I won’t rant. There are times when pain is too profound to even weep, but I admit that even this is not one of them.
I won’t go crazy about the idiotic announcement in the New York Times that contained additional unrelated ‘news’ s that turned the piece into one baffling and discordant jumble.
Nor will rattle on about the double-speak military spokesman Lt. Col. Stewart Upton was quoted as gurgling, or the chain of communication that led to a promise of ‘an apology’.
This is the time of the Taliban spring offensive, and someone called in some Taliban threats, some helicopters apparently responded. Maybe. Or were they drones? Accounts differ; it’s war, after all, and very foggy.
What we do seem to know is that ‘a mistake’ was made; one in which a bomb or bombs hit the ‘wrong house’ again, and a woman and five children were killed. Three girls and two boys.
We don’t know their ages, or what they loved to do in life, what they feared. Did the boys help tend the family sheep and goats up in the hills? Did they want to learn soccer and dream of becoming national heroes one day? Was their father still living, and did he tell them stories at night before they slept? Tales of cunning animals or legends of great bravery about their kinsmen?
Did the girls want to be like their mama, perhaps sing and weave and bake as she perhaps did so wonderfully well? Were they eager to grow up more quickly like so many children? Did the younger ones trail behind their elder sister out in the fields to watch the snowmelt coming down from the mountains, leaving flowers in its wake? Did they pick the flowers an take them home to mama, or perhaps stick them in their hair so they would feel beautiful? Did they love dressing up for weddings and village celebrations?
We may never know anything much about them save for the fact that their deaths were ‘a mistake’ by US forces. I can almost hope their husband and father was no longer alive; when a child dies, half a parent’s life often dies with them. Five gone? It doesn’t bear imagining.
But at least we can see this photo of two wee ones being held in a quilt while villagers look on in love and concern, as few of the men gaze in to the bed of the pickup where the other four bodiespresumably lie.
Yes, weep for them and their loved ones who treasured them and taught them; they will never see them grow up. At least we know they once lived and died. And even though the Times didn’t tell us so, we know that on the same May 5, 14 other civilians were killed and six others wounded in another ISAF airstrike in Badgis Province.
We may never discover anything about them, either: not their names, genders or dreams, nor whether the military admits their deaths were ‘mistakes’. Did any of them have any idea why ten and a half years of war had been rained down on them by the United States of America?
Light a candle for them please, in your hearts if not in fact. Perhaps you would them in your hearts for at least as long as Sweet Honey sings of children and our ancestors’ prayers and dreamings.
Love and treasure all the people you can; build community and share knowledge…and maybe some food you’ve prepared; nothing is more loving than that.
“For each child that’s born a morning star rises and sings to the universe…who we are…we are One.”



38 Comments

I don’t know how to respond. I looked at the photo. The curve of that little child’s cheek reminded me of my granddaughter Emma. How would I respond, if it had been her? How can we allow this to continue, this murder of children and grandchildren?
There was a hue and cry over travon martin, yet here you can here spiders chirp louder…
until the phoniness is gone from our hearts, the murder will continue
Look again; I’m pretty sure it’s two wee ones. Doubly evocative and painful.
Wish I had anything smart to say about how we stop this, OmAli. But somehow we have to. Clearly, with each dead child we welcome more hate into the world as well.
Thank you for reading, and for caring, and for seeing your grandchild in the child’s face in the photo. We are one, and more of us need to understand that, don’t we?
I’m having that white space/dead air thing that you mentioned over on my diary, wendydavis. The perpetual knot in my stomach just gets a little tighter as I read about five children killed and formal apologies and floods and snow melt and improvised bombs and lah de dah, another roundup of events in that far off place that we all don’t want our soldiers flying off to much longer. I console myself by thinking about Dick Lugar.
Rec’d, of course.
Nice to meet you a little bit, afterthought. Outrage can take the place of dedication to truth and justice too often, but I’ll breeze on by my thoughts on that disconnect in the Librul blogosphere just now.
