(Dedicated to my friends, wolf lovers and admirers hfc and tm, who are in anguish over this news.)
“The wolf exerts a powerful influence on the human imagination. It takes your stare and turns it back on you.”
~ Barry Lopez
From the New York Times:
Yellowstone National Park’s best-known wolf, beloved by many tourists and valued by scientists who tracked its movements, was shot and killed on Thursday outside the park’s boundaries, Wyoming wildlife officials reported.
The wolf that researchers called 832F, left, was shot on Thursday. The alpha female of the Lamar Canyon pack, she wore a tracking collar. The wolf with her, known as 754, was killed last month.
The wolf, known as 832F to researchers, was the alpha female of the park’s highly visible Lamar Canyon pack and had become so well known that some wildlife watchers referred to her as a “rock star.” The animal had been a tourist favorite for most of the past six years.
The wolf was fitted with a $4,000 collar with GPS tracking technology, which is being returned, said Daniel Stahler, a project director for Yellowstone’s wolf program. Based on data from the wolf’s collar, researchers knew that her pack rarely ventured outside the park, and then only for brief periods, Dr. Stahler said.
This year’s hunting season in the northern Rockies has been especially controversial because of the high numbers of popular wolves and wolves fitted with research collars that have been killed just outside Yellowstone in Idaho, Montana and Wyoming.
“It does not demean men to want to be what they imagine the wolf to be, but it does demean them to kill the animal for it.”
~ Barry Lopez
I’d wanted to embed Bill Moyers’ final interview in 2010; he chose Barry Lopez (vimeo here) as what he’d thought would be his final guest. Lopez, an author, moral philosopher and righteous human being wrote, among other great books, Of Wolves and Men in 1978. To say it’s a book that can change the way you understand life may be trite, but it’s also true.
This is the link to the vimeo version of the interview; if I knew how to embed it, I would. The transcript is here.
Once my friends emailed me the news, I thought a lot about wolves and humans and the attempts to re-introduce them into the Northern Rockies. My mind was full of the images wrought by Barry’s having said concerning the idea that so many of us have effectively separated ourselves from nature by seeing it as ‘the other’. Here he was speaking about the oldest metaphor for those living in North America being…nature. Here is some of it from the interview:
So, it’s the oldest metaphor, because our stories began where we used animals and wind and light as a context in which to develop something that was very complicated. And that’s how we communicated with each other.
We have from, you know, the beginning of the Holocene, you know, the raising, the creation of cities in the Tigris/Euphrates, we have created a world in which we marginalize that which we don’t think serves us as well as it could. We’ve turned nature into a thing. You know, Martin Buber’s wonderful I/it relationship and I/thou relationship. This is an “it.” The book is an “it.” It is soulless. It is utilitarian. I can throw it on the ground if I want. But if it’s an I/thou relationship, you never make those kinds of presumptions. So a lot of what traditional people when you watch- when you’re in their environment, everything is I/thou. The relationship to the wind; the wind is alive. It has a soul. It’s part of the moral universe.
And we’ve created something in which we have excluded from our moral universe everything but us. And in fact, a lot of people have been excluded from this central White Western European dominant culture. Everything else is an I/it relationship. With African Americans or, you know, in Aboriginal people, whatever it’s going to be. But when you– with traditional people, the relationships with everything are about the holiness of the other, the mystery of the other. That’s that I/thou relationship.
And what I would like to I guess encourage people to understand is that for the sake of our own convenience, we created an “other,” and that other was nature. And we said, if it doesn’t serve us, kill it, move it, destroy it, crush it. Make it serve us. And if it doesn’t, it’s no good.
The next part about the impossibility of directing the play in life, but needing to be part of the play, and interact with other humans in love and community is simply beautiful; I hope you read it. Or watch the video.
Goodbye, Wolves 832F and 754.
“How is one to live a moral and compassionate existence when one is fully aware of the blood, the horror inherent in life, when one finds darkness not only in one’s culture but within oneself? If there is a stage at which an individual life becomes truly adult, it must be when one grasps the irony in its unfolding and accepts responsibility for a life lived in the midst of such paradox. One must live in the middle of contradiction, because if all contradiction were eliminated at once life would collapse. There are simply no answers to some of the great pressing questions. You continue to live them out, making your life a worthy expression of leaning into the light.”
~ Barry Lopez
Bill Moyers Journal: Barry Lopez video, from BillMoyers.com on Vimeo.



