#S17: The first anniversary of #OWS:
“Occupy Wall Street invites you, the 99%, down to the Financial District for three days of education, celebration and resistance. (Sept. 15-17)
Join us for three days of education, celebration and resistance to economic injustice with permitted convergences and assemblies, concerts, and mass civil disobedience. (video by Dennis Trainor; his great ‘American Autumn’ video is available here.)
“On #S17 Follow the Money, All Roads Lead to Wall Street. Can’t join us in NYC? It’s just as important that we Occupy Main Street. Pick a local target that embodies corporate greed—occupy your state Capitol building like the people of Wisconsin, or a chamber of commerce conference as they did in D.C. Take inspiration from revolutionary occupations worldwide, from the railroads of India to the rivers of the Amazon to the streets of Spain. Wall Street has occupied our entire planet. What do you have to say about that?” ;o)
If you don’t care about the electoral dog-and-pony show, and are tired of those who continue to declare OWS dead and buried since the security state has clamped down so hard that encampments on The Commons aren’t possible now, you will be pleased to know that a lot is still going on in the shadows, and more is planned. Many more events are at the various Occupy aggregator websites, even arrests and raids that we don’t hear about.
September and October hold high potential for a new round of actions to Fight the Machine. You will likely remember the October 2011 coalition Margaret Flowers and Kevin Zeese worked so hard to organize before a scheduled occupation of Washington D.C. in that month, that year.
As joss would have it, that event was completely upstaged by those crazy, wonderful kids who said, “Enough of this shit!”, and headed to Zucotti Park on September 17, 2011, the impatient rascals. ;o) Now their organization is another aggregator site for protests and activism, as well as other endeavors to re-imagine an America future that is 99%-friendly . These are a few bits from their recent newsletter. Downthread I’ll fill you in on some reformist organizations and coalitions that have formed to either challenge or make end runs around the current machine, imagine new business models, etc.
Here are some highlights of some of the many Occupy activities that are going on around the country. There is more information on October2011.org, as well as at the other links.
CNN reports that there are 86 million unemployed…and explains how that number is true.
First, we encourage you to start organizing now to join in “Occupy the Debates: The People’s Dialogue,” which seeks to demonstrate the disconnect between the presidential candidates of the two corporate parties and the people of the United States whom they are supposed to represent. Occupy Denver, the site of the first debate (October 3), has started to organize and we urge occupations throughout the country to join in. Among the activities being planned are canvassing the community to hear their views, teach-ins, truth-telling sessions, general assemblies and conferences to discuss issues of concern and possible solutions.
Second, trade advisers for the notorious secret trade agreement being negotiated by the Obama administration, the TransPacific Partnership, will meet in Leesburg, Virginia from September 6th to 15th. Occupiers and advocacy groups are working together to put a spotlight on this agreement which amounts to a Global Corporate Coup. The TPP will set the rules for international business dealings for the foreseeable future and gives transnational corporations more power than governments.
To learn more about the TPP and events, register for the @StopTPP call on Monday, August 20 at 9 pm eastern time on InterOccupy.net. There will be events outside of the meeting to educate the public about this trade agreement and actions to let the trade advisers know that the public opposes the TPP. The Backbone Campaign will hold a direct action training for Occupy the TPP on Sept. 8 and 9 in Baltimore, Maryland. If you want to participate, contact info@october2011.org.
A student strike was announced in Quebec A13-A17 and the first ever call for a Global Day of student strikes is being planned for October 18th and November 14th-21st.
Join Occupy SEC and get involved in keeping the pressure on calling for criminal investigations of the big banks for their security fraud and the LIBOR scandal.
On Thursday TransCanada began construction on the Southern leg of the Keystone XL pipeline in Cushing, OK. Activists protested in Oklahoma and Texas; you can look at the Tar Sands Blockade website for future actions and solidarity protests and blockades; they say they won’t quit.
“TransCanada is putting families that wanted nothing to do with this pipeline in harm’s way,” Tar Sands Blockade Spokesperson Ron Seifert said. “Since our leaders and representatives will do nothing to protect our friends and neighbors, the Tar Sands Blockade is calling for people everywhere to join us and defend our local communities from a multinational bully.”
The message remains clear, people across the political spectrum, from Tea Partiers to environmentalists are uniting to TransCanada that while this project has started, we will ot allow it to be finished.”
““If there were ever a moment to take a stand, this is it. Everyone who cares about the future owes these Texans a debt,” said Bill McKibben at grist.org.”
You can read the rest here, and decide how to parse the contradictory things he follows with…(never mind).
