by Jason Leopold and myself at Truthout about Col. Larry James, former chief psychologist for the interrogation group at Gitmo:
Do you have a rendition location in your neighborhood? Ask questions. Find out. Put up a notice on your local neighborhood association, website, newsletters and membership name tags: “We Are Black Site Free Since April 2011!”
Have a jail or prison in your neighborhood? Find out how to close it. Boost housing, food, education and social justice programs. Starve jails. Can your neighborhood association say “Jail and Prison Free Since April 2011″?
The Department of Defense has maintained for some time that it considers someone an adult who is age 16 or older.
The Convention on the Rights of a Child defines a child as someone under the age of 18.