85 Comments

very sad news and a fine tribute, Wendy. Thank you.
RIP, Wolves 832F and 754.
another day sickened by wholesale animal slaughter,by the great white hunters,like Darth Cheney and his 100,000$ Italian women’s shotgun
hate BHO,hell no,these killers i despise,8 billion ugly humans,how many lovely wolves? sad,sad,sad
i loves me some HDT
Welcome, karenjj2. Blessed are they…
Yes; Thoreau knew, didn’t he? We’re not separate, but wholly linked to All That Is.
Barry, imo, has the key to how we can survive it and still live well, eh? Difficult, but crucial, especially in these times when we know only too well…what’s afoot.
animals in our world,are under constant siege,just like children,and the poor or elderly….creatures that cant fight back….it makes ones heart heavy,and overwhelmed
I like to think there are creatures who are not as bloodthirsty as we are here on earth. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I-eAxVs7LCU
Oh, and by the way: fuck you, hunters, every last godforsaken one of you.
there would b NO humanity,without,the wolf,
for ALL dogs descend from wolves,and without dogs helping man hunt,man would have perished,period the END.
i must tell this little bit of a funny on myself,to lighten my mood.I Didn’t know but they introduced Coyotes here to kill the groundhogs,which did not work.Leaving a friend’s dinner party,I followed what thought was a German Shepard,down the road about 2 miles,thinking it was lost,and hungry ,and i would rescue it,well it was evening,it turned around to face me,and i realized it was NOT a German Shepard…..hilarity ensued
ps …thank you Wendy Davis for your constant display of BEAUTIFL humanity….thank you,thank you
The video was lovely and I am still crying over it; thank you, my friend.
I just found this news about OR-7, a lone wolf born in Oregon who now lives in California (I wrote about him in August). The article says that he’s moving to lower ground for the winter and that he is just east of Red Bluff. We were in Red Bluff yesterday; I had an unexplained need to go on a road trip there and to Redding farther north. Perhaps Journey was calling me.
^^Journey is what some people call OR-7.
and thak you for your beautiful humanity constantly shown here
our poor mother earth
i cant watch any sad animal videos,or even hear sad stories makes me too sad…the wild things have no guile,and therefore are precious
they never LIE
It’s awfully kind of you to say that in response to my angry comments; I am feeling a little bit less angry now that I have sort of re-established my connection with the California lone wolf. I didn’t really know how much I admired wolves until I started looking into Journey’s story.
you have a connection to the real world
must see TV
after the nuclear holocaust at Chernobel the wolf,and other animals exist
http://video.pbs.org/video/2157025070/
Thank you, I’ll watch that later.
For what, exactly, was this wolf killed?
Terribly sad and senseless.
Of Wolves And Men is one of the few great books that helped me to learn and know. I’d linked to it and offered some trite but true comments awhile back at HFC’s diary.
We (all) had been warned and some of us were urged to contact our Congressional reps in the House and Senate when it recently became lawful again to murder wolves in their homes.
I’ll write to Senator Kay Hagan and ask her how she feels about the murders.
all for the glory of the gun
Killing Afghani children when they’re inconvenient; killing American wolves when they are inconvenient and, of course, for sport. Dare we consider the possibility that some Americans kill Afghani children for sport?
Human beings believe human consciousness, which is to say, self-consciousness, differentiates humanity from mere critters. It doesn’t. We humans are made from the same muck as the wolves and other animals. Each one of us will eventually perish, just like every member of the Animal Kingdom. Why would we ever feel superior to our kind?
So that some jerk could tell his friends what a big hunter he is, since he needs that to feel like a “man.” What a terrible loss to feed someone’s ego. My daughter has a dog that is part wolf and the most beautiful dog I’ve ever seen. And very sweet.
Love and admiration to all of you who care and who have commented. Real Life has me by the ovaries (?) right now, and I hope that hotflashcarol might host this thread as she is able, and then pass the baton to others who may wish to help out.
If hfc (Mz. Firecracker to me) hasn’t, I hope she will bring her diary on the Lone CA wolf. Sorry I don’t even have time to check the links and comments.
A good Hanukkah to you all, as well.
And, bigass, brass belt buckles…! ;-)
very sad to read this.
shame on everyone responsible for destroying
these beautiful animals.
agreed with twain: ‘a terrible loss to feed someone’s ego.’
for shame.