I’ve followed some blind leads trying to put this together, and as you know, there are plenty of populist-looking groups fronting for the 1%. Consider this headline: “Labor Launching America’s Second Bill of Rights” (Workers Stand for America conference on August 11, 2012). Sounds intriguing, right? But here’s what I found after the description of the bits about ‘listing as rights things like full employment, a living wage, full participation in the political process, a voice at work, quality education, and a secure and happy future’, etc.:
“Labor leaders say there is no contradiction between labor’s renewed determination to stake out its own independent position and its support for President Obama’s reelection campaign.
AFL-CIO Executive Vice President Arlene Holt Baker said unions and “all working families really have two jobs this November. The first is to defeat right wing politicians who want to end collective bargaining rights, who want to keep outsourcing every good job in America and who want to divide and conquer working people.”
She noted that the AFL-CIO’s decision to deploy 400,000 union volunteers for the election was proof of the labor movement’s seriousness in this regard.”
NOTE: When launching his new organization, Richard Trumka had said that it was to be a labor movement, you know: ‘independent of Democrats’. Bah!
But moving along…and please feel free to add other working groups/workshops; there are so many out there:
~ The writers at Black Agenda Report have spotlighted an organization called the Black Is Back Coalition for Social Justice, Peace and Reparations whose annual conference is meeting today and tomorrow to discuss whether or not voting can bring social and economic justice to blacks:
“Most of us greeted the election of Barack Obama with hope and excitement in the U.S. and around the world. However, since his election the U.S. continues to make war and threats of war against people in the Middle East and elsewhere. Also, the issues of jobs, the economic quarantine of our communities, police violence and mass incarceration are not even being addressed during the current presidential election campaign.”
~ At Common Dreams, Abby Sher has a post up about the New Economy Institute (formerly the Schumacher Society):
“With the help of the London-based New Economics Foundation, the Schumacher Society rethought what kind of “think and do” tank is needed to transform our fossil fuel-powered, finance-bloated, inegalitarian economy into one that is resilient, just, and sustainable in the environmental and economic transition given true urgency by climate change. And with the help of some deep pockets, it re-launched as NEI and pulled together, all in one place on Bard’s rural campus on the Hudson, some of the thinkers and organizers who might have a piece of the puzzle.” (foxes turned game-keepers?) ;o)
Shur says that the New Economy is a big tent, and offers some concern that these white and middle class academics might share leadership with the poor immigrants, progressive unions, and co-ops, but acknowledges that a massive change to the US political economy will take many hands on deck to offer alternatives to create just and sustainable paths for the future. Her headings are:
Beyond Growth and Finance; Solidarity and Division (my fave); Slow Money; American Sustainable Business Association; B-Corporations.
Speaking of the overlaps of the NEI and the Solidarity Economy (‘Mondragon Diaries’ are at the site), Sher says:
“Critical here is a common progressive platform. It should embrace a profound commitment to social justice, job creation, and environmental protection; a sustained challenge to consumerism and commercialism and the lifestyles they offer; a healthy skepticism of growth mania and a democratic redefinition of what society should be striving to grow; a challenge to corporate dominance and a redefinition of the corporation, its goals and its management and ownership; a commitment to an array of prodemocracy reforms in campaign finance, elections, the regulation of lobbying; and much more. A common agenda would also include an ambitious set of new national indicators beyond GDP to inform us of the true quality of life in America.”
~ It’s Our Economy (Zeese, Flowers, et.al.) has good links, good events and actions.
Gar Alperovitz’s site is here; He and Richard Wolf discuss Economic Democracy here.
Don Milligan wrote a good piece at the Anticapitalist Initiative called ‘Flogging a Dead Horse’. He wrote it as a counter-argument to the prevalent opinion among ACI members that it’s *disarray*, or *disunity* among factions that is responsible for the British public to be so turned off to socialism. Among his arguments for rethinking a new socialism is:
“…people do not believe in the abolition of private property. Enormous numbers of working people in the middle class and in the working class have worked hard to buy their houses, to maintain their mortgages, to improve their houses and flats, with endless trips to B & Q and thousands of hours of unpaid labour; they work tirelessly to conserve their savings, and pay into their pension pots. Indeed, this is why they are so outraged by the theft of pension funds, by the manipulation of interest rates, by tax evaders, and freeloaders on the welfare system. Most working class people, and tens of millions of middle class people, have what they perceive to be a vested interest in the protection of private property from the depredations of common criminals and ‘nefarious entities’ like local councils, the state, and big capitalists.”
He said that right, imo.
~ From Workers Action (‘Who We Are’ page):
“Our aim above all is to encourage working people to unite and put up a fight in order to defend and improve our standard of living and to create a far more just, rational, and economically viable economy to replace capitalism, which has thrown billions of people into poverty and is destroying the planet.