I go a little bit into something akin to temporary autism over events like this, and I kept hearing ‘when will they ever learn’ and ‘when will we ever learn’; of course it was here. I reckoned two songs might be overkill.
Thanks for being here, my friend.
We are implicated by proxy in too much death. And we have gotten way too used to it. Heartbreaking story. Rec’d anyway.
Carol, it’s gremlins – you have to remove the
& n b s p ;
from the HTML version of the post, they are verry sneaky
Pretty sure hfc was echoing my comment on her Kelly Thomas post re: staring blankly at the white space in the comment box, hoping words might come.
“LASHKARGAH/QALA-I-NAW (PAN): A mother and her five children were among 20 civilians killed in two separate airstrikes ”
Why would, and how could, anybody continue to believe in the nonsense and endless tragedy of war?
So heartbreaking I am at a loss for words. I cannot get the photo out of my mind.
rec’d.
Now ‘the flowers’ aren’t even much at risk; Mechanized War. But mebbe it was helicopters; didn’t even know they could drop bombs.
Wiped out a whole box o’ tissues today; hope it’s clear enough to see the Milky Way tonight; fucking-A: do I need some perspective. Weeping, endorphins, all that aside.
Keep thinkin’ we’re on the verge of another sea-change of consciousness, but today, it’s hard to sustain. Tomorrow we can kick back again, yes?
Stick this in the ‘lest we forget or get used to it’ column. And thanks, dear, for the ‘anyway rec’.
Hard to keep Bearing Witness, but we need to, don’t we?
I have to watch the Milky Way online; too much light pollution here. But it still helps. I imagine this must be a little like what you see from your backyard – if you could hold still long enough. :)
I haven’t been crying; it has manifested as that knot I mentioned, and a very clenched jaw. Tomorrow I am going to try to avoid outrage and sorrow, just for a day. Maybe.
Thank you, my dear, but I was indeed making a reference to wendy’s comment about the other “mistake” I wrote about. There are no shortage of “mistakes” to bear witness to.
Your question stands best as rhetorical, dear C-S, so I won’t list the nine mechanisms at play off the top off my head.
Wish we could make the Masters of War look at the photo alternating with ones of their children and grandchildren for a few hours. Would they see? Do they have the bit of residual self-examination to see? (More rhetorical questions, but…probably not)
‘All the money you’ve made…will never buy back your souls.’
i can not stand this kind of news anymore…need a break from the intertubes….France must show Merka the way to LEAVE AfGOREistan
when the Xtians went to “liberate”the holy land during the crusades,blood was measured to be waist high on the gated cities….
It looks like a gorgeous video. Yosemite is awesome, but soooo crowded, and my stars: the speed the traffic travels, as though there isn’t a wonder to see every 200 yards! Thank you; I’ll watch on the morrow, as I think I’ll be more ready to enjoy it.
The rage and the grief are different sides of the coin; I go through both, depending how cerebral v. emotionally personal an event is, or strikes me at the time.
Sleep well, dream well, my friend.
Can France help stop the rain, sadlyyes? Still more drones dropping bombs in Pakistan, Somalia…Yemen….such a list.
UnHoly Wars. But you have me thinkin’ about Saladin…
Take your break, dear one, and come back restored; we need you.
“We are not THOSE men. I am not THOSE men. I am Saladin.”
–Saladin, accepting the surrender of the Christians at Jerusalem, 1187, explaining why he could be trusted not to massacre all of the inhabitants as had happened in 1099 when the Christians took the same place.
Saladin was a Kurd, you know. And a truly honorable man, too. We need his ilk now.
I think he would have liked Harry Truman. Obama? Not so much.
Thank you for bringing the good Saladin quote, Babarian. If I had ever known he was a Kurd, I’d forgotten, but such a beacon of a ruler. Imagining him likin’ Harry brought me a needed smile; thanks for that, too.
Love to T; keep some for yourself, and sleep well.
wd
I am lighting a candle in my heart tonight for those who died from this unspeakable insanity. The photo was almost too much to bear. my mind saw baby Ja in the murdered child nearest the camera.