It’s getting beyond the pale. Somebody in our small apartment neighborhood today just started firing a gun in a backyard like the place was a goddamn shooting range. There’s kids living here. It’s insane.
And on the wolf thing: Never Cry Wolf should be required reading for everyone. That glory thing doesn’t work for me today. (I will have to read Of Wolves and Men)
Crap like this makes me sick. There is no reason for this at all.
i believe so
PREDATOR NATION imo
That’s on my list of stuff I need to read. I have been trying to force myself away from the computer and back into books when it gets dark at night; I don’t ever feel like I have wasted time when I am reading (as opposed to some of the mindless time I spend online).
Real Life is good but I hope it is gentle on yer lady parts. :)
Hello, Mz. Firecracker; thank you for hosting while you can; I love ya silly. Sleep when you need to, and pass the hosting on. Of course, the thread may just do fine on its own…. ;o)
Wish I still had my copy of ‘…of Wolves’; sent it to RAD. Lovely copy.
From what I reckon here, you don’t need to read that great book, though when you do read it you might wonder what took so long. ;o)
Annie Dillard said something like reading every day can be pretty dull while a lifetime of reading is a treasure.
I guess they didn’t eat what they killed.
Y’know, you can wish that on each of the eight nights and never have to spell it the same way twice. ;o)
No, they kill wolves because the livestock they’ve domesticated and raise for slaughter can’t defend themselves against the wolves. We don’t know how to have a world with lamb chops, buffalo wings, bacon, roast beef and also wolves.
I watched the video, but can’t get through your essay. Tears on the keyboard. And sometimes the weaker side of me wishes there was an open season on bureaucrats. There are all these tracking collars – what if instead of money for those, they used that money for the protective electric pulse fences that homeowners use to keep animals inside a designated backyard lot.
Who killed the wolf?
Some redneck rancher who pays $1 per head per year to graze his cattle on national land which destroys it?
just installed one…85$ of equipment to install on my chain link fence,keeps dogs in,pests out
thanks, i’m about halfway through the video. i don’t know if they’ll clarify later, but i don’t understand how all the animals are thriving when the area is poisonous for people.
Not directly yet. But we know that American helicopter gunship pilots killed a Reuters photographer in Iraq for sport (or as in a video game). We know that because of Bradley Manning. Documented in a video called “Collateral Murder”.
And we know the novel by Jack London, The Heart of Darkness (adpated as the movie Apocalypse Now).
And that when you have half a million soldiers rotate through Iraq and Afghanistan under enough rotations without destressing, you get rampant PTSD. Just the random occurrence of crime in humanity would guarantee you all sorts of murder and rape by American soldiers. And then there are the American “security contractors” who thought rape was a party game for female staff. It is highly likely that at least one American treated the shooting of kids as a sport, whether in Afghanistan, Iraq, or both.
Worth a Congressional investigation to expose.
you might check what the laws are there. it’s illegal here to fire guns in backyards.
i sent $$$ for their protection,always 2 steps foward,3 steps back,same with the whales,elephants,tigers,Urangs,tuna,damn i hate opening my emails from these failed endeavors
forgot Mustanags and burros
and how are you otherwise friend?
Condolences, elisemattu. Tears for the planet.
My weaker side wishes all members of Congress had shocking collar and all lobbyists a radio that triggered it.
My weaker side is LOL at the thoughts your weaker side contemplates.
If I thought it would actually come true, I’d pray for it night and day and consider it a contribution to humanity.
‘Tis the dose that makes the poison. Long term exposure to the levels, and types, of radionuclides scattered around Chernobyl increase ones risk of various cancers, and engendering children with genetic and/or developmental defects. As such, the area has been deemed unfit for human habitation. Note the emphasis on deemed. No one can tell a fox, and owl, or a primrose where to dwell. They are blissfully ignorant of the risks they run in a habitat that in the short-term seems paradisically lacking in us.
im also wondering whether the flora cleanses some of the toxicity,i cant remember why they look and seem healthy
ya know i have the same problem,some joker set up a target FACING my house,he asked me if he could hunt on my property,and i said was just the caretaker,and it is animal rescue/preserve….makes me nervous
The money should come out of their first paycheck. And their second paycheck. On and on.
Make them pay for their own enslavement like they do to us.