This means that we are encouraging our individual unions to fight to improve our standard of living, as opposed to accepting concessions passively. We encourage unions to unite in coalitions in order to fight concessions and win demands by, for example, placing “tax the rich” measures on ballots in order to fully fund public education and social services. We encourage the unions and community groups to join with the Occupy Movement to demand concessions from the 1 percent. We strongly support the Occupy Movement’s coming to the defense of unions engaged in struggles with their employers. And we strongly encourage all working class organizations to join together in a united front in order to mobilize massive numbers of working people in huge demonstrations and other mass actions to win these demands. The larger the movement, the greater our prospects for success.”
“Give us grace and strength to forebear and persevere. Give us courage and gaiety and the quiet mind. Spare to us our friends and soften to us our enemies. Give us the strength to encounter that which is to come, that we may be brave in peril, constant in tribulation, temperate in wrath and in all changes of fortune, and down to the gates of death, loyal and loving to one another.”
~Robert Louis Stevenson
Stay strong; this is indeed a marathon, not a sprint. Love and take care of one another: generous spirits are indomitable.
(cross-posted at kgblogz.com)



54 Comments

Great diary Wendy, done with your usual thoroughness and due dilligence.
I just posted my last comment at Janets diary, check it out you might get a chuckle out of it. My nonscientific poll determined that cats are twice as popular as voting in the coming election.
LOL!
Our hopes for the future are intertwined with those of the Occupy movement and similar anti-corporatist resistance groups.
Rec’d
Occupy Everywhere…! Congrats, wendy, on being front paged…! And, mahalo for all those links…! ;-)
The democracy movement holds all my hopes at this point, Scrabbleddie.
Thanks for reading (pretty long altogether). ;o) Some might say: 2L2R, lol!
Mahalo, Tuttle; Occupy Hilo!
(Eeeek…and me in my nightshirt…) ;oP
Seriously good things going on out there; so many of the links have leads to other progressive economics and models. Too much to learn, I swear. But I’d reckoned I might create a piece that folks might book mark for future reference. (It was hard to know when to quit wid the info.) ;o)
What’s Going On…?
The TTP is some serious BS…! We’re talking about a Global screw job to 99ers everywhere…! 8-(
Had a friend in California who thought they were called ‘Haulin’ Oats’, lol! As in Great Plains grain truckers; I loved it.
Yeah, TTP. I…er…was a little on the mouthy side when I wrote about it back in November. (Need my mouth washed out with soap, I reckon. But I was furious!) (As though it’s not obvious…) ;o)
And yes; the citizens in the signatory nations will be messed up, and no recourse to sue multinationals under the law, as far as I understand it.
An X-file, though: To go find the post, I stuck ‘my fdl wendydavis’ into a Bing bar, and the sole drop-down suggestion was: ‘Pacific Rim’. Doo doo doo dooo…
Sleep well, dear. Or are you just getting up? ;o)
We’re talking about maybe the beginning of history and a renaissance? The “Global screw job” began in the mid-1970′s with the de-industrialization in the US and the simultaneous shift to finance as the economic basis, followed by outsourcing of labor. That’s when ‘dependence’ on foreign labor and resources also began (Hondas, Datsuns, cheap steel, etc.) The 1980′s made insurgency and warfare necessary — the peasants were either eliminated or enslaved to assist the ‘free trade’ markets. The 1990′s enabled the IMF and World Bank to indenture entire countries and societies through (what credit card banks call ‘Balance Transfer’ without irony), inflating the famous bubbles in the finance economies. At the same time, these finance economies waged permanent warfare to try to eliminate the remaining insurgency.
First, the labor unions had to be destroyed and the working class re-indentured, and that’s what began in the 1970′s.
(I’m currently reading Jefferson Cowie’s Stayin’ Alive: The 1970s And The Last Days Of The Working Class.)
I would like for OWS to become more educated in regard to how the commodity markets are connected to Wall Street.
While I’m knowledgeable about the commodity markets, I didn’t know how connected they were to “big money” Wall Street. All of this commodity market manipulation began to occur after that connection was made.
Go to this website http://wp.me/p2vRlu-4
Thanks Wendy. Recommended. At least I am not alone if there are 86 million other unemployeds out there, not that I would wish this condition on anybody. In the CNN article they wrote:
“The truth is, the Labor Department simply doesn’t know why they’re not in the labor force.”
My opinion is that the Labor Department has been advised not even to report that they are not in the labor force, much less to guess why they are not in the labor force.
