Time is indeed running out. We are soon to become officially a nation that sanctions torture. At the time the United States ratified the Convention Against Torture (1994), we also passed a federal statute criminalizing torture and conspiracy to torture (18 U.S.C. Secs. 2340 and 2340A). That statute has a statute of limitations period of eight years, meaning if it is not enforced within eight years of the alleged act of torture or conspiracy to torture, it cannot be used against the perpetrators of that particular act.
In 2002, the United States began an official policy of torture. It was "legalized," authorized and ordered at the highest levels of our government. Beginning some time in 2010, those who conspired to torture in 2002 will no longer be prosecutable under the federal torture statute.
The evidence that we tortured people is overwhelming. Major General Antonio Taguba wrote in a 2008 preface to a Physicians for Human Rights report that "the Commander-in-Chief and those under him authorized a systematic regime of torture." FBI Guantanamo interrogator, Ali Soufan, reported "borderline torture" to his superiors in Washington. Judge Susan Crawford, the convening authority for the Guantanamo military commissions, said earlier this year, "We tortured Qahtani. His treatment met the legal definition of torture. And that’s why I did not refer the case [for prosecution]." (The Washington Post, January 14, 2009)
Yet not one single person has been charged for these and numerous other crimes. The statute of limitations will soon begin to expire. We will then become a nation that officially sanctions torture.
The Convention Against Torture requires President Obama and Attorney General Holder to investigate allegations where there is a "reasonable ground to believe that an act of torture has been committed." Every single U.S. Attorney in the country also has jurisdiction. So far, none of them seems to recognize we are a nation of laws.
For goodness sakes, the U.S. Attorneys appointed by President Bush had greater courage and integrity in standing up to the pressures coming down on them from above. Some of them remembered the oaths they took. Apparently, none of the Obama-appointed U.S. Attorneys can say the same thing.
Time is of the essence if we are not to become officially a nation that tortures. Call President Obama. Call Attorney General Eric Holder. Call the U.S. Attorney in your federal district.
Call your Senators. My two Senators are both on the Senate Judiciary Committee. On this issue, their conduct has been disgraceful.
This coming week the Human Rights and the Law Subcommittee of the Senate Judiciary Committee is going to hold its first-ever hearing on the implementation of human rights treaties that we have ratified. This includes the Convention Against Torture.
The Senate Judiciary Committee needs only to look at itself to find one big reason for problems in implementation of the CAT. So far, it has shown no interest in pushing the enforcement of the already-passed implementing legislation of this treaty. The Judiciary Committee oversees the Justice Department, but it has never put pressure on the Attorney General to move forward on torture and torture conspiracy prosecutions.
The Human Rights and the Law Subcommittee will take written comments on this issue. Any written statements can be sent to Heloisa at Heloisa_Griggs@Judiciary-dem.senate.gov. Any statements received by December 14 will be entered into the record at the hearing but the record will be kept open for a week after the hearing for additional statements.
Please write. Time is running out.



9 Comments




Thanks, writing!
Obama shoots baskets yet apparently doesn’t understand why there’s a shot clock.
Thanks, I will.
Can we say that standing in orange jumpsuits, black hoods, in freezing temperatures in front of the U.S. Courthouse in Minneapolis on Human Rights Day? You betcha!
See “Human Rights Day 2009–Waiting for Justice”: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SWBWFIYjhBA
Harper, as you likely know, is continuing to try and hide documents relating to torture in Afghanistan. The battle to get them released continues. No doubt there is information in them that would be tied to Americans.
************
“The Harper government is citing concern over security as reason to ignore a parliamentary vote passed by opposition MPs Friday, demanding it release uncensored information on Afghan prisoners.
Colvin, who was at one point Canada’s No. 2 official in Afghanistan, told the committee that he informed the government in writing about suspected incidents of torture by Afghan authorities but says he was told by people higher up to stop writing about the incidents. ”
http://www.ctv.ca/servlet/ArticleNews/story/CTVNews/20091211/afghanistan_motion_091211/20091211?hub=TopStoriesV2
Western civilization is in decline, even as the the really smart advisers to presidents try to destroy it.
Gandhi was asked once what he thought of western civilization. His response was, “I think it would be a good idea.”
The rest of the world see’s us as always putting our selves above any treaties, and doing what we want and disreguarding anything we don’t want to follow.
We have a Government of fools, and they reflect on everyone of us, making us all look like fools by acting in our name.
Thank you for expressing so well what is turning out to be the most important legal challenge of our time. For people in our government to betray us by violating our taboo of torture they indeed should be prosecuted. I knew that torture was illegal in grade school and anyone who ordered, enabled, encouraged, or participated in torture needs to be held to account. Unless they are held to account our claim of being a society of law will soon have little meaning.