According to the researchers in the part I watched, the bones of the moose they ate were radioactive so the wolves must be accumulating radioactivity.
From what I read, there have been about 1 million excess human deaths in the area around Chernobyl since 1986 as well as many many cases of birth defects in children that are continuing through the generations.
Feeling the same, Sweetie, poorer also for the same hopeful wildlife hopeless defenders. At least they don’t send calendars.
damn. that sounds dangerous.
I once had a roommate in a house that had a refrigerator door that was difficult to open. I was awakened one night by my drunk roommate shooting the refrigerator in his frustration.
I was VERY quickly an ex roommate of his.
Wolves have it tough, but some animals have it even worse. Wolverines are all but disappearing from the same part of the Rockies these wolves inhabit. Very few of the worldwide populations of them are viable, most declining.
Back in the 1970s, I was able to camp in a valley on Montague Island during deer hunting season, that had a large. healthy population of wolverines. I was able to observe them for four days. Pretty soon, I realized they were watching me. And getting carefully closer. When they were satisfied I wasn’t hurt, they backed off a bit. They are really amazing animals.
I thought that was already the way it is set up….
I’m not sure why I feel a need to say this, but just for the record, my sights and concerns are more firmly focused on the many human deaths, and especially children, caused by cavalier disregard of those whose duty was to have been to serve The People.
I won’t even try to list my long wildlife advocacy, except for the joy of seeing foxes here, after having been totally trapped out (for bounty and varmint reasons) three decades ago.
I’m just sayin’ that ‘Mankind is my Business’, even though I know that The Whole is supremely important. Here, we at least still have coyotes and mountain lions. That’s…a blessing.
i thought the tough wolverines were doing well.they are indefatigable….oh sigh,im gonna logoff too much sorrow
i am the flipside…to many peeps…they overun the resources imo
i may call the game warden dont want to provoke
…Worth a Congressional investigation to expose.
That would be one, serious-ass, ‘can of worms’ to open up, Tarheel…! ;-)
I’ve been ‘tracked’ by those wily critters, and, even seen them take down full-grown Moose…! They’re certainly cunning and fearless…!
Recc’d. Thank you, wendydavis.
“History accumulates like rubbish at the portal of nature.” Thoreau
It’s time for Federal protection for all wolves and mountain lions in the United States:
They are too close to extinction: Here in Massachusetts, there are only a few breeding pairs of each, but the Federal Government refuses to extend protection, claiming that they are already extinct here, further claiming that the wolves roam here from hundreds of miles away and the mountains lions roam from thousands of miles away, and therefore are not worthy of Federal protection.
If you see a wolf or mountain lion here, there not even considered endangered, because they supposedly don’t exist, so if you see them, you can kill them.
i love this
pp&m ,where have all the flowers gone
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1QZq-wKaBWc
when will they EVER learn
I think someone said this upthread, but perhaps a little clarification. I talked about this with someone I know who works with the containers of nuclear waste in Los Alamos. He said that wolves have such a shorter life span than people, so their body burden of exposure is not like ours, because we live (theoretically) so long.
The wildlife in the film has moved back into the area since it has become wild from the lack of human habitation. There’s a great book called The Earth After Us, that investigates lots of places where humans don’t or can’t live, and how long it takes for evidence of our stamp on a place to go away. It is interesting. Chernobyl is one of those places, but there are many others.
Also, wendydavis and hfc. Thank you for the post/host. Really tragic, incredibly sad. And outrageous. RIP wolves.
Guess which state and under whose leadership it was decided that wolves (at about 500 individuals before the hunt) needed their population to be reduced this past season. Well that would be Wisconsin and “gov,” Scott Wolfkiller and his ilk, who also decided that hunting and trapping in 2/3 of the State Parks should enjoy a generously extended season. Almost 100 wolves killed thus far, and supporters of the hunt were angry that dogs had not been allowed to be used.
Aw, fuck me, nonquixote. Did he say, “Ah, the hell with dogs; let them hunt from helicopters!”?
A federal judge wisely ruled that no adequate language in the bill to allow the hunt addressed how dogs could be used or be protected or how their use would “unduly,” harm wolves.
The dog trainers can run their dogs off season as I understand it and the state would reimburse them an inflated $$ value for any “trained,” dog that the wolves killed. Sick all around.