Great Post. Thanks again.
I assume you mean post-CFMA?
Part of Dodd-Frank (I think it was) was supposed to have made manipulation a lesser burden to prove, but I’m sincerely losing faith in regulators as a serious force in crime-stopping.
There’s been a financial working group at OWS-NY working on financial regulations that might neutralize regulatory arbitrage, etc., and the fun part is that a couple of former women from JP Morgan are making it happen. One was a quant there, the other, I think…invented interest-rate derivatives. (Can’t recall their names right now; Cathy and not-Blythe, lol.)
You could google for the working group reports they’re working on. But most of the study groups are looking at larger changes to banking than just tighter regs; more like banks as public utilities, and state owned.
Mr.wd found this theory at one of the links I stuck in; pretty interesting.
Oh, and this piece at NC, too, you might want to read.
Wendy, I thought you and your readers might like to know that they can listen to Occupy Radio, at 6:30 PM, weeknights, Eastern Standard Time on WBAI.org radio online. They also archive all of the Occupy Radio programs online in case there is a program or an action or a training that people want to find out about. Their goal is to spread information and links to more information to their listeners.
Sorry: actually it is called Occupy Wall Street Radio:
Here is a link to WBAI.
wendy — clearly the Resistance and Revolution continue as you amply document. Thanks for assembling all of that useful information.
As for Zeese and Flowers, meh. They’re too authoritarian for my hot blood, but at the same time they can provide a dose of coherence that is sometimes hard to find among the dispersed Occupy remnants.
The most productive work during the fluorescence of the Occupy movement was the development of alternative social and economic models. That was the scariest thing about Occupy for the PTB, and it my view, the development and showcasing of alternatives precipitated the official violence used against the Occupations.
Development of alternatives is still going on, and the ideas generated in the development process are spreading. That’s the key to building a better future.
Ah, shoot; did I know you’re out of work, TomThumb? Bugger; how long? Hope you’re at least getting compensation.
That CNN number is even larger than the Shadow Stats guy’s numbers. Dept. of Labor has those six categories, but even then…the U-3 doesn’t seem close to describing the conditions out here in the Real World, does it?
The ‘jobs added’ stats don’t seem close, either, from what economists say about seasonal, temp, part-time, wage totals, etc. But when the financial pages gloat: Productivity Up!!!…you know something’s sick.
Ooops; looks like I forgot to say: ‘cross-posted at’ again…but please: contact me a http://www.kgblogz.com; I (almost) always have an extra small bit of $ from the cards I make and sell, and it’s all for giving away. (Hippie tithing theory) We can swap addresses.
Welcome, ChePasa, and I agree with all you say. Zeese and Flowers: they’ve been put in the awkward and unenviable position of being relevant to the Occupy movement, playing catch-up in a way. The fire the youth have brought is incalculably beneficial; the Oldsters can help in the ways they are now helping the study groups and parallel movements and organizations.
I’d be interested to know what you (or anyone here) thinks of Ian Welsh’s new piece; I’m with his frequent commenter Raven on this one, not that I don’t understand his thinking.
October2011′s newsletter sure did save me some work; this sucker took me days to pull together even then. ;o)
Thank you, TT. ;o)
Whoa up there Wendy Davis. The Old Ones will not allow me to cause distress to other human beings and I might have to discorporate like Michael Valentine Smith in Stranger in a Strange Land, (written by Robert Heinlein) if I upset you in any way! Let’s not go there!!! It helps me to read your posts, links and realize that we can do something to turn this ship around. Carry on, WD!
Inspirational post WD, you must have been in an internet ‘sweat lodge’ to gather all this together. No, not too long, in fact, the volume of activity recharges my hope. Enough so to try to help even harder, which we’ve got to do.
This marathon doesn’t have a finish line, but the water points provide some relief, and are worth the slog. Rec’d
A while back, WD, you wrote a diary and included a video clip of a biologist (no memory for names in my head) who likened the whole of the protests around the world, to the phases of a caterpillar’s transformation into a butterfly.
I so loved how he said it. In that vein, perhaps, Occupy, is now in its cocoon – hidden from view – but where the imaginal cells are working their magic. I wondered then, playing with the idea, what the mysterious, metamorphic phase would look like within the context of our culture’s transformation. Maybe this is what it looks like? Lots and lots is going on despite the seeming “inaction”.
One thing about butterflies, is that, even with the most compassionate of hearts, should one “help” it get out of its cocoon, it will be unable to fly. It is the beating of wings against the cocoon that strengthens them for later flight.
Great links, which I intend to explore further as time permits.
