In a 1/10/09 LA Times op-ed, noted Harvard law professor Alan Dershowitz makes an interesting argument:
Several months ago, the head of the Israeli air force showed me a videotape (now available on YouTube) of a Hamas terrorist deliberately moving his rocket launcher to the front of a U.N. school, firing a rocket and then running away, no doubt hoping that Israel would then respond by attacking the rocket launcher and thus killing Palestinian children in the school.
[...]
Consider a related situation: An armed bank robber kills several tellers and takes a customer hostage. Hiding behind his human shield, the robber continues to kill civilians. A police officer, trying to prevent further killings, shoots at the robber but accidentally kills the hostage. Who is guilty of murder? Not the police officer who fired the fatal shot but the bank robber who fired from behind the human shield.
And, who is guilty if the police open fire in that crowded bank after the robber has run away? As Professor Dershowitz has noted, Palestinian rocketeers generally flee before Israeli bombers can arrive. The inescapable conclusion is that, if the Israelis bomb that U.N. school, their purpose is not to kill the rocketeer, who has almost surely fled, but rather to use the rocketeers recent presence as a pretext for the very predictable outcome of killing scores of Palestinian children.
So, what would be Israel’s motivation for doing such a thing? I don’t know, but there are two common reasons for people to practice such violence:
- Retribution — Palestinian rockets have killed a couple of Isreali children in the past year.
- Intimidation — Israel wants the Gazans to vote for someone other than Hamas next time. (But note that violence against civilians for political ends is the very definition of "terrorism," a crime against humanity.)



10 Comments







Some of the things that Hamas does are despicable as well as what the Israeli government and some in the I military take part in. What Dershowitz fails to discuss is that Hamas has been demanding that Israel abide by the findings of the conservative International World Court. The Wall is illegal, occupying Palestinian lands is illegal and the Wall being built on Palestinian lands is illegal.
Few address why Hamas is so pissed off and why they have been launching rockets.
Wigwam here is why Huffington Post is Isreali Occupied Territory
Not a neutral place over at the Huffington Post
http://www.antiwar.com/justin/?articleid=13990
Professor Norman Finkelstein is a wonderful source for info on this critical issue
http://www.normanfinkelstein.com/
Can you believe that NO JOURNALIST ARE BEING LET INTO THE GAZA. AND ISRAEL CALLS THEMSELVES A DEMOCRACY. Hooey
Noam Chomsky Accuses Alan Dershowitz of Launching a “Jihad” to Block Norman Finkelstein From Getting Tenure at Depaul University
http://www.democracynow.org/20…..showitz_of
Scholar Norman Finkelstein Calls Professor Alan Dershowitz’s New Book On Israel a “Hoax”
http://www.thirdworldtraveler……stein.html
Debate between Dershowitz and Finkelstein
11 parts
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mzobRw3in9I
http://www.democracynow.org/20…..essor_alan
Justin Raimando’s latest on the appointment of Dennis Ross as the envoy to Iran. Can not think of a more inappropriate envoy to Iran. WTF is up with Obama this is not a good sign
The Same Old Change
Obama’s Middle East ‘czar’ signals the Lobby’s still in charge
http://www.antiwar.com/justin/?articleid=14019
Steve Clemons take on Dennis Ross
http://www.thewashingtonnote.c…..powell_fo/
Yes, I am a longstanding critic of Dennis Ross and I find his choice as envoy to Iran as effectively undercutting Obama’s claimed interest in establishing a dialogue with the Iranians.
Check this out Professor Walt of Mearsheimer and Walt has a blog
http://walt.foreignpolicy.com/node/10732
Hi Leen. Thanks for those most excellent links.
This is a particularly biased “situation”. By making Israel the bank, the Israeli military the policeman, and Hamas the murderous bank robber, do any of us have any doubts about what kind of conclusions Dershowitz is going to draw, or whose violence is going to be sanctioned?
And the proof that it was Hamas, not a staged event by the Israelis is?
As Palestinian blood flows, Jews are asking to be relocated to Gaza.
Jewish settlers: Move us back to Gaza
Israeli soldiers evacuated all the Jewish settlements in the Gaza Strip and demolished the houses.
Former residents of the Gush Katif Jewish settlements have asked Israeli officials to relocate them back to the evacuated communities in Gaza.
“Let us return home. We are ready at a day’s notice to set up tents in the area, until permanent construction,” the group said in a news conference in Jerusalem (al-Quds) on Sunday, the Israeli daily Haaretz reported.
“It is time to correct the national damage that was caused by the expulsion of Gush Katif,” Reuven Rosenblatt, the former head of the settlement’s council said.
http://www.presstv.com/detail……=351020202
Dershowitz is a propagandist and a sophist. His analogy is pretty poor as one might expect.
The policeman, acting as Israel does, would not have shot at the hostage-holding robber. He would have been blocks away calling in an air strike to destroy the bank as well as the surrounding buildings.