On the extending of hunting and trapping seasons in our state parks, basically Labor day to Memorial Day, I don’t think that there is a restriction from non-hunters using the designated hunting zones. There are tons of physically able people, against this who might have to become physically involved by casually observing hunters within sight of them, to get this new law, 65 pages released Thursday and final public input is tomorrow, before going through the R controlled legis and on to the “gov’s,” desk.
Sorry, meant to type, …to get this new law…eventually removed.
Sorry to be late to this thread. Thank you, wendydavis, for speaking for your friends, animal and human. As you linked to the Moyers interview with Barry Lopez and through him to Buber, here’s a quotation that goes with all of this, and with your comments, from I and Thou:
“An animal’s eyes have the power to speak a great language. Independently, without needing co-operation of sounds and gestures, most forcibly when they rely wholly on their glance, the eyes express the mystery in its natural prison, the anxiety of becoming. This condition of mystery is known only by the animal, it alone can disclose it to us – and this condition only lets itself be disclosed, not fully revealed. The language in which it is uttered is what it says – anxiety, the movement of the creature between the realms of vegetable security and spiritual venture. This language is the stammering of nature at the first touch of spirit, before it yields to spirit’s cosmic venture that we call man. But no speech will ever repeat what that stammering knows and can proclaim.”
Finally able to read all of your post, Wendy. Glad you could put the energy into making the entry a tribute to the wolves. Also I am so glad that many fellow animal activists are here on this political site.
May I add one small bit of “Happiness” concerning some hunters.
I live in an area which has more than its share of people who like “sports” like hunting. But some hunters are very understanding of their place in the Universe. I was at a party recently, and a friend came over to say, “There he is – the guy I told you about.” So I went over to talk to him to thank him.
A year back or so, the guy was out hunting during deer season. And he made a “stand” by using some brush and a tree. He was sure if he stayed perfectly still he’d manage to “get a buck.” He heard a rustle down the hill aways. And so he waited, figuring it was probably the big buck he’d seen the day before.
Well, it wasn’t a buck. It was a big bear. A rather big bear. And not only that – it came right up to his “stand” and nuzzled around, while he slid up the tree.
Remember, he had a gun. He didn’t have to slide away from a bear. He could have taken aim and fired.
Now that I was meeting him, I asked him the questions I had thought about ever since I first heard the story…”So why didn’t you protect yourself? I think I’d have taken out the bear, assuming I had a gun and some ability to shoot it. Didn’t you think of shooting the creature when it was snuffling around at your feet?”
He looked me in the eye and said, “It wasn’t legal to shoot bears. Not then. And besides, I was in that guy’s home turf, not him on mine.” A pause. “Plus gosh, was he ever magnificent!”
After my fourth reading of the Buber quote, juliania, I’m not sure I’m really getting closer to his meaning (my failure, not his). I see the progression of the imagery and even the restrained communication…but when I come to this:
‘before it yields to spirit’s cosmic venture that we call man.’ ~ and I think I haven’t taken the small journey he wanted me/us to understand. If you could throw some light on that?
Thank you; I’d reckoned you the I/Thou might make your antennae quiver. Mine, too. ;o)
Great story, elisemattu! Well done, Mr. Hunter. (But did he not know that bears climb trees, lol?) We get bears in the fall now since there haven’t been many acorns and berries in the mountains recently (drought, temperature differences), so they come down to stock up fat for hibernation, and are (ahem) interfacing with humans and their trash too often for their health in town. Out here, they climb our fruit trees and gorge.
And the li’l fuckers (well, some are huge, but still…) are too good to eat the fruit we shake down for them! Oh, no, they climb, break branches, and claw all the bark off, and kill trees. But I did read up on bear protocols, and it seems you want to make yourself look as large as possible, and make a whole lotta noise. No running, no turning your back on them, of course.
I was camping in the Zirkel Wilderness once with a girlfriend and our dogs once when a bear came into our camp. Eeek! Two Boulder city gurls, and we took the cowering dogs across Mica Creek hoping he wouldn’t follow, lol. He didn’t, but did take a long siesta next to our tent, got up, yawned, left his calling card…and toddled along. I had a nice hunting knife at my waist for camp chores, and I’m surely glad I hadn’t needed it. ;o)
Thanks for the fun story; the local hunters here all hunt for meat, and the Texas hunters that were our bane no longer seem to come, thank goodness. Hunters kill hundreds of times more humans than wolves or bears do…
You know how when you want to scare a friend by hiding and then jumping out and yelling Boo! or Aaaaa!, you always put your hands up to the side of your mouth and chin with all ten fingers spread wide and clawlike? Is that instinctive ancient memory? To scare a beast with what look like huge saber teeth?