Thank you, WD for all the work you do. srsly.
rec’d,
Shoot dear; I grok M. Valentine Smith; and ‘waiting is’ most of the time, but not alla the time. But ya silly, you cause me no suffering, just…sometimes a Ben Franklin (about all my pin money ever is) can arrive just at the right time, remember? Most recent one I sent to a blogging friend was replaced double by the dearest man here who ordered that many dollars worth of cards from me (*and* at his inflated prices, no less.) Theory being: keep stuff flowing out; it’ll be back when ya need it.
So do lemme know; and Mr.wd checked this week, and the store in town had sold another 12. Booyah! So all this largesse will be burnin’ a hole in my pocketses… love you ya, but…that’s wendydavis to you, son. ;o)
Oooh. Cyndi Lauper’s ‘True Colors’ is playing on my RealPlayer. Gotta love her; whoosh.
Ah, bootsie; such a memory for the wondrous you have! It was Bruce Lipton, and his spontaneous evolution theory. Here’s the video I think I used…
Epigenetics. Cellular membranes turning genes off and on…trippy stuff.
I needed to remember it all today to restore me; thank you sooooo much, dear one.
wendy — Re: Ian Welsh on the dismissal of a credible threat of revolt from the left, and what that says about the left’s dismissal of the American Revolution.
That’s a somewhat bigger topic than it may seem, so I’ll probably post something in comments over at his place in the bye and bye. But let it be said here that violence by the state, its agents, and a certain cadre of lone gunmen against the People is ongoing throughout the “Free World.” There is no armed uprising in response. Whatever armed resistance there is tends to be concentrated on the right, and I’ve long believed that if there ever is an armed revolt in this country, it will come from the right.
Be that as it may, I’m not sure what The Raven’s point is in bringing up 1789 and the French Revolution. Neither the French nor the American Revolutions were sui generis. There was a long history of revolt, civil war and revolution in Britain that led pretty much directly to the American Revolution. The success of the American Revolution helped trigger the French Revolution to be sure, but there was a long French history behind the French Revolution and its consequences. Those consequences were partly a reaction to the fact that all of Europe united to invade France and crush the Revolution and restore the Bourbons. Much the same situation obtained in Russia after the Bolshevik Revolution.
What’s going on now strikes me as being categorically different. But even if it were something like the dreaded French Revolution, the consequences wouldn’t necessarily be anything like what happened then.
So why even bring it up?
wd–
Not to disparage the “union rank and file” (’cause it’s not their fault), but unions are all but dead, now. Leaders (like Lane Kirkland, AFL-CIO) were selling out, even when I was an union steward in the ’80′s. So I wouldn’t have expected any different from Trumka.
On a bright note, thanks for info on the “Occupy the Debates.” We’re going to look into to participating in the one in Kentucky.
Recommended.
Blue
TomThumb–
Guess this is proof, that bad things seem to happen to the nicest people. Hope you find employment soon.
And thanks much for the WBAI link.
Blue
Nice comment, thanks for reminding Wendy.
We need all of our organic symbolism in order to remember and recapture the ‘original intent’ of who we are. We are not just mathematic models, despite the scientific polemic, we’re so much more.
Kind of you to say it wasn’t too long, my friend. I’d reckoned it might be a place for future references, so…it grew long, and you should see all I left out!
Sometimes I wonder if folks DO envision a finish line; I’m more about process than end product. But I admit that all the contentious diaries over voting…caused me to focus on all these next-evolution harbingers of human growth and resistance to rule by the corrupt, lawless, inhumane and amoral government that must be declared null and void…soon.
Just to let you know: I’ll vote, but *yes* on legalizing marijuana in CO, *for* a nominally Republican DA, and…dunno if there’s even a Dem I’ll vote for. ;o)
“I’ve long believed that if there ever is an armed revolt in this country, it will come from the right.” I share that view, and dread it.
I think Raven’s point was that this time we’ll have to forgo the blood since, imo, the only force that might underpin a mass uprising and resistance large enough to void the present government’s authority is a moral one, steeped in the knowledge that all of our futures matter, as does the planet’s health.
It may be that Raven read Hannah Arendt on revolution (decades ago for me) and saw the cautionary tale of Robespierre as producing limited participatory government for most citizens, and too many beheadings. Kinda reminds me of the adage about staring into the abyss foo intently and for too long, lest…
Just went and looked at your comment, and I do take your comment and its historical context as well, as worthy of more consideration. But we can’t beat them with bullets; we have to win with all the ethical force we can muster, imo. If that seems utterly naive, I understand. ;o)
I appreciate your not bringing your double barrel to my post, your bullets hurt deeply, when others bounce off.