Really appreciated the descriptive paragraphs you created to remind us all that they were essentially like any of us.
It is all so evil and so wrong. May we have the wisdom and strength to do all that we can to end this obscenity.
‘Ja’ made me tear up again; he has that bit of slant to his little eyes, doesn’t he? Like his mum.
Thank you for caring for them, and get some sleep. The night sky here was lovely, and Venus hanging in the west toward the horizon looked soft as silk.
Nite, nite, dear. I’m for bed.
xoxo
Weep, light a candle, console each other. None of this will stop the drone attacks by obama.
I know you all feel badly about this as do I. I not only feel sad and sick to my stomach, but enraged.
We need to take to the streets, we need to mobilize millions of people to march upon washington.
I’m tired of hearing how sad everyone is. That is not going to accomplish anything.
I hate obama, I hate his policies, I hate that he’s a fraud and always has been, and I hate that he’s a killer.
I’m ready – ready to march. We have to do something other than commisserate.
Karen
Wow. Really evocative. After a decade of “oops” … it’s almost like these incidents have lost their ability to shock – although certainly not to disturb. But either reaction (which many posts highlighting these screw-up attacks often engender) seem to jump the gun past a moment of simple respect – maybe even a eulogy – and bothering to know of the people we’re gunning down by mistake on some sort of human level. Or something. Anyhow. I really like this one.
Now, Chica, I certainly hope you are exaggerating about your rate of surprisingly-soft tree byproduct consumption. Don’t forget to unplug and watchout for yourself .. especially if Mr. Stardust is under a different sky. Get out and visit the sun for a bit (or maybe even for a while).
In one of the predictably triumphalist posts at DKos about the reported intelligence success in thwarting an Al Qaeda bomb plot, the diarist wrote, without irony,
The answer is, What?
Obama will not demonstrate that he has a handle on terrorism (much less “terror”) until he renounces the absurdity of waging “war” on it.
He will not demonstrate that he has a handle on terrorism until he acknowledges, and acts upon, the fact that one does not bomb terrorists out of existence, one bombs them into existence.
He will not demonstrate that he has a handle on terrorism until he stops bolstering the recruitment efforts of thugs by flattering them as world-historical warriors.
He will not demonstrate that he has a handle on terrorism until he recognizes that the less contempt he invites — by, just most recently, incinerating a mother and her five children — the smaller the pool of contempt from which seeds of violent reaction may emerge.
(My longer comment from 2007 on these points still applies but deserves expansion to cover the new outrages that Obama is perpetrating and his supporters obliviously cheer.)
Yes, when bearing witness is all you can do, you must do at least that.
“Weep, light a candle, console each other. None of this will stop the drone attacks by obama.”
No, it won’t directly help, karenb. But it’s what’s left, imo. But even David Graeber points out, “But hey; they’ve got the 101st Airborne, so we have to be smarter than they are”, or something close.
So what do we have that’s much better than moral suasion and telling the truth about what’s really going on? If we’re to provoke massive uprising, it will take personalizing some of the killings, personalizing: foreclosures brought due to fraudulent lending, deaths from not having access to medical care, lost pensions and economic futures, police state injuries and incarcerations, the wage race to the bottom brought to us by off-shoring and union-smashing, etc. by the MOTUs…on and on.
We can look at charts all day to see how Bernanke’s quantitative easings and Twists solely benefited the big banks, but when the *results* of all that get spun into stories, that’s when they can have some traction with those who haven’t awakened yet, and still find false safe harbor in the same old propaganda.
These are the same reasons that there was a total press blackout during the first Gulf War; why returning body bags weren’t permitted to be shown. Nor are stories like this allowed to be known except by a few of us who hunt them down. Do you think that the Times will tell us of the second ‘oops’ that killed the other 16 civilians unless the story gets out widely? Or that the military will give their strained uncaring apologies or pay their blood money to the families?
Our jobs as diarists who support non-violent revolution is to provoke enough outrage to get them into the streets, and, imo, for many it begins with connecting the dots.