Oh, sorry, wendydavis. The important connection for me was to Barry Lopez’s statement which you lead with: “… It takes your stare and turns it back on you.” I think (don’t pretend to understand all of Buber’s thought) he would include animals in ‘spirit’s cosmic venture’ – as ‘the first touch of spirit’, which I felt corresponded to your sentiment in #55. We are humans relating to each of these ‘realms’ – the plant world, the animal world, the world of men. Here’s what he has just said about the relationship with trees (probably will confuse the issue further, but he’s going step by step):
“…Everything belonging to the tree is in this: its form and structure, its colors and chemical composition, its intercourse with the elements and with the stars, are all present in a single whole.
The tree is no impression, no play of my imagination, no value depending upon my mood, but it is bodied over against me and has to do with me as I with it -only in a different way.”
Now, Buber will ultimately go beyond into a theological relationship with which many will disagree, but I think in these matters he and we stand on common ground.
I confess I don’t understand the thinking, but it seems to default to wolf cruelty, human…cavalier brutality. Good luck, I guess. Perhaps the Great Awakening will offer some amelioration to the genetic fear and loathing of the wolf archetype.
Er…did you think that we all do that, HiDef? I can squeeze you in at six tomorrow evening if you’d like. ;D
Sabertooth Chanelling? Hold that thought for tomorrow…
He may mean that there’s essentially a vibrational exchange of understanding of the ‘reality’ of Treeness, and the exchanges vary on his mood. Is that the ‘cosmic venture yielding to man’? Almost wanting to have those bits understood by said man? Sorry to be so thick here… Do give up any time. ;D
Thank you for your very kind attention. I have been contacting and politely encouraging several of the very sincere and devoted nature lovers around here (and their group affiliates) and suggesting that they need to be ready to organize and physically demonstrate their convictions as participatory activists to contest some of the legislative action being considered here, regarding public lands, habitat and wildlife denigration regarding our state parks.
Sorry to be so imprecise with my prior information. My comment of a population of 500 wolves pre-hunt was wrong. Estimates were more like 800 wolves pre-hunt and a minimum of 500 wolves for keeping them as a viable population and off the endangered species list in this state.
Please forgive me for not responding sooner, nonquixote. I haven’t been able to break my bad habit of zipping to the end of a comment thread and working my way upstream. I miss things that way, especially if RL calls me away.
I assume you mean demonstrating at the Capitol Building? If any of you organize something, it would really, really help if you could notify any media ahead of time to amplify your voices.
It really is surprising to me that there are so many wolves in WI; heartening, actually. I read a lot of wolf reports as I tried to string this post together, and read a lot of Jack London as a kid, and realize how sad I am never to have heard a wolf howl.
Good on you, and good fortune with your eco-comrades.
I am working from a purely local, county level, people who I actually know and see with some regularity. I have digitally suggested simple models for wildlife activism to larger audiences, though. I would be embarrassed to think of the carbon foot print I would leave, singularly cause, by driving to the state capitol.
Nothing to forgive, wendydavis. You attend to your diaries extraordinarily well. Peace and resolve.
Where are the solar-powered jetpacks they promised us, anyway?
Peace and solidarity to you also. ;o) (workin’ on a wee antidote piece on economic issues.)
Ah wendy, I’m really sorry to trouble you with this. One more try:
“This language [the language of animals]is the stammering of nature at the first touch of spirit, before it [nature] yields to spirit’s cosmic venture that we call man.”
Just a poetic way of saying, I think, that the mystery of animal spirit is the threshhold impulse of spirit which then becomes involved with actual language in the case of man. (My point about trees was that in that prior primitive relationship between vegetal nature and man we don’t ‘observe’ one another,(except when we think of the tree as ‘it’) the tree and I, but we do most definitely relate to one another, are affected by one another. Strictly on the level of relationship, which is what ‘I and Thou’ is all about. But I’m very sorry – I wasn’t trying to be argumentative, just to give a parallel sentiment.
And all are part of the cosmic venture.
I weep for the wolves. I pray to the spirits in the trees. I see all that ever was and will be in the eyes of my beloved rescued pets.Blessed be all.