I just hate war. I used to be a highly trained ‘kill a commie for God’ warrior who trained the ‘kill a Hajji for God’ crowd. So there is that indirect PTSD blood on my hands. I’ve got two warrior sons, 5 grandkids supported by the MIC, so am crossed purposed to assist their side effects.
Just more afraid of R than O; the sorry choice that it is. R is upper, O is lower class. O is subconsciously more caring about human lives, they’re not just R’s ‘externalities.’
That all the Dem thats really left in me. Loveya ;^)
My larger point was that Trumka, and his new group, keep making feints at pretending they ‘aren’t gonna take any more of this shit’ (quote)…and then take it. Also that the workerscompass/workersaction folks and other labor groups are forming as breakaway groups (aprescoup mentioned another one I’ve forgotten).
I may not be able to avoid writing up a current story a man named Heyden is telling as a counter-argument to what is now the *official* union history of what happened at the Port of Longview with their strikes (and Occupy solidarity) against EGT. He even made the point that some of the socialist workers groups were eager to call it a Union Win…which it was not, and he explains in detail.
Anyhoo, interesting on your labor history, but restoring worker rights is key in this struggle, especially given the nature of the crap Unfair trade bills about to become Offishull, including military presence (ours, NATOs?) in the signatory nations. Sucks.
Thank you for the good words, Blue Onyx. Personally, I am one of the lucky few and nearing early retirement age for Social Security. Being able to read posts here like this one by “wendydavis” helps tremendously.***
***Just happen to be working on a project to describe some of the many meanings people give to long-term unemployment experiences. The written, described “experiences” of people who are long-term unemployed are truly tragic, saddening and outrageous.
Well, I wouldn’t mean them to hurt, srsly. And your experiences with killing are devastatingly hard to hear, my friend. Won’t glurge on about it, lest I sound patronizing. That it makes it hard with your kids and grandkids is hard news.
But as for as O and R: O wasn’t lower class, but middle, if it matters. But he has proven he has no conscience about killing, lying, government secrecy, torture rendition…ah, well…I’ll leave out the American kids and likely Iranian, Iraqi kids…he’s killing with sanctions and austerity. I just can’t vote for him, knowing what I know. Easy decision, and it has been for years.
So…that electoral politics seem beside the point, I pin my hopes on non-violent revolution and Occupyin’. Even in Mancos, CO. (really we’re on a heat hiatus just now)
wendy — the moral argument has been made for decades, and it will continue to be made no matter what else happens. FWIW, I think there was a very strong moral argument backing the French Revolution, perhaps more of a moral argument than there was behind the American Revolution — which, from an objective standpoint, was based on pure selfishness (no Frenchy fraternité for Americans, no sir! Appeals to morality by themselves tend to be ineffective.
Ian’s point has long been that to be effective, a revolt or revolution must have a creditable threat of real harm to the Powers That Be (not necessarily bloodshed, but harm) or it will get nowhere, or as we’ve seen, it will literally be pushed ever farther backwards.
I agree with Ian that the mainstream “left” in the Free World primarily exists to prevent that credible threat from ever arising on the Left.
Notice there’s no such prohibition on the Right. In fact, threats of armed insurrection are routine on the Right. Whether they’re “credible” or not is up to you to decide, but the Right has no compunction at all about making these threats — and backing them up with private arsenals and militias. And Rightist officials and media personalities will defend them to the hilt.
Is it any wonder that their armed argument — even when they don’t actually use their armaments — prevails more than occasionally?
They have a moral argument, too, one that they piously assure us is based in Holy Scripture. Surely you don’t want to go against the Word of God, do you?
Rather than characterizing the dichotomy as left and right though, I tend to see it as one of predator and prey. The predator class — which amount to very few as a proportion of any population — has become emboldened by the perceived passivity of their prey. They see no reason to back off so long as no one and nothing stands in their way. Besides, they have what they believe is a far stronger moral argument on their side to continue on their path.
They will not stop themselves.
Oh, dear; I didn’t mean there wasn’t a strong moral argument for the French Revolution, just that in this nation, at this time, as Graeber says: ‘They have the 101st Airborne’.
And yep, Saul Alinsky said it right:
“You don’t communicate with anyone purely on the rational facts or ethics of an issue… It is only when the other party is concerned or feels threatened that he will listen — in the arena of action, a threat or a crisis becomes almost a precondition to communication… No one can negotiate without the power to compel negotiation… To attempt to operate on a good-will basis rather than on a power basis would be to attempt something that the world has not yet experienced.”