This diary is one dot, karenb. The tags may bring others searching the web to read it, and hit them viscerally hard enough to piss them off, and decide to kick back against this insanity. I went a grabbed a diary link again, and scrolled through the comments. The now-banned RADumas put up these lyrics to a Pink Floyd song I’d never heard (nor did I ever listen to the band), but in a nutshell it makes the connection I’m trying to make:
“Us and Them
And after all we’re only ordinary men
Me, and you
God only knows it’s not what we would choose to do
Forward he cried from the rear
And the front rank died
And the General sat, as the lines on the map
Moved from side to side
Black and Blue
And who knows which is which and who is who
Up and Down
And in the end it’s only round and round and round
Haven’t you heard it’s a battle of words
The poster bearer cried
Listen son, said the man with the gun
There’s room for you inside
Down and Out
It can’t be helped but there’s a lot of it about
With, without
And who’ll deny that’s what the fighting’s all about
Get out of the way, it’s a busy day
And I’ve got things on my mind
For want of the price of tea and a slice
The old man died”
Hope it helps your understanding in some way; many of us want what you do.
I’m so glad you liked it, my dear friend; and yes: a bit of a eulogy-by-wondering, to give the dead some humanity. In cases like this, sometimes I remember Lenny Bruce saying that the only truly obscene four-letter word he knew was: DEAD. It fits like a glove here, and in so many other stories. Made a longer attempt at it here; kinda too bad Seaton and Larue had to take issue with the post due to the confusion from which I couldn’t talk them down, but…here it is anyway. I spent a couple days trying to find out who this boy might have been, how he might have spoken, his family’s tribal customs, all that.
And really, after hfc’s videos of Kelly Thomas being beaten to death by police while 50 people stood by, and reading this new story at OpedNews, I bailed for the day. Patched the bed quilt (terrible job, tugging all that fabric through the sewing machine, lol!), got the wood in, fed the birds, did some gardening, tra la la…took a nap, got up…and found I couldn’t *not& write it. And so it goes; best laid plans and all that… ;o)
Yeah, runnin’ low on soft-trees, but Mr. wendydavis will be home on Saturday night. He can always get me more; no surfeit of hard stories, and I’m…sorta a wimp between bouts of killer outrage, lol!
Thank you oodles, kgb. I’ve come to depend on your sensibilities, but goddam I hate it when we disagree. You can best me in an argument with one hemisphere tied behind your back, I swear. Thank gawd I love ya.
p.s. yep; they was Puffs, soo soft. ;o)
p.p.s. Love it when ya call me ‘Chica’. ‘nother: ;o)
Both comments were spot on, ralphbon, though the longer one is so well-thought put and well-constructed. Worth a diary, really.
But as far as I can tell by now, the whole notion of ‘The War on Terror’, is a giant con game, so these murders have become a feature, not a bug. Seems that they have to know that they are creating more enemies, not less, and it allows them maneuvering room for staying longer. Same with torture, really, and rendition; plenty of Generals and former CIA biggies tell them what’s so, but they are not to be dissuaded: they are on an Unholy Mission from God. Their gods are: Profit and Power. They don’t give a crap about public opinion when Obama can gargle his lies about ‘winding the war down’ and ‘using that money to’ yada, yada…
You bring up a point that I’d forgotten, and it used to irk the crap outta me: painting, say, the Republican Guard as ‘world-class warriors’ to make shock-and-awe spent-uranium, etc. destruction a necessary endeavor. But you’re taking it one step further to the pride factor of fighting The Great Satan; nice job, I hadn’t considered it.
Sorry to hear, but not surprised, that commenters at Kos would engage in such unholy blather, though I don’t grok the folks here who assail Obama endlessly, but rue the fact that they’ll just have to vote for him anyway. Does.Not.Compute.
Anyhoo, thanks, ralphbon.
And we hope the witnessing will spread, more citizens awaken, and we can do plenty more (she waxed hopefully).