My thing is: Our Power needs to be…not killing power, but Life Affirming Power of the strongest kind. ‘Ethically impeccable’, really, or as close as we can come. I’ve been struggling with the terms ‘immoral’ and ‘amoral’ this week, and am more familiar with the lesser meaning of ‘amoral’, which I think the Predator class embodies: they don’t even *consider* right from wrong. Not to say that a few may make some pretense at religious jingoism now and again…
But yes; I go against the putative Word of God all the time. ;o)
And I think folks of similar goal all along the L/R spectrum can join forces to neutralize their Machine, which really…all the end runs around the big banks, fighting against GMO foods and seeds, grow-your-own movements, local community strengthening and job creation thru co-ops an Cleveland-like green industry, etc. shows a nascent power shift that is truly frightening, which…was in your first comment.
While I was just out doing a couple chores in the (crap) garden, I was reminded that we’ve had this discussion before, and I appreciate your easier tone this time. Srsly, dear ChePasa.
wd–
I got the larger point on Trumka. That’s his “MO.” Until several months ago, I still tuned in to anywhere from 2-6 so-called “left” radio programs on Sirius-XM satellite radio. Trumka gets on the radio with Schultz, etc., and “talks big, as though he’s going to give an ultimatum to the Dems,” and then issues a press release supporting O and the Dem Party, the next day or week.
And, no, we can’t give up on workers rights and struggles. Sort of like the Dem Party, though, I think that they’ll have to be another venue, because of corruption. The interests of the unions today, generally have little to do with the workers, and their best interests. I’ve racked my brain, and admit, I can’t imagine what “vehicle” that will be. Wish I knew.
Again, thanks for bringing “Occupy the Debates” info, to light. We’re looking into it today. May just support with contributions, but hope that we might make it to Kentucky to actually participate in Occupy. It would be a thrill–hope we get to do it.
Blue
Thank you for this post, wendy. On the TPP, on Sunday the Green Party of Aotearoa New Zealand, Australian Greens, and Green Party of Canada issued a joint statement that can be read at
http://www.scoop.co.nz/stories/PA1208/S00268/joint-statement-on-trans-pacific-partnership-agreement.htm
It is a comprehensive statement and contains the following:
“The current Australian Government has indicated it will not agree to these clauses [spelled out in the statement] intended to protect multinational businesses from the impact of policy decisions, but New Zealand’s and Canada’s leaders refuse to do the same (even after Canada was on the receiving end of costly lawsuits under NAFTA.)”
Boo to my native land and Canada on this, and goodonya, mate! to the Aussies.
Dear Wendy, with all due respect, we’re talking about political corruption at the very highest levels of government for two administrations.
When you go to this website http://wp.me/p2vRlu-4 you can see that gas never went much over $1.00 before Bush. Corn never went much over $3.00 before Bush. Those two commodities represent “food and transportation”, two necessities even poor people can not live without.
Notice how gas dropped to $1.00 a gallon in January of 09. Notice how corn dropped to $3.00 a bushel in January of 09. Notice how gas went right back up to $3.50 a gallon on the commodities market which is over $4.00 at the pump. Corn went to $8.00 a bushel in 2011, a long time before the drought. An “astronomical” amount of money went into the “market manipulators accounts”, that was your money when you paid the manipulated price for gas and food.
All of this happened twice, and don’t nobody know nothing……..
I am duly humiliated to say that I actually posted a diary on Trumka’s ‘Not Gonna Take This Shit Anymore!’. Gadz; what a burn. I was similarly jazzed about Occupy the Dream announcing as a social gospel force for Occupy. Dave De Graw’s involvement made it seem real. When the next week Glen Ford ran a column that the two ministers were preaching to their congregations that now they *seriously* had to contribute to, and knock on doors for…OBomba, I was crushed. The churches of good will should be in this struggle, and I had a document going for a time of churches saying they were in solidarity with the movement, but…they’re in the shadows.
Cool on Kentucky, I hope ya can go, but I’m sure contributions for food or other needs would be greatly appreciated it if ya can’t make it. C-S and Mason are in KY, by the by. Dunno how close to Danville.
Funny Australia would balk; we have a new base there, lol! Reckoned that was part of what it was about. Well, that, and the ‘Pivot to the South China Sea’ State Dept. announcement.
Cool site; got waylaid there for a bit.
Wouldn’t be hard to imagine that the largest protests will be at Leesburg for the *final* TPPA meetings. God, small wonder we’re seen as The Evil Landlords of the planet.
Sorry to be so late to the party. Excellent diary, wendydavis. Boy howdy, do I need some hope today and this is it. And, as usual, the commenters are so smart and I have learned stuff I didn’t know.
As for your comments directly above, the co-opters are in a gear so high you can barely even perceive it. Hang on, it’s gonna be a bumpy ride.
Well, they were above when I was typing. That was in reference to Trumka and Occupy the Dream.
Due respect received, lakota, and I’ve looked at your page several times, and understand your outrage. I just don’t know what to do about it, or any of a host of corruptions at the highest levels of our government. The 9/11 Truth, for instance.
You could get on some economics sites that allow questions and comments, post your link, and ask for feedback. Zero Hedge, New Economics Perspectives, Angry Bear, FT Alphaville, any, really. Zero Hedge has covered it; dunno that he has what you’re seeking in the way of a big megaphone.
Or ask Cathy O’Neil, the former JippyMo quant I was speaking about; she’s here, and invites questions.
Good luck; hope these help somehow.
You…must be the creator of another X-file. After you commented, my Firefox jumped around like an earthquake was shaking my laptop, I swear. It finally settled, but it was purdy funny altogether. ;o)
Yep; everyone’s for the 99%. Cripes, where was I? Some site had a video where a former Union organizer was speaking to a group about capitalism’s inherent bias toward the 1%. They had clipped it to where he sounded pretty extreme, and all the commenters were calling for him to be arrested for sedition, and telling the ‘Obama is a socialist’ stories. My stars; yes, if ya count Lemon Socialism, I reckon.
Can’t believe all the election arguments here; I knew, as we all did, that it would get crazy, but I had no idea how crazy.
How go the fires thee+ I was looking on inciweb.org, but I don’t your state well enough to suss out which fire name to click into.
Sorry we drank all the beer; blame hermit. ;o)
Great, that you can just retire early, you are one of the lucky ones. Many folks won’t have that option.
Tom, I hope you put that project in diary form, here at FDL.
Blue
The air is really bad here today and it’s very smoky. We have old fires and new fires and it’s very hard to keep track. Plumas, Lassen and Shasta Trinity are the locations that basically surround us, and those fires all seem to be getting worse.
The circular election arguments would be downright amusing if the world wasn’t on fire.
Sorry I missed the beer . . .
You have helped. I was despondent before I read your reply, now I feel so much better just knowing that you understand and feel my rage.
Has it been raining ash? One of the weird things about sitting outside the little motel while we were evacuated, was the ash. For a couple days it was white; when it turned black and greasy, it was somehow more alarming, and that was at the point that the firefighters were battling to save our places. I’d figured that it was both the vegetation *and* the insane speed of the burning and torching.
The smoke we’ve had here from the current fires they say is ‘diffuse enough’ to not be dangerous, whatever the hell that means.
Hope you keep the inciweb site so you can bookmark the CA separate website. Knowing what’s up is better than not knowing, imo.
love you, even if I didn’t think to save ya a beer,
wd
Wish now I’d said so earlier, my friend. I just spend so much time outraged over so many things going on, and have to either write about them, compartmentalize some of it, find some measure of peace in the night skies, go outside to treasure the growin’ thngs and critters who live here, or…mediate some of it away.
But I do hope you might ask and show some of the economists what you’ve seen, and mebbe they can share your ire or answer questions.
Now yer gettin’ with the program, TomThumb. ;oP
Yes, not sure on that bit about Australia as they seem ok with other aspects of TPP.
There’s a businessman’s article at the NZHerald site (nzherald.co.nz) that is simply fascinating and comments as well – here’s the opening salvo:
“The business community is an ardent supporter of the Trans-Pacific Partnership, a free trade agreement being negotiated among 11 Pacific Rim countries. It will make business easier for our exporters and since international business accounts for over two thirds of New Zealand’s economic activity, freer trade should make us all wealthier.” (Richard Fyers)
One comment was, “Who is us?”
The article accuses folk opposed of “scaremongering” and says the following: “All TPP signatories will lose sovereignty to the same extent – if any do.” Unbelievable!
Comments made it clear that small countries don’t have the clout, pretty obvious that one. And New Zealand already lost out on labor laws when Warner Brothers and “The Hobbit” came to town.
A lot to chew on here and a lot to ponder. Recommended, of course!
Answer: “The folks in the Front Row Seats; NOT the Peanut Gallery.”
Not only ‘Unbelievable!’…but pretty fooking cavalier, given the whole truth of selling a nation’s sovereignty, the 99% civil rights, and self-determination. What.a.tool.
You got somethin’ against Hobbitses, juliania? One of them little dudes holds the One Ring That Rules Them All.
Lotta links within links…it is too much for one time, but read at your leisure, dear Kurt Sperry. And thanks ever so for bein’ so clear-headed in advocacy of valuable discussion. I appreciate it mightily.