You’re up early, dear; hope you’re getting stronger every day. We need you up to snuff, armed with your edginess. ;o)
thanks
welcome, mafr.
wendydavis–
Thank you for this very powerful and touching diary. (Truthfully, I often avoid reading diaries when the topic is “the ravages of war,” because I just can’t handle knowing that this is done in our names).
I’m always left wondering how a population of people (such as those in Iraq, Afghanistan, Pakistan, etc., etc.–in other words, all the many countries that we bomb in the name of “peace”) even functions, considering that vast numbers surely must suffer from the most severe form of PTSD. All I can say is, “God bless them all . . .”
Highly recommended.
Blue
Interesting how murder becomes “mistakes” in these dirty wars.
Iraq will never recover, in all likelihood. Won’t drag you down further with what it’s like there now that we’ve fooked its land and people over so totally…but the depleted uranium is taking an enormous toll by now, and will for a long, long time. Tragic. In our names.
Afghanistan…the night raids will continue, the drones, the conventional bombing…at least the areas are vast, so some may escape the direct fears; I just don’t know, Onyx. But the hatred directed our way must be enormous. If we ever leave, civil wars will likely become common; it never should have been called a nation.
Thanks for reading even while having a strong aversion to it. We need to be aware of some of the truth of it, even to tell others of our acquaintance.
wd
Yes, Alan Maki. Military Madness TINA cavalier bullshit thinking. Ooops; we were aiming at those other guys, ya know, the ones who hate us.
Arrggh.
Wendy, I admire and honor the size of your heart. I believe you write these posts to add awareness to acts of war, but also to find something within you that will help you understand and cope with the crazy things that continue in far off lands.
May I pose a question? What’s that? Yes? Ok, do you believe that we are all connected? Do you believe in a universe that is created through one source? If so, something that has helped me in the terms of light years, is recognizing that it is all part of the Divine creation that we live. So, in order to calm our emotions and to ramp up the heart to a more sustained / helpful frequency, I BLESS these acts, just like the massacre of 10,000 Rawandans, I shift in my heart the emotion of blessing those that have killed….those that have created such wrath….I bless them, I do not agree with their actions, but I bless them, giving off a softer change within me, which to me is healthier.
Also a side note, there was a study done in 1993 done by the Institute for Heart Math, that said there was a field of energy around the heart that we can measure. It also said that emotions, can relax the helix nature of DNA as well as pain and the other emotions such as anger, which contracts the DNA making your immune system weaker.
Bottom line, our emotion changes our DNA, and in other studies our DNA changes the matter of the world in which we live.
Never think for a moment that you aren’t changing things around you, for the heart beat of the world. You are beginning the resonance that others are starting to feel. Yes we cannot see it, but damn it woman, we can surely FEEL it, and this is on the rise.
It’s said that they can’t even measure how far this field of energy reaches…..a few miles whatever…your heart is the source, and my friend, you have one of the largest beating ones that I know.
Love on, and bless it all.
all the love.
So kind of you to offer me your wisdom, chebetts. One creator: dunno, for certain, but I do obviously think we are all connected.
It may be you’re right that I would be calmer, even healthier if I didn’t suffer so from barbarity like this. But in the end, I really don’t think I want *not* to feel it, nor indeed can I even imagine blessing it to soften its blow to myself.
Perhaps I’m fooling myself, but personalizing these deaths makes them even more objectionable, thus can often lead to further resolve to stop them. Both sorrow and anger over this stuff can be self-indulgent, and I work to avoid that, seriously. But at a number of points in my life, when offered practices that would cause me to be more detached, I chose not to be. In no way do I want to be aloof from the often needless pain and suffering from my brothers and sisters, especially if equanimity might mean I don’t help change it.
You may say it’s not what you’re advising, and maybe I just don’t get it, my friend, and that the state you advise would be more productive.
Guess for *me*, I don’t think so, for *you*, it may be so. I’m getting lost in my imagination and thoughts now, but I will say that on my death day, I will want to know that I kicked hell outta life, lol! And in my own limited fashion, I think I’m well on the way!
love to